I have some really silly claims about SNS like you asked :P 1) SNS could never be canon or had no potential to be. 2) Two men cannot be best friends without being shoved into a gay relationship. 3) Any friends would do that for each other.
Send me claims you’re sick of hearing, and I’ll refute them.
1) SNS could never be canon or had no potential to be.
There’s a difference between having the potential to be canon or becoming canonised. Canon pairings aren’t necessarily good pairings; likewise, pairings that aren’t canonised do not necessarily lack potential. When it comes to SNS, the potential is very real, but unfortunately, they had never a realistic chance of being canonised for the following reasons. Firstly, the targeted audience and the sociocultural background of Naruto is conservative. I’ve never expected Naruto and Sasuke to be in an actual romantic relationship by the end of the manga. The genre and the cultural context play an important role. To expect a Japanese shounen manga this popular to end with the male protagonist choosing his male rival over two already established possible female love interests is simply unrealistic.
For example, Yuri!!! on Ice managed to overcome these difficulties of censorship. Kubo fought a lot to create a universe for queer individuals who can relate to non-hetero interpersonal relationships. But Kubo is not Kishimoto, and Shueisha Inc. knows their respective audience well enough to judge whether or not the series would survive a homosexual ending, which in Naruto’s case, both Shueisha Inc. and Studio Pierrot intended to further profit from the series. So including the genre, the cultural context, and the staff, I can’t see a romantic SNS having ever been taken into consideration. Still, Naruto and Sasuke have enough development to be canonised.
2) Two men cannot be best friends without being shoved into a gay relationship.
This is a blatant lie. Our society is heavily influenced by heteronormativity. Thus, heterosexuality is expected and labelled as natural. Anything that doesn’t fit into the norm counts as unnatural. Since Naruto and Sasuke fit into the norm, they are immediately seen as heterosexual, hence why we have fans claiming Naruto and Sasuke are definitely straight despite the fact that their sexuality was never confirmed. Some of these fans even think it’s absurd to challenge their perception by saying Naruto and Sasuke are not straight.
Their beliefs are strongly shaped by heteronormativity to the point where they believe it is laughable to disagree with their opinion since they expect everyone who fits into the norm to be heterosexual anyway. This is why it’s only logical to infer that the claim “Two men cannot be best friends without being shoved into a gay relationship” is likely to be untrue. In fact, we come across fans describing an innocent conversation between characters of the opposite sex to be of romantic nature, whereas a similar conversation between characters of the same sex would be described as solely friendly. Why? They expect characters to be straight—unless their behaviour goes against gender norms.
3) Any friends would do that for each other.
Lol, the way this subjective claim works is by using the argument that NH and SS were canonised. “Any friends would do that for each other. This is true because Naruto and Sasuke aren’t in a romantic relationship.” The thing is, there is no absolute truth in literature. I could use the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet in order to prove them wrong. Romeo was willing to die for Juliet, and both are regarded as the archetypal lovers in our today world’s society. Naruto was willing to die for Sasuke. So Kishimoto used a typical romantic trope right there, and they cannot deny it.