How would Sabrina Spellman react to falling in love with the reader after seeing them the first time?
A/N: This took me FOREVER I’m so sorry.
Sabrina has a tendency to let her heart rule over her head
Which means she falls in love too quickly
It happened with Harvey, it happened with Nicholas
And now, it’s happening with you
From the moment her eyes land on you from the bleachers, she knows
At first, she doesn’t want to acknowledge her feelings so hastily
Based on experience, she knows the heart can sometimes lead to nothing but hurt
She doesn’t really know what to do, so she decides to not approach you
The next time she sees you, you’re on the field running drills with your teammates
Sabrina often forgets that the soccer team and the cheer squad practice on the same days
She tries to focus on her routine, but she can’t tear her eyes off of you
It isn’t until Roz breaks her out of her trance that she decides to talk to you
And for the first time ever, Sabrina Spellman is nervous
She waits until practice is over to approach you
You’re sitting on the bleachers with your water bottle, waving goodbye to your teammates as they leave
And Sabrina moves to stand in front of you
“Hey! Sabrina, right?” You greet with a wide smile
Sabrina is left breathless for a moment
How did you know her name?
As if you could read her mind, you chuckle
“We had biology together our freshman year.”
Oh, of course
Sabrina suddenly remembers the awkward teen that sat at the back of the classroom, quiet as ever
She smiles and nods her head
“I remember. Y/N?”
“The one and only.”
You decide to chat with her for a bit, seeing as your ride isn’t there yet
While you both hide it well, you and Sabrina are equally nervous
You’ve liked Sabrina for years
From the moment you walked into that classroom your freshman year
Meanwhile, Sabrina feels stupid for not talking to you sooner
Your conversation is natural, easy
Most of it consists of the two of you catching up
Asking about subjects, shitty gossip, and life experiences
But soon, your ride arrives
You stand up and shoulder your bookbag, ready to leave
“Wait!”
You look to Sabrina before you leave, and she smiles softly
“Do you want to grab a bite with me tomorrow? After school, it’s a half-day.”
You contain your excitement as well as you can as you nod your head
“Yeah! I’d like that.”
You exchange details before you’re on your way
As you climb into the car, happy as a clam, your step-brother turns to look at you
“Why are you so happy?” He teases
“Mind your business and drive, Kinkle.”
Tommy smiles, peeling out of the parking lot
And you press your forehead to the window and forget all about hiding your excitement for tomorrow









