Tech Rambles: Pocahontas VS Other Historical Fiction
It’s funny how people are still to this day, complaining about how Native Americans are portrayed in Pocahontas. Why I am saying this, because recently on WaltDisneyConfessions, another person bitches about how they wish the movie was remade with Native Americans working on the set, which there were Native Americans working on the set and even with it, they still made the film the way it was.
Either way, I find it disgustingly ironic how people complain about romanticizing or not getting a culture, outside European completely accurate, but other historical fiction, mainly that focuses on European culture no one baps an eye at!
Shoot, Japanese and Chinese people romanticize and inaccurately portray their own culture all the time in media. Japanese through anime and Chinese through their dramas portraying ancient Chinese culture as being glorious and pretty, when it wasn’t really that way. Again, no one really baps an eye at it and even embraces the romanticized versions of both cultures. But if it’s a culture with particularly dark skin, people lose their shit!
Balto’s story is heavily romanticized obviously with a talking dog and the fact that no one supposedly died, despite in the wake of the real event people did died and it wasn’t just kids, adults were too. Again, no one baps an eye about that or hardly ever complains. Amadeus was an inaccurate historical fiction of Mozart and shoot, time travel kids shows like Time Warp Trio and Flint the Time Detective. They were far from accurate more than half the time. No one gave a shit about those series and shoot, they even touch upon other cultures.
I have Native American on my mom’s side and was raised to embrace that culture respectively. I even live in a town that embraces the culture and even sells goods made by actual Native Americans, being there are several tribes a few miles away. (I live in Arizona) Even so, I still wasn’t bothered by how Native Americans were portrayed in Pocahontas. Neither was my mom and her grandmother was pure Choctaw!
I thought they were portrayed well. They were a people that lived and respected nature and all that it had to offer. When the settlers appeared, they acted the same way the settlers acted. Scared of unknown thing and when it appeared threatening they vowed to destroy each other out of fear fueling hatred. Showing that despite their different ways in culture, they’re still people just trying to survive and are just faced with something unknown to them, despite yeah an obvious villain. But the villain is just a fuel to the settler’s fire and the Chief, though with better intentions, wasn’t completely good either by fueling the fire of his people. Just again driven by hatred fueled by fear.
What really gets to me is just the fact that Disney portrays cultures inaccurately most of the time, but since they’re mostly European cultures and even Asian cultures with lighter skin, no one cares. It’s only Pocahontas and sometimes Brother Bear and shoot, even Coco is getting slammed on and that’s not even out yet and people still complain because the characters are supposedly darker skin cultures. Truth be told there are pale Native Americans and Hispanics. Shocking truth I know... Lighter skin native people. (Also, truth be told, “Native American” is kinda improper term for the culture anyway, but people defending the culture still uses that term. Ignorance is bliss!)
If it were Native Americans fully telling the tale of Pocahontas, no matter what if it was good or accurate or not, shoot they could make the white man just more evil looking, no one would care! I bet you no one would complain so much because that’s how I see all this constant complaining. White guilt and I say that because most of the people that complain about Pocahontas to this day, are either bi-racial like me with little Native American or white. They’re hardly ever purely Native American themselves. I mean, yeah I heard some Native Americans didn’t like the movie but that was years ago. I have yet to see a pure Native American bitch about to this day, especially since there are other romanticized media about Native Americans.
Truth be told, they probably don’t honestly give a shit about that much anymore. It’s a movie. It’s historical fiction meaning people are going to expect some or if not a lot of inaccuracy. It just depends on if it’s got a good story and good character and this movie to me does. I actually find it more racist to the fact that people think it’s okay to embrace romanticized European/Western and even Japanese and Chinese culture, but it’s horrible to do it to other cultures that happen to have darker skin within that culture.
It’s stupid and it’s completely hypocritical! Native Americans and darker skin people are people. They’re not special little fairies. They don’t need special treatment. Alls fair! I get getting offended by some obvious racial stereotypes but for heck’s sake. This is a Disney kid’s movie we’re talking about! Let kids have their fun and let them love their movies! Guide them and let them know, media is fiction not real. That’s all you gotta do. Again, I grew up with Native American and Japanese culture and I grew up with Disney movies. I know fact from fiction just fine and even I’m telling people to calm the fuck down about it!
It’s a movie. “Historical fiction” Get that “fiction” part down with a chill pill and move on!