What are Archives and what can we do with them?
“Archives have the capacity to produce and reproduce social justice and injustice through their constructions of the past, engagements in the present, and shaping of possible futures” - Michelle Caswell and Marika Cifor [1]
The word “archive” has many meanings. Archive(s) can refer to a place, a repository where records are kept. Archives can refer to material, historical documents, personal and community belongings. To archive can be a verb, used to describe the transfer of records. Archives can refer to computer data. They can come in any shape or form and contain records of past actions so that we may reference them in the future. The concepts and definitions of “record” are constantly challenged and debated even within the archival profession.
Terry Eastwood states “the roots of archival theory may be traced to certain ancient legal and administrative principles. In order to conduct affairs, and in the course of conducting affairs, certain documents are created to capture the facts of the matter of action for future reference, to extend memory of deeds and actions of all kinds, to make it enduring” [2]. Archives can be considered monuments to the past because records were produced by specific entities during their activities under certain conditions. They can therefore attest to those recorded “acts” and “facts”. It is because archives provide an unbroken chain of custody, in a protected setting where corruption or falsification is difficult, that they can be deemed trustworthy and reliable.
The concept of archives and records being trustworthy and reliable is deeply important for the idea of evidence and the demonstration of accountability. We can hold people, corporations, and governments to account by exercising our right to view information produced by them to confirm that they act how they purport to act. This can be an important tool in rendering social justice, exercising rights, and maintaining fiduciary trust. We can see how people, corporations, and governments deny transparency by destroying, restricting, or simply not producing their records. We see this in the BC government’s intentional deletion of emails relating to the Highway of Tears, the US government’s unethical disregard for the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe’s treaty rights spelled out by the Fort Laramie Treaty, the memorandum released by the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) of the US stating that the records produced by the then President-elect’s Transition Team (PETT) will be considered private and restricted instead of being publicly available as they usually are [3][4][5].
Archives as evidence can have powerful outcomes for those who utilize them in legal affairs. But, the conceptual stillness of archives as evidence does not always represent the truth or at least not the whole truth. Documentary truths are not all truths. A document that is accurate, as in, it is produced by and when it says it was created, does not mean it resides outside of the realm of human processes and intentions. Rather, it is an indication of those human processes and intentions. Archives can promote social justice and injustice, sometimes simultaneously.
Archives are contingent on the nature of their creation, preservation, and dissemination. The criteria determining each set of actions and procedures is inherently historical, cultural, and political. Verne Harris writes, “an archive is a sliver of a sliver of a sliver of a window of a process” [6]. No archive preserves all the records of everyone, leading to inherent omissions from the public record and raising questions about who gets to decide what shall be saved.
Archives are select records decidedly put aside for future reference - a very small sliver of a complex result of context, narratives, and production. Rodney Carter writes “archival power is, in part, the power to allow voices to be heard… The power of the archive is witnessed in the act of inclusion… (but also) the power to exclude. Inevitably, there are distortions, omissions, erasures, and silences in the archive. Not every story is told” [7].
Community archives are an extremely important infrastructure and public service to the community it serves and more. When large or institutional archives fail to represent communities who are marginalized by race, class, sexuality, gender, and politics, communities themselves will often create their own archives outside the boundaries of the formalized institution. Often, with the grassroots labor of devoted volunteers and limited staff. These valuable community archives come in many forms and can counteract the way their community is represented by the mainstream archival, historical, political, and social discourse. Communities can include artist-run centres, LGBTQ+ initiatives, racialized peoples, independent collectors with specialized interests, religious centres, geographic and/or rural communities, cultural associations, political and activist movements, and survivors of atrocities. Creating an archive can then become a political and reflexive act; by constantly repositioning collecting and descriptive strategies with the needs of the community in mind, archives can be used as a means to empower and construct one’s own identity.
Archives themselves are not necessarily powerful, it is how they are created, used, and received by people that is powerful. They are meaningful extensions of human interactions that allow or deny histories and futures. Archives should be “activated” by being used, promoted, and questioned.
Text
Anna Tidlund
Notes/Sources
[1] Michelle Caswell and Marika Cifor, “From Human Rights to Feminist Ethics: Radical Empathy in the Archives”, Archivaria 81, Spring (2016): p. 26.
[2] Terry Eastwood,”What is Archival Theory and Why is it Important?”, Archivaria 37, Spring (1994): p. 125.
[3] The BC Liberals staffer, George Steven Gretes, was fired and charged with wilfully making false statements to mislead, or attempting to mislead, under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. The crime led to the publication of Investigation Report F15-03 Access Denied: Record Retention and Disposal Practices of the Government of British Columbia that champions for The Duty to Document. The investigation was lead by Elizabeth Denham, Information and Privacy Commissioner for BC (now the Information Commissioner of the UK).
[4] In 1851 the (colonial) Treaty of Fort Laramie “legally” asserted that Standing Rock Sioux Tribe owned land, including the land west of the Missouri river. Shortly after the Treaty was signed, white settlers began to encroach further on Indigenous lands, sanctioned by the US Government without tribal approval. This disregard for Indigenous peoples and their rightful ownership to land was further provoked in 2016, when the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers granted authorization to the Dakota Access Pipeline without tribal consultation.
[5] On November 16, 2016 the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) issued public memorandum AC09.2017 stating that the Donald Trump’s (then) President-elect Transition Team (PETT) would not be considered Federal or Presidential records, but private materials. The result is that NARA is not required to collect or preserve records created by the PETT, denying access to these records for future reference.
[6] Verne Harris, “The Archival Sliver: Power, Memory, and Archives in South Africa”, Archival Science 2, (2002): p. 84.
[7] Rodney Carter, “Of Things Said and Unsaid: Power, Archival Silences, and Power in Silence”, Archivaria 61, Spring (2006): p. 216.
Image
Photo by Anna Tidlund, taken at the Western Front’s Videotape Archive (2016).













