Temporal Sovereignties: On Memory as the Future’s Ethical Demand
In dominant epistemological traditions, memory has been frequently treated as a passive storage system, a neural or archival mechanism through which the past is retrieved and brought to light in the present.
Photo by Pixabay on Pexels.com
Whether in Enlightenment empiricism or late-positivist cognitive psychology, memory is frequently reduced to a retrospective function: the recall of that…
Focus on the Fan-mily: Community Archiving and the Archive of Our Own
A five-part series on AO3 as a community archive, considering how archival theory and fandom history meet to create a ground-breaking fan archive experience like no other, and the possibilities this has for the archival profession moving forwards.
Full essay (with citations) here
Part I | Part II | Part IV | Part V
Part III - Chasing the Ephemeral: An Overview of Fan Archival Activities
To understand AO3’s insistence on enabling the creator with full power over their works, it is important to understand the fan culture and context that AO3 developed out of, as well as the complex history of fan archival activities. Since the early days of modern fan culture, with Star Trek fans in the 1960s, fan spaces have been a place of sub-culture and secrecy, with transformative works and fan fiction —the dominant form of record on AO3— being particularly revolutionary. Fan academics such as Abigail Derecho often identify fan fiction as a form of societal criticism, predominantly created by women and people from minority groups. Using fan fiction, fans from marginalized groups create content for themselves that reimagines the hierarchical and societal norms reflected in the original media and wrests control of storytelling and creativity away from mainstream capitalist studios and publishers. This content often contains themes and subjects considered counterculture or radical by mainstream society — for example, until very recently (and arguably in some corners still), this included any queer interpretations, feminist discourse, or erotica. At the same time, fans use the spaces in and around this content —the writer-reader relationship, the aggregation of stories with similar subjects, the use of particular tropes and specialized lingo— to create a community and culture that reflects their own, often marginalized, experiences. Particularly with the connectivity of the Internet, Abigail De Kosnik observes that digital fan fiction archives become “safe spaces” where fans with similar experiences can “come together, sharing ideas and experiences without fear of silencing.”
This “fear of silencing” has long plagued fan spaces and has come both from within and without communities. Throughout the 1970s and 1980s, fans largely shared their content through zines and amateur press associations, relying on conventions and meet ups to come together with other community members and distribute their work. With the advent of the Internet, fan communities —known as fandoms— began to attract a new and wider scope of members. Now younger fans, international fans, and even people who had never heard of fandom before, could connect with existing communities so long as they had access to an Internet connection. A fan scholar by the pseudonym of Versaphile observes that early digital sites were particularly ephemeral in nature — posts and discussions on forums had a lifespan of days or weeks, and it wouldn’t be until the mid-1990s that sites began retaining user content. Major archives dedicated to fan fiction began emerging in the mid 1990s, usually centred around stories from a single fandom. These early archives would perhaps be more recognizable to archival professionals — users posted their content or submitted them to the web archivist, who would format, file and preserve the materials they received in order to make them available to archive users. Creators could request that their content not be archived, or that their previously archived materials be deleted, but generally, archives retained their materials until they were dissolved or deleted.
While there were technical issues with these early archives, such as poor accessibility and search functionality, one of the greatest threats to these archives was the loss of their archivists. Once an archivist lost interest in the fandom, or was no longer able to manage the archive, the entire site could disappear as maintenance ceased, domains expired and were not renewed, and reorganization destroyed years of existing structure and links. This is a common concern with community archives, particularly those of the Do It Yourself variety — as Rebecka Sheffield observes, the loss of interest from archive members or the inability to maintain the existing collection has led to the disappearance of many archival projects. With the disappearance of each archive, years of fandom discussion, content, and community were lost forever, unless individual members made a special effort to preserve certain elements on their own ends. Fans began to learn an important lesson that would continue to shape fandom for years to come — their communities, the stories they created and shared, the unique fandom cultures and relationships that they had developed, even the shared memory of their own history, was only as stable and permanent as the whim and will of the site administrators.
As fans explored different methods of communication and content sharing into the early 2000s, the role of the administrator remained a question. Mailing lists centred around a particular theme, genre, or relationship provided a decentralized and highly tailored fandom experience at the cost of accessibility. Links to content were closed to non-members, who had to apply for membership with the list’s moderators just to access a single story, and moderators had the power to delete entire lists whenever they pleased, thereby deleting all the works preserved within. The popular journaling website LiveJournal dominated fandom communities through the early 2000s, granting creators seemingly exclusive control over their own content. Creators could make their journals public or private, and rename, hide or delete them altogether. Accessibility remained an issue: content was poorly and inconsistently tagged, the search function was nigh non-existent, and users had to develop through experience a knowledge of which journals might contain content they were interested in and what terms a creator might use to describe their work. Although some users began developing general guides for creators to describe and tag their work, compliance with these guides depended on the individual creator. With the rise of the creator’s autonomy over their own work came issues of organization and management, and the ever-present question about the preservation of content.
While fans wrestled with the question of intracommunity preservation, outside forces began emerging as threats to fandom communities and creators, as litigation, censorship, and commercialization began targeting fan spaces. In the late 2000s, LiveJournal saw several waves of migration to other sites as website staff began banning users en masse and taking down content which they judged to be immoral or illegal. These takedowns, supposedly aimed at sexual crimes, could affect any content that involved sex — from age-restricted adult fan fiction journals, to sexual assault survivors’ spaces, to queer fan fiction, which was seen as inherently sexual regardless of content. Similar censorship restrictions affected other popular fan hosting sites, such as Fanfiction.net, which was in many ways a precursor to AO3. As a centralized, multi-fandom site with a relatively organized structure, Fanfiction.net provided fan creators with the ability to format and post their own stories in one place, and enabled users to find and access those stories with comparative ease using a controlled vocabulary with its descriptive elements. However, throughout the mid-2000s to the early 2010s, the website began imposing restrictions on the kind of content that fans could publish. Adult fan fiction was banned, as was any content which could potentially result in litigation from a studio, publishing company, or author. Creators issued lengthy disclaimers with each post, making it clear that they did not own the original media or characters on which their fan work was based. It was vital that no one could argue in court that they had given any impression of owning the intellectual material, as there had been high profile cases of authors suing and harassing fan writers. Works containing quotations of more than a few lines, such as a stanza of a song or a paragraph from a book, ran the constant risk of sudden deletion by administrators. Users became increasingly disgruntled with the censorship and the constant fear of deletion by site staff.
The intrusion of mainstream capitalism also began to challenge the sub-culture of secret community that many fans had become used to. As “fandom” became increasingly prominent, corporations saw fan communities as a potential resource. For media companies, fan content produced through free fan labour increases the presence and reach of the original media. Popular fan sites were also profitable places for ads, and web servers and companies benefitted from the increased traffic. In the eyes of many fans, this was nothing short of exploitation. Coming from a strongly decentralized period in fan history, fan spaces were seen as personal and counterculture — fans made the content they wanted to consume for their communities, not for their own profit, and certainly not for the profit of large corporations. The increasing presence of commercial ads on fan sites such as Fanfiction.net was insulting, and the creation of the notorious FanLib.com in 2007 was even more so. If the presence of ads on sites like Fanfiction.net —where users feared that failing to write a clear enough disclaimer could be interpreted as an intent to profit by lawyers— was controversial, then FanLib, which was designed to profit off of fan fiction and which boasted paid promotions from media companies, was intolerable. The FanLib debacle was the last straw, and outraged fans, frustrated with censorship and corporate intrusion and the loss of communities and cultures over the years, began to organize.
It was against this backdrop that the OTW formed, and it was in light of these discussions around the preservation of fan culture and history, the questions of censorship and profit, and the rights of fans, that fans created AO3 in 2008, with the site going into open beta in 2009. Their rallying point was the idea of “owning the servers,” creating a centralized space controlled by fans where their communities and creators could exist in safety and stability, creating the content that they wanted without fear of deletion, censorship, or exploitation, which by its long-term preservation would help keep alive the fan cultures and communities that produced it. With personal experience in fandom and previous fan archival projects, AO3’s creators were familiar with what fans needed or looked for in an archival space. Accessibility was a must. To that end, AO3 maintains a highly sophisticated descriptive tagging system, with volunteer “tag wranglers” interpreting and linking unique creator tags with larger related tags, preserving the creator’s descriptive intent while facilitating access to their works. Autonomy was balanced with archival preservation — creators can submit and describe their works however they feel is best, and retain rights of deletion and anonymity, while leaving the archival work of preservation, management and accessibility to site volunteers. Crucially, and sometimes controversially, AO3 permits fan content containing any subject without fear of censorship or deletion. While users may submit complaints about individual works, and creators must still abide by the laws of their jurisdiction, AO3 enforces the rights of creators to create without fear of censorship or arbitrary deletion. AO3 also operates entirely as a noncommercial and nonprofit organization with no ads or user fees, relying on a fan volunteer staff and annual fundraising drives.
Despite all the answers AO3 proposes to issues such as fan preservation, censorship, accessibility, and rights, many questions remain from both an archival and a fannish perspective about AO3’s role and functions as a community archive. Just who is included in this community “of Our Own?” What kind of cultural memory is being preserved, and how? What is included and what is left out? How does AO3’s commitment to freedom of the author relate to offensive content? If the subculture being documented in these records is, by nature, counterculture, why seek legitimacy from mainstream institutions? And in what ways does AO3 actually serve its users as a community archive, apart from making it easier to find a good read for a few hours?
Part III Sources
De Kosnik, Abigail. Rogue Archives: Digital Cultural Memory and Media Fandom. Cambridge, Massachusetts: The MIT Press, 2016.
Derecho, Abigail. “Archontic literature: a definition, a history, and several theories of fan fiction.” In Fan Fiction and Fan Communities in the Age of the Internet, edited by Hellekson K and Busse K. Jefferson, NC: McFarland. Quoted in A. Lothian, “Archival Anarchies: Online Fandom, Subcultural Conservation, and the Transformative Work of Digital Ephemera,” International Journal of Cultural Studies 16, no. 6 (2013): 545. Accessed December 10, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1177/1367877912459132
Johnson, Shannon Fay. "Fan Fiction Metadata Creation and Utilization within Fan Fiction Archives: Three Primary Models." Transformative Works and Cultures, no. 17 (2014). Accessed December 10, 2020. http://dx.doi.org/10.3983/twc.2014.0578.
Lothian, Alexis. “Archival Anarchies: Online Fandom, Subcultural Conservation, and the Transformative Work of Digital Ephemera.” International Journal of Cultural Studies 16, no. 6 (2013): 541–56. Accessed December 10, 2020. https://doi.org/10.1177/1367877912459132
Sheffield, Rebecka. “Community Archives.” In Currents of Archival Thinking, 2nd ed., edited by Heather MacNeil and Terry Eastwood, 351-376. Santa Barbara: Libraries Unlimited, 2017.
“Strikethrough and Boldthrough.” Fanlore. Accessed December 10, 2020. https://fanlore.org/wiki/Strikethrough_and_Boldthrough
Versaphile. “Silence in the Library: Archives and the Preservation of Fannish History.” In "Fan Works and Fan Communities in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction," edited by Nancy Reagin and Anne Rubenstein, special issue, Transformative Works and Cultures, no. 6. (2011). Accessed December 10, 2020. https://doi.org/10.3983/twc.2011.0277.
“Archives have the capacity to produce and reproduce social justice and injustice through their constructions of the past, engagements in the present, and shaping of possible futures” - Michelle Caswell and Marika Cifor [1]
The word “archive” has many meanings. Archive(s) can refer to a place, a repository where records are kept. Archives can refer to material, historical documents, personal and community belongings. To archive can be a verb, used to describe the transfer of records. Archives can refer to computer data. They can come in any shape or form and contain records of past actions so that we may reference them in the future. The concepts and definitions of “record” are constantly challenged and debated even within the archival profession.
Terry Eastwood states “the roots of archival theory may be traced to certain ancient legal and administrative principles. In order to conduct affairs, and in the course of conducting affairs, certain documents are created to capture the facts of the matter of action for future reference, to extend memory of deeds and actions of all kinds, to make it enduring” [2]. Archives can be considered monuments to the past because records were produced by specific entities during their activities under certain conditions. They can therefore attest to those recorded “acts” and “facts”. It is because archives provide an unbroken chain of custody, in a protected setting where corruption or falsification is difficult, that they can be deemed trustworthy and reliable.
The concept of archives and records being trustworthy and reliable is deeply important for the idea of evidence and the demonstration of accountability. We can hold people, corporations, and governments to account by exercising our right to view information produced by them to confirm that they act how they purport to act. This can be an important tool in rendering social justice, exercising rights, and maintaining fiduciary trust. We can see how people, corporations, and governments deny transparency by destroying, restricting, or simply not producing their records. We see this in the BC government’s intentional deletion of emails relating to the Highway of Tears, the US government’s unethical disregard for the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe’s treaty rights spelled out by the Fort Laramie Treaty, the memorandum released by the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) of the US stating that the records produced by the then President-elect’s Transition Team (PETT) will be considered private and restricted instead of being publicly available as they usually are [3][4][5].
Archives as evidence can have powerful outcomes for those who utilize them in legal affairs. But, the conceptual stillness of archives as evidence does not always represent the truth or at least not the whole truth. Documentary truths are not all truths. A document that is accurate, as in, it is produced by and when it says it was created, does not mean it resides outside of the realm of human processes and intentions. Rather, it is an indication of those human processes and intentions. Archives can promote social justice and injustice, sometimes simultaneously.
Archives are contingent on the nature of their creation, preservation, and dissemination. The criteria determining each set of actions and procedures is inherently historical, cultural, and political. Verne Harris writes, “an archive is a sliver of a sliver of a sliver of a window of a process” [6]. No archive preserves all the records of everyone, leading to inherent omissions from the public record and raising questions about who gets to decide what shall be saved.
Archives are select records decidedly put aside for future reference - a very small sliver of a complex result of context, narratives, and production. Rodney Carter writes “archival power is, in part, the power to allow voices to be heard… The power of the archive is witnessed in the act of inclusion… (but also) the power to exclude. Inevitably, there are distortions, omissions, erasures, and silences in the archive. Not every story is told” [7].
Community archives are an extremely important infrastructure and public service to the community it serves and more. When large or institutional archives fail to represent communities who are marginalized by race, class, sexuality, gender, and politics, communities themselves will often create their own archives outside the boundaries of the formalized institution. Often, with the grassroots labor of devoted volunteers and limited staff. These valuable community archives come in many forms and can counteract the way their community is represented by the mainstream archival, historical, political, and social discourse. Communities can include artist-run centres, LGBTQ+ initiatives, racialized peoples, independent collectors with specialized interests, religious centres, geographic and/or rural communities, cultural associations, political and activist movements, and survivors of atrocities. Creating an archive can then become a political and reflexive act; by constantly repositioning collecting and descriptive strategies with the needs of the community in mind, archives can be used as a means to empower and construct one’s own identity.
Archives themselves are not necessarily powerful, it is how they are created, used, and received by people that is powerful. They are meaningful extensions of human interactions that allow or deny histories and futures. Archives should be “activated” by being used, promoted, and questioned.
Text
Anna Tidlund
Notes/Sources
[1] Michelle Caswell and Marika Cifor, “From Human Rights to Feminist Ethics: Radical Empathy in the Archives”, Archivaria 81, Spring (2016): p. 26.
[2] Terry Eastwood,”What is Archival Theory and Why is it Important?”, Archivaria 37, Spring (1994): p. 125.
[3] The BC Liberals staffer, George Steven Gretes, was fired and charged with wilfully making false statements to mislead, or attempting to mislead, under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. The crime led to the publication of Investigation Report F15-03 Access Denied: Record Retention and Disposal Practices of the Government of British Columbia that champions for The Duty to Document. The investigation was lead by Elizabeth Denham, Information and Privacy Commissioner for BC (now the Information Commissioner of the UK).
[4] In 1851 the (colonial) Treaty of Fort Laramie “legally” asserted that Standing Rock Sioux Tribe owned land, including the land west of the Missouri river. Shortly after the Treaty was signed, white settlers began to encroach further on Indigenous lands, sanctioned by the US Government without tribal approval. This disregard for Indigenous peoples and their rightful ownership to land was further provoked in 2016, when the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers granted authorization to the Dakota Access Pipeline without tribal consultation.
[5] On November 16, 2016 the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) issued public memorandum AC09.2017 stating that the Donald Trump’s (then) President-elect Transition Team (PETT) would not be considered Federal or Presidential records, but private materials. The result is that NARA is not required to collect or preserve records created by the PETT, denying access to these records for future reference.
[6] Verne Harris, “The Archival Sliver: Power, Memory, and Archives in South Africa”, Archival Science 2, (2002): p. 84.
[7] Rodney Carter, “Of Things Said and Unsaid: Power, Archival Silences, and Power in Silence”, Archivaria 61, Spring (2006): p. 216.
Image
Photo by Anna Tidlund, taken at the Western Front’s Videotape Archive (2016).
The creation of archives is part and parcel of how we produce and legitimize knowledge and make our voices audible in the public sphere. Rather than a destination for knowledge already produced or a place to recover histories and ideas placed under erasure, making archives is frequently where our knowledge production begins. Perhaps, more surprisingly, for many feminists of my generation, the archive is also a site of pleasure and even entertainment. As one of the doctoral students I met at the conference explained, her archives are both her “porn” and the “legitimate” objects of inquiry at the center of her dissertation research.
Kate Eichhorn, “D.I.Y. Collectors, Archiving Scholars , and Activist Librarians: Legitimizing Feminist Knowledge and Cultural Production Since 1990,” Women’s Studies 39 (2010): 622–646, 625.
Not to care about archives is not to care about basing thought and action on evidence and knowledge, to be careless of precise memory of events, and to limit one’s ability to access a wider sphere of experience than one alone possesses.
Terry Eastwood, “How Goes it With Appraisal?”, Archivaria 36 (Autumn 1993), p.113.