Unpopular opinion here, but am I the only one that loves the original overlays for good and wicked witches? I love the fact that they're references to the Wizard of Oz, and I also like the idea of wicked witches being "punished" by getting hideous green skin that represents their sins and envy.
Default overlays for witches usually are under-stated, less bold, but The Sims 2's greatest feature is its exaggerated and over-the-top humour! Why make it LESS crazy?















