to the boys i’ve crushed on .ᐟ k.hj, j.yh, j.wy, p.sh
.ᐟ you’ve always been something of a hopeless romantic, even more so than you are a stumbling social disaster, which is saying something. you fall easily for four guys around campus and of course, because your luck is just that great, the sappy love letters you wrote to each of them end up delivered and send your usually uneventful life spinning into total chaos.
.ᐟ part one (~15k) | part two | part three | part four
.ᐟ music major!hongjoong x fem!reader, brother’s best friend!seonghwa x fem!reader, tutor!yunho x fem!reader, baseball golden boy!wooyoung x fem!reader
.ᐟ eventual smut minors dni 18+ | cursing, drinking, marijuana usage, shy!reader, reader can give second hand embarrassment but we love her anyway
.ᐟ this is my first ever attempt at a fic this size and it is NOT proofread but i’m super excited! highly inspired by the many masterpieces thanks to lovely writers participating in @sungbeam’s college au collab, but (not to spoil anything), one of the plot lines is loosely inspired specifically by @minkieater’s dare! sorry to tag you both, just think you both deserve recognition <3 anyway i love this fic a lot so far it’s my baby and i can’t wait to continue our reader’s story 🥹
For as long as you could remember, you lived more in your head than in the real world. You prefer the version of things in your imagination as opposed to real life. In your daydreams, you could be the charismatic and charmingly clumsy romance protagonist you always yearned to be; the effortlessly beautiful main character who puppy-eyed love interests fawn over.
It was easier that way, and a hell of a lot more enjoyable than your dull life as an invisible, broke college student. You’ve never really had a knack for social interaction, or as your brother, San, would say when he thought you were in a better mood than usual to accept his teasing, ‘biologically adverse to friends’.
A statement which you found cruel, in the kind of way that the things older brothers say are always cruel, but he’s not wrong. You really are probably the closest example this world has of someone ‘biologically adverse to friends’. Your pauses always run too long, your sentences tangle halfway through, and by the time you figure out what you should have said, the moment has already passed, sealed off and unreachable, condemning you to live with the shame of the interaction.
In your head, though, everything waits for you — for your thoughts and your dreams, for you to build worlds with your fantasies.
There, you can take a feeling and turn it over slowly, examine it from every angle, soften its edges until it becomes something worth holding onto. Conversations don’t slip away there. You can be better there — wittier, warmer, easier to love. You can be someone who doesn’t second-guess every word before it leaves her mouth, because unlike in the real world, nothing ever leaves before it’s ready.
It’s a big part of the reason you’ve always loved romance the way you do; quietly, obsessively, even a little desperately. Not the kind of romance in real life, with its awkward starts and complicated, messy endings, but the kind that unfolds over a two-hour-and-twenty-minute runtime, flawless and soft and never-ending.
But life can’t be as perfect as it is in your mind, so you’re in your dorm on a Friday night while your roommate is across the room getting ready for some frat party — you wish you could recall the name of the frat, but that’s just how little social presence you have.
You sit at the edge of your bed, laptop balanced carefully over your knees, the glow of the screen washing everything in that familiar pale blue. It reads your English discussion post prompt back to you, the blinking cursor against the screen serving to indicate that you’ve written absolutely nothing since you sat down to complete this twenty minutes ago. Outside your dorm window, someone laughs and you feel that small, humbling ache that you’ve felt all day.
Nothing specifically upsetting happened, but nothing needed to. Sometimes you just have days like this, where your lonely lifestyle catches up to you and reminds you that you’re just a girl in her room, dreaming of a life where she isn’t.
And when the ache gets like this — dull, stifling, impossible to ignore — you fall back on the one thing that has never made you feel out of place.
Your letters.
Your eyes linger on the blank discussion post for a few seconds longer than necessary, the cursor blinking like it’s waiting for you to become someone else — maybe someone more articulate, more motivated, more capable of existing in the world without overthinking every breath. But you don’t write anything in the box, instead clicking off to your drive.
Your fingers move with a quiet kind of familiarity, opening a folder you’ve never named.
You don’t remember exactly when you started writing these helplessly cliche, embarrassingly smitten letters, only that at some point, putting the feelings somewhere outside of yourself became easier than carrying them around all the time.
They were safer than real conversations, where your words tangle and your voice comes out too quiet, where eye contact feels like standing in direct sunlight for too long — less humiliating than having to admit that you’re a real human, with real feelings, for people with lives so much bigger than your own, so much less pathetic than the hermit life you live.
So far, there’s four of these love letters with sweet ‘Dear, name’s and ‘Sincerely, _____’s addressed to boys across the campus, some of which you’ve shared more words with than others.
Your cursor hovers over the preview of the letters, the cute digitally decorated docs, their names staring back at you like an accusation:
Kim Hongjoong, the effortlessly talented music major, who you hid out with during your first — and last — frat party during freshman year, utterly embarrassed yourself in front of with stuttered inquiries of ‘s-so, what’re you into?’, and then stared dumbly at when he returned the question, because, really, what are you into? It’s not like you could say ‘oh yeah, I love pretending I’m a loveable romcom protagonist because my life is so insufferably boring.’ You sat there with him for a while attempting to be halfway decent at conversation until his friend (you think he was called Mingi?) poked his head in the room with a sighed ‘there you are, hyung’ and dragged him out to actually enjoy the party. Hongjoong didn’t leave the room without sending you a charming, apologetic smile and a soft ‘bye’ that made your heart flutter and haunted your dreams for at least a few weeks.
Jung Wooyoung, the star golden boy of the university’s baseball team, the kind of guy every girl dreamed of having because he was just that handsome and charismatic and easy to love. Honestly, you’ve never spoken a word to the guy, but you always hear the girls gushing over him behind you in your foreign language class, and come on, a hopeless romantic like you was always destined to harbor a crush on the gorgeous, reportedly hilarious campus jock. He was practically an antisocial romcom fiend’s wet dream.
Jeong Yunho, your soft-spoken economics tutor whose nervous nature almost rivaled yours, except his motivation to teach you outweighed his awkwardness. He always leans a smidge too far into your space for your delusional, making-up-romance-where-there-isn’t-any imagination to let slide, encouraging you to keep trying and softly correcting you when you mark something wrong. He’s never as disappointed as he is expectant, quietly waiting for you to fix your mistakes because he knows you have the capability to ace it. He even usually throws in a couple muttered ‘good’s or ‘there you go’s in a probably unintentionally sultry manner that gives you butterflies. You don’t even blame yourself for your crush on him, you’re sure any girl would develop one.
And last but not least, Park Seonghwa, arguably the most controversial non-recipient of your letters. Because he wasn’t just some one-off meet-cute, he was your brothers best friend, and more than just knowing you actually existed, he knew all the embarrassing, stumbling, ugly parts of you and still hung around — whether that’s because you were near your brother or not is entirely irrelevant.
All of your feelings for these men were real, you knew that better than anything else. They were the kind of crushes that reach right through your ribcage and clutch your heart, leaving your breath seizing; the kinds of crushes that linger on your mind all day, not once forgotten in the chaos of the day.
Still, you know it’s a little silly for you to be so smitten over these men, some of which you have hardly even spoken with, or at all. But they’re all undoubtedly handsome men, and you are one undoubtedly hopeless girl when it comes to crushing.
“Babe, you’re really sure you don’t wanna come to this thing?” Your roommate, Nakyung, pouts at you from across the room, pulling a mesh jersey over her head. Her boyfriend, Yeosang, is on the football team, hence her choosing to wear the green and white jersey even though it clashes with her skirt, “I promise you’ll have fun!”
You look to your laptop and shut it in an intentional manner before sighing, “I dunno, Kyung… last time I went to one of those, I kinda just… hung around.”
“What else do you think people do at parties?” She huffs even though she knows that’s not what you mean, leaning over in front of her floor-length mirror to apply lipgloss.
“I dunno, like… talk? Mingle? Kiss?” Your suggestion comes only from the knowledge of how parties usually go in the movies.
Nakyung exhales heavily, finally turning to you, “Whatever, forget that. The point is, you’re so sheltered that it’s getting kind of sad, girl.” She closes the distance between you, grabbing your wrists and insistently pulling you to your feet, “Come on, babe, let’s just let you have one night of fun before you go back in your shell. Please?”
“Kyung, I—“
“I’m your roommate, it’s my campus-issued responsibility to make sure you have a social life!” She frowns, reaching to press her hands to your shoulders as if she was a second away from shaking you. “What class are you so busy with on a Friday anyway?—“ She drops her ringed hands and turns to your laptop, arms extending toward it.
Cold panic floods you at the thought of Nakyung seeing all your cutesy, delusional love letters, “Don’t!” You scramble forward, snatching it from the pillow it was perched on and clutching it to your chest.
For a moment, Nakyung’s hands freeze in the air where she had been reaching, then she blinks at you, eyebrow raising. “What’re you hiding?” She always knew you were glued to that laptop, but she just assumed you were really diligent in your studies. You look the part, anyway, dressed in your beige sweaters and skirts layered with leggings and those glasses you’re always adjusting.
“Nothing, I just… I’m, um. It’s for…” You swallow your saliva, lips clicking as you try to steady your voice so it doesn’t raise an octave. If you weren’t awkward and stuttering before, you’re definitely accomplishing it easily now thanks to the need to lie, “I’m… I’m not proud of what I have now for the discussion post in English.”
Nakyung doesn’t buy it for a second, because who would? “Uh huh… right. If you say so, babe.” The ravenette huffs slightly, shoulders raising, lips pulling into a pout once again, “Seriously, _____, if you do this, I’ll buy you that banana milk you love so much, for, like, the whole week. And I bet you’ll have so much fun you’ll just be begging me to take you to another.”
“That’s very unlikely — like, the probability is zilch.” You mutter, fingers picking at a small piece of rubber coming from the laptop feet as you hold it to your chest. You draw in a shaky breath. What’s the worst that can happen? Surely it can’t be worse than having to pay for your own banana milk everyday of next week. Still, you hesitate. Last time you went to one of these parties, you sat out in one of the frat brother’s rooms with Kim Hongjoong, and that had you practically hearing wedding bells. What if you go out tonight just to fall in love with some other charming musician? Four love letters was already getting a little greedy, but five? It’s pushing it, no?
But honestly, you really do love those banana milks and you tell yourself that to avoid getting all starry-eyed, you can just make sure you don’t get into any one-on-ones with cute guys. Besides, cute guys weren’t exactly lining up to get you in a room alone. You worry the inside of your cheek with your molars before you reluctantly agree, “But… fine. Just this once, I mean it, okay?”
Nakyung squeals out a high-pitched cheer, “Yay! Oh my gosh, I’m getting _____ out of the house! I must be dreaming!” She giggles softly, turning too quickly on her heel and stumbling before she regains her footing, walking over to her closet, “Gotta find you something to wear!”
“Um, wait, Nakyung, I think I’m just gonna go in this—“ You start, fidgeting with the sleeves of your oversized sweater that dwarf your hands.
“No way! You need to look hot! If this is the only party you’re ever going to, I might as well make the most of it and finally get you a boyfriend, yeah?“ She insists while she digs through her closet, fingers swiping hangers aside as she looks for what can only be just the thing she has in mind. Finally, she pulls out a hanger from which a fitted black lace camisole dangles. It’s semi-sheer, giving it that soft, romantic texture while still feeling bold, and she tosses it on the bed as she continues the search for the skirt she’s thinking of. “I can introduce you to the football guys, Yeo would probably do it happily!”
Nakyung finally fishes out a black miniskirt, humming to herself in victory as she bundles the hangers and outstretches them to you. She sees your troubled expression and pouts, “Come on, please? Just trust me.”
If there’s one thing you learned about your only real friend (even though technically she’s more of a roommate who gives you the time of day), it’s that she’s very hard to say no to, with her sweet puppy-eyes and pouty glossed lips.
“…Fine, but only if I can wear my cardigan over it.”
Nakyung pulls you forward by your hand a little faster than your feet were ready for, beaming with delight as she walks up to the door. As you cross the threshold, the bass from whatever playlist someone threw on pulses through the walls and floor. You’re wearing the outfit Nakyung picked out for you, and you would have felt uncomfortably out of place in it if it weren’t for the black cardigan you’d convinced Nakyung to let you wear over it. To compromise, even though she was already the one getting her way, Nakyung insisted you wear these tights that make a pretty lace design run down your legs. Honestly, they were pretty cute and probably something you’d usually wear on your own, but the way they mesh with this outfit makes the whole thing feel a little bolder than you’re used to dressing. Nakyung seems happy with her work, though.
She maneuvers the two of you throughout the crowd, head on a swivel as she looks for the blond head of her boyfriend. Finally, she spots him, shouting a little too loud for your comfort to grab his attention, “Yeo!”
He turns as you two approach, a smile pulling at the corners of his mouth, “Hey, baby. And _____, right?” Nakyung cuddles up to his side, a much bigger lover of PDA than Yeosang is, clearly, but he’s so head-over-heels for her that he sucks it up.
Yeosang has only been to your dorm a few times to pick up Nakyung and once to watch a movie with her on the living room couch, but that’s enough for the two of you to be acquainted well enough. You always thought he was nice and super sweet to Nakyung, in the lead love interest kind of way; doting on her everyday and showering her in affection even if PDA wasn’t his thing, all just because it was Nakyung’s love language.
You nod at his question, but before you can even try to reply verbally, Nakyung is clinging on your arm now instead, turning her puppy eyes to Yeosang, “Baby, do you think you could introduce _____ to some of the guys? Maybe one of them will like her!”
Yeosang knew very well of his girlfriend’s matchmaking tendencies, and his face twists into a soft, amused smile, “‘Course, baby. I think most of them are outside around the fire pit.” He shrugs before he swivels on his heel and starts advancing toward the patio’s sliding doors, and Nakyung is quick to pull you along in the same direction.
You’re maneuvered through clusters of people until you all stop at the fire pit, the orange firelight casting a glow onto the face of everyone sitting around it. You quickly count 5 people around the fire, but one stood out: the Jung Wooyoung in the flesh, leaned back in the seat with his legs spread, red solo cup held on his thigh by his hand. You breath seizes in your chest in that typical way it always does when you even just think about your crushes.
“Hey guys, had someone I wanted to introduce you to,” Yeosang motions you over, and Nakyung nudges you in that direction before he continues, “This is _____, Nakyung’s roommate. She’s cool.”
You offer a small wave, not trusting your voice to come out smoothly, and a few of the guys around the fire snicker at you. Anxiety bubbles in your chest — what’s so funny?
“Cute,” a voice appears on your right, and you turn again to see Wooyoung looking at you. Oh my god, Jung Wooyoung was actually looking at you. More than that, he was… complimenting you?
“U-um…” You start, glossed lips opening and closing like a fish. Wooyoung doesn’t let you flounder for long, an amused smirk tugging at the right corner of his mouth that either says ‘you’re adorable’ or ‘your awkwardness is hilarious’. You’re not sure which of those would embarrass you more.
“Come on, sit with us for a minute,” he pats the chair next to him, looking back up to you expectantly.
You have half the mind to refuse and save yourself the embarrassment, but Nakyung grins at you and gently pushes you forward to accept the offer. “We’ll be right back, _____, just gonna get some drinks!” She sends you a not-so-subtle wink, clearly expecting that one of these guys is going to be your prince charming.
But who is she kidding, really? You can’t really hold a conversation without a hitch, and this is Jung Wooyoung you’re talking about: the guy you’ve been silently crushing on since freshman year, wide-eyed admiration clear on your face as you’d watch him come into your econ class, always a little too late to be acceptable.
Eventually, realizing Wooyoung’s eyes are expectant as he looks at you, you finally lower yourself into the cushioned patio seat, back rigid. Luckily, most of the other guys around the pit seem to have continued their conversations amongst themselves, except Wooyoung, who looks at you in a way that sends the butterflies fluttering around in your stomach. You immediately resort to fidgeting with your ring, spinning it in place around your finger.
A hand comes to rest over yours, and when you look up to see who it belongs to, your heart nearly stops. Wooyoung’s leaned closer to you, teasing grin settled on his face in a way that makes his asymmetrical eyes crinkle. His dark hair comes down to his eyebrows, styled a little too perfectly to seem effortless, but it’s nice nonetheless. He’s gorgeous, you think, and he’s touching you.
“What’re you fidgeting for? C’mon, you gotta lighten up a little, _____,” He takes his hand from yours before he extends his cup to you, waiting for your tentative hand to take it. You don’t mean to, but you think you give him an unsure look because he laughs softly and shakes the cup in his hand slightly to urge you to take it, “Come on, it’s not that bad. Trust me, will you?”
With a small sound in the back of your throat, you realize this is probably something that your elementary school teacher would dub ‘peer-pressure’, but you also realize you don’t care about anything in the world right now other than pleasing Wooyoung.
You take the cup from his grip, glancing down to the liquid inside before Wooyoung reaches over to press two fingers to the bottom of the cup as if to tip it into your mouth. He didn’t actually, though, only urging you to stop overthinking and take a drink.
The liquid burns as it goes down and you cough slightly, fist coming to cover your mouth. Wooyoung chuckles at you, nodding and saying ‘there you go’ in that flustering way that reminds you of Yunho. Wait, why are you thinking of Yunho right now when Wooyoung is right in front of you, actually talking to you?
“See, now you’ll stop fidgeting and actually talk to me, won’t you?” His grin is lopsided as he leans back into his own seat, fingers idly dancing across the wooden armrest.
“Um, I guess so. S-so, are you on the football team with Yeosang?” You ask dumbly, a question you already know the answer to but one that you hope makes it seem like you haven’t been obsessed with him since freshman year.
His nose scrunches up at that, a small, amused scoff falling from his lips, “Hell no. Do I really look like a football guy?” He doesn’t give you time to answer before he continues, “I’m on the baseball team, pitcher. You should come to our first game of the season next week, see a real pro in action.”
Oh my god, is this real? Are you really getting a personal invite to the baseball game from Jung Wooyoung? You’ve never really been a sports person, but the invite coming from him made you more excited than a diehard fan getting lower bowl seats to a pro game.
Still, you try your best to act natural, “Um, yeah, okay. I’ll see.”
“You’ll see? You gonna leave me hanging, tiny?”
“W-Well, I—“
“Jung Wooyoung!”
Your mouth snap shut and you turn to the source of the very angry sounding exclamation. One of the girls you recognize from your math course storms over, you think her name is Karina? She stops in front of you and Wooyoung and huffs petulantly, “Seriously? We’re only broken up for a day and you’re already flirting with other girls?”
Wooyoung looks largely unbothered by the whole fiasco, “We were just talking, Rina.” He slides further down in the chair, the picture of indifference. His hands slide across his jean-clad thighs as he weighs his next words, shrugging, “Besides, you broke up with me, didn’t you? I’m free game.”
Karina gapes at him, as if she truly couldn’t believe her ears, “That’s—“ Her retort dies on her tongue as she stares at Wooyoung before her eyes slide over to you.
Her gaze lingers, dragging over you slow and deliberate, taking in everything from the cardigan you’re clutching tighter around yourself to the way you’re sitting just a little too stiffly beside him. You feel it immediately, that familiar, sinking awareness that you don’t belong in this scene the way everyone else does.
“Oh,” she says, and there’s something sharp tucked into that single syllable, something that makes your shoulders instinctively draw in. “So this is what you’re doing.”
You don’t know what to say to that. You don’t even know if she’s talking to you or at you or through you, and your mouth opens slightly before closing again, your grip tightening around the cup in your hands.
Wooyoung exhales, long and unimpressed. “Rina, don’t start.”
“I’m not starting anything,” she snaps, even though she very clearly is. Her arms cross over her chest, her attention still fixed on you like you’re part of the problem just by being here. “I just didn’t think you’d move on this fast. Guess I overestimated you.”
“I haven’t ‘moved on,’” he replies, tone flattening slightly. “We’re just talking.”
“Yeah,” she scoffs, rolling her eyes. “Looks like it.”
The conversation spirals around you, tension building in a way that makes your chest feel tight. You can feel the other guys around the fire quieting down, their attention shifting over in that subtle, curious way people do when something uncomfortable starts unfolding.
You don’t know what to do. You’re just sitting there, holding a drink that isn’t yours and wearing clothes that don’t feel like you, being glared at by someone who clearly wishes you weren’t here.
“I—I should probably—” you start, voice small, barely cutting through the space between them.
“No, wait—“ Wooyoung starts, only to be interrupted by Karina.
She laughs, short and disbelieving, before shaking her head. “You know what? Whatever. Do what you want.” Her eyes flick to you one last time, and there’s something dismissive in it now, something that stings more than it should. “Enjoy… whatever this is.” Then she turns, walking off with the kind of finality that would make you worry if you were Wooyoung.
There’s a beat of silence before Wooyoung sighs again, dragging a hand through his hair like he’s trying to shake the whole thing off. “Sorry about that,” he mutters, glancing at you. “She’s just—”
“It’s okay,” you rush out, too quickly, too eager to smooth things over, even though nothing about it feels okay.
He studies you for a second, like he’s trying to decide whether to say something else, but then someone calls his name from across the yard, and his attention shifts just as easily as it had landed on you in the first place.
“I’ll be right back,” he says, already halfway out of his seat.
You’re left sitting there alone, the warmth from the fire suddenly feeling too much against your skin, the noise of the party creeping back in now that the moment has dissolved into nothing.
Of course. Of course your only interaction with Wooyoung ends like that. Just your luck.
You swallow, staring down at the drink in your hands. Your thoughts are already turning in on themselves, replaying everything, picking it apart—what you said, what you didn’t say, how you looked, how you must have come across.
Your spiraling thoughts are only interrupted by some guy’s gasp as his foot snags on your chair’s leg as he walks. The entire front of your top is suddenly soaked, the liquid from his cup sloshing over the edge and spilling straight onto you, darkening the lace and clinging uncomfortably to your skin.
“Oh shit, sorry,” the guy mumbles, already half-turned away like he’s more focused on rejoining whatever conversation he was having than the mess he just made of you.
You sit there for half a second, stunned, holding your breath like if you just pretend you don’t exist it will undo itself. Then the embarrassment hits: hot, immediate, all-consuming.
“Oh my god,” you whisper under your breath, your free hand coming up instinctively like you can somehow hide it or fix it.
You can’t, of course you can’t, because your life fucking sucks.
Your chair scrapes softly against the ground as you stand too quickly, your heart pounding in your chest as you glance around, suddenly hyper-aware of everything; of how you must look, of the damp fabric clinging to you, of the possibility that anyone might be looking.
You swallow a pathetic sound threatening to crawl up your throat as you weave back through the crowd, movements quicker now, your head ducked slightly like that might make you less noticeable. The music feels louder than before, the air thicker, every laugh and voice scraping against your nerves as you push your way inside.
You keep your arms crossed tightly over yourself, cardigan pulled in as you spot the hallway and move toward it quickly, slipping into it as if it were some kind of escape. You open the first door you see, you don’t even check, pushing it open and stepping inside.
The smell hits you first, undoubtedly weed. You freeze in place, eyes wide as you stare at the scene in front of you. “Oh,” the sound slips out before you can stop it.
He’s leaning against the counter, one shoulder resting lazily against it, a joint held between his fingers. The faint glow at the tip flickers in the dim light, smoke curling upward in slow, lazy spirals.
Kim Hongjoong. Of course, because apparently, if the night was going to go wrong, it was going to go all the way.
His eyes flick up at the sound of your voice, landing on you almost immediately. There’s a brief pause as he takes you in, a flicker of recognition in his eyes before it’s overwhelmed by what you think is confusion as he looks at your outfit. “You’re soaked.”
For a second, you just stand there, like if you don’t move, don’t speak, don’t breathe too loudly, maybe the situation will dissolve on its own and you won’t have to participate in it.
After it doesn’t, you draw in a shaky breath, “…Yeah,” you manage, voice small and uneven, your grip tightening on the edges of your cardigan. “I, um— yeah.”
Brilliant. Truly articulate.
Hongjoong’s gaze lingers, not in a way that feels invasive, but in a way that makes you more aware of yourself — the damp lace clinging to your skin, the way your shoulders are hunched in, the fact that you probably look like you just crawled out of some kind of social disaster, which, to be fair, you did.
“…What happened?” he asks after a moment, tone casual, but there’s something quieter underneath it that you can’t place.
“Nothing,” you say quickly, too quickly to be natural. “Just—someone bumped into me.”
He just hums, like he doesn’t quite believe that that’s all but isn’t going to push. His fingers tap the side of the counter once, twice, before he reaches over and grabs something — paper towels, you realize a second later — and holds them out toward you. “Here,” he says simply.
You blink, staring dumbly for a minute before your brain finally catches up, “Oh—um, thanks,” you murmur, stepping forward just enough to take them, careful not to get too close. Your fingers brush his for half a second, and it’s enough to send that stupid, familiar flutter through your chest.
You dab awkwardly at the front of your top, which does absolutely nothing except make you more aware of how soaked it actually is. “Yeah, that’s not gonna fix it,” you mumble under your breath, more to yourself than to him.
There’s the faintest hint of a smile tugging at his mouth, “No,” he agrees, softer, “Probably not.”
Silence settles for a second, not yet awkward but you can feel it creeping in — that familiar pressure to fill it, to say something before it stretches too long and becomes another moment you’ll replay later, cringing at everything you didn’t say.
“Um…” Your brain scrambles. Hurry, say something. Say something normal, something casual, something that makes it seem like you’re not the same girl who completely blanked the last time you were alone with him. God, you hope he doesn’t remember that.
And right as the thought crosses your mind, like the universe is just out to make your life a living hell, he speaks up, “Hey, I remember you.”
Your stomach drops, and not in a dramatic, cinematic way, nothing quite that graceful, instead in that quiet, awful lurch that makes your thoughts scatter and your body go a little too still.
“Oh,” you say, because apparently that’s the only word you’re capable of producing tonight. Your fingers tighten slightly around the paper towels, the flimsy material crinkling under the pressure as your eyes flick down, then to the side, then anywhere that isn’t him. “Um… yeah.”
“Last year, right?” he adds, tilting his head slightly as he studies you. “That party upstairs. You were—” he hesitates, just briefly, like he’s choosing his words, “—in the spare room.” You suppose you can be grateful for his phrasing, not choosing to point out you were obviously hiding out from even the idea of social interaction.
Your face burns. It’s immediate, blooming heat that crawls up your neck and settles into your cheeks, because of course that’s how he remembers it — not your name, not anything meaningful, just the setting. “Yeah,” you confirm, softer this time, a little more resigned. “That was me.” You press the paper towels a little harder against your top, even though they’re already damp and useless, just to have something to do with your hands.
God. Why did you come tonight?
He nods once, slow, like that confirms something for him, before he takes another slow drag of his joint, flicking the ash onto a rolling tray. You glance down at the front of your top, at the way the lace has gone darker where it’s soaked, clinging in a way that makes you hyper-aware of your own body. Your fingers move again, dabbing uselessly.
His gaze follows the movement of your hands for a second, then lifts back to your face. “Didn’t think you’d come back to one of these,” he says.
“Me neither,” you reply quickly, the honesty spilling out before you can filter it. You huff out a quiet breath, shifting your weight where you stand. “My roommate made me.”
There’s a small sound of acknowledgment from him, and when you chance a look at his face there’s a small, entertained smile on his face. “Mm. Yeah, that tracks.”
He’s still leaning against the counter, posture loose, one shoulder resting back. The joint sits between his fingers, smoke curling upward in thin, lazy spirals, the faint scent of it mixing with whatever cheap soap lingers in the bathroom air. The dim light casts soft shadows along his features, catching in the slight tilt of his mouth, the line of his jaw.
He looks calm, unbothered, like the chaos of the party outside doesn’t even cross his mind in here. You wonder what that feels like.
“I, um…” you start again, and immediately regret it when he looks up at you expectantly. “I’m— sorry,” you land on, the word slipping out too easily, too familiar. “For, like… barging in. And ruining your…” your hand lifts slightly, gesturing vaguely toward the counter, the smoke, him, “…thing.”
There’s a beat, then he exhales a quiet breath through his nose, something just shy of a laugh, his head tilting back a fraction. “You didn’t ruin anything,” he assures, voice low. “It’s just a bathroom.”
“…Right,” you murmur, nodding even though you weren’t really expecting reassurance. You shift again, the damp fabric dragging slightly against your skin, and instinctively your arms pull in tighter around yourself, cardigan closing in like the shield you treat it as.
“You’re gonna freeze like that,” he points out, motioning towards your wet outfit.
“I’ll survive,” you reply quickly, almost automatic.
There’s a pregnant pause, then he speaks.
“Take it off.”
Your brain stutters, completely blank for half a second. Everything in your body stills, tensing up the way you usually did when someone says something unexpected, but a million times worse because this is one of your crushes. Did you hear that right? No, there’s no way you heard that right.
“…W-What?” you manage, voice small and meek.
His expression doesn’t change much, but there’s the faintest flicker of realization, like he’s just caught up to how that sounded. “The cardigan,” he clarifies, nodding toward it. “It’s wet too, right? It’s just gonna make it worse.”
Oh.
Heat floods your face all over again, somehow worse than before because now you’re acutely aware of everything; of how you must look, of how he must be seeing you, of the fact that you’re standing here dripping alcohol onto a frat house bathroom floor while talking to a guy you wrote an entire letter about.
“Right,” you mumble, the word coming out quieter than you mean it to, your gaze dropping to the darkened fabric clinging to you. You can feel it now that he’s pointed it out. You can feel the cold seeping in, the way the damp lace sticks uncomfortably against your skin, the cardigan doing nothing except trapping it there.
It would make sense to take it off, logically, practically, but taking it off means… being seen more. It means losing one more layer you’ve convinced yourself is saving you from scrutiny, even if it really isn’t doing that at all.
“I—no, it’s fine,” you manage quickly, shaking your head a little too fast. “I’m okay.”
He watches you for a second, then he shrugs like it’s not something worth arguing over, and shifts his attention back to the counter. His fingers reach for the joint again, lifting it with a practiced kind of absentmindedness. The ember glows faintly as he brings it to his lips, the inhale slow and steady in a way that matches the rest of him: unhurried, unbothered.
You watch without meaning to. It’s subtle, the way the smoke curls when he exhales, thin strands catching in the dim light before dissolving into the air. The scent thickens slightly, warm and hazy, wrapping around the small space of the bathroom until it feels even more removed from the chaos outside.
He glances at you through it, and your gaze snaps away a second too late, landing somewhere on the tiled floor, on the faint scuff marks and the edge of the sink. Anywhere that isn’t him.
“You smoke?” His question lands casually, like it doesn’t matter what your answer is. Your brain lags behind for a moment before you answer.
“Oh—um.” You blink, looking back up at him, caught somewhere between honesty and whatever version of yourself you think would sound better right now. “Not really.”
Not ever, actually.
You’ve thought about it, in that abstract, romanticized kind of way, like something that belongs in late-night scenes and quiet conversations, something people do when they’re effortlessly cool or a little bit broken in a way that still looks good on them.
He hums softly, like he expected that answer. “Figured,” he replied, but it didn’t feel judgmental. You think Hongjoong had a special kind of way of making whoever he’s talking to feel the furthest thing from scrutinized.
He takes another slow drag, then taps the ash off against the tray, “You can,” he adds after a second, lifting the joint slightly between his fingers in a small, almost-offhand gesture toward you, “If you want.”
Your heart stutters just slightly, enough to make your chest feel tight again, “I—” you start, then stop, because do you want to? You don’t even know, but what you do know is that this feels like something out of the kind of scenes you replay in your head. It’s the kind of moment where the main character says yes without overthinking it, leans into it, lets it become something she never thought she’d get to have.
You hesitate, fingers twitching slightly at your sides. “…I don’t really… know how,” you admit finally, voice softer now, a little more honest than you intended.
His mouth curves, just slightly, an endeared kind of smile. “It’s not hard,” he starts, tone easy and smooth. He steps a little closer, not enough to crowd you, just enough to close the distance in a way that makes your awareness spike again. “You just…” he lifts the joint slightly, gesturing, “don’t overthink it.”
You almost laugh at the irony. Don’t overthink it. That’s kind of your whole thing.
You hesitate another second, then, almost without fully deciding to, you shift your weight forward slightly. “Okay,” you utter, quieter than you mean to. Your hand lifts, tentative, hovering for just a second before you take it from him. Your fingers brush his again, warmer this time, or maybe you’re just more aware of it, and you swear your brain short-circuits for half a beat.
You bring it up awkwardly, unsure, glancing at him like you’re waiting for some kind of instruction. He just raises his eyebrows at you in a way that you think is probably more attractive than it should be, motioning his hand in a small gesture as if to say ‘well?’.
You try to mimic the effortless way he took his drag, but you inhale too quickly. The smoke hits your throat wrong, sharp and unfamiliar, and you cough — small at first, then a little harder, your free hand coming up to cover your mouth as your eyes squeeze shut instinctively. “Oh my god,” you rasp, voice breaking slightly as you try to recover, your whole face heating up again for an entirely new reason.
Great. Smooth, really smooth. Nice going.
There’s a small, quiet laugh from him, not cruel or loud. “Yeah,” his voice is almost a whisper, the curve of his smile making his voice come out sounding a little more tickled than he probably intended. He reaches out to take it back before you can accidentally drop it, “Maybe do overthink it a little.”
You let out a weak, breathless laugh, still coughing lightly as you shake your head. “I— yeah,” you manage, blinking a couple times as your eyes water slightly.
“First time?” he inquires, already knowing the answer.
You nod, still a little embarrassed, still very aware of yourself, but somehow, not in the same crushing, suffocating way as before.
“Yeah,” you admit, voice a little hoarse now, whether from the smoke or the embarrassment you’re not entirely sure. You clear your throat lightly, gaze dropping to the tiled floor for a second before flicking back up to him. “Was it that obvious?”
His mouth tilts again, that same almost-smile lingering, “A little.”
You huff out a small breath, something that might be a laugh if it had more confidence behind it, your shoulders lifting faintly before settling again.
He lets out another quiet breath through his nose, something just shy of amusement, before bringing the joint back up to his lips. This time, when he inhales, you watch more carefully, not in the same distracted, flustered way as before, but with something closer to curiosity.
You lean back a fraction against the door behind you without fully thinking about it, the cool surface grounding against your shoulder blades. The faint hum of music seeps through the walls, muffled now, distant enough that it feels like it belongs to a completely different place.
“…You always hide out in bathrooms?” you ask him after a moment, the question slipping out before you can second-guess it into oblivion.
He glances at you, one brow lifting slightly. “Only the nice ones,” he claims.
You blink, pausing for a moment, then, unexpectedly, you let out a small laugh, soft and a little surprised, like it slipped past your usual filter before you could catch it.
“This is not a nice bathroom,” you point out, gesturing vaguely to the scuffed tiles, the slightly crooked mirror, the faint smell that definitely isn’t just soap.
Hongjoong looks around, considering it for a second like you’ve made a valid argument. “…Yeah,” he concedes with a small grin, “Okay, maybe not.”
You shift your weight again, the damp fabric still clinging but no longer the only thing you can think about. Your hands rest more loosely now, no longer gripping, no longer trying so hard to make yourself smaller.
“I didn’t think you’d remember me,” you say after a second, softer this time, less abrupt than your last sentence, and more like something you’ve been sitting on.
His gaze moves back to you, steady and relaxed as he regards you. He pauses for a second longer than is good for your anxious heart, then he speaks, “Why wouldn’t I?”
You swallow, your fingers brushing lightly against the edge of your sleeve, “I don’t know,” you admit, a little quieter, “I wasn’t exactly… doing much worth remembering.”
Hongjoong shifts his weight a little against the counter, the movement subtle but grounding. His gaze doesn’t leave you as he shrugs, “You were kinda hard to forget.”
You look at him again, properly this time, searching his expression for something, looking for some sign that he’s just being polite, or filling space, or saying something he doesn’t actually mean.
Your fingers loosen their grip on your sleeve without you realizing, “Oh… I thought I was just… being awkward,” you admit after a second, a small, self-conscious laugh slipping out. “Like, really awkward.”
His mouth curves faintly at that, not quite a smile, but close. “I mean,” he starts, a hint of something lighter in his tone now, “you were a little awkward.”
Heat flickers across your face instantly, predictable and immediate, your shoulders drawing in just a fraction.
“Wow,” you murmur under your breath, gaze dropping for a second as your fingers fidget loosely at your side, “Okay.” You shift your weight again, leaning back just slightly against the door now, the cool surface grounding you, brain scrambling to say something to change the subject.
And of course, in all your grace, what you manage is: “I replay that a lot.” The words come quieter than everything else, almost like you weren’t planning on saying them at all. Your eyes widen slightly as you realize what you said. His gaze flicks to you, something a little unreadable slipping into it and you feel like you need to say something to fix this now, “That night,” you clarify, swallowing lightly. “That conversation.”
Oh my god, you’re making it worse! You almost take it back immediately, your stomach twisting at how that must sound, like you’ve been holding onto something that meant nothing to him.
But he doesn’t react the way you think. He doesn’t laugh at you, he doesn’t scoff in your face and ask why the hell you still replay a memory from a year ago of a guy you don’t even know. “…Yeah?” he asks instead, tone softer now.
You nod once. “I always think about what I should’ve said instead,” you admit, your voice dipping slightly, your gaze drifting somewhere past him. “Like… better things. Um, smarter things. Less…” you trail off, your lips pressing together briefly. “I don’t know,” you finish weakly.
There’s a quiet stretch of silence after that that makes your stomach lurch. You think you’re going to be sick, this is so humiliating. He watches you for a second longer, something thoughtful settling into his expression again. The joint rests loosely between his fingers now, forgotten for the moment.
“You were fine,” he maintains after a long moment, bringing the joint back to his lips.
Your brows knit faintly, “I really wasn’t,” you counter softly, not intending to be argumentative, just certain.
He exhales lightly through his nose, like he expected that answer, tilting his head, “I wouldn’t have stayed if you weren’t,” he claims.
You blink at him, caught off guard by how easily he says it, like it’s just a fact, like it doesn’t need to be dressed up or explained.
“But… you kinda didn’t. Stay, I mean.” The second it leaves your mouth, you feel embarrassed. It felt too sharp, too close to something that sounds like you’ve been keeping score. Your stomach twists and you almost rush to take it back, to soften it into anything less… telling. “I mean—” you start, your fingers curling slightly against your sleeve, “you got pulled away. By your friend. I just—”
Stop fucking talking.
You press your lips together, the rest of the sentence dissolving before it can make things worse. You refuse to look at him after that, you just can’t.
“You’re right,” He taps the ash off the end of the joint against the tray again, the small motion giving his hands something to do as he thinks, “I got dragged out,” he continues, glancing back at you. “Mingi doesn’t really take no for an answer when he’s already decided something.”
You nod slightly, because even in your brief interaction, that part felt obvious. “I remember,” you mutter.
He studies you for a second longer, something shifting subtly in his expression, “I was gonna come back, y’know.”
You hope he doesn’t realize the effect that has on you, breath hitching slightly as you search his face for any sign of deceit. “What?” you ask before you can stop yourself, your voice edged with something uncertain.
He shrugs, like it’s not a big deal, like it doesn’t carry the same weight for him that it does for you. “Yeah,” he confirms, “I just… didn’t see you again.”
Your fingers loosen at your sides, the tension you hadn’t fully noticed easing just slightly. “…I think I left,” you admit, your voice barely above a murmur now.
He nods once, like that fills in the gap for him, “Yeah,” he mumbles. “Guess we just missed each other.”
You don’t say anything right away. You’re not sure there’s anything you can say that wouldn’t ruin it somehow or turn it into something awkward again, something you’ll pick apart later when you’re alone in your bed, staring at the ceiling and wishing you’d just stayed quiet.
Hongjoong leans back against the counter again, posture easy, like nothing about this moment requires effort from him. He brings the joint back up, taking another slow drag, the faint glow illuminating his features for half a second before it fades again. When he exhales, the smoke drifts lazily between you, softening the edges of everything.
“You still do that?” he questions after a moment.
You blink. “Do what?”
“Leave early,” he clarifies, glancing at you.
You let out a small breath, something almost like a laugh. “Yeah,” you admit. “it’s kind of my thing.” Speaking of, you need to get out of here before you completely ruin this interaction. You glance toward the door for a second, like you’re suddenly aware of it again; of what’s on the other side, of the noise and the people and everything you’d managed to forget about for a few minutes in here. “Um, now that you mention it, I should probably…” you start, trailing off as your hand lifts slightly, gesturing vaguely toward it.
“Alright,” he nods, like he expected this, eyes dragging over your frame in a way you wish was easier to interpret as interest. Maybe it was, your idealist mind tells you. Hongjoong’s just hard to read after all.
“…Thanks,” you add dumbly, your fingers brushing absently against your sleeve again. “For, um… not making that worse.”
He exhales a faint, amused breath, shaking his head slightly. “You’re good,” he says. “It wasn’t that bad.”
You almost smile at that and your hand reaches for the doorknob, fingers curling around it, but you don’t turn it right away. There’s a brief pause before you speak again with more confidence than you think you’ve had this entire interaction, “…See you around?”
He looks at you, something steady in his expression again, that same quiet certainty you don’t really understand. “Yeah,” he nods. “You will.”
You nod once, small, before finally turning the handle and pulling the door open.
The noise hits you immediately: music, voices, laughter, all of it rushing back in at once like you never left. It feels louder now, harsher, after the quiet you just stepped out of.
“_____?!”
You barely have time to react before Nakyung is in front of you, her hands immediately grabbing your arms, eyes wide as she looks you over.
“Oh my god, where did you go?” she demands, then her expression shifts dramatically as she takes in your still-damp outfit. “And why do you look like you just got baptized?!”
You blink at her, the moment snapping a little, reality rushing back in.
“I—um—” you start, your voice catching slightly as you try to piece yourself back together. “It was an accident.”
“No kidding,” she huffs, already tugging you a little further into the hallway. “I turn around for two seconds and you disappear, and then Wooyoung’s ex is making a scene and— wait…” her eyes narrow slightly, suspicious now. “Where were you?”
The bathroom door is still slightly ajar, the faintest trace of smoke slipping out into the hallway, a quiet reminder of something that seems oddly separate from everything else.
“Just… hiding,” you finally reply.
Nakyung studies you for a second, like she’s trying to decide if she believes that, then she sighs, dramatic as ever, looping her arm through yours again.
“Okay, well, hiding is over,” she declares. “We’re getting you cleaned up, and then I’m getting you a new drink. One that hopefully doesn’t end up on your clothes.”
You wake up wrong.
It was like your body remembered something before your brain could catch up. Your eyes snap open to a room that feels too bright, too still, the quiet almost suspicious in a way that makes your stomach twist before you even know why.
For a second, you just lie there, staring at the ceiling, your thoughts moving sluggishly, like they’re wading through something thick. There’s a faint pressure behind your eyes, your throat a little dry, your limbs heavier than they should be.
Your gaze drifts, slow and unfocused, toward your nightstand. Your phone lays on the lacquered wood, dark and still and wrong, because your alarm usually goes off on Saturday mornings.
You lunge for it, the sudden movement making your head spin just slightly, and when the screen lights up, it hits you all at once.
10:47 AM.
Your stomach sinks so fast it almost feels physical.
“No, no, no—” you mumble under your breath, your voice rough with sleep as you scramble to sit up, your blanket tangling around your legs in the process. Your alarm — your multiple alarms — sit there uselessly on the screen, all missed, all ignored, like the world just decided to betray you entirely.
It’s 10:47 AM on a Saturday, which would be perfectly fine if it weren’t for the fact that Saturday mornings belonged to your tutoring sessions with Yunho.
The thought lands with a very specific kind of dread, the kind that presses into your chest and makes you wince before anything has even happened yet.
Because it’s not just that you’re late. It’s that you’re never late, not for this.
Saturdays are quiet and predicable and yours, in a way that the rest of the week never quite is. A soft routine carved out between two people who don’t really have anywhere else to be, who meet at the same time, in the same place, week after week without needing to say much about it.
And you like that. You like that Yunho is steady and patient, the kind of person who waits when you take too long to answer, who doesn’t rush you when your thoughts get tangled, who just sits there with that soft, expectant look like he already knows you’ll get there eventually.
That’s exactly why this feels worse, because you wanted, at the very least, to be someone who shows up on time.
You stare at your phone for another second, like the time might change if you just give it long enough. When it doesn’t, your fingers move quickly, clumsy with urgency as you unlock it, thumb hovering over his contact.
What do you even say? ‘Sorry I overslept’ sounds pathetic; ‘Sorry I forgot’ sounds even worse, even if it’s not true. Your thumbs hover over the screen, the cursor blinking up at you like it’s waiting for something better than whatever you’re about to say.
‘I’m so sorry, I overslept—‘ You type it out halfway, then stop. It looks wrong, like it reduces the whole thing to something small when it doesn’t feel small to you at all. You stare at the words for a second, your chest tightening just slightly, then delete them. The text disappears all at once, leaving the message box empty again.
You try again. ‘I’m on my way—‘
No. That’s worse, because you’re not, not even close.
Your fingers still, hovering uselessly over the keyboard as your thoughts start to tangle again, slipping into that familiar loop: what sounds right, what sounds normal, what sounds like someone who isn’t currently sitting in bed at almost eleven in the morning with a missed obligation sitting heavy in her chest.
You exhale sharply, your free hand coming up to press against your forehead. This is stupid. Every second you spend sitting here trying to craft the perfect message is another second you’re just… not there.
Yunho isn’t someone who needs a perfectly worded apology. He just needs you to show up.
The realization lands simply, but it’s enough to put you into action. You stare at your phone for one more second, then, almost abruptly, you lock it. The screen goes dark in your hand, your reflection faintly staring back at you for half a beat before you drop it onto your bed.
You push yourself up quickly, the movement a little clumsy as your body catches up with the decision. You grab the first sweater you can find, tugging it over your head in a hurry, your hair catching slightly before falling back into place in a way that you’ll probably hate later. You don’t check the mirror beyond a passing glance that confirms you look… somewhat presentable enough.
Your bag is half-packed from yesterday, notebooks already inside, pens scattered loosely at the bottom. You shove your laptop in, zip it halfway, then stop to shove it the rest of the way closed.
Your shoes go on unevenly, the backs of them slightly crushed as you step into them without untying anything before you’re rushing out the door.
The campus air hits you cooler than you expect, the kind of crisp that lingers in the late morning. It wakes you up a little more, clears the last bit of sleep from your head as you walk faster than usual, your steps just shy of a run.
Somehow, your mind is running even faster than you are.
What if he already left? What if you left him waiting until he just assumed you weren’t coming? What if you totally ruined what you had hoped was a studious, punctual perspective of you?
You push the thoughts aside, your grip tightening slightly on your bag strap as you cut across the usual path, your route so familiar you don’t have to think about it.
The library comes into view sooner than you expect, or maybe you just got there faster in your panic. You don’t slow down as you step inside, the shift from outdoor air to the quiet, controlled stillness of the building making everything feel sharper to you.
Your footsteps soften automatically as you move through the aisles, past the usual clusters of students, past the rows you don’t ever pay attention to, until you reach the spot.
Tucked near the back, by the tall windows that let in just enough light, stands your usual table. Your chest tightens slightly as your eyes flick toward the table and you see Yunho sitting there, glasses perched on his nose and tasteful beige flannel making him seem perfectly settled in the nest of soft morning light.
He’s seated exactly the way he always is: back a little straighter than most people sit when they’re relaxed, one arm resting near his notebook, the other loosely holding a pen he isn’t really using. The soft morning light filters in through the windows behind him, catching faintly in his hair, settling over him.
His eyes find you almost immediately, like he’d been glancing up every so often without realizing it, like some part of him was expecting you even if the time had already passed.
“Oh,” the syllable falls from his lips as he sits up a little straighter when you approach, “Hey.”
You move toward him quickly, the apology already building in your chest before you even reach the table. “I’m so sorry,” you rush out immediately, your voice low but urgent, bag slipping from your shoulder as you set it down a little too quickly. “I— my alarm didn’t go off, or I just didn’t hear it, and I woke up late and I didn’t text and I—”
Stop. Please, stop talking.
You clamp your mouth shut, the rest of the words tangling in your throat before they can spill out. Yunho blinks at you, clearly caught a little off guard by the sudden rush of it, then he shakes his head quickly, almost a little too quickly.
“No, it’s— it’s okay,” he reassures, the words coming out a touch uneven, like he’s trying to meet your pace and not quite managing it. “Really. I mean, it’s Saturday, so… it’s fine.”
You pause, studying him for half a second. Something’s different. His usual calm, steady presence feels a little disrupted, like there’s a slight stutter in it. His hands move more than they usually do, fingers adjusting the edge of his notebook, then the position of his pen, then back again. His gaze flickers down for a second before returning to you, then away again.
“…Are you sure?” you inquire, a little more cautiously now, easing into your seat across from him.
“Yeah. Yeah, of course,” he nods, then clears his throat lightly, like he’s resetting himself. “Do you, um— do you want to just start?”
He’s eager, a little too eager. That, more than anything, throws you off. Usually, there’s a rhythm to this. A quiet settling-in, a moment where he asks how your week was, where you fumble through an answer and he nods like it’s enough. Today, it feels like he’s skipping ahead.
“Um—yeah,” you answer, a little unsure, pulling your notebook out of your bag and flipping it open, your movements slower than his.
You start where you usually do: he explains a concept, voice steady enough, pointing to your notes, leaning slightly closer when you get something wrong, guiding you through it with that same patient tone you’ve come to rely on.
But it doesn’t hold. There are small things; little hesitations, the way his eyes don’t quite linger the same way when you look up at him, like he’s deliberately redirecting them back to the page. He clears his throat more than usual, or his pen taps once, twice, against the table before he stills it.
Your focus slips — not completely, but enough that you have to reread the same line twice before it makes sense, your pen hovering uselessly over your notebook as your thoughts drift.
Did you do something? No, you couldn’t have, you just got here, and he said your tardiness was fine.
You try to ignore it, but after a while, he stops mid-explanation, his pen stilling completely against the paper. You look up, brows knitting slightly, “…Yunho?”
He exhales slowly. It’s subtle, but you catch the way his shoulders drop just slightly, like he’s letting something go and bracing himself at the same time. “I, um…” he starts, then stops. His gaze lifts to you, but it doesn’t quite stay there, flickering between your face and the table, like he’s not entirely sure where to land it, “Um, I read the doc you emailed me,” he finishes.
Your heart stutters in your chest, and you hope he means anything but what you think he does. “…What?” you breathe, the word barely making it out of your mouth.
“I didn’t realize what it was at first,” he continues quickly, like he’s trying to explain before you can react, before you can shut down entirely. “I thought it was just, um, notes, or something you wanted help with, and then I started reading and—”
Your heart is pounding now and there’s a sharp, rising panic clawing its way up your chest, your fingers going cold where they rest against your notebook. Your mind scrambles, trying to retrace something that doesn’t exist — trying to find the moment where you did something that could’ve led to this.
You never sent it, you couldn’t have. You’d been careful with that folder, obsessively careful.
“I don’t know if I should have read it,” he continues when you’re silent, “it seemed kinda personal, and… I didn’t mean to keep reading, I just— I didn’t realize until I was already…” he trails off, studying your face and trying to find anything other than panic.
Your chest tightens. The thought lands slowly, like it has to force its way through your disbelief. He read it. He read every line, every stupid, soft, embarrassing thought you never meant for anyone to see, especially not him.
Your fingers curl slightly against the edge of your notebook, nails pressing into the paper without you realizing. Your heart is loud in your ears, and his words hardly make it through the haze.
“I’m really sorry,” he adds uselessly, as if that could ever cushion the blow, the fact that your life is completely fucking ruined because, if he got the letter, that probably means all the other guys did, and oh god, you’ve got to kill yourself.
Your brain is moving too fast now, spiraling, pulling up flashes of the doc — the way you wrote his name, the way you described him, the way you—
Oh my god.
“I just wanted to say… it was really nice.” Your gaze lifts slowly, like it takes effort, eyes landing on him. He looks… earnest. He looks careful, like he’s choosing every word, “Really thoughtful,” he continues, “and… flattering.”
Flattering. The word twists something in your chest.
“I just don’t think it would be right,” he speaks again after a second, quieter now, “to accept that. There’s, um, a power dynamic,” he adds, his hands shifting slightly against the table, fingers curling and uncurling like he doesn’t know where to put them. “I’m your tutor. I was assigned to you through the school, and it wouldn’t be fair.”
Fair. None of this was fucking fair. All of your helpless crushes probably read your sappy, stupid, romantic declarations of love and that alone is enough to make you consider moving to Antarctica or somewhere where you’ll never have to face any of them ever again.
“I’m really sorry if that’s—” he starts, but you think if he finishes that sentence you’re going to pass out.
“It’s fine,” you blurt out quickly, way too quickly to be casual. Your voice sounds wrong even to your own ears, brittle and soft and seconds away from breaking.
You can feel everything pressing in at once: the weight of what he knows, the way your thoughts won’t slow down, won’t stop, just looping over the same thing again and again—
Your fingers press harder into the edge of your notebook, like you can anchor yourself there, like you can keep everything from spilling out if you just hold still enough. “I should—” you start again, your chair shifting slightly as you begin to push it back.
Leave, leave now. You can’t sit here. You can’t breathe here. You can’t exist in the same space as him knowing what he knows.
You scramble to shove your notebook back into your bag, before that feeling hits you again — eyes are on you, more than just Yunho’s, and your head lifts before you can stop it, like your body already knows something your mind hasn’t caught up to yet.
And there Seonghwa is, across the aisle, walking directly toward you. His steps are steady, his posture composed in that way it always is, but there’s something in his expression that makes your stomach drop instantly. It’s the same look, the same knowing glint Yunho had just seconds ago.
Your breath stutters in your chest. Your mind scrambles, pieces snapping together all at once, too fast and too overwhelming. If Yunho knows, if the letters somehow got out, then Seonghwa—
Fuck. Your vision blurs at the edges. You can’t let him get any closer. You can’t stand there while he looks at you like that, like he’s already seen every part of you you tried so hard to hide.
Your body moves before your brain can catch up. It isn’t a decision. It isn’t even a thought, it’s cold, startling panic.
You lurch forward across the table, one hand bracing against the surface to steady yourself, the other catching lightly on Yunho’s sleeve as you lean in, and then you kiss him.
It’s clumsy, rushed, and completely unplanned. Your lips meet his wrong, barely aligned, more a collision than anything else, your breath still uneven, your heart pounding so loudly it drowns out everything else. Yunho freezes beneath you, completely caught off guard, his body going rigid in shock, like he hasn’t even processed what’s happening yet.
From the edge of your vision, you see Seonghwa stop. His expression shifts, something tightening, something conflicted flashing across his face as his gaze lands on you, on this, before he looks away, just slightly. He doesn’t turn fully, not leaving, but it’s enough for you that he doesn’t keep coming.
You pull back just as quickly as you leaned in, your breath shaky, your entire body buzzing with the aftermath of something you didn’t think through even a little. “Oh my god,” you whisper, your hand flying up to your mouth like you can undo it, like you can physically take it back. “Yunho, I’m— I’m so sorry—”
Yunho is still staring at you, wide-eyed and blushing, completely thrown, his usual composure nowhere to be found.
“I didn’t— I just—” your words tangle immediately, falling apart before they can become anything coherent, your voice breaking.
You can’t look at him. You can’t look at Seonghwa. You can’t be here. “I have to go,” you blurt out, the sentence rushed and uneven, barely held together.
You don’t wait for a response. You grab your bag in a hurry, nearly knocking your chair over as you sling it over your shoulder, your movements frantic, uncoordinated as you rush past Seonghwa who you think tries to stop you.
The realization keep replaying in your head as you storm out, over and over and suffocating:
They know. They all know.
You don’t remember the walk home. Your thoughts don’t slow down the entire way, looping, overlapping, collapsing into each other until they stop feeling like thoughts at all and more like noise.
They know.
By the time you reach your dorm, your hands are shaking. You fumble with your keys, missing the lock the first time, then the second, your breath coming a little too fast, a little too shallow. When the door finally swings open, you slip inside quickly, like something might follow you in if you’re not fast enough.
You drop your bag somewhere near your desk without really aiming, your laptop already halfway out before you even sit down. Your fingers move too fast, clumsy against the keys as you flip it open, the screen lighting up your face in that familiar pale glow that usually calms you.
You go straight to your email, because of course you do. There has to be an explanation. There has to be something you missed, something you did without realizing, some kind of glitch or mistake that makes this less catastrophic than it feels.
Your heart pounds harder as your cursor moves to the ‘Sent’ category, and your breath stops. There it is.
Four different threads sent from you, your school email. Your vision blurs for a second before it refocuses, your eyes scanning too quickly, skipping over words because you don’t want to see them but you can’t stop yourself from looking.
Four names, four attachments, four names. Kim Hongjoong, Jung Wooyoung, Jeong Yunho, Park Seonghwa. All sent, all timestamped, all from you.
Your stomach drops so violently you have to grab the edge of your desk to steady yourself. This can’t be real, you didn’t— you’d never accidentally send these, you couldn’t possibly have, you guarded those docs like they held the key to fucking Pandora’s box. In a way, to you, they did.
A small, broken sound leaves your throat before you can stop it, your hand coming up to press against your mouth as your chest tightens painfully. “Oh my god,” you whisper, barely audible even to yourself.
It’s worse than you thought. It’s so much worse, because it’s not just Yunho and Seonghwa, it’s all of them, all four. Every version of you you tried so hard to keep contained has been spelled out, signed, and delivered neatly into their inboxes like some kind of cruel joke.
You feel sick, actually, genuinely sick.
Your chair scrapes harshly against the floor as you push back suddenly, pacing once, twice, your hands tugging at your hair, at your sleeves, at anything you can reach.
What do you do?
What do you even—
A knock hits your door and your heart leaps into your throat so fast it hurts. Of course this was happening now. You sigh, smoothing your hand over your hair and approaching the door, hoping you look at least a little more put together than you feel.
You cross the room too quickly, your hand gripping the doorknob before you can second-guess it, and the second you pull it open, there he is, leaning slightly forward like he was about to knock again, eyes sharp, already locked onto you.
You gasp as you stare at Jung Wooyoung standing in front of your door. “Hey, Yeosang said I could find you here—“
Before he can finish, before he can look at you any longer, you slam the door — at least, you try to, because his hand shoots out faster than you expect, planting firmly against the wood, stopping it mid-swing with a solid thud.
“Whoa— hey, relax,” he placates, pushing it back open with barely any effort. You stumble back a step, your breath catching, your heart racing all over again as he steps inside like he belongs there, like you didn’t just try to shut him out completely.
“Wooyoung—“ you start, your voice already shaking.
He closes the door behind him, turning to face you fully now, his expression unreadable in a way that makes your stomach twist. “We need to talk,” he speaks simply.
“No, we don’t,” you shoot back immediately, too fast and too defensive. “I don’t—there’s nothing to talk about, I didn’t even—”You stop yourself, your words tripping over each other.
“Oh, yeah?” he raises an eyebrow as he talks, slow and unimpressed. “Because I got a pretty long email from you last night that says otherwise.”
You shake your head quickly, backing up another step like distance might help. “I didn’t mean to send those letters,” you rush out, the words spilling over themselves now, desperate, frantic. “I really didn’t, I don’t even know how that happened, I— it wasn’t— I don’t even like you like that anymore, it’s just—” You cut yourself off again, your breath uneven. Wooyoung just stares at you for a second.
“Letters?” he repeats, tilting his head slightly. “Plural?” His mouth curves, not quite a smile, something more amused than anything else. “Wow,” he lets out a quiet huff, shaking his head. “Way to make a guy feel special, tiny. Here I was thinking I was the only one getting a fancy love letter.”
Your face burns. You don’t even try to respond to that, because there’s nothing you can say that wouldn’t make it worse.
Wooyoung watches you for a second longer, his head tilting slightly, eyes narrowing just a fraction like he’s piecing something together. “…So who else?” he asks.
You freeze. “What?” you manage, too defensively.
He gestures loosely with one hand, like it’s obvious. “You said ‘letters,’” he points out, tone light but persistent. “So who else got one?”
“I— it doesn’t matter,” you say, shaking your head immediately, your fingers tightening in your sleeves. This is humiliating.
“Oh, it definitely matters,” he counters, pushing off the door and stepping further into your room like he’s settling in for this. “C’mon, don’t be like that. Who am I sharing the spotlight with?”
“There’s no spotlight,” you mutter, your voice thinner now, your gaze dropping. “It wasn’t even supposed to—”
“Then just say it,” he presses, not letting you slip away.
Saying it out loud makes it real in a way you don’t think you can undo, but the way he’s looking at you makes it feel like you don’t have a choice.
So you admit it in the only way you know how: blurting it out and hoping it’s coherent, “Jeong Yunho, Kim Hongjoong, and Park Seonghwa.”
There’s a small pause before he lets out a short breath through his nose, something almost amused flickering across his face. “Hongjoong? Kim Hongjoong, is that who you’re talking about? The music major?” he huffs lightly. “Really?” He glances at you like he’s reevaluating something. “Thought you had better taste than that, tiny. Y’know, considering you like me.”
“I do not like you,” you shoot back instantly.
The words hang there for a second, heavier than you intended and he pauses for a beat before one corner of his mouth tugs up slightly, like he doesn’t quite believe you, like he’s filing that away as something to poke at later. “Right. Sure you don’t.”
“I don’t,” you insist, more firmly this time, even though your voice wavers just slightly at the edges. “I didn’t— I mean, I did, but not— it’s not—” You stop yourself, your frustration spiking as your words tangle beyond repair. He seems to be on a different thought process, though.
“Wait, Seonghwa?” His brows lift, something amused flickering across his face. “No way,” he huffs, almost like he’s impressed. “Isn’t that guy, like… your brother’s best friend?”
Heat floods your face all over again, this time sharper, more panicked. How does he even know that? You know San’s on the football team and Wooyoung’s always hanging around them, but you didn’t think he even noticed you until yesterday.
“Stop,” you snap, the word coming out more forceful than anything you’ve said so far.
But he doesn’t, of course he doesn’t. If anything, it just encourages him. “Wow,” he continues, shaking his head slightly like he’s trying to wrap his mind around it. “That’s bold. I didn’t think you had it in you, tiny.”
“I said stop,” you repeat, your voice tighter now, your hands curling at your sides. “Those letters were private, and no one was supposed to see them, and now my whole life is a living hell and— I don’t… I don’t know what to do, so I really don’t need you coming and— and just making it all worse!”
He studies you for a second, then exhales through his nose lightly, dragging a hand through his hair as he looks off to the side for a second, like he’s thinking or recalibrating. “…Okay,” he offers after a moment. “Yeah. That’s—” He nods once, like he’s acknowledging it. “That’s rough.”
You let out a small, humorless breath at that. Rough. Right, that’s one way to put it.
Silence settles for a second, the atmosphere of the conversation heavier now, less chaotic but no less uncomfortable. You shift your weight, your fingers picking at your cuticle. “I really didn’t mean for those to get sent,” you start again, voice nervous and shaky. “I don’t even know how it happened.”
Wooyoung glances back at you, studying you for a second longer, then he exhales again, sharper this time, like he’s coming to some kind of conclusion. “…Okay,” he repeats, more decisively now.
Uh oh. That tone can’t mean anything good.
He steps a little closer, not enough to crowd you, but enough that you can’t pretend he’s not about to say something that will change the direction of this entire conversation.
“I’ve got an idea,” he declares.
You already don’t like it. “A bad one,” you mutter under your breath, and he ignores you completely.
“What if we fake date?”
You blink at him, like maybe if you give your brain a second, it’ll rearrange his words into something that actually makes sense. It doesn’t. They sit there exactly as he said them, heavy and absurd, and it’s all you can do not to stare at him like he’s just suggested something completely detached from reality— because he has. “…What?” you finally manage, your voice coming out quieter than you intended.
Wooyoung doesn’t look unsure. If anything, he looks more settled now, like saying it out loud only solidified it for him. He shifts his weight slightly, one shoulder angling forward as his attention locks onto you in a way that makes it clear he’s not joking. “Fake date,” he repeats, slower this time, like you’re a dunce. “You and me.”
Your stomach twists. “That’s not—” you start, shaking your head immediately, your hands lifting slightly like you can physically push the idea away. “That’s not a solution, that’s— that’s insane.”
“Is it?” he counters, one brow lifting.
“Yes,” you reply within a second, more sure of this than you’ve been of anything else in your life. “Very. Extremely. Incredibly—”
“Okay, then what’s your plan?” he cuts in, arching a brow as he watches you flounder.
Your mouth opens, but nothing comes out this time. The confidence drains from your expression almost instantly, your gaze dropping somewhere between his shoes and the floor as your fingers tighten in the fabric of your sleeves again. You hate that he asked that. You hate that you don’t have a good answer.
You swallow, your shoulders pulling in slightly. “I’ll just… avoid them,” you try, even though the words feel weak the second they leave your mouth.
“All of them?” he questions, tilting his head slightly, studying you. “Your tutor?” He pauses slightly, “your brother’s best friend?”
You flinch at Seonghwa’s descriptor, subtle but there and he sighs. “…Okay, my bad,” he mutters under his breath, though there’s the faintest flicker of amusement before it fades again. He exhales lightly, pushing off from where he’d been leaning, his posture shifting to be more grounded, more deliberate. “Point is, you can’t just disappear.”
“I can try,” you mumble, though it sounds less like a plan and more like a last resort you already know won’t work.
“Yeah,” he huffs, glancing at you, then vaguely gesturing between the two of you. “And how’s that working out so far?”
You don’t answer, because you don’t need to. The evidence that you can’t hide from the recipients of your letters is standing right here, in the middle of your dorm room, living and breathing and looking at you like you’re a problem that needs solving.
He exhales again, slower this time, like he’s choosing his words more carefully now. “Look,” he starts, his tone leveling out into something more practical. “This fixes two problems at once.”
Your brows knit slightly as you look back up at him, cautious now. “What problems?”
He lifts a hand, ticking them off on his fingers like he’s already thought this through. “One: Karina.” His mouth tightens just slightly at her name before he smooths it over. “She sees me with someone else, she gets jealous, realizes what she’s missing—whatever. Doesn’t matter. It works.”
Your expression shifts faintly at that, but before you can interrupt, he continues.
“Two: you.” His hand lowers, gesturing toward you in a way that feels more intentional now, “You don’t have to explain any of this. Not to me, not to them, not to anyone. It’ll just look like…” he pauses, shrugging lightly, “…you didn’t mean it. Like you’ve already got a boyfriend and the emails were just a joke.”
Your chest tightens at that, because that… that actually makes sense, in a way you didn’t want it to. It would give context to something that currently has none. It would take the edge off the humiliation, dull it into something more understandable, something less exposed.
“…It’s still a bad idea,” you offer uselessly after a moment, but there’s less conviction behind it now, more hesitation creeping in at the edges.
Wooyoung watches you carefully, as if he can see the exact moment your resistance starts to slip, “Maybe, but you’re thinking about it.”
You let out a quiet breath, your gaze dropping again as your mind starts racing in a different direction now, turning the concept of it in your mind. Fake dating. With him. The thought alone makes something uneasy twist low in your stomach, something you don’t want to examine too closely.
“No,” you refuse again, softer now, like you’re trying to convince yourself more than him. “People will know it’s fake.”
“They won’t,” he refutes immediately.
“You don’t know that.”
“I do,” he counters just as quickly. “because I won’t act like it’s fake.”
You look back up at him, your expression caught somewhere between suspicion and overwhelm. “And I’m just supposed to… what? Go along with it?”
“Yeah,” he replies simply, like it’s obvious.
Your mouth opens, then closes again, your hands lifting slightly in a helpless, uncertain gesture. “I don’t— I can’t just—” you start, your voice tightening. “I’m not good at that. I’m not good at…” You trail off, vaguely motioning between the two of you, unable to even fully articulate it.
“Liking someone?” he fills in.
“I already told you, I don’t like you,” you shoot back automatically, even as your voice wavers just slightly.
He huffs slightly, “Right,” he repeats again, in that same tone that makes it clear he doesn’t quite buy it. You glare at him weakly, but it doesn’t have any real bite.
“…You don’t have to be good at it,” he adds after a moment, his voice lowering just slightly, “I’ll handle most of it.” He studies your face, the tentative energy practically rolling off of you. “…and it wouldn’t be forever,” Wooyoung maintains after a moment, and there’s a subtle shift in him when he says it, like he’s consciously dialing himself back. The earlier edge in his tone softens, not disappearing entirely, but rounding out into something steadier. He drags a hand through his hair, fingers catching briefly at the strands before falling away, a quiet exhale slipping out of him like he’s trying to make the idea sound less overwhelming. “Just until things calm down.”
Your gaze slips away from him almost instinctively, dropping somewhere near the floor before unfocusing entirely. Your thoughts don’t land on one thing so much as they spiral, pulling everything in with them— Yunho’s careful, apologetic voice, the way Seonghwa stopped mid-step, that look on his face you didn’t dare stick around long enough to understand, Hongjoong in the bathroom, quiet and observant and there at the worst possible moment, and now this.
Your fingers tighten in the sleeves of your sweater, the fabric bunching under your grip like it could ground you. It just makes you more aware of how tense you are, how tightly wound everything feels inside your chest.
Wooyoung shifts again, pushing himself more fully upright from where he’d been leaning, his posture straightening but not closing in. He gives you space without stepping away, like he’s figured out that pressing you any harder right now won’t get him anywhere.
“It gives you an out,” he adds after a second, his voice quieter now, like he’s laying it out instead of arguing for it. One shoulder lifts in a small shrug, casual on the surface but not careless.
Your fingers loosen slightly in your sleeves, then tighten again, like your body can’t decide what it’s doing any more than your mind can. Your gaze stays down for a second longer, fixed on nothing, your thoughts still turning over themselves.
An out, that’s what he called it, and God, you want one, because the alternative — facing Yunho again after that, looking Seonghwa in the eye knowing exactly what he’s read, existing in the same space as Hongjoong with all of that hanging unspoken between you — it makes your chest tighten in a way that feels almost unbearable.
You shift your weight slightly, your shoulder brushing faintly against the edge of your desk behind you, grounding you just enough to pull yourself back into the moment. “…And it just stops?” you inquire finally, your voice softer, not as frantic as before but still uneven around the edges. You don’t look at him yet. “After things calm down.”
“Yeah,” he answers, so sure of it.
You finally glance up at him, hesitant, searching his expression for certainty, or reassurance, or even doubt. He just looks steady, like he’s already decided this works.
“…And you get Karina back,” you murmur, more to yourself than to him.
A flicker passes over his face at that, but it’s gone just as fast. “That’s the idea,” he confirms, tone flattening slightly, like he doesn’t want to linger on that part too long.
You nod once, small and absent, your gaze dropping again as your thoughts circle back inward. Your breath comes out slow, a little shaky at the end as you press your lips together, weighing it one last time even though you already feel the answer settling in your chest.
“…Okay,” you say finally. Wooyoung is quiet, uncharacteristically so, and you think he’s waiting, making sure you don’t take it back, so you swallow and add, a little more firmly this time, even if your voice still wavers just slightly, “…Okay. We can—” you hesitate for half a second, your fingers tightening around the edge of the desk, “we can try it.”
request to join the taglist in the replies or in my inbox!
masterlist | part one , part two , part three , part four








