Enshadowed- Kelly Creagh
Read on August 28, 2012
Grudging 3 stars. I'm so damn annoyed. The ending was just...AAARRRGGGHHH! I figured that reading through long descriptions of where Isobel was and what she was doing would eventually get me answers to all those questions I had in the first book. I really wasn't expecting to be ending the book with a shit load of new questions. Let me make it clearer. I read Nevermore a long time back in maybe December last year and so I didn't remember quite a lot of details from the book. I did my homework and went through my review and a few others to help me refresh my memory. Even though it was useful, I still had trouble remembering the exact detail of a previous event; but thankfully the author has given tidbits of information of those events whenever the need be. The main problem with the book, apart from the disappointing ending, was the detailed description of every damn scene that had less to do with any eventful happening but more to do with getting a clearer picture of the situation; which appreciated in the case of the Dreamworld, were downright annoying otherwise. Initially, I was very patient and read every line so that nothing goes amiss but when I realized that there was too much useless dwelling into what Isobel and everyone around her was doing, I started skimming through the lines to see if something, anything interesting happened at all. The story starts with Isobel having recurrent dreams about Varen which she can't seem to recall when she wakes up. She knows that he's trying to leave her a message somehow but what troubles her is the impossibility of it since she had cut the line between the Dreamworld and the real world. Shadows haunt her and she has many unpleasant encounters with Pinfeathers and in one instance Bess herself. She is distracted, depressed and worrying everyone around her. Her only hope is catching Reynolds on Edgar Poe's birthday but for that she has to convince her parents to let her go to Baltimore. That's pretty much the introductory synopsis. The prologue covered the death of Poe and that had me very excited in the beginning. As the story progressed, I was waiting for a quick pacing and something remarkable to happen but my wishes were left to drown in a pool of annoyance and disappointment. ** minor spoilers ahead** Bess turned out to [Lilith, the demon queen, the harbinger of death and mental instability, the succubus who ensnares her prey by seduction]. It explained a lot of things about how and why Varen was the target as was Poe but yeah there was a little eye-rolling that followed. Pinfeathers appearance in the mortal realm made little sense to me. His connection with Varen changed him? What happened that he became less evil and more considerate and amiable? How could he and the other Nocs even come to the real world? Pinfeathers said something like, "she taught us.." but why? Varen made an appearance for a maximum of three times in the book along with a guest appearance in the epilogue. His behavior made sense to me, somewhat, but I can't seem to remember why I even cared if he was stuck there. He wanted it himself, just as Gwen mentioned. I could understand why Isobel felt so determined to bring him back. It was guilt mixed with love and blah blah blah but wasn't she as clueless as ever? Isobel wasn't as irritating as she was in Nevermore but her brain remained uncooperative even this time around. If not for Gwen and her little brother Danny, she would have either gone crazy herself or drove everyone else crazy, including me. For all her big talks about saving Varen, she had no idea how she was even going to contact him, let alone find him and get him out. Gwen's reaction in the beginning hearing about Bess was believable but how nonchalant and helpful she acted later on didn't match up to her initial response. Gwen was the funny, perky bff as usual but her intentions to help Isobel staying aloof only proved her character to be a mere convenience for the whole story line. Danny was adorable. The only times I giggled a little was because of him and Gwen. Isobel felt a twitch in her left eye. “Danny, just spit it out and move already.” “If it makes it easier for you to understand,” he said with a sigh, adopting a tone one of his computer screen characters might use with any nameless underling, “I shall hereafter employ the usage of smaller words more digestible to your limited heathen mortal palate.” Makes me wish I had a younger brother. *sigh* Anyways, Isobel's parents had a lot of involvement in the story and her father was an amazing support for her. I was glad to see that Isobel felt guilty about her decisions and didn't act like a brat who only cared about the love of her life hurting her family as if they meant nothing. I'm still not done with the confusing parts so let the questioning begin: -Who put Varen's jacket outside Isobel's cupboard? -Remind me the significance of the bird on the jacket again? Anything to do with Poe's raven? -Why was Isobel hearing that woman [who turned out to be Varen's mother] sing? -What was with Brad's cryptic message? (I felt bad for him though. He was a jerk in the last book but still...) -Why did Pinfeathers decide to show Isobel that memory? And how did he even know about it? -What's the deal with Reynolds? Are we ever going to find out? -The ending...... just what? I'd like to talk about the ending in length. Varen is definitely not the guy who Isobel left and he clearly is over her or doesn't wanna leave or whatever it is that happened to him, but how does [him pushing her off a cliff] end up with [her body in the real world when she had clearly left the mortal realm through that tomb?] Also, how did she [ in her astral form finally get back to her body?] How is that even possible? How much longer do I have to wait to know real answers? I went through all those pages of insignificant blabbering to get what in the end? More questions? Another cliffhanger? I'm getting tired of all the mystery and illogical scenes that hold no semblance to what really was happening. As you might have already noticed that I've written a full review rambling about everything I disliked. Why the 3, if grudging, stars then? Even though the scenes ended up being very long, there was a spooky feely to them which I enjoyed. It was clichéd, like the TV turning up on its own, the radio streaming the haunting melody, the book shutting on itself, but I liked it. It fit in the situation and the concept of controlling dreams and the confusion that Isobel faced not knowing if something was real or in her head felt realistic. I don't understand how Isobel finally [found her way to Varen, like was that door a secret passage or did it work because of Reynolds being present?] but the descriptions in the ending chapters held me captive. Let's just hope that I get some sensible answers in the next book or I'll do some serious damage to the books.











