APEC Alert—an ‘Affair’ to remember
Text by Steph Glanzmann, Noni Nabors, and Marisa Pavone
Edited by Alexandra Bischoff and Anna Tidlund
In collaboration with UBC Geography Department’s Dr. Jessica Dempsey and her Fall 2017 GEOG 419 class, students were invited to submit archival based research for publication on the Both/And blog. The class thematic surrounded societal amnesia. Dempsey was interested in having students investigate major efforts for social change which had occurred in the past, the memories of which have not persisted in present social consciousness.
On November 25, 1997, anti-globalization activists at the University of British Columbia (UBC) Vancouver campus harnessed the attention of the nation during the Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) Leaders’ Summit, in a protest that became known as the “APEC Affair”. APEC is an organization consisting of Pacific Rim countries seeking to promote free trade, economic cooperation, economic growth and prosperity among member states [1]. The APEC Affair garnered nation-wide media attention after local RCMP used pepper spray against nonviolent student protesters [2][3][4]. Unfortunately, the events that unfolded on November 25 (and the sequential court cases [5]) largely overshadowed the purpose of the anti-APEC campaign. This report intends to show how student organizers in opposition to APEC were able to engage and mobilize students on the UBC campus. With many of the organizers’ records and external communications accessible [6][7], we are able to analyze the principles, strategies and tactics used to mobilize the student body at UBC.
The APEC Affair occurred during a time of broader anti-globalization movements, which arose as a form of resistance to the widespread neoliberal policies being implemented around the globe [8]. The structural adjustments that came with globalization policies disproportionality impacted economies of Africa, Asia and Latin America and benefited those of the Global North [9], while simultaneously diluting democracy across borders and eroding workers rights around the world [10]. Other international bodies with similar neoliberal motivations include the International Monetary Fund and the World Trade Organization, which both promote trade liberalization internationally [11].
In January 1997, outgoing UBC President Dr. David Strangway announced that the UBC Vancouver campus, including the Museum of Anthropology, would be the venue for the sixth annual APEC Leaders’ Summit. This would come to be the biggest and most expensive private meeting in Canada [12], with the intent of fostering economic partnerships between member states [13]. The decision was widely criticized for being outside Strangway’s scope of decision-making power, sparking anger among students who were not consulted about the decision [14][15]. Further to this, anti-APEC students and community members fundamentally opposed the meeting on the grounds that it was to be a meeting place to implement corporate globalization agendas [16]. The fall after the summit announcement, several students began organizing efforts against the APEC Leaders’ Summit and referred to themselves as “APEC Alert” [17].
APEC Alert “considered APEC to be undemocratic, complicit in the erosion of human rights . . . fostering a society of consumption, and promoters of environmental destruction” [18]. In resistance, APEC Alert created a powerful campaign that included diverse tactics and messaging, which resonated with a large student base. Approximately 1,500 individuals protested in opposition to the APEC summit [19][20]. Protesters were concerned that the APEC summit would be focused on trade agreements without considering the human rights abuses of Indonesia President Suharto and Chinese General Secretary Zemin, as well as the environmental and social ills of the trade deals [21][22]. Although the protest itself was peaceful, 48 students were detained and multiple individuals were pepper sprayed by police [23][24].
Organizing materials and threads of communication used to mobilize UBC campus have been preserved through email lists, news articles, and local archives, but there has been little work to re-centre this story of student resistance to the conscious of the UBC community. By threading together primary sources, first-hand accounts and anti-APEC material, we seek to create a roadmap for future student organizers and to distribute the story of a meaningful student-led movement on UBC campus. By framing the voices of APEC-Alert organizers and protestors, our work serves to counterbalance the largely institutional and legalist research already done on the APEC Affair.
We visited the UBC Alma Mater Society (AMS), Museum of Anthropology (MOA) and Morris and Helen Belkin Art Gallery archives, looking at collections both online and in-person. When visiting the AMS and MOA archives, we focused on student-generated content such as leaflets, posters, event itineraries and email communications. Archival sources included a Vancouver-wide anarchist email list used to coordinate events and as well as circulate alternative media. This list, which included over 24 threads containing the term “APEC” in their titles, acts as the backbone of our research as we used it to piece together the larger organizing process and identify key members of APEC Alert [25].
We compiled a list of potential interviewees and, ultimately, interviewed four individuals: Garth Mullins, a writer based in East Vancouver; Jonathan Oppenheim, a former UBC student and APEC Alert organizer; Katja-Anton Cronauer, also a former UBC student and APEC Alert organizer; and Jamie Doucette, a former UBC student and activist taken into custody during the APEC Affair.
These interviews revealed many aspects of the APEC Affair and the campus culture of 1997. For one, the success of the APEC Affair is largely credited to the diverse tactics used by organizers in mobilizing 1,500 protesters. Organizers were able to foster a successful movement on campus because of the diverse tactics they used to activate the student body. APEC Alert split their campaign into three sections: “Refuse APEC,” “Summit Under Siege,” and “Crash The Summit” [26].
Refuse APEC spanned from the beginning of September to November 17, 1997 [27]. This period involved a series of acts of civil disobedience that engaged students as well as created situations which forced UBC administration to act. When asked about the strengths of APEC Alert’s campaign, past member Jonathan Oppenheim said, “[protesters were] effective at creating situations where we put both the university and the state . . . at a loss of what to do. We were quite good at creating situations where they were kind of forced to choose. [We pushed] them in situations they were uncomfortable with” [28]. Examples of these situations include camping at the Museum of Anthropology and the AMS Student Union Building, tabling motions for both the AMS and the UBC Board of Governors to overturn the decision to host the Summit [29], a series of road hockey games on the driveway of the Norman Mackenzie house [30] and a Halloween campus march that ended with two student being detained for writing “BOO APEC” on a newly renovated building [31]. The Refuse APEC period was also used to educate the student body through both informational and provocative posters, debates on campus, classroom announcements, film screenings and talks.
The next phase, Summit Under Siege, was a transition point in the campaign where organizers ramped up the intensity and size of anti-APEC demonstrations in preparation for the beginning of summit proceedings on November 19. Summit Under Siege began on November 17 with a tent city outside of the AMS Student Union Building (SUB) called Democracy Village, or DemoVille for short, which lasted until November 25 [32]. Other UBC student groups were encouraged to show their support by setting up a tent in DemoVille and to participate in the ongoing civil disobedience trainings, cook-outs and workshops. On November 21, APEC Alert held a concert next to the restricted area of the Museum of Anthropology called “Rock Against APEC” [33]. On November 24—the day before the Leaders’ Summit—APEC Alert organized a campus wide walk-out, directing students, faculty and Vancouver supporters to a day-long teach-in called “Free University” in the SUB.
Summit Under Siege culminated with the final phase of the campaign: Crash The Summit. On the morning of November 25, 1997, protesters were invited to gather at the Goddess of Democracy statue for a “Refuse APEC Festival”, which included street theatre, music, speeches and civil disobedience preparation [34]. Over 1,500 protesters marched throughout campus in opposition to the Leaders Summit, eventually clashing with police, finding themselves on the receiving end of pepper spray and excessive force [35][36].
Our interviewees spoke of the necessity of mixed-methods organizing, emphasizing that any movement will not succeed without them. Katja-Anton Cronauer recalled [37]:
What I liked was that it was very varied—our strategies. We employed our educations, had workshops, showed films, invited presenters for talks, plastered the campus with posters, did civil disobedience actions, beautified the campus—as we called it—with chalk and paint and posters. So I liked that because it drew a lot of different people in.
During the APEC Affair there were events tailored for those with deep, academic knowledge of power systems and international affairs, as well as events for those less familiar. Garth Mullins remembers thinking, “this is great, are you kidding me? We’ve like broken through to the Zeitgeist or whatever, because the truth is [UBC] . . . was not a hotbed of radicalism” [38].
People were made to feel welcome through these tactics regardless of how much they knew when they arrived at an event. In this way a welcoming atmosphere was created, and increased awareness about APEC attracted more individuals to the events who were curious. The multitude of events leading up to the summit generated momentum for the main protest, Crash The Summit.
The gender dynamics in APEC Alert are also worth considering. While APEC Alert centered anti-oppression and consensus as guiding principles in their organizing, in our research it was clear that certain identities and voices were missing from conversations while others dominated. Cronauer’s thesis, for example, suggests that women and non-binary individuals were underrepresented in APEC Alert email exchanges [39]. Furthermore in our interview, Cronauer spoke of a “boy’s club” within APEC Alert that implicitly excluded women and non-binary members. According to Cronauer, there “was difference among groups. There was a boys club, [ . . . and] there was a core group which I was a part of, which was the next inner group” [40].
Cronauer later went on to say that following the Summit, a group of female organizers created a women’s only group to discuss the sexism they faced both from police and from within APEC Alert [41]. Seven out of eight persons we contacted for interviews identify as cis-male. It is not immediately clear whether this is because the archive selectively overrepresents male voices and/or whether women and non-binary individuals were excluded from organizing.
In addition to the gender power dynamics, Cronauer recounted how APEC Alert was predominately white, a fact she believes influenced their activities. Cronauer recalls that “using [tactics] like ‘Hockey Against APEC’ —which as I know is a very white Canadian game,” could have been a subtle form of exclusion [42]. In fact all our interviewees are white, something we realized only at the conclusion of our interviews.
It is impossible to say what the specific impacts of a predominately white and male organizing leadership are, especially within the scope of this report. Regardless, it calls to attention critical questions of power structures within justice-oriented organizing groups. Who has the ability to be speak, and to be heard, as well as whose voice is represented in archival histories are crucial and power-laden questions.
Our interviewees stressed that, up until the day of the summit, they could not have predicted whether Crash The Summit would be “successful” or not. There is no benchmark for “success” in such movements, so describing it as such is fickle. They emphasized that, rather than focusing on the “success” of events, aspiring organizers must keep an eye on their long-term goals. As Katja-Anton Cronauer said, “I think one important thing is: keep going” [43].
The APEC Affair occurred 20 years ago and yet we suspect the majority of students on UBC campus are unaware of it. We believe there is still a need for student movements today, including the movement to divest UBC from fossil fuels, which stem from the same neoliberal forces the anti-APEC movement rallied against. It is ironic that 20 years ago UBC students protested against the widespread implementation of neoliberal policies, while students today are affected by the consequences of those policies—yet are unaware of the efforts of the students before them. We encourage future research into the connection between this lack of memory, and the student body’s perceptions of social action on campus today.
Notes
[1] Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation. "Mission Statement." Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation. Accessed April 12, 2017. http://www.apec.org/About-Us/About-APEC/Mission-Statement.
[2] Winter, James. "Canadian PM in hot water over APEC '97." Green Left Weekly. September 5, 2016. Accessed June 21, 2017. https://www.greenleft.org.au/content/canadian-pm-hot-water-over-apec-97.
[3] Pue, W. Wesley. Pepper in our eyes: the APEC affair. Vancouver: UBC Press, 2000.
[4] Abbate, Gay. "Mounties assailed for APEC bungling." The Globe and Mail. March 21, 2009. Web. Accessed June 21, 2017. http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/mounties-assailed-for-apec-bungling/article1032642/.
[5] Ibid.
[6] Cronauer, Katja-Anton. "Activism and the Internet: a socio-political analysis of how the use of electronic mailing lists affects mobilization in social movement organizations." PhD diss., University of British Columbia, April 2004.
[7] A-Infos News Services: News about and of interest to anarchists. Accessed April 12, 2017. http://www.ainfos.ca/A-Infos97/4/index.html#545.
[8] Ericson, Richard and Aaron Doyle. "Globalization and the policing of protest: the case of APEC 1997." British Journal of Sociology 50, no. 4 (1999): 589-608. Accessed June 21, 2017. doi:10.1080/000713199358554.
[9] Redclift, Michael and Colin Sage. "Global Environmental Change and Global Inequality." International Sociology 13, No. 4 (1998): 499-516. Accessed June 21, 2017. doi:10.1177/026858098013004005.
[10] Biebricher, Thomas. "Neoliberalism and Democracy," Constellations 22, No. 2 (2015): 255-266. Accessed April 12, 2017, doi:10.1111/1467-8675.12157.
[11] Chorev, Nitsan and Sarah Babb. "The crisis of neoliberalism and the future of international institutions: A comparison of the IMF and the WTO." Theory and Society 38, No. 5 (2009): 459-84. doi:10.1007/s11186-009-9093-5.
[12] Mackin, Bob and Geoff Dembicki. "Mercer Blasted APEC Protesters with Pepper Spray." The Tyee. Web. October 22, 2009. Accessed April 12, 2017. https://thetyee.ca/News/2009/10/22/MercerPepperSpray/.
[13] Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation. "Mission Statement." Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation. Accessed April 12, 2017. http://www.apec.org/About-Us/About-APEC/Mission-Statement.
[14] Clark, J. "APEC Economic Summit." The Ubyssey (Vancouver): 3. January 10, 1997. Vol 78 Iss 24. Web. Accessed April 12, 2017. https://open.library.ubc.ca/collections/ubcpublications/ubysseynews/items/1.0127434.
[15] Cronauer, Katja-Anton and Nicole Capler. "APEC-Alert voices views." UBC News: News from the University of British Columbia. July 10, 1997. Web. Accessed April 14, 2017. http://news.ubc.ca/ubcreports/1997/97sep04/97sep4let.html.
[16] Ibid.
[17] Mackin, Bob and Geoff Dembicki. "Mercer Blasted APEC Protesters with Pepper Spray." The Tyee. October 22, 2009. Web. Accessed April 12, 2017. https://thetyee.ca/News/2009/10/22/MercerPepperSpray/.
[18] Doyle, Alan. “B.C. Civil Liberties Association - APEC Inquiry fonds,” December 2002, last revised September 2010. Finding aid at the University of British Columbia Archives, Vancouver, BC. Accessed April 12, 2017. https://www.library.ubc.ca/archives/u_arch/bc_civil_liberties_association.pdf.
[19] Nuttal-Smith, Chris and Sarah Galashan. “APEC slams UBC.” The Ubyssey (Vancouver): 1. November 28, 1997. Vol 72 Iss 23. Web. Accessed June 7, 2017. https://open.library.ubc.ca/collections/ubcpublications/ubysseynews/items/1.0126666#p0z-2r0f.
[20] Doyle, Alan. “B.C. Civil Liberties Association - APEC Inquiry fonds,” December 2002, last revised September 2010. Finding aid at the University of British Columbia Archives, Vancouver, BC. Doyle, A. 2002. B.C. Civil Liberties Association - APEC Inquiry fonds. UBC Archives. Accessed April 12, 2017. https://www.library.ubc.ca/archives/u_arch/bc_civil_liberties_association.pdf.
[21] Ibid.
[22] Cronauer, Katja-Anton and Nicole Capler. "APEC-Alert voices views." UBC News: News from the University of British Columbia. July 10, 1997. Web. Accessed April 14, 2017. http://news.ubc.ca/ubcreports/1997/97sep04/97sep4let.html.
[23] Pecho, J. “APEC Inquiry Collection (various collectors),” 2008. Finding aid at the University of British Columbia Archives, Vancouver, BC. Accessed April 12, 2017. http://www.library.ubc.ca/archives/u_arch/apec_coll.pdf.
[24] Bradley, Nicholas, and Daliah Merzaban. “APEC remembered: two years later.” The Ubyssey (Vancouver): 1-2. November 23, 1999. Vol 81 Iss 20. Web. Accessed April 12, 2017. https://open.library.ubc.ca/collections/ubcpublications/ubysseynews/items/1.0128705#p0z-2r0f.
[25] A-Infos News Services: News about and of interest to anarchists. Accessed April 12, 2017. http://www.ainfos.ca/A-Infos97/4/index.html#545.
[26] Oppenheim, Jonathan. "(en) Summit Under Siege!" Forum post. A-Infos News Services: News about and of interest to anarchists. October 30, 1997. Web. Accessed April 12, 2017. www.ainfos.ca/A-Infos97/4/0320.html.
[27] Ibid.
[28] Oppenheim, Jonathan. "Questions on APEC Alert." Online interview by Steph Glanzmann. March 9, 2017.
[29] Bradley, Nicholas, and Daliah Merzaban. “APEC remembered: two years later.” The Ubyssey (Vancouver): 1-2. November 23, 1999. Vol 81 Iss 20. Web. Accessed April 12, 2017. https://open.library.ubc.ca/collections/ubcpublications/ubysseynews/items/1.0128705#p0z-2r0f.
[30] APEC Alert. "UBC PRESDIENT WANTS THE ARREST OF STUDENTS FOR PLAYING ROAD HOCKEY." [sic] British Columbia Anarchist Association. Geocities, October 29, 1997. Web. Accessed April 12, 2017. http://www.geocities.ws/CapitolHill/6322/apec.htm.
[31] The Ubyssey. "The Circus Comes to Campus." The Ubyssey (Vancouver): 10. November 4, 1997. Web. Accessed April 12, 2017. https://open.library.ubc.ca/collections/ubcpublications/ubysseynews/items/1.0127649#p8z-6r0f:halleen%20APEC.
[32] Howe, Brendan. "B.C. APEC Protest." UWO Gazette (London, ON). November 21, 1997. Vol 91 Iss 48. University of Western Ontario. Web. Accessed April 12, 2017. http://www.usc.uwo.ca/gazette/1997/November/21/News3.htm.
[33] Oppenheim, Jonathan. "(en) Summit Under Siege!" Forum post. A-Infos News Services: News about and of interest to anarchists. October 30, 1997. Web. Accessed April 12, 2017. www.ainfos.ca/A-Infos97/4/0320.html.
[34] Ibid.
[35] Douglas Quan, “Necessary force: Students accuse police of brutality”. The Ubyssey (Vancouver): 1. Vol 79 Iss 23. 28 November 1997. Web. Accessed 8 June 2017. https://open.library.ubc.ca/collections/ubcpublications/ubysseynews/items/1.0126666#p0z-5r0f:necessary%20force:%20Students%20accuse%20police%20of%20brutality
[36] Alan Doyle. “B.C. Civil Liberties Association - APEC Inquiry fonds,” December 2002, last revised September 2010. Finding aid at the University of British Columbia Archives, Vancouver, BC. Doyle, A. 2002. B.C. Civil Liberties Association - APEC Inquiry fonds. UBC Archives. Accessed April 12, 2017. https://www.library.ubc.ca/archives/u_arch/bc_civil_liberties_association.pdf.
[37] Kajta-Anton Cronauer. "Questions on APEC Alert." Online interview by Steph Glanzmann and Noni Nabors. March 23, 2017.
[38] Garth Mullins. "Questions on APEC Alert." Interview by Noni Nabors. March 15, 2017.
[39] Cronauer’s “Activism and the Internet: A socio-political analysis of how the use of mailing lists affects mobilization in social movement organizations” (2004) discovered that from the APEC-Alert email list 72 messages were sent by women, 266 were sent by men, and 17 were sent by individuals whose gender is unknown.
[40] Kajta-Anton Cronauer. "Questions on APEC Alert." Online interview by Steph Glanzmann and Noni Nabors. March 23, 2017.
[41] Ibid.
[42] Ibid.
[43] Ibid.
Images
APEC protesters gathering outside the Walter C. Koerner Library at the University of British Columbia in November 1997. Photograph by Todd Tubutis. Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) collection, series 6, box 3, file 6-9. Courtesy of UBC Museum of Anthropology, Vancouver, Canada.
Police presence at the University of British Columbia in November 1997. Photograph by Maria Roth. Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) collection, series 6, box 3, file 6-1. Courtesy of UBC Museum of Anthropology.
Demoville Tent City outside the old Student Union Building at the University of British Columbia in November 1997. Photograph by Todd Tubutis. Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) collection, series 6, box 3, file 6-9. Courtesy of UBC Museum of Anthropology, Vancouver, Canada.
APEC protesters gathering outside the Walter C. Koerner Library at the University of British Columbia in November 1997. Photograph by Todd Tubutis. Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) collection, series 6, box 3, file 6-9. Courtesy of UBC Museum of Anthropology, Vancouver, Canada.
APEC protesters gathering outside the Walter C. Koerner Library at the University of British Columbia in November 1997. Photograph by Todd Tubutis. Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) collection, series 6, box 3, file 6-9. Courtesy of UBC Museum of Anthropology, Vancouver, Canada.














