PODCAKE'S TOP REVIEWED PODCASTS OF 2025
i've always wanted to do one of those end of the year send offs, and what better way to sum up another exciting year of podcake then with my personal rewards show, commending all the wonderful audio drama i reviewed this year?
bear in mind, that these are shows that i reviewed throughout 2025, not strictly shows that debuted during 2025.
also, even if i really wanted to, i was only able to hand out so many rewards for the grand total of thirteen shows i covered, so, unfortunately, not all audio dramas i talked about this year will be featured.
now, let's get started! ♡
receiving the reward for best original music is childish
childish was a brief listen but also a very fun, very punchy one that makes the most of its short runtime. it's really the dialogue that did it for me in childish, but i simply can't deny my love for its music, being one of few audio dramas out there with a rap-centric soundtrack.
my review of childish: the podcast musical
receiving the reward for most feel-good listen is life with leo(h)
i have plans to do a full deep dive for the works of @atypicalartists so consider this commemoration of 2021's life with leo(h) as a sort of precedent to my plans for "atypical august".
life with leo(h) to its very core is an adorable, sci-fi(ish) romantic comedy, filled to the brink with good vibes, good humor, and good characters, which makes for an all around strong package for anyone looking for an endearing, low stakes listen.
my review of life with leo(h)
receiving the reward for best worldbuilding is @killjamxxx
killjam xxx is yet another audio drama darling from the we are not alive crew, an amazing addition to the 2025 line up and one of the most innovative out there.
dubbing it as a "post-punk" entry to the audio drama scene, the world of killjam is as brutal as it is brightly colored, a bold cyberpunk endeavor never seen before that gets its hooks into you from bubbly start to bloody finish.
my review of killjam xxx
receiving the reward for most bingeworthy is @brimstonevalleymall
when it came to figuring out my halloween recommendations, there was none i was more eager to revisit again than brimstone valley mall-the show has demons, that counts for something.
brimstone valley mall is simply a fun time, and anyone with a particular craving for nineties memorabilia and the early stages of the goth scene simply must check it out.
brimstone comes with a delightfully devilish two seasons packed with excellent humor, a magnetic ensemble cast, and the kind of playful edginess that gives the entire series a one-of-a-kind attitude.
my review of brimstone valley mall
receiving the reward for best sound design is dreamboy
adding another splash of insanity and erotica to my summer was night vale presents', dreamboy, a weird and wonderfully produced hidden gem from 2018 that i simply struggle to put into words.
which is okay because to simply listen to dreamboy is a riveting experience in itself, this gorgeously detailed sound design feeding into its strong music motif makes an already great show even greater
my review of dreamboy
receiving the reward for best production art is hearthbound
kudos to @straylungs for creating some gorgeous title cards that truly represent the energy of their show, hearthbound: an untelling of the odyssey!
i once did an article about the importance of presentation in the audio drama space, and hearthbound's rustic charm and homey yet melancholy vibe is encapsulated perfectly by its stunning collection of original illustrations.
my review of hearthbound: an untelling of the odyssey
receiving the reward for most atmospheric is the sulphuric secrets
filling out my late spring review was the sulpuric secrets, a gripping and excellently creepy horror show detailing the whereabouts of cults and conspiracy theories with a sort of unnerving, clinical detachment to its narrative style.
the show's off-putting, atmospheric vibe and blending of reality and fiction really left an impression on me, and while i can't say i've listened to many horror shows this year, this one definitely got my skin crawling.
my review of the sulphuric secrets
receiving the reward for favorite newcomer is @wakerscast
i've already voiced my appreciation for wakers, even making it my special entry for tink media's 2025 audio delicacies, but i'd be doing myself a disservice to not properly honor it with the prize for my favorite 2025 newcomer.
many wonderful 2025 audio dramas came out this year, but something about wakers really stuck with me, and i look forward to seeing more of it hopefully sooner than later.
my review of wakers
thank you all so much for reading and i look forward to making these little reward shows a regular thing going forward! (better late than never, right?)
and thank you to all the audio drama creators out there who filled my 2025 with so much wonder and discovery, be it rekindling my love for old favorites or finding new ones.
and, if you've read this far, consider supporting the blog and following for more audio drama excellence!
♡ i'll see you all next year for a positively pink 2026! ♡















