many people demanded the list so here we go! this list is anachronistic and uncomprehensive! cheer up me lads let your hearts never fail! [spotify playlist]
1. Don’t Forget Your Old Shipmate
it doesn’t get more homoerotic than this
2. The Handsome Cabin Boy
three cheers for the ‘girl dresses as a boy to go to sea’ motif! ‘And the captain’s wife she says to him, “My dear I wish you joy, / For it’s either you or I betrayed the handsome cabin boy.”’
3. My Johnny’s Gone To Hilo/Tom’s Gone To Hilo
shoutout to the first-person pov in this mournful shanty about a lover who’s gone away to sea
the pathos of cameraderie in the face of a cruel captain! ‘So then the cabin boy he swam unto the starboard side / Saying, “Messmates, take me up for I am drifting with the tide.”’
5. Greenland Whale Fisheries
depending on the version - some have the captain lamenting the loss of the whale more than the lives of his crew, others vice versa. all are bops
the lyrics make it pretty clear that the ‘her’ refers to the ship, but the ambiguity is still good, and either way it has a strong sense of cameraderie and the tune is a+
some good old-fashioned rousing patriotism and loyalty to your heroic captain. there are two versions of this song and they’d both do fine on this list but i’m going with this one for this verse: ‘Now the guns they did rattle and the bullets did fly, / But brave Admiral Benbow for help would not cry; / “Take me down to the cockpit, there is ease for my smarts, / If my merry men see me, it would sure break their hearts.”’
‘haul away together’/‘haul for better weather’ is up there on the list of ‘good if unintentional metaphors for gay solidarity’. also featuring the very gay moods of regicide and being told to kiss girls by your parents
9. The Bonny Ship The Diamond
‘Now don’t you weep, my bonny lass, though you be left behind, / For the rose will bloom on Greenland’s ice before we change our mind.’ this earns points for being very similar to some verses quoted in moby-dick
this is a song about holding hands with franklin. what more do you want