Roxane Gay called me (and Rachel Sawdy) cute!
I attended Roxane Gay’s speech last week at St. Thomas. I always enjoy going to readings because I think it sheds a new light on the passage. Gay’s writing is extremely lively and entertaining on the page; however, hearing her read it first-hand was an entirely different experience. It was very clear how much of herself she pours into her writing, as it seems like such a natural extension of her personality. When she started reading her essay about the UPS man I nearly didn’t realize that it was an essay and not just a very artfully articulated story.
      Although I was looking forward to encountering such a prestigious and well-known author, I will admit that I was a little nervous. I have struggled with the idea of feminism because there are a lot of things about me that, I think, would go against typical feminist beliefs. For example, I would love to be a stay at home mom one day—I’m perfectly content with the notion of my husband being the breadwinner and me staying at home, being a homemaker and raising my kids. I am also very pro-life and feel very strongly against abortion being legal. I don’t like the idea that it seems like in today’s culture we are pushing for men and women to be so much the same because I think men and women are supposed to be different—equal in rights, but different and complimentary. I know Roxane Gay’s whole point is that it’s okay to be a “bad Feminist,” but I don’t really proclaim myself as a feminist at all, and I was worried that I would feel shame for that after listening to her speak. Thankfully, that was not the case.
      The question and answer portion of Gay’s visit was really inspiring for me. I took the opportunity to ask her a question and inquired about one of her essays that we read for class, “Not Here to Make Friends.” I was intrigued by this essay because Gay works through the idea that our flaws are what make us human and our imperfections make us real. I agree with this, but struggled with the idea that we shouldn’t try to improve our flaws. So, I asked Gay to what degree we should embrace our flaws versus try and become a better version of ourselves. She responded, as eloquently as ever, that we should accept what we can about ourselves because we can be flawed and still be valuable. In turn, she also warned us not to let acceptance of our flaws allow us to be complacent. Although that was a really powerful sentiment for me, I think the moment when I most connected with her message is when she addressed how to have the conversation about feminism with people who aren’t feminists (i.e. me). She really emphasized how important it was not to shame people, because when you shame people they shut down. I think that’s what has happened to me when I have encountered “traditional” feminism. I feel ashamed and then turn away from the notion entirely; however, I can see now that it is okay to not agree with every degree of feminism because I think it means something a little different for everyone. Like Roxane Gay said, I would rather be bad feminist, than not a feminist at all.