Into the Light - 11 of 18
(Some readers may find content within this section upsetting.)
Bryan tapped ‘ambulance at the doyles’ and sent it to his wife. He swiped the app closed and consulted his rearview mirror. Nothing. He looked into the house as best he could. It looked empty. His phone chirped. ‘what happened?’ ‘dunno’ he replied.
Given Suzanne’s and Bill’s size, Bryan assumed one of them had had a coronary. That’s where the road of weight gain heads. Bryan’s dad Ron fattened in retirement. Heart attacks followed. The last one brought his miserable life to a swift end. Bryan thought about the funeral and all of the handshakes and pats on the back.
His dad’s friends, those that were still among the living, were effusive in their praise at the podium. A patriot. A war hero. A helluva engineer. A loyal friend. Gruff, sure, but loyal. It didn’t sound like the man Bryan knew, but that’s what death provokes us to do. Revise.
When people die, we file them away. Sometimes we file them away sooner, but in the end the bereaved never fail to come together and catalog. We put labels on the box of memories and ship it to the archives. Few who attend a man’s funeral tag the box with Asshole after seeing so many people weep over him.
If Suzanne or Bill had died, more than just their vital state had switched. Yesterday’s gluttony was today’s love of life’s simple pleasures. Bill used to be a long-winded bore, but now he’d be a gifted conversationalist. Suzanne wasn’t out and about as much, so Bryan could only speculate about her. From the times he’d heard her muffled rage as he jogged by the Doyle’s house, he could guess yesterday’s short-fuse was today’s indomitable spirit.
Since Ron’s funeral, Bryan has wondered about his own service. How would his shortcomings be spun? Bryan mused about how his character would be burnished by his death. His awkwardness would become his eccentricity. His aloofness would become even-temperedness.
He wondered about the mourners, too. Who in the audience would inwardly dispute this communal act of reclassification? Would someone feel ashamed for denigrating the dead in her heart but also find it irresistible? Would there be someone in the audience who knew Bryan better than the rest? Had she told anyone else? Would the others be at her side, handing her tissues for a different type of tear?
Even when a eulogist revealed a little something dark, a little something unseemly, it was in the service of a larger narrative. The admission was for the sake of rounding out the picture of an exceptional human being who will be missed, flaws and all.
And wasn’t it a little something from long ago, spontaneous, even confused or accidental, that morning when the two of them were supposed to stay back and clean the campsite before joining the adults at the lake? What of that isolated mistake?
Did the fractured memories not pop up with the smell of pine needles, for instance, it’d be forgettable. It was a different Bryan, a much younger, more vulnerable Bryan that could have asked her to do... Could have lead her to do... And did ask and lead in his shaded Boy Scout’s tent. If only but no. The same Bryan who did that thing is responding to his wife of four year’s ‘anything yet?’ with a ‘not yet’ .
And what does she think, accepting the bowl of mashed potatoes passed to her at the Thanksgiving table with the hands that had touched her? And what does her husband think of Bryan, as he hugs her and sincerely rubs her back and earnestly says it’s great to see them as always. Does he know what a very lost younger version of Bryan did? The sights he saw with his eyes that see her now, grown up and happy with a child of her own? The thrill he sensed in his fingertips, standing before him 16 years after the fact, handing her a poorly written card or explaining to the husband how to solder? The nausea he felt in his stomach in the years before suppression took over and how he couldn’t maintain a stable romance until his mid-20s because bedrooms reminded him of forest floors?
Bryan could read it on his sister’s face. He could detect it in the brief dead stares his brother-in-law flashed him in the lulls they shared digesting pie. The judgment. The everlasting condemnation. He could make out the label on his own box in the mirror of her look.
Not a convicted child molester, but a child molester all the same. Not written on one of those records, but on a record all the same. And also: male, son, brother, artist, assistant manager, uncle, husband, and maybe someday father if his wife has her way. The labels were never enough, yet they pegged him. How he hated being pegged. He was a man defined by secret knowledge. But the definition was in the truth, not in the knowing. Thought, written, or spoken. Frequently or never. It didn’t matter. The facts—under the covers or spotlit—muddied everything.
Which is part of why Bryan never said sorry. Especially not to her. To his little sister, Emily. He was probably sorry. He registered a dull and blunt something every time that family trip was recalled. Gummy worms. Scrunchies. Umbro shorts. The emotion could have been remorse.
But as to saying sorry, no. Because what would it do? That was the thing. It would do, not undo. You can apologize, but apologies add. They don’t subtract. They add how you feel after the fact, how much you wish and have even let yourself believe that after the fact, it wasn’t actually a fact but a fictional event, and how at this great distance the memories, those brief clips that represent a small fraction of what actually took place, are made-up.
Which is why, on the other hand, Bryan wouldn’t allow himself to be forgiven. Although she tried. In the way she fearlessly presented her little girl to him to be held, she had absolved Bryan as best she could. But when holding this squirming creature on his lap, a tiny reproduction of the girl he betrayed, he felt his guilt. The baby was right for wanting to wriggle away. His sister’s forgiveness overlooks, but the facts remain underneath the line of sight. The past doesn’t forgive. It can’t. It’s impersonal.
The facts were what kept, keeps, and will always keep him from ever acknowledging, let alone apologizing for, what he did to Emi. 31 miles away from where he was sitting. There is no sorry to atone with. No unspoken undoing. It is an unrectifiable wrong that he carries with him in the back of his head all the time but that, more importantly, is true of him, whether or not he carries it, or she carries it, or any of their family, friends, or significant others carry it, or whether everyone lets it go when he goes into the ground in another 30 or 40 years. It never, ever goes away. At best it gets forgotten, or maybe suppressed or denied. But that’s just like eulogies. Wishful thinking.