Bees and whales are going extinct and being changed to fit into the wars that humans create. The effects on the militarization of dolphins have still yet to be seen, but can be assumed to happen because their nature is being changed just like the bees. Nature has a breaking point to where if the nature of the dolphins is changed past that breaking point their population is going to die off just like how the bees reached their breaking point. People don’t talk about how to stop animals from being used wars, but are more likely to discuss how to keep animals safe in war. The nature of the bees and dolphins should not be altered to fit the needs of modern war. In changing animal’s instinct and/or physical features it is making them more likely to be able to survive in war. The effects of militarization of honeybees can be seen through the bee population dying off, like the bees, the dolphins are being militarized, but the effects are yet to be seen.
Bees have been used in war since the beginning of warfare. The war tactic of swarming the enemy came from how the bees will swarm an enemy that is attacking the hive. Bees have also been catapulted onto the enemy because bees swarm and sting when they feel threatened. In order to control a country, the enemy country would take over the bee population because then the food supply would be in the control of whoever had control over the bees. Bees are fighting a war against the change in their environment, physical changes and behavioral changes that humans have brought about. In “Ecologies of Empire: On the New Uses of the Honeybee” Jake Kosek writes “This question demands attention to entangled histories of humans and bees and to current remakings of the modern honeybee. It also requires an epidemiology mindful of how human interests, fears, and desires have become part of the material form of the bee. This remaking is not just symbolic. The bee has experienced transformations to its exoskeleton, its nervous system, its digestive tract, and its collective social behavior. There are many sites (from federal laboratories to the backyards of beekeepers), as well as many pressures (from industrial agriculture to global climate changes), involved in the remaking of the bee.” The honeybee is being remade in order to survive in this world, but is no longer able to survive due to the changes that have occurred. One reason for the honey bee being remade is to be able to be used for military purposes, such as detecting landmines.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1548-1360.2010.01073.x/full
The picture above shows how bees are being trained to detect chemicals in land mines. The bees are stretching out their proboscis towards the chemical. When a bee successfully reacts to the chemical, it is rewarded with sugar water. The bee is being trained to look for mines rather than to go with it’s survival instinct and look for food. Bees genes are being altered so that they have a tougher outer shell so that they are less affected by the rising temperatures. Due to the changes in the bee, the population of bees have been in decline. scientists have called the declining bee population Colony Collapse Disorder and it is caused by a multiple of factors, but the main one would have to be the change in the behavior and physical appearance of the bee. The bee has reached it’s limit to where it is no longer capable to live in the world.
Like bees, dolphins are being trained to detect underwater mines. Dolphins, unlike bees though there is no known effects on the dolphin population. The dolphins nature are being trained to locate and then mark underwater mines, so that they can be disarmed before a ship gets blown up. $14 million is being given to the Navy to train dolphins to be trained to detect mines. Dolphins are being used because of their intelligence, trainability and speed in water. To detect underwater mines dolphins are being trained to detect mines by using their echolocation. The sound bounces of the mine and the dolphin finds where the mine is, goes and marks it with a locator devices and then will receive a reward such as a fish from the handler.
Bees and dolphins are trained to be used in war, but they are unaware of the effects that will happen if they don’t perform the tasks correct. If a soldier dies or a ship blows because a bee or dolphin didn’t do their task correctly, they are not going to feel know that a person has died or even care.
Dolphin’s and bees are being trained to be used directly in war, as whales are becoming innocent victims in the wars. Whales are dying off because of the rising sound levels in the ocean due to sonar usage to detect submarines. Whales are needing to either adapt all die of because of the raise in noise levels in the ocean. Since wars have been taken to the ocean, dolphins and whales have had to learn to adapt to ships and noise levels rising in the ocean. There is no other known safe way to detect mines rather than using bees and dolphins. Bees and dolphins are used because they are relatively safe because they won’t trip the mines when they locate they like a human would.
The articles are similar in that they are focused on the effects of using animals in war and the change in the way the animal thinks and act. Like how the honey bee is trained to detect a mine and changes its dance so that it can receive sugar water as a reward. Bees and dolphins are being trained for military use, as whales are being made victims by the rising noise levels. Whales, honeybees, and dolphins have to adapt to the new way of life brought about by the expansion of war zones.
The bees and the whales are facing extinction. The bees are affected on the raise in temperature due to climate change, genetic changes to harden their outer shell, the training to change their instincts to detect land mines instead of looking for food, and the scarcity of food sources. Whales are facing extinction because of the raising temperature of the ocean due to climate change, plastic pollution in the ocean and the raising of noise levels in the ocean due to Navy sonar testing. With bees and whales facing extinction it is easy to say that the dolphins will soon be facing extinction.
Information on the declining bee and whale population is well known as the dolphins are not yet facing extinction, but soon in the future they will be. Bees and whales have been pushed to the point in which they can no longer adapt and are dying off. The dolphin is the next victim, but it doesn’t stand alone other animals that are being used for military purposes are going to be dying off.
To decide whether or not bees and dolphins should be used in war, alternatives would have to be presented. People aren’t going to stop fighting wars, so there will have to be an alternative to using bees and dolphins to detect mines. The issue of human lives over animals lives will have to be decided upon, and in most cases human lives will always trump animal lives.
Survival in the new changing temperature, noise levels, and behaviors means that the animals have to evolve or die off because it is no longer able to survive. If the whale doesn’t evolve to fit into the noisy ocean it is going to die off. Honeybees might have reached their limit to how much a human can alter their genes and the bee still be able to live. The question that still remains is is it fair to change and use honey bees and dolphins in war, and how far can we change their nature until their population reaches the breaking point and die off?
Anthony, Sebastian. “Honeybees Trained to Sniff out Land Mines, Might Replace Sniffer Dogs in Airports | ExtremeTech.” ExtremeTech. Http://www.extremetech.com/extreme/156259-honeybees-trained-to-sniff-out-land-mines-might-replace-sniffer-dogs-in-airports, 2013. Web. 30 Sept. 2015.
Bienaimé, Pierre. “The US Navy’s Combat Dolphins Are Serious Military Assets.” Business Insider. Business Insider, Inc, 12 Mar. 2015. Web. 21 Oct. 2015.
Bale, Rachael. “Everything You Wanted to Know about the Bee Die-off.” Reveal.Https://www.revealnews.org/article/everything-you-wanted-to-know-about-the-bee-die-off/, 20 Feb. 2015. Web. 30 Sept. 2015.
Kosek, Jake. "ECOLOGIES OF EMPIRE: On the New Uses of the Honeybee." Web. 7 Nov. 2015.
Writing to bring awareness to an environmental, social or ethical issue that needs to be addressed to bring about a change.
In my paper I address the issue of militarizing bees to the point in which they are dying off and how this can relate to the later effects that dolphins will suffer. The effects that militarization have on dolphins have yet to be seen but can be inferred based on the effect it has on bees.
Gathering of information to support an idea. Information from another person's writing that is built upon or supports the main argument of a paper.
I researched the militarization of bees and dolphins and the effects that the military has on whales.
Luis Amezcua suggested in my peer review that I should be less general in the sense of using the words bees, dolphins and whales instead of using the term animals, or what kind of changes that are happening. He suggested that I should add the photo of the bees being trained to be useful for military purposes.