"You're Not A Real Gamer": The Fake Gamer, the Gamer Girl, and Other Nonsense
Iâve played and loved a lot of video games from a lot of different genres: from turn-based strategy like Jagged Alliance 2 to first-person shooters like Black and Left4Dead to action RPGs like Dragon Age: Origins. But for every game I have played, there are hundredsâthousands, evenâof other games that Iâve never heard of, let alone played. Yet I donât see this as an earth-shattering, unforgivable transgression, because (1) more often than not, I have stuff that needs to be done, (2) I canât afford to buy all the video games Iâd like to play, and (3) some games just donât appeal to me (like games set in outer space). I still consider myself a gamer.
Suppose that one day, I happen to enter an online discussion as a girl with a bunch of guys who also love video games. The conversation moves to a game Iâve never playedâmaybe Pokemon or Star Craftâso I voice my ignorance. What might be their response?
If you havenât played it, then youâre not a real gamer.
You probably donât even really like video games.
I bet youâre doing it for the attention.
Youâre one of those Gamer Girls, arenât you?
Go back to the kitchen and make me a sandwich.
Years of slaying darkspawn, overthrowing the evil dictator Deidrianna, and thinking with portalsâall invalidated because I didnât play a few games.
After all, isnât that why all girls play video gamesâto get guys to notice and validate them?
Over the past two decades, more and more women have been playing and loving video games. From a paltry 3% in 1989, female gamers comprised 47% of the game-playing population in 2012. Thatâs practically half! Yet certain members of the male half seem intent on keeping the female half out of the MMORPG and in the kitchen.
The amount of backlash that women face as a result of their participation in the video game industry is astounding. Anita Sarkeesian of Tropes Vs. Women in Video Games fame has received countless rape and death threats on all of her social media platforms. A petition on Change.org tried to get Carolyn Petit fired from Gamespot after she commented on Grand Theft Auto Vâs misogynistic portrayal of women. Countless women have stories of their knowledge and skill in video games being questioned so much so that a whole blog called Fat, Ugly or Slutty is devoted to them. Despite comprising almost half of all gamers, it seems like women are regarded as outsiders who will never be ârealâ gamers.
Enter the âFake Gamerâ and the âGamer Girl.â These two pejorative terms describe how female gamers are perceived in the gaming community. Although they might sound similar and are indeed related, I will use them to describe the two distinct models Iâve observed. Iâm not saying that all female gamers can be categorized according to these models. Far from it, in fact. What I am saying is that when it comes to criticizing women who play video games, these two models arise.
The first model, the Fake Gamer, can be illustrated by the example I gave in the first part of this blog post. The Fake Gamer is an ordinary woman who enjoys playing video games as much as any gamer. She might even be a devoted fan of certain games, like Assassinâs Creed or the Bioshock series. But any video game knowledge or skill she possesses is no match for that of her male counterpart. No, that shitâs too mainstream. He might challenge her to validate her knowledge of the game and if she doesnât know this tiny, obscure detail, then OH MY GOD WHAT A POSER SEND HER BACK TO THE KITCHEN BROJOS BEFORE SHOJOS
 The Gamer Girl is a slightly different story. Unlike the Fake Gamer label, which is used exclusively by men, Gamer Girl is used by both men and women to refer to a particular subset of female gamers. Like the Fake Gamer, she might also enjoy playing video games and demonstrate a high degree of knowledge on the games she loves. The key difference behind the Gamer Girl and the Fake Gamer is the motive for gaming. The Fake Gamer plays for fun; the Gamer Girl plays to get noticed by men. The Gamer Girl realizes that gaming is a boysâ club, and will do whatever she can to infiltrate it. This might include posing suggestively with a console controller or spontaneous declarations of her love for video games or cosplaying video game characters. The Gamer Girl feels the need to stress the fact that sheâs a girl who plays video games to distinguish herself from other women. This can breed hostility with other women who play video games, who make it a point to separate themselves from Gamer Girls: âIâm not a Gamer Girl, Iâm a girl who games.âÂ
The root of these two models can be found in what social psychologists call ingroup-outgroup bias. We define ourselves in terms of social groupings. These groupings are determined by shared, often arbitrary characteristics: we might be of the same nationality, support the same sports teams, or have the same hobbies. Anyone who shares these characteristics forms our ingroup, while everyone who doesnât forms our outgroup. We will defend the members of our ingroup because they give us the self-esteem and support we need, and decry any outside interlopers.
Now letâs apply that to the video game community. A certain portion of male gamers feel that their ingroup of "realâ gamers is being threatened the outgroup of female gamers, so they denounce them as âfakeâ gamers whenever they intrude in the male-dominated space of video games.
Ingroup-outgroup bias can also explain the Gamer Girl model. Female gamers push Gamer Girls into the outgroup because they feel that their motivations (playing for fun vs. playing for attention) are different. Because Gamer Girls donât get the support the need from other female gamers, they will try to find a new ingroup by way of male gamers.
These two models can lead to undesirable consequences. One of the most well-known pictures that poke fun at Gamer Girls is of a girl named Courtney, often coupled with the caption âYes, I play video games.â Unsurprisingly, the photo was met with nerdrage as male and female gamers alike denounced her as a âfake gamer girl.â
As it turns out, Courtney took the picture as a joke for her boyfriend, who at that time was so in love with his PS3 that she decided to express her own love for her XBox. In reality, sheâs been playing video games since she was 3 years old, and unlike the Gamer Girl label that other gamers decided to force on her, she doesnât feel the need âspout to everyone that [sheâs] a gamer.â
People werenât aware of these facts, yet they still saw fit to pass judgement on her:
âI was honestly baffled by how many assumptions everyone could come up with about who I was based off of one photo. Apparently Iâm a slutty bitch who borrows her brotherâs Xbox to take photos in an attempt to seduce the men of the internet by feigning interest in gaming.â
Iâm not denying that some people really do play video games for attention. Itâs definitely not impossible. But I think the same can be said for every hobby; why fixate on Gamer Girls?
Iâm also certain that not all male gamers view female gamers as either Fake Gamers or Gamer Girls. I have the good fortune of having many male gamer friends who simply see me as a fellow gamer whenever we play video games together; my gender has no bearing on my skill, and as such is of no consequence.
Does anyone really have the right to wear the Gamer Inquisitorâs badge and decide whoâs a ârealâ gamer? To paraphrase the Youtuber albinwonderland, you can own every video game in the world, but you donât have the right to decide who can enjoy them. No one has that right. Names like âreal gamerâ and âfake gamerâ only serve to divide a community that should be playing together and enjoying video games together.
I have a revolutionary idea: letâs all just be gamers.
Now pass me that controller.