Pretty Little Liars @a-nowcrylater - Tumblr Blog

ENDGAME THEORY: 🧵😱😭

Geezus. This shit is getting good. This 🅰️ is really sick and cutting DEEP. Tabby and Imogen being the ones who were raped was calculated. This rapist isn’t terrorizing ALL high school girls.

Imogen is the daughter of Davie. Davie was the leader who made the decision to ignore Angela after she’d been raped and needed help.

Tabby is the daughter of Sidney. Sidney made the decision to turn away from Angela, even as she begged for help on her hands and knees.

Imogen and Tabby were raped for the sins of their mothers. 🅰️ wants the mothers to have to deal with the burden and trauma of knowing their daughters were violated and no one helped them either. Like Angela…

KAREN died for more than one reason. The main one being, because she’s the daughter of Sheriff Beasley. Sheriff Beasley raped Angela. Ultimately, she killed herself, because of what HE did to her.

I initially thought Karen died, because she was a bully and 🅰️ hates bullies. That was only the surface though. The deeper reason was because of who her father is.

🅰️ manipulated Kelly and that’s what has added to her sorrow. 🅰️ is the one who suggested the Carrie scenario. 🅰️ wanted to be certain to get Karen up on that level. He needed Karen to die the same way as Angela. Symbolism.

Now, Sheriff Beasley has to deal with the agony of knowing his daughter died in the exact same way as his rape victim.

Kelly thinks 🅰️ has been helping her and has her best interest. That’s why he switched up his appearance when threatening her in the theater. If she were really Kelly he didn’t want to risk losing her trust and loyalty to 🅰️.

Are you guys keeping up?? It’s getting wild. 😭 This 🅰️ has the strategic planning capabilities of a fucking General Officer in the military.

Kelly is this season’s Mona. Mona was manipulated by CeCe/Ali. Remember the famous, “I did everything you asked me to”…?

It’s possible that this mystery, 6th “A. Waters” was pregnant by her rapist, Sheriff Beasley. I just know he’s related to the twins by blood in some way. Uncle/cousin/sibling…something.

If the 6th “A. Waters” was pregnant, that means her child would be 5-6 years older than the girls. Born some time in 2000. 😳 The only person around them who fits that age bracket, is Wes.

🅰️ showing up while Wes is in the car with Tabby, is meant to throw us off. He can’t be in 2 places at once, right? Sure, but we already know there’s more than one person in play. An “🅰️ team.”

We haven’t heard much about Chip and Wes’ background. I bet they’re brothers, but obviously with different fathers. Our mystery “A. Waters” may have given Wes up for adoption and he found his way to Millwood once he got older.

Chip may not even be aware of who Wes really is. And now I think Chip is another red herring…last night, I was convinced he was probably the rapist, but nah.

Tabby is going to find a way to use the donated blood to find out who hurt her and Imogen. She’s going to convince Chip to donate with them. She ALWAYS convinces Chip to join in her shenanigans.

They’re going to get a familial DNA hit. They’ll see Imogen’s baby is related by blood to Chip, but he’s not the father. NIPP can be done after 8 weeks of pregnancy. It’s a non-invasive prenatal paternity procedure.

Chip will be just as shocked as them to find out he’s related to Imogen’s child.

Wes is into horror films. It makes sense that he would choose a Carrie scenario for Karen’s demise. In this scene, he told us he was doing “research.” He basically looked us dead in our faces and said, “I’m 🅰️.” 😭

His “research” was for creative, horrific ideas in how to torture the girls and their moms. Lastly, Tyler died for fucking with Tabby. We all know Wes is obsessed with her.

🅰️ = Wes + 1.

#pll #prettylittleliars #plltheories #pllclues #pll original sin #hbo max #plltheory #finale

I absolutely loved the finale and I’m so excited we’re getting a season 2. I can’t wait to drive myself crazy coming up with new theories. 😭

#prettylittleliars #plltheories #pllclues #pll #hbo max #pll original sin #plltheory #finale #pllos #pll os finale

I really like the idea of Chip being the one in the theater costume chasing Kelly. That would mean he knows Wes is his brother and they’re definitely working together.

I haven’t decided where I stand on that yet. I’m currently rewatching every episode.

#prettylittleliars #plltheories #pllclues #pll #hbo max #pll original sin #plltheory #finale

a-nowcrylater

Theory time. 🧐🧵

Kelly is sneaky as hell and unhinged. Karen was the loudmouth, but Kelly is absolutely more sinister. She was the quieter one so easily overlooked in comparison to Karen. Overlooking Kelly is a dangerous mistake.

Karen had a life. Kelly comes off as “just there.” She probably had a lot of time to herself whenever Karen was out with her friends and boyfriend. During that time, I think she did some digging into their family history.

I think the twins’ mom is Angela’s sister. Making Angela their aunt. We know Angela’s mom had some type of mental issues. That can be hereditary.

I mention hereditary, because it’s been clear from jump that Mrs. Beasley is a bit off. So, Kelly’s “research” into her family history led her to Angela and that led her to A. She probably found A in some type of Radley Sanitarium.

Angela was obsessed with reading the Scarlet Letter. I think she had a child. I think Davie and the others judged her over it. Well, Davie judged. They followed her lead. They were all friends at some point.

That’s why Davie screamed when she saw Angela was going to jump. She screamed the loudest. It’s also why Davie was so determined to be there for her daughter now that she’s a pregnant teen.

So, I think A is Angela’s child. I think she was forced to give him up at some point and it fucked with her mentally. It’s probably why Sidney said there were things they couldn’t help her with.

Are you guys keeping up? Angela is Mrs. Beasley’s sister. Angela is the twins’ aunt. A is Angela’s child. A is the twins’ cousin. Kelly found A in a nut house…my money is on Radley Sanitarium.

Kelly built a bond with her crazy cousin, A. Kelly feels like she can relate to her cousin. They’ve both been discarded. They’ve both been robbed of the life they think they deserved.

Kelly comes off as extremely protective of her sister, but she’s really extremely JEALOUS of Karen. Kelly knew Imogen didn’t kiss Greg. She planted that seed in Karen’s head on purpose.

Karen was genuinely shocked at the girls accusing her of setting them up, because she really didn’t do any of it. Kelly did…with the help of her cousin.

In detention, Noa says Karen probably got her sister to swap her pee. That’s a huge hint at how everyone views the dynamic of Karen and Kelly. EVERYONE thinks Karen is the mastermind to everything and Kelly is the puppet.

Well, everyone has it twisted. Kelly has always been the mentally stronger twin. She’s been showing us throughout each of the first three episodes. She’s a manipulative, evil little cunt. She gets a kick out of seeing Karen hurt.

Kelly lied to Karen about Imogen. Kelly was in the office when she saw Noa do her drug test and she heard them talk about her drug test schedule. Kelly heard Karen bitching about ballet.

Kelly was there when she heard Imogen say she would be running against Karen. Kelly orchestrated every single thing that happened to Karen and made it look like it was the girls coming after her. 6 birds, 1 stone.

I’m also pretty sure Kelly had Karen give that flyer to Davie. Bottom line, Kelly and her cousin are A. At some point we’ll learn Mrs. Beasley’s maiden name is Waters and she’s the older sister of Angela.

a-nowcrylater

Update to my theory:

After seeing this photo in this week’s episode, I think 🅰️ is most likely her brotner. It’s possible he’s a different relative…uncle, or even cousin, but I think brother is most likely. I definitely believe they’re related by blood. So, based off of my theory, that would make 🅰️ the uncle of Kelly and Karen. This photo looks like it’s from the early 80s and that lines up with AW being in high school in 1999.

#pll theories #pllclues #plltheory #pll clues #pll original sin #hbo max #pll

The new episodes were so good. Faran was definitely the majority of this fandom thinking Kelly is Karen.

Kelly is Kelly and Mallory Bechtel is my favorite. 😭

#prettylittleliars #pllclues #pll #plltheories #hbo max #pll original sin #plltheory

When Zaria Simone retweets what you’ve been screaming at the top of your lungs for days and you feel a little vindicated. 🥴😂🤣

#prettylittleliars #plltheories #pll #pllclues #pll original sin #plltheory #hbo max

Kelly, watching everyone freak the fuck out and immediately blame Karen…and Karen immediately blame them…not even looking her way. Enjoying the fruits of her labor.

#pll original sin #plltheories #prettylittleliars #pll #pllclues #hbo max #plltheory

Politely blocking people who are regurgitating theories as their own. That shit is annoying.

#pll #prettylittleliars #plltheories #pllclues #hbo max #pll original sin #plltheory

m0tel6mxzzy-deactivated20250326

i feel so bad for kelly she’s such a sweetheart and she loved her sister so much 😭😭😭

a-nowcrylater

I’m loving that so many people seem to have this view, because they’re going to be floored when the truth is made even clearer. Kelly is far from a sweetheart and she was extremely jealous of Karen.

I’m enjoying seeing her play this role so well. She has the majority of viewers fooled. Everyone thinks Karen was the real bitch.

#kelly beasley #pll original sin #pll #prettylittleliars #plltheories #pllclues #hbo max #plltheory