#i feel like this is also the stance of the movies#because lando spends approximately zero seconds redeeming himself#think of how black characters are usually treated for betrayals#even if it is an airquote betrayal#lando helps at the end of esb and is officially one of the heroes no redemption necessary#the whole choking thing is a misunderstanding really tags via cadesama
#also note how Leia forgave him #real fast#this is a woman who does not do forgiveness easily #but she knew he was right#she was fully aware of that #she was angry because she loves Han#but she moved past it #because she knew he was right#the movie knows he’s right #the characters know he’s right#it isn’t even a question
Lando is 100% right to do what he did. He was Responsible for everyone on Cloud City. Leia, who grew up as the Princess of an entire planet, 100% understood that. Lando is completely validated by the story, the characters, and everyone for what he did.
And we see that he did try to shoo off the “hero crew” when they arrived in Cloud City in such a way that a) they’d have a decent chance of escaping, and b) he’d have plausible deniability. We see him ribbing Han a lot, for example, in such a way that it would be entirely possible that Han, who’s very touchy, might well just … go off in a huff. Lando could then easily go “haha, sorry Darth Vader sir, didn’t realize that Han couldn’t take a joke.” Win-win.
I also really appreciate that Lando is depicted as a solid person. He’s in a position of trust and authority, and he acts like it. He might have a bit of a checkered past, but he’s trying his best to do the right thing - and he’s doing a better job than Han, who’s still in trouble with the law.
I also think that Lando’s choice is supposed to be something of a parallel to Luke; Luke knows, on Dagobah, that the galaxy needs a Jedi to defeat Vader and the Emperor. He knows that becoming that Jedi is basically the most important thing, and as far as he knows, he’s the only one who can do it. He also knows, from the cave vision, that his friends/the Special Important Heroes are in danger.
He’s got a choice to make: either stay with Yoda and ghost Obi-Wan and keep learning how to be the Jedi the galaxy needs, or put that on hold and save the Special Important Heroes against his teachers’ warnings.
Lando’s situation is pretty similar. He’s in charge of Cloud City and responsible for its people, and when the Empire comes, he knows that he’s the only one that can protect them. His choice is to either save his city full of people and let the Empire in for Han and Leia, or refuse, save the Special Important Heroes, and watch the Empire destroy his city. He chooses right, and because of that he’s actually able to do more good, because he can evacuate the city and use the trust he’s gained with the Empire to get Leia and Chewie out.
Luke, on the other hand (sorry), chooses the Special Important Heroes and abandons his training. And it goes bad. He loses his fight, loses his hand, learns that Darth Vader is his dad in probably the most traumatic way possible, and, in Hamil’s own words, attempts suicide. He’s not actually able to help anyone; Lando’s already got Leia and Chewie out by the time he gets there, and the fact that they have to go back for him means that they lose the chance to go after Han until RotJ.
The narrative clearly indicates that there’s a right choice in each of these situations. It’s also the one that seems, at face value, to be the morally wrong one; Lando’s choice to give Han, Leia, and Chewie up to the Empire feels like a betrayal, and Luke staying on Dagobah would’ve felt like him abandoning his friends. Still, when you think about it from a practical rather than emotional perspective, it’s clear that Lando makes the right choice on Cloud City, and Luke makes the wrong one. It’s a fun parallel




















