What Could Have Been...

The Rental

rosieoliverpayne:

Rosie could tell how much Andrew really wanted to cook for her, even if she was teasing him with her body already. Feeling his hand on her ass, she knew where his other hand would lead to and just thinking about it made her smirk. But then when he did it, she didn’t expect it to be this good. It felt better because of how she missed his hands on her. Rosie could feel her heart racing as he teased her, just wanting him to push inside her already. “If… If you want to cook so bad, then I’ll wait for you. I’d love to…to taste your food.” She said, stumbling with her words as she could feel herself getting wetter by the minute. Nodding, she was excited that he agreed with her rule. Andrew’s lips were a pout away and Rosie wanted the situation to go his way so she waited for him to move, surprised at what he did next. His fingers pushed deep inside her, causing her to gasp loudly and their lips on each other. His taste was so good and his finger felt amazing. How would she let him cook if he already gave in like that? “Babe…” She murmured, still locking lips with him as she spread her legs to give him a better opening. “One more finger please. Just a quickie, with your fingers. Then I’ll let you cook. I promise.”

Andrew’s hand went up the small of her back and then around until he palmed Rosie’s side. He pressed her body closer to his but still gave a touch of a gap between to have enough space to keep fingering her. “The food’s not going anywhere,” He said, keeping it to one digit. It plunged deep and he waited a few beats before pulling it back to push straight up again. She reacted perfectly and Andrew’s lips slipped over hers once more to give Rosie a deeper, better kiss than the ones he did since he got here. His finger kept moving but soon a second joined and he smiled into their kiss. Smirking actually because he loved how she wanted him to do his thing but he wanted this more. “You missed this,” he whispered, not a question but a statement. “Just as much as me.” This was true. He missed the sex and the way they riled each other up. But he missed kissing and holding her even more. “Think you can keep standing or do I have to hold you up?”

The Rental

rosieoliverpayne:

Rosie had to giggle, knowing he’ll enjoy the appetizer more than the dessert she had planned for him. When his lips trailed down, Rosie leaned her head back to give him room to explore. As Andrew started undoing her robe, she had to smirk wide and moan a little, loving his hand on her bare skin. “I’m not hungry for food yet. I’m craving for something else.” She teased him, squealing a little when he squeezed her ass before giggling. Rosie nodded, removing her robe and tossing it to the side. She was now fully naked right in front of him and she didn’t even care. They have the house to themselves and there’s nothing stopping them. This definitely feels like something couples would do on their first night as newly weds but of course, this is better than what she had with Chris before. Watching him him remove his shirt, Rose moved closer to help him remove his belt, pressing kisses on his arm. “Strictly no clothes allowed in this household for the rest of time here.” She told him, holding his hand before moving it in between her legs. “I really missed you. This is gonna be the best vacation yet.”

There was a lot which needed to be cook but how could he think of food when there was something so much better right here with him. Andrew’s hand went down Rosie’s bare back and as soon as he reached her ass again he squeezed it appreciatively. His other hand cupped her warmth and soon his fingers curled just enough for him to tease her opening. “You saying you’re not hungry for this meal I planned for us?” His finger dipped deeper, finding that sweet spot which beckoned him to push in. “No clothes.” His lips skimmed hers but he didn’t kiss her yet. Instead he waited another few seconds of teasing her pussy before he pushed his finger deep within, catching her lips at at that instant because he wanted to taste her initial gasp from it.

#para: Rosie

The Rental

rosieoliverpayne:

When Andrew got some dessert related ingredients from the bag, Rosie had to smile big and nod at him. It was the perfect ingredient for what she has in mind. “Yes, that’s perfect. There’s this sweet snack my son loves that I make him all the time. It’s just a simple ice cream cookie sandwich but the trick is to under-bake the cookies a little to make it more chewy.” She said, suddenly missing her son at the mention of him. Giggling, Rosie nodded at him, knowing it really was important to time their meals because they get easily distracted, especially since they have the house all to themselves. “I’m definitely timing mine as well. Not sure what surprises you have up your sleeves.” She teased, feeling his lips on her skin on the throat, his body pressed onto hers as she closed her eyes with a smile. “See. Just when you do that, you make me forget about everything. I like it, though. Keep doing that.” She requested, remember she was still just in her robe. “Mhm, do you want me to take off my robe and just be naked around the house? Just a little appetizer for you.”

While his arms remained around her, enjoying the ice cream cookie sandwich idea but loving the suggestion of her appetizer more, Drew said, “You should. It’ll be a nice one to have. I can have just enough to satiate my appetitie but not enough to fill me up completely.” His mouth lowered and he kissed across her collar bone, undoing the front of her robe and making himself right at home by pushing a hand through the opening and laying it against her hip. “I should start dinner first before I get carried away.” He mumbled against her sweet skin, sliding his hand over to her ass and squeezing it. It was a good thing he made certain they had a propane grill because charcoal would take too long to heat up. “Take this off.” he slid the robe off one shoulder before he went to take his own shirt off. “I’ll strip while I get things together.” This felt very much like they were newly weds, unable to get enough of each other.

The Rental

rosieoliverpayne:

Rosie nodded and smiled at him, glad that they’d still have one day after his full day meeting. After this, he wasn’t sure when they’ll be seeing each other again. But then again, the question is whether they’d still be seeing each other after this or will they be stopping their infidelity? It’s only the first day so it was too soon to think about that. Laughing as he reminded him about the burnt pizza back in high school, Rosie nodded at him. “I do remember that. She was so mad that she kept you off the kitchen for like a week.” She said, smiling as Andrew talked more about food and cooking. He really has changed a lot since they were last together and it was very impressive. But then, he started talking about his wife so she had to turn her attention to a different side of the kitchen. Grabbing the wine bottle she pulled out from the fridge earlier, she poured herself another glass, giggling a little to let Andrew know she’s still listening. “Mhmm. Sounds good. Can’t wait to eat then.” Turning around to him, she took another sip of her wine. “Well, I gotta have some input here, right? Should I make maybe…some appetizers? Dessert? What can I do?”

“Ah. Lets see.” He said as he went through the groceries and thought of what else to make. He handled the main dish but there was always room for more. “I did get a roll of cookie dough and ice cream. Do you want to get creative with those?” he asked as he tugged the Pillsbury package from a bag and handed it to her.” Andrew liked to come up with different ways to make dessert. It was something he did with his girls but this would also show him if Rosie still had that spark of creativity In her that he loved so much all those years ago. “This time I’ll remember to set timers for all my cooking. Don’t want to ruin this kitchen when it’s not one I own.” He went closer to her and pressed a kiss to her throat. “Can’t have you distracting me again to the point I ruin our dinner again.” He joked against her skin while his hand pressed against her lower back, pulling her to him.

The Rental

rosieoliverpayne:

“Do you even have to fly back home after?” She pouted before smirking and giggling at him. Of course, Andrew still has a family to come home to and she might have forgotten it for two seconds but she has a family that needs her too. As much as she wanted him all to herself for the entire trip, he clearly has to work and Rosie understood that. She got her off days until he flies back home but after that, it’s all business to her again. Nodding, it was better that they were apart because if they lived close by, Rosie knew she’d probably want to see him more often than she’s supposed to. That screams so much trouble so meeting half way really is the best way to do whatever this is that they are doing. It gave her comfort when Andrew started drawing circles on his side, groaning a little when he got up. She was missing his touch too much.

Following him, Rosie decided to help him store their groceries. He surely bought enough like they were actually living there. It made her wonder how he is as a husband. But when Andrew suggested to grill dinner, Rosie gave him a look, surprised and impressed. “Oh, so you cook now?” She asked, giggling as she got up and wrap her arms around him to give Andrew a kiss on the cheek. “I never thought you’d be the kind of guy to hang out in the kitchen. But okay, I wanna taste your grilling skills. I can wait. What are you cooking?”

“Not after the meeting. You’ll still get me another day after that. I might see if I can squeeze one more but I have to come up with a good reason.” Andrew went to the fridge and dropped his head, laughing. “Yeah. I know. Remember when I tried to make us that pizza one time and it burned so bad my mom forbade me from using the oven ever again?” He closed the door and went to the counter, giving some of the vegetables a nice tap. “I made sure this place has an outdoor grill. I love the taste of food when it’s grilled.” he pulled out the eggplant, zucchini, squash and bell peppers.” Victoria is a vegetarian so I’ve learned to like vegetables.” he joked. “I’m cooking those chicken breasts, too. Have to marinate them for an hour.” Andrew felt like he was showing off now and he wondered just how much Rosie liked this side of him.

The Rental

rosieoliverpayne:

Rosie could still remember a line that one patient once told her about having a third person in a relationship. When a husband sleeps with different girls, you can still believe that he’ll come home to you but once he starts seeing and sleeping with the same girl over and over again, be afraid ‘cause that might ruin your relationship. And right now, Rosie was definitely relating to that saying so much. This might be an affair to people’s eyes but it’s Andrew and she just keeps coming back to him, even if she loves her husband truly. That’s where the trouble comes in and that scares Rosie. But then, when Andrew smiles and kisses her, he doesn’t become the other man anymore. He becomes the only man she could think about. Maybe if she just focuses on Andrew during this entire trip, she’ll figure out what to do and eventually, wouldn’t have to lie to anyone after.

Feeling his lips on her neck, Rosie had to close her eyes and sigh in comfort. Nodding, she let her fingers draw circles on his back. “It’s fine. It wouldn’t take long, right? Or are you gonna be gone for the entire day?” She asked, moaning a little when she felt his bite, causing her to giggle as well. Straightening herself up a bit, Rosie looked at Andrew with that flirty smirk. “Really? You think it’d be easier? Easier for us to get caught?” She joked, leaning forward a little to kiss him on the lips. “You do know we have to figure this out before you leave, right? I want to relax and just enjoy our time together but we do gotta think about that.” Her fingers started playing with his hair as her eyes were just staring at his lips, then licking her own lips in pleasure.

They fell into their little Rosie and Andrew cocoon and he thought about canceling the next day’s meetings but knew that if he did then he would get asked by his wife about details he just can’t give. IT was bad enough he was lying about what he was doing in his spare time here, he didn't need to add more to it. “It’ll take the better part of the morning but I’ll be back here after 2pm. Then it’s you and me until I have to fly back home.” He sighed at the end of that and kissed her cheek. “I know it sounds ideal to be near each other and you’re right. It’ll be easier for us to be found out.” His hand went to her side and he laid it there as he drew small semi-circles on the material before he slid off the couch and went to take care of the groceries.

“Did you get something to eat while you waited for me?” He asked as he removed milk and eggs from a bag, along with chicken breast and steaks. Another bag contained fresh fruits and vegetables. “I bought some things to grill for dinner but if you’re hungry now we can order something small.” Andrew liked to cook, it was something he picked up after his first daughter was born and Vickie didn’t have a lot of energy to prepare dinner. He watched videos online and found great recipes and went from there.

The Rental

rosieoliverpayne:

As much as possible, Rosie didn’t want to label them anything. If they put a name on what they are or what they are doing, it’ll just turn worse as it already is. She didn’t want to think about that so much. Right now, things are still working in their favor so that’ll be the light that Rosie will just keep in mind. Sure, when she’s with her family, the guilt continuously flows all over her but the second she saw Andrew, her eyes and mind were entirely focused on him and how much she missed him. Nodding at his question, Rosie looked around with a smile. It did feel like home on its own but when they both got there, Rosie knew it could feel so much more. “Yeah, it’s lovely. How long did you you rent the place? It’s gorgeous.” She reached for the groceries he had and brought it over to the nearest counter.

When he reminded her about the night of the reunion, Rosie couldn’t help but blush and giggle. They really made the most out of their night and Rosie is definitely looking forward to more of it. “How sure are you that there won’t be complaints at the door before the night ends? I know me, babe. I can be really loud.” She admitted, laughing a little as they went back to the couch and the TV is still on. “Oh, I don’t know, I just switched it open and clicked on whatever channel’s available.” She sat back on the couch and gently pulled Andrew down beside her, wrapping her arms around him. “I really missed you. I’m glad that we got the chance to do this. I… I wasn’t sure when I’ll be seeing you again after the reunion.”

There wasn’t an immediate rush to get to the groceries and Andrew allowed himself to be brought down onto the sofa with Rosie. It felt far too good to be at this place with her. Both physically and mentally. Did that make him a terrible person?To people outside of what he and Rosie shared than yes, but this wasn't some random hook up. This was someone he loved. Still loves but they were dealt such a crappy hand all those years ago and carried on with their lives; which landed them in this very place where they both had oblivious partners to their infidelity. These were the thoughts which plagued him late at night when he thought about confessing the whole thing to Vickie to get it out in the open. But that would cause him to lose his three girls because what court would favor a man who cheated on his wife with someone else who had a child of their own?

Andrew, however, didn’t think any of this when he held her. Lips to the crock of her neck and getting lost in Rosie’s sent. “I’ve got this place for a few days. I do have a couple meetings I need to attend the day after tomorrow but outside of that it’s you and me.” He promised, giving the skin a gentle bite. “It’d be much easier if we lived in the same city and I wasn’t miles away.” He mused but would it? To have that access to one another was bound to cause them to get figured out. Even with the disposable cell phone, he knew it was a matter of time before this was all found out...

#Para: rosie

The Rental

rosieoliverpayne:

It’s been a while since they last saw each other so to say that Rosie was excited was an understatement. Sure, the moment she got back from the reunion, her life went back to her husband and her kid. But she’d be lying if she said she hadn’t thought about Andrew. It felt like high school again, that feeling of butterflies having a riot in your stomach. She never thought she’d feel something this extreme again. She never thought she’d see Andrew again yet here they were, getting ready for another few days together. Her excuse was taken innocently by Chris and as much as she hated saying goodbye to her son again, he didn’t seemed too bothered about it considering it was a “work getaway”. That made things much easier for her to go on with her fantasy life with Andrew.

Once she has her bag, which didn’t contain much clothes knowing Andrew would take them off of her anyway, Rosie took a cab and was dropped off to the place Andrew had rented for them. Thankfully, it wasn’t in that part of their town where most people are so she was quite certain that they’d be safe there. Getting the key from where he had told her, she then opened the door and entered quietly. “Andrew?” She spoke, waiting for a response if he was there already. Noticing she was alone, Rosie locked the door and went inside, dropping her bag on the ground. The place wasn’t too big but everything they needed was there. It had that feeling of home and she was sure she’d feel it more once Andrew arrives. It was like playing house again and she couldn’t help but be excited. Rosie jumped in the shower quickly as it had been a long day at work for her and she just can’t wait to relax with him already. Once she was done, Rosie settled on the couch in her robe with a glass of red wine in hand and some random show playing on TV while waiting for Andrew.

After a few minutes, the doorbell rang and Rosie was like a bulb lit to its high power. Smiling big, she placed her glass of wine on the table in front as she walked to the door. Opening it, she never thought her smile could grow any bigger, seeing Andrew with bags of groceries on hand. “Prepared. That’s smart.” She teased, stepping to the side to let Andrew in. Once the groceries were placed down on the counter, Rosie turned him around, wrapping her arms around his neck and pressing her lips on to his. No thought of Chris running through her head at all, which was concerning. “I missed you.” She whispered, bring her lips back to his.

How was it she had the ability to make his worry about their adultery disappear as soon as she smiled at him? The phone call wasn’t completely forgotten but he couldn’t wait to be back here with Rosie, with her in his arms and all of the outside world on the other side of this door. All of this was selfish, which he recognized, but as soon as they were reunited he caved and went in for that kiss; wrapping his arms around her completely so the bags nearly tangled against one another. “I missed you, too,” he said into the kiss, closing the door with his foot. Andrew pulled her as close as he could before, eventually, releasing her. “Made yourself at home?” he asked as he looked down at the robe which partially opened during their greeting. “Give me a hand with putting these up and I’ll join you. We have a lot of catching up to do.”

Andrew’s nose bumped against her as he kissed Rosie once more and he looked around the house. “Say. This isn’t bad. It’s more than what we need and there’s no need to worry about waking the neighbors in the middle of the night because I know we’ll be going at it like we did reunion night.” A smirk tugged at his lips and Andrew went towards the kitchen, which he spotted from where he stood. “What do you have on the tv?” They may be here to fuck around but he also likes they could be themselves and have a pseudo-relationship, even if it was in secret.

The Rental

Andrew knew he shouldn’t encourage this behavior. That they were way too deep to turn around and slap an apology to their significant others if they happened to be caught. Not that he expected an apology to mend the damage caused to his marriage if Vickie happen to learn the truth but it would be chalked up to getting lost with reuniting with an old flame. This wasn’t getting caught up. This was way past that point but he needed to see Rosie. The time apart drove him crazy and he counted the days until his flight, practically whizzing off the plane to get his meeting handled.

In the car, he texted Rosie to let her know he was close by and that he hoped she managed to get into the house without any issue. Before he reached the neighborhood he picked up some groceries so they didn’t have to go anywhere for a couple days. When he pulled into the driveway his phone rang and he saw it was his wife. Immediate guilt hit him and he contemplated letting the call go to voicemail. In the end he answered and spoke briefly with her, acting as if he were still in the meeting and promised he would call later. These lies were getting too easy and Andrew knew that should concern him. That when this all blew up in his face, which it was bound to do, he will look the bad guy...

Still, with that, he got out of the car and grabbed the groceries. Andrew rang the doorbell and waited for his Rosie to greet him.

TEXTS: ROSIE x ANDREW

Rosie: Can't wait! Just trying to get everything done here, too then I'm free. I'm all yours.

Andrew: Do you know where to meet me?

Andrew: I left the key underneath a rock near the front door. It's one of the bigger rocks.

Andrew: There's some food and wine there, too. Made sure to get us enough to keep us going for awhile.

TEXTS: ROSIE x ANDREW

Rosie: It's fine. I understand. I love Chris but I'm sure I never stopped loving you. If that even makes sense. And yeah, I don't know how things will change but I hope they do soon.

Rosie: I'll see you okay. Come back to me soon.

[A couple days later]

Andrew: I just landed. Need to do a couple meetings and then you'll get me for the rest of the night.

TEXTS: ROSIE x ANDREW

Rosie: Of course, I want to go. I’ve been waiting for this for a long time now. I need to be with you.

Rosie: Feelings? Are you...uhm, are you saying...?

Andrew: I know what I feel for you hasn't changed at all over the years. Seeing you again at the reunion and sharing that time together showed that. My love for you hasn't changed but I get both of us have lives right now which would make it hard to pursue anything. I hope that changes soon.

#text: elle

TEXTS: ROSIE x ANDREW

Rosie: I know that. It's not like I want to ruin your girls' lives. And let's be honest, Andrew. Nothing about this IS right. We just want it that's why we think it feels right.

Rosie: Are you thinking of cancelling? I mean, about going to Boston and meeting up?

Andrew: No way. I'm still going and I will like to think I'll see you when I get to the house. But only if you want to go.

Andrew: Just because we want it doesn't mean it's the only thing that feels right. My feelings for you feel right.

TEXTS: ROSIE x ANDREW

Rosie: Okay, well, that makes the two of us.

Rosie: The kids are what makes this harder. I honestly don't know what to do either. My son is my life but you. Baby, you were supposed to be my life too. What do you think we should do then?

Andrew: I don't know, Rosie. I have my three girls and they're attached to their mom and I know I'll be made into the bad guy if we speak up about what we're doing. No matter how right it feels to be together.

TEXTS: ROSIE x ANDREW

Rosie: As bad as it sounds, that's kind of exactly correct.

Rosie: Wait, you want to stop this? What exactly do you mean? Like, come clean or get it over with?

Andrew: I don't want to stop this. No way.

Andrew: Sometimes I want to come clean so we can all move forward with our lives but I know to do that will screw everything up with our families. If it was just our spouses involved it's one thing. With the kids...that makes it hard.

TEXTS: ROSIE x ANDREW

Rosie: Well, what if we're thinking of different reasons? You should tell me what you're thinking first and I'll tell you my reason why I reject Chris everytime.

Rosie: I'm gonna have to say no because I'm not an old lady :P

Rosie: Guess I'll always just be jealous of her.

Andrew: I think it's because you rather have sex with me than him. That I know how to make you feel good.

Andrew: There's not much I can do to help the jealousy because I feel it with your husband.

Andrew: Do you ever think that we should find a way to stop with the sneaking around? We just started with it but I do have some guilt.