I got this product for 1 USD from the Dollar Tree. For the price, it was not an awful product.The color was very pigmented. the product went on my lips very smoothly. I have very dry lips and this product did not enhance that dryness! It seemed very moisturizing. There is a barely-there feeling of this product meaning you can’t even feel anything on your lips. You may just forget you put anything on. The staying power is okay. It does last a good amount of time and it leaves a stain but if you plan on eating or drinking, you will have to reapply this product. There are a few other downsides. I did find it a little bit difficult to apply. The applicator is a little difficult to use to get good lines around the lips, which it shows a little bit in the photographs which is why I smiled, to minimize how the product was outside of my lips. Also, if you do get it outside your lip line, even if you take care of it right away, it immediately leaves a stain on the skin so you will need to perfect the edges a little bit with some good concealer. Overall this product was pretty good for being only $1!