Critical Analysis
The Constructing Narrative’s module began by looking at several different narrative structures that can be created through visual series’, such as: Circular, de-centred, user defined, linear and non-linear. The work of Duane Michals, Melanie Pullen and the film, La Jetee, by Chris Marker, were discussed in one of our first lectures to help myself and peers, distinguish what certain narrative structures mean. My year group were given two tasks in which to create our own responses to certain narratives, the first was creating a photographic response to the song ‘A day in the life’ by the Beatles and the other was to produce 3 images about yourself and upload them to an Instagram account. I also attended the William Eggleston exhibition in London, at the National Portraiture Gallery, which included all of his works throughout the years. I enjoyed seeing his works up on walls in their true sizes, rather than online which I had previously seen but also, with descriptions explaining who the people were in the images.
The brief itself had a starting point of finding a text or e-mail we had received in the past week and, from the one we chose, create some form of a narrative. The text I chose to use was from a friend who, at the time, was experiencing a tough break up. She was extremely upset about the whole situation and would text me consistently about the memories/issues she was having trying to get over him. From this point, I realised that, when break up’s happen, they leave behind emotions, feelings and unresolved issues and, the more my friend messaged me, the more I came with terms of how hard it is to let go of someone after a break up. From here, the idea of looking at objects people have kept/left behind appeared into my head, when people break up, sometimes they will throw everything away or give everything back but, some will be hidden away and forgotten or kept in plain sight and I wanted to explore this deeper.
Once coming up with my idea, and speaking to both my peers and lecturer about it, I decided to take it further by making post’s on social media, and flyers, in order to find people who were willing to be involved. From doing this, I got feedback from a fair few people and was able to arrange six shoots at people’s houses to photograph where they kept the item’s, as well as portraits of the people too. From this point on, it was more a case of following up people about the shoots and getting from A to B. An issue that occurred was trying to run up the people to photograph for this project, who said they would like to help out but, never got back to me. Also, travelling to people’s houses became a slight issue as not all of them lived locally which meant I had to do a fair bit of travelling. One girl in particular who I was hoping to photograph did not get back to me but, she had court documents left behind from a restraining order she had to get from a past relationship, due to abusive behaviour. At that point in my project, I thought photographing the court documents would have been interesting and help me understand more distinctively how break ups can differ however, now I have the final 6 images I have printed, I realise it may not have linked as distinctively with the rest of people I have photographed.
Throughout the project I gained many different influences from Alec Soth’s Niagara series, that focuses in on modern romance and love letters, to Sophie Calle’s deeper meanings toward’s break ups to Larry Sultan’s image ‘Dad on bed’, from his series ‘Picture’s from Home’. The composition used in their work as well as their approach to constructing narratives stood out when analysing their work’s inner context’s towards love/break up’s definitely played a stance on how I approached this project with more sensitivity and how I spoke about the subject matter with the people I shot.
After having done all 6 shoots and laying out both portraits of people as well as the items they had kept over the years, I found it hard to narrow down the images I wanted for my finals and which route to go down. I was unsure whether to go for purely portraits or just the items or both as, I personally felt that the photograph’s of the objects without the portraits, linking them back to who had kept them, were not as strong alone. They did not show a deeper meaning as to who had kept them all these weeks/months/years, which I wanted to definitely be shown in my final piece. It was difficult but, baring that in mind, I was very critical and with help from both lecturer’s and peers, I decided on using three portraits of people along with the objects they had kept.
I also found it difficult coming up with a title for my project as, I did not want to just call the items ‘objects’ or just ‘items’, they all represent memories and experiences the person had been through in a relationship and are more than just those. I originally had the title ‘The things that you left behind’ but, even that, I felt was too blunt and sounded too casual with the word ‘things’. I chose to use a thesaurus to come up with a word more meaningful and ended up with the title ‘A reminder that you once existed’ which I feel is stronger and also allows my project to not need a description. The items placed underneath the portraits is made clear they have been kept by that person but, it may not 100% come across to the audience that they are from break ups and could be from people who have passed away but, I will leave that to the audience to interpret.
In light of my final outcome to the project, I am pleased with the progress I have made from the start to finish and the final prints I have chosen. The portraits of Emily, Rebecca and Alex along with three landscape shots of their left behind object’s are my finals and, when I look at the 6 images now, I feel the objects show a sense of nostalgia, although the break up’s occurred and they were all hurt emotionally, the object’s all bring back a time where they were happy and experienced some fond memories. The narrative of break up’s and how people struggle to or forget to give back certain items is what I see through this series but, people may interpret it differently due to the title or the final prints I have chosen.











