- Latest hyped tech product, giant corporations in competition
- Google, Amazon, Apple, Microsoft
- Still in early âgenerationsâ
- Not many people are using them right now
Creator intentions
- Intended to be part of an âecosystemâ of other networked appliances based in a house setting
- Intended to encourage use of other products and services provided by the originating company and partners
â- I think you can buy Amazon products directly thru the Echo
â- Google Home obviously integrates with all the Google services, Calender, etc.
â- I can imagined the program being biased towards recommending certain partnered products, businesses when asked for recomendations
â- different smart home products will be compatible with different companysâ home assistants
- Intended to impart a sense of increased productivity, ease busyness
- Planned obsolescence, advancing AI tech, competition to add new features will mean new ones every few years
- Can maybe become part of bot net
- Is âalways listening to youâ
- security problems: âcan something your shitty teen says in the presence of the Echo come back to haunt him in the future?â
- collected speech is used to train AI Â and advertise to you better
- what if you canât speak, or donât speak a supported language
- Â âsub-human thing that is subservient to youâ
Design
- appearance of home assistants tend towards smooth, blank, few seams
- criticized as looking like âtrash binsâ or cans
- small, but not comfortably portable, except for a few types
- not to be picked up and thrown around
- Mostly resemble things already present in home environments in shape and materials
â Echo sort of looks like a mini air purifier or something
â Â Google Home and Apple Homepod resemble speakers
â- Â to mitigate expectations of actual capabilties of the AI?
ââ Â âa speaker, but fancierâ
- users encouraged to use natural speech
â We are told often how much effort went into the natural language processing algorithms
â people will probably develop Alexa-specific lingo, etc. anyway
- What they mostly do NOT look like:
â a computer
â a robot (varies)
â a toy
â a bunch of circuits and electronic components
â a person or creature
â nothing (disembodied presence)
â something that is connected to a a huge network of computers and other things Â
â a thing that is actively paying attention/listening to you
â how could the visual aspect of home assistants more âhonestlyâ, if possible, represent its functions and capabilities
- the Baidu Raven has an usual design. Hipster Fisher-Price, one is not sure exactly what it does just by looking
Why the personal assistant metaphor?
- people who have personal assistants- important and powerful business people and professionals, people with disabilities
- anthropomorphizing
âcreates sentimental attachment
â altthough âpersonal assistantâ has some professional distance built in
- what other metaphors could there be
â A little node of [corporation], right in your home
ââ Google Lobe âą
â Engine of Reminding
- âpersonalâ - belongs to you, serves just you
Expected consumers
- people who have a stable place to live, spare income
â I can imagine someone getting evicted and sitting at the bus stop with their Homepod :(
In the future
- Assistants using tone of voice and emotion as contextual cues
â could also analyze your emotions over the day in different to give you suggestions, ask you to reconsider an action if it seems you are angry
- Amazon is developing home assistants that look more like robots
Other stuff
âUsing the voice to communicate with an outside entity makes for an intimate and innately human experienceâŠ.speech is the quickest way to get a point across â
https://www.engadget.com/2016/10/05/personal-assistants-google-home-ai/
Assistant software enforcing certain modes of interaction:
- I think of Google Home there is something called âmanners modeâ, where you have to say please, to train your kids
- https://www.forbes.com/sites/kalevleetaru/2017/12/13/can-ai-assistants-help-curb-harassment/#1ea5e9e1843f
â Google Home asks not to be referred to as sweetie, etc.
- I can imagine these things being incomprehensible, omnipotent objects of wonder to a kid