Ok hear me out.
What if Eli Hale was actually Stiles’ son?
What if he was both a Stilinski and a Hale, but not a Hale through Derek?
I mean we all know the writers were setting up Stiles and Cora in season 3. What if and just hear me out here - What if something happened between them before she left for South America. What if when she first realized, her first instinct was to call her brother? To tell him that she was too young to raise a child.
I guess this would explain why Derek leaves after season 4, he was raising Eli.
He didn’t tell Stiles for the same reason Cora didn’t. He was young, he had a bright future in front of him, he didn’t want to ruin that. This would also explain why Eli acts like him, looks like him even.
This would explain why Derek hates that he keeps taking the jeep, it serves as a reminder that he kept this from Stiles that he should’ve told him.
This could explain Derek’s complicated feelings about the jeep.
