Bordeaux 2015
Bordeaux visit #primeurs2015 - April 2016
After the difficult vintages of 2011, 2012, 2013 and a better vintage in 2014, there has been a great deal of Bordeaux excitement about this 2015 vintage. Much of this hype is justified. There are some truly wonderful wines.
2015 was a very dry year – a heatwave in June and July used up most of the over winter water reserves in the soil. In July alone Bordeaux had 24 days with temperatures higher than 25 degrees of which 10 days were over 30 degrees. As a result veraison was relatively late – end of the 1st week on August as the rains came. Chateau Palmer described this ‘as the perfect conditions for veraison’. August was a wet month which balanced the heat and dryness of the previous 2 months. It also meant that as the grapes ripened through August, they built up freshness and recovered acidity levels to balance the high levels of sugar.
Harvest started, for Merlot, after 18th September, with most vineyards picking between 18th – 30th September. While Cabernet was picked from 30th September – 9th October. Potential alcohol is high – towards 14 degrees but this is nothing new these days in Bordeaux. Acidity levels can be an issue in some wines and the tannins are generally deep, velvety and ripe. Some vineyards picked a little early as the sugar levels were high and have not reached full phenolic ripeness. In general it is a vintage of wonderful sweet, pure fruit - wines with balance and finesse. In good hands the highish level of alcohol is not evident in the slightest and the wines should age magnificently.
I sampled over 200 wines over 3 days of the Union des Grands Crus de Bordeaux tastings from 5th-7th April. The UGC tasting were held at Ch. Gruaud Larose (St Julien), Ch. Lafon Rochet (St Estephe & Pauillac), Ch. La Lagune (Sauternes & Barsac), Ch. Malartic-Lagraviere (Graves), Ch. La Couspade (St. Emilion), Ch. Beauregard (Pomerol). I went to Ch. Laroze (St. Emilion) to taste wines shown by the Grand Cercle des Vins de Bordeaux –plenty of petits chateaux wines and some real delights. I also arranged private visits to Ch. Palmer, Ch. Kirwan, Domaines Fabre (Haut Medoc), Cheval Blanc, Angelus, Ch. Bel Air La Royere (Blaye), Ch. Veyry (Castillon), Haut Brion. At Haut Brion I tasted 1st and 2nd wines of Quintus, La Mission Haut Brion and Haut Brion – red and white.
So a fairly thorough immersion into the vintage. These are my highest scoring wines. More thorough tasting notes to follow.
Richard Household, April 2016
Summary
Left Bank
Margaux Score /10
Ch. Palmer 9
Ch. Kirwan 9
Ch. Lascombes 8.5
Ch. Malescot 8
Ch. Brane-Cantenac 8
Ch. Labegorce 7.5
Of all the communes Margaux was the most inconsistent – some wines were a little green, some wines had low acidity and some wines had heat from alcohol imbalance.
St Julien Score /10
Ch. Leoville Poyferre 9.5
Ch. Leoville Barton 9
Ch. Branaire-Ducru 8.5
Ch. Beychevelle 8
Ch. Gruaud Larose 8
Wines from St Julien were the most consistent.
Pauillac Score/10
Ch. Lynch Bages 9
Ch. Batailley 9
Ch. Pichon Comtesse 8.5
Ch. Grand Puy Lacoste 8.5
Ch. Pichon Baron 8
Ch. D’Armaillac 8
Overall Pauilac has produced wines of power and richness. Some are over extracted and some showed a hint of green.
St Estephe Score/10
Ch. Lafon Rochet 8.5
Ch. Meyney 8
Ch. Phelan Segur 7.5
Lafon Rochet was a delight but overall the purity and sweetness of fruit evident in Medoc further away from the coast was not so expressive in St Estephe. Often quite jammy.
Graves Score /10
Ch. La Mission Haut Brion 9.5
Ch. Haut Brion 9
Quintus 9
Ch. Pape Clement 9
Ch. De Fieuzal 8.5
Ch. Les Charmes Haut-Brion 8.5
Domaine de Chevalier 8.5
Ch. Malartic Lagraviere 8.5
Ch. Olivier 8.5
I think had some of the stand out wines – powerful, yet pure sweet fruit with layers of cassis and hedgerow earthiness. There were a few shockers where growers had tried to force more richness which resulted in harsh, stewed fruit bitterness but overall very good indeed.
Right Bank
St Emilion Score/10
Cheval Blanc 9.5-10
Angelus 9.5
Ch. Pavie Macquin 9
Ch. Troplong Mondot 9
Ch. La Dominique 9
Ch. Grand Mayne 8.5
Clos Fourtet 8
Ch. La Gaffeliere 8
Ch. Soutard 8
The highest scores and some charming, wonderful wines.
Pomerol Score/10
Ch. La Croix de Gay 9
Ch. Beauregard 8.5
Ch. Petit Village 8
Plenty of other wines scored around the 8 mark but overall I found the wines lacking in finesse, clunky and overbearing. Purity of fruit was generally lacking.














