Part One: The Man in the Corner Booth
Every night, just after midnight, the same man walks through the door. Tall, broad, a worn t-shirt clinging to a frame that had been built overtime. Tired dark brown eyes, hair always a little messy. He orders the same whiskey, sits in the same booth, and leaves right before sunrise. He barely speaks, but when he does it’s low, rough and steady, the kind that lingers long after the words are gone. You don’t ask about the bruises, the blood on his knuckles, or why he always watches the exits. And he never asks why you always save him his seat.
content warnings: sex. drinking, blood, swearing, making out, weapons, you get it.
pairing: frank castle x reader
part one of After Midnight a series I making 🤤
____________________________________________
The bell above the door rang just after midnight. By now, you didn’t have to look up to know who it was. The same heavy footsteps. The same quiet pause before he walked further inside. The same man who always chose the booth in the corner the one with the best view of the door and the rest of the room. Frank Castle.
He wasn’t the kind of customer who came in looking for conversation. He didn’t flirt, didn’t make small talk, didn’t linger around hoping someone would notice him. He came in, ordered the same whiskey, and sat in silence. And somehow, that silence became familiar.
You set the glass down in front of him before he even had to ask. “Rough night?” you asked. His eyes lifted to yours for a moment. Dark. Tired. Guarded. “Something like that.”
A small answer. Barely anything. But with Frank, it was something. You allowed yourself a small smile before turning away. Because every night after midnight, Frank Castle walked through that door.
And every night, you saved him his seat.
The next few weeks were the same. Same routine. He’d come in just after midnight, you poured his whiskey. He took his usual seat. But slowly, the silence between you two became a comfortable kind of one.
The bar was quieter than usual, most of the crowd already gone. You were wiping down the counter when a man slid into the seat in front of you.
“Busy night?” he asked. You glanced up. “Not really.”He smiled. “Good. Means you can keep me company.” You gave him a polite smile, already knowing where this was going.
“I’m working.”You turned back to the counter, hoping he’d take the hint. He didn’t. Instead, he leaned against the counter, clearly not understanding the hint. “Come on,” he said, a crooked smile on his face. “I’m just trying to keep you company.”You gave him a look. “I don’t need company.”The man laughed. “Everyone needs company.”You ignored him, turning back to the glasses you were cleaning. Usually, that was enough. Usually, people got bored and left. But he was drunk. And drunk people rarely knew when to stop. “You always this stubborn?”You glanced back at him. “Funny. I was about to ask you the same thing”The room was quiet enough that you could hear the ice shift in frank’s glass from across the bar. You didn’t look over. You didn’t need to. You already knew he was paying attention. The man leaned closer. “You got a mouth on you.”You smiled slightly. “You gonna shut me up?”That seemed to irritate him.
His hand moved toward the counter, a little too quickly. Not enough to scare you. Just enough to confirm what you already knew. He was testing boundaries. Your hand moved beneath the bar, fingers brushing against the hidden gun tucked away there.You weren’t planning on using it. You rarely ever did. You just wanted him to know you weren’t someone he could push around. Frank noticed the movement. Of course he did. His eyes lifted from his drink, watching you for a moment. Not the weapon. Just you. Like he was realizing there was more to you than the person who poured his whiskey every night. The man didn’t notice. He just kept talking.
“You gonna keep acting like you’re better than me?” You looked at him calmly. “No.”A pause.
“I’m gonna tell you what’s going to happen next.”
The man’s expression hardened. And before the situation could go any further-
Frank’s voice cut through the room. Quiet. Low. You looked over. He was sitting where he was still but now he was watching. The man turned around, looking toward him. “You got something to say?”
Frank didn’t answer right away.He took another sip of his drink. “She told you to leave.”The man let out a laugh. “And that’s your business?”Frank’s eyes lifted. “No.”A pause. “But you’re not listening.”
The simplicity of the answer seemed to irritate him more. The man looked back at you, shaking his head. “You always need someone else to speak for you?”That almost made you smile. Because he clearly had no idea who he was talking to. You opened your mouth to answer, but Frank spoke first. “She doesn’t.”The man looked back. Frank’s expression didn’t change. “She’s been handling you just fine.”That caught you off guard. Not because he defended you. Because he didn’t make you smaller to do it. He didn’t act like you needed saving. He just stated what he saw.
The man scoffed. “Then why are you talking?”
Frank looked down at his glass. “Because I’m tired of hearin’ you. ”The man stared at him. For a second nobody moved.
Then the alcohol, the anger, and all the embarrassment all mixed together. His expression changed. And you saw it happen before he even moved. Frank did too. The man made a fist and swung, more out of frustration than anything else. But he never got the chance to do anything. Frank moved. Fast. One second he was standing there, the next the man was pinned against the table, Frank’s grip keeping him completely still. Frank leaned slightly closer, his voice low. “Bad choice.”
The man struggled for a moment before realizing it wasn’t going anywhere. Frank didn’t look impressed. He didn’t look proud. He just looked tired. Frank leaned closer, his voice dropping lower.“You’re gonna get up, you’re gonna walk out that door, and you’re gonna forget you ever came in here.”A pause. “You understand me?”
A few seconds passed. Then Frank let him go.
The man stumbled back, fixing his jacket and suddenly a lot less confident than he was a minute ago. He didn’t say another word. He just left. The bell above the door rang. Then silence. You looked at Frank.
“I had that handled.”Frank looked at you. “I know.”
You raised an eyebrow. “Then why?”His eyes flickered toward the door. Then back to you.“Didn’t like the way he was talking to you.”A pause.
“No man talks to a lady like that. For a moment, neither of you said anything. You held his gaze from across the bar. Those dark, tired eyes of his met yours, and for once, he looked like he didn’t have somewhere else to be. The silence between you stretched. Not awkward. Just different. Then you looked away first, reaching for his glass. “You’re getting another.” It wasn’t a question. Frank watched as you poured the whiskey, the amber liquid catching beneath the dim lights of the bar. You slid the glass back toward him. “This one’s on the house.” His eyes dropped to the drink, then back to you. A small pause. “You don’t have to do that.”A slight smile appeared on your face. “I know.”
The bell above the door rang. This time, you knew something was wrong before you even looked up.
Frank did too. The second he saw who was standing there, something in him changed. The relaxed posture. The quiet man sitting at the bar with a glass in his hand. Gone. The man from earlier stood near the entrance, but this time he wasn’t drunk. And he wasn’t there to talk. Your eyes dropped for a moment. The gun in his hand.
Your stomach sank. “Frank.” It was barely above a whisper. But he heard you. Of course he did. His eyes moved toward you for half a second.
“Get down.” The words were quiet. Not panicked.
Not loud. Then everything happened at once.
The sound cut through the room. The lights above the bar seemed to flicker in the chaos, glasses rattling against the counter as everyone moved at once. Your first instinct wasn’t even fear. It was him. Frank. He was already moving before you could think, putting himself between you and the danger like it was automatic. Like he didn’t even realize he’d done it.
A few moments later, the room was silent again.
The man was gone. And Frank was still standing there acting as if nothing happened. You stared at him. And then at his arm, blood leaking through his black t-shirt.
“My car’s right out front frank, we need to get you to the hospital right now.” His expression immediately changed. “No.”You blinked. “No?” “No hospitals.” The answer was too quick. You looked at him. And suddenly it made sense. The way he always watched the exits. The way he never stayed too long. It was clear to you that Frank avoided being seen. “Frank…”“I’m fine.”
You gave him a look. “I’m not letting you deal with that alone.” For the smallest second, something almost like amusement crossed his face. Almost.
Then it disappeared. “You got somewhere I can go?”Your eyes dropped to his arm again. Blood had soaked through the sleeve of his shirt now, running down toward his wrist in slow, steady lines before dripping onto the hardwood beneath him.
“You’ve lost a lot of blood.”“I’ve lost more.”
“You say that like it’s supposed to make me feel better.”“It doesn’t?” You shot him a look. “No.”
For the first time that night, the corner of his mouth twitched. Barely. Almost like he’d forgotten how.
“My apartment’s five minutes away,” you said quietly. “I can patch you up.”Frank held your gaze.
Long enough that you wondered if he’d walk out that door anyway. “You know how to stitch someone up?”A small smile found your lips.
“You think I’d keep a gun if I didn’t?”For the first time since you’d met him, Frank looked genuinely caught off guard. Just for a second. Then he gave a slow nod. “Lead the way.”
romaincrisis
theartofmadeline
kianamaiart
snowghoul
blakekathryn