The Drowner in Lake Winnipeg
You might think you know what a Wendigo is, and I would wager that you would be right in most cases. However, folklore is rarely that simple - and so the definition of a Wendigo is somewhat liable to change based on the individual group of Algonquian people discussing it. There is one particularly intriguing story that comes out of the Lake Winnipeg area, which suggests that perhaps these malevolent cannibal spirits could even be aquatic on some occasions.
Wilma Raynor began her career as a nurse on a reserve in Alberta in 1944. She would help to set up nursing stations throughout the Canadian north, and would eventually become the nursing director for the Manitoba branch of the Canadian Red Cross Society after eighteen years of hard work. Throughout her many years, she heard countless tales of the terrifying Wendigo spirit, but she dismissed them all as 'ridiculous' until she witnessed something she couldn't quite explain...
She was working with a Cree community near the northern end of Lake Winnipeg, and one morning she caught sight of a girl quietly walking along the shore of the lake holding a pail. This girl was 19 years old, and her name was Christina. She briefly stood there, just staring out into the lake - before suddenly screaming in terror at something unseen and running for the nearest cabin. Christina found her mother in this cabin, grabbed her by the arm and dragged her down the shore of the lake. She desperately tried to point something out to her mother, but she strangely refused to look at whatever it was - and then pulled her daughter away from the lake to safety.
Presumably alarmed by this bizarre happening, Wilma made her way back the cabin. By the time she got there, it was already packed with concerned Cree neighbours, listening intently as Christina described her frightening vision. She had apparently seen a female figure stood in the water, which went up to her waist. There was long, dark hair hanging around her 'evil' face and she used a spindly arm to beckon for Christina to approach. Her mother claimed to have seen nothing, and noted that it was a 'hard struggle' to drag her daughter away from the potentially lethal water. Wilma was driven by this story to believe the assertion that Christina was nearly drawn into the water by a malevolent spirit of some kind. She gave Christina a sedative and kept her company while she calmed down.
However, the nightmarish influence of this watery Wendigo on the Cree community of Lake Winnipeg hadn't ceased yet. You see, it was apparent that the spirit wanted to claim a human life, and it wasn't going to rest until it had one. It laid in wait for months until a young Cree man came to visit Christina. He was a potential marriage partner for her, and after seeing his possible future wife, he decided to go skating on the frozen lake. You can guess how this ends.
The young man fell through a hole in the ice, and nearby people immediately rushed to the scene to try and save him from the freezing embrace of the water. However, they were ultimately unsuccessful - and the unfortunate suitor drowned in Lake Winnipeg. Intrigued by this harrowing incident, Wilma spoke to an older man in the Cree community about it - and what he had to say was shocking to say the least. He slowly shook his head and started, saying that he had never seen anything like it before. He had seen many people drown before, but never 'like that'.
The community members had apparently managed to find the hole in the ground into which the young man had fallen, and had shone a light down into it. They were able to see the man's head just underneath the ice. He was just floating there - 'like he just stand there'. Wilma visited the lake the next day, and likely felt a chill scuttle up her spine when she realised that the man had drowned in the same area from which the Wendigo had attempted to lure Christina.
Wilma told this terrifying story in 1957 in a short article called 'Windigo Woman' in issue 228 of a local newspaper for the Hudson Bay Company called The Beaver. It was originally meant for employees of the aforementioned company when it was first launched in the 1920s, but it had since expanded readership to all those with an interest in the Subarctic. Wilma apparently would've been writing both to inform and entertain. The newspaper in question is now simply called Canada's History.
Source: 'Dangerous Spirits' by Shawn Smallman