Andrew “Pope” Cody x curvy f!reader - I have no idea where this came from??? I thought of it while I was in the shower, and once I got to writing it just started pouring out of me. MDNI, 18+
Andrew “Pope” Cody who very quickly takes advantage of the fact you’re the first ones in the hot tub on a slow night in at the Cody’s. The other guys were inside changing into their trunks and let’s face it - pregaming for even a chill night in the jacuzzi. You climbed in first, smiling at Pope as he held his hand out for you to hold while you got in. You sighed at the feeling of the warm water against your skin, oblivious to Pope ogling the itsy bitsy bikini on your body. If this was the last sight he saw before he died - the way your nipples peeked through your top from the contrast of the cool night air, and the warm bubbles against your skin…the feminine way the bottoms hugged your soft lower belly and cushy upper thigh - he’d die a happy man.
Pope loved the parts of you that you thought were ‘pudgy.’ You reminded him of those white, marble statues of Greek goddesses draped in the finest linens and adorned in lavish necklaces and head pieces. He loves laying his head on your tummy as you run your manicured nails through his auburn curls. He loves driving down the road, windows down, with his freckled hand on the meaty part of your bare thigh.
And speaking of bare thighs, he loooves when you wear those teensy denim shorts where your ass hangs out a little. You get insecure about the cellulite under your ass cheeks, but he reassures you by constantly grabbing and smacking your ass whenever you walk around with them on. Doing laundry? He’s coming up behind you and grabbing both cheeks in his hands while putting his head on your shoulder. Prepping lunch for him and the guys? He’s walking by and giving it a hard smack on his way to grab a beer from the fridge. You + daisy dukes = a man possessed.
He climbs in after you, and before you can even get comfy he’s on you like a fucking jungle cat. He’s grabbing at your plushy hips and spinning you around so your back is to him. He pats the side of your left thigh, gesturing for you climb up onto your knees on the jacuzzi bench that runs around the inside. You’re confused but obliging, always eager to please him. And before you can ask what the fuck he’s doing, he’s pulling at the strings of your bikini bottoms and yanking them off. He ignores the way you squeal and scoots you so you’re facing one of the jacuzzi jets.
“C’mere, I wanna show you something.”
“Andy, what are you doiiing? They’re gonna be out here any minute.”
“Huh-?” He cuts you off, positioning himself behind you and wrapping his arms around you. He slides his right hand down between your legs. He spreads your pussy lips with his thick fingers so the jet hits directly on your clit. You gasp and immediately throw your head back against his shoulder, your eyebrows scrunched together as you look at him. He rubs slow circles on your clit, the combined pressure from the heavy stream of water and his fingers making your brain foggy. You grab onto his beefy arm for support.
“Fuckkk Andy, feels s’good. But what if they-?“
“What’s wrong baby? You don’t want ‘em to see you like this? Bare pussy in the hot tub, using the water and my fingers to get off?”
You whined and squirmed against his arms, the outside breeze and the overwhelming feeling of warmth blossoming all over your body making you restless. You wanted to moan and curse but were still too shy at the thought of his family coming out any second. A sudden loss of contact snapped you out of a very frustrating - but also toe curling-ly blissful - internal dilemma. You felt Pope shift behind you, his muscular arms dropping from your sides. He stands up straight and presses his hand against your upper back, making you lean on your elbows over the outside of the jacuzzi. At some point while he was making your brain cloudy and thoughts sticky like cotton candy, he had removed his swim trunks.
You could feel his hard cock against your ass. He grabbed the base and aligned it with your glistening pussy, using his thumb to pull your left cheek to the side to see better. He rubbed the tip up and down your entrance, practically drooling from the shiny mix of the water and your own wetness. He slid into you, slow at first while you adjusted to the sensation, and then picked up a consistent pace. He was in no hurry at all, and he certainly couldn’t care less about the fact his family was so close he could hear them from out here.
He moves a large hand up to your right tit, sliding it beneath the wet fabric and massaging it. He rolls the nipple between calloused fingers and does the same to the left. He pumps in and out of you slowly, the only sounds besides the crickets being your joint groans and moans and the splashing of Pope’s hips snapping against the water. Your pride falls apart and before you know it, you’re begging him to fuck you faster and harder without giving a shit about who sees. You’re quite literally matching his freak, if you will.
“Please what angel? Big girls use their words to get what they want. You know that.”
“Please, please fuck me harder. I need you.”
“Aw. My pretty, needy baby. Doesn’t even care that her boyfriend’s family’s about to see her bent over and fucked out of her mind in their hot tub. Needs my cock so badly that she’s willing to be a nasty girl. Shameless.” He moves his hand from your breast to up around your throat. He squeezes it firm but gentle, nearly making your eyes cross. He begins pounding into you. His eyes are closed as he leans forward and licks along the side of your face where your jawline meets your neck.
At this point you’re a fucking hot mess, clawing at the edge of the hot tub and garbling out moans that would make a porn star jealous. It’s all so much. The weight of his heavy dick inside of you…the weight of his hand, veiny and always sprinkled with cuts and bruises from jobs, squeezing your throat…the breeze picking up, causing the water to ripple and the palm leaves to rattle. Your thighs were shaking, and a hot spring of Yellowstone proportions was bubbling inside of your lower belly and ready to burst. Goosebumps kissed your arms and lower back. Your lips were puffy and sore from biting down before to stifle the noises you were now making, tossing all caution to the wind.
“Andyyy. Andy, I feel like I’m gonna-“
“Uh-uh.” He clicks his tongue. “You can’t come until they get out here.”
“What??? Andy, no. I can’t, I have to-“
“I said no. You’re gonna show them how much you love this cock…how you wish you were molded to it.”
“Fuck, please Andy. I can’t hold it any longer, need to come on your cock so badly.” And he really could tell you were close, based off the way your thighs were quivering and your pussy was clenching around him.
“I know you can hold it a little longer, sweetheart. I know you can be a good girl for me.” He was seriously underestimating you because with the way he was currently railing you and the way he was talking to you, you weren’t going to last long. You were in the front cart of the coaster clicking up and up the tracks, reaching your peak and about to tumble over the edge. Your eyes screwed shut, your calves and feet tensed up, You were biting your lip so hard trying not to cum that you might’ve drawn blood. You couldn’t hold on any longer, you were losing your grip on the edge. At the same time a distant screen door flies open and slams shut, every single cell in your body explodes.
The guttural moan you release is otherworldly. You slip in and out of reality, multicolored static and stars buzzing behind your closed eyes. Fireworks erupt in your lower belly and you shimmy and press your ass as far back as you can go, aching to be as close to him as possible. You didn’t give a fuck if you were on display for the world to see if it meant Pope made you feel this fucking high for the rest of your lives.
“Aw Jesus, what the fuck Pope?” Baz’s voice cracks through your hazy euphoria. Almost immediately Pope loses control too, hips stuttering and rutting against your backside. You feel him twitch and you both groan at the feeling of him spilling inside of you. His grip on your neck tightens and he’s sloppily kissing and nipping at your bare shoulder while you both ride out your highs.
“Fuck, you guys. There’s eight fucking bedrooms here. You can’t pick one?” Craig chimes in. Him and Baz both shake their heads, turning on their heels to head back inside. They warn Deran and J before they can even step out the door, both of them reacting with disgust at Pope defiling you in the jacuzzi they all shared. The door slammed shut again, and you both sat in silence while continuing to breathe through the aftermath of your shared orgasm. You’re the first to speak, pink returning to your cheeks after the brain fog had cleared and you realized what you had just done.
“Oh god. I can’t believe I just did that,” you started. “I’m never going to live that down.” Pope straightened up again, sliding out of you reluctantly and reaching for his trunks.
“Live what down?” he asked, as if he was completely unbothered by the fact his family just saw him plowing you.
“Andy are you serious? The fact the guys just saw us fucking in here…”
“So what? Let ‘em see who fucks you this good. It’ll teach Baz and Craig a lesson about staring at your ass when I rub sunscreen on it by the pool.”
“Andrew Cody. Was this all because you were trying to teach your brothers a lesson about eye fucking me?” you questioned, feigning disbelief. You pressed the palm of your hand to your chest, mouth agape but slightly turned at the corners.
“I am the only one who gets to eye fuck you. Ever. And if they can’t get that through their thick fucking skulls, they’re gonna watch while I actually fuck you.”