I just got a tgwdlm au idea:
What if Emma was in on the apotheosis all along?
• This is based off that “the opening song is the finale” thing and that “the show is actually a loop until Paul succumbs to the apotheosis” thing
• “The Guy Who Didn’t Like Musicals” opens the show, telling us how the story starts, how they want Paul to bend to their will to join them in the number, but he just wouldn’t. He doesn’t enter when they tell him to and he just casually takes a seat like nothing is happening.
• And people have pointed out that what if this show is the last time Paul defies the Hive because it was later said “You, Paul have defied us thrice” sounded like the apotheosis has happened before. So what if everyone except Paul, but including Emma was infected in the prior apotheosis?
• Because Emma’s in the opening song too. She’s singing and dancing and revealing how Paul actually had feelings for her. The Hive will eventually use this to get Paul infected too. What if she found out about Paul’s feelings for her in the prior apotheosis and that’s how she knew in the opening song?
• What if she already was infected and throughout the show that we see, she’s just acting out the role of being uninfected, just like everyone else? And it works in getting Paul to trust her
• What if her planting the idea for Paul to get to the meteor was intentional, so Paul could really become infected?
















