Ok hear me out Enid dies during her fight with Tyler for the sake of this I’m gonna say that the sheriff shot twice and they were silver bullets Enid couldn’t recover and died and so The Hug™️ never happened she never came back right so funeral happens people grieve then there’s Wednesday who’s not gonna accept that death took her girl before she she even got a chance to become her girl so she pulls some seance stuff and she brings her back but here’s the twist her ghost ancestors are like "fine we’ll bring her back but it will cost a price" and of course she’s like "anything" and boom before you know it enid is bursting out of the ground Wednesday’s confused at first but she recovers quickly when she finally gets a chance to help her up out of the hole she notices Enid is different she’s not hugging her or questioning why she’s back she’s just quiet staring at her with an emotionless look on her face she thinks maybe she’s in shock so she does what any reasonable person would do and starts bombarding her with questions Enid, are you okay?" "Are you hurting at all?" "Do you remember me?" So Enid responds, "Why wouldn’t I remember you? I’m fine." And that just left her with more questions than answers, cause that’s an interesting tone to use for the girl you DIED for, but she didn’t care at the moment; she was just happy Enid was back, so she led her back to the room, then asked Enid to shower to get the smell of death off her. Enid agreed, and so she waited. That’s when all the questions came to mind: why does she sound so emotionless? Why was she so stone-faced? Was she angry with her? So Enid’s done showering and the night goes on. The next morning they go outside and try to explain how Enid was brought back from the dead The only issue is that it seems that Enid hasn’t snapped back yet. She’s still got that same dead look and tone. Even when people come up to her and cry or hug her, she doesn’t change. It’s becoming more concerning than the fact she was dead yesterday, so Wednesday confronts get about it. "What’s wrong with you?" "Excuse me?" "What’s wrong with you? you’re acting strange." "Thank you." "That wasn’t a compliment." "Oh." "Answer the question, why are you being such a brute?" "I don’t know; I can’t feel anything." "What do you mean you can’t feel anything." "I have all my memories. I remember feeling sadness, joy, and anger, but I can’t bring myself to feel any of those things." And then Wednesday is reminded of the price she was told about, so she accepts it and thinks back to how Enid got her to open up to her, and just like that, the roles reverse. Enid’s the silent one who seemingly wants nothing to do with anyone, and Wednesday attempts to be more outgoing to try and coax Enid to open up again, but she’s being difficult; she has no interest in interacting with Wednesday at all, but Wednesday is persistent, and very slowly, Enid starts feeling again.
(Maybe I should make an au I have a lot of ideas for this)