Bartender, gimme an Amazon over Ice 9
What sort of world do we live in where Amazon, founded as an online alternative to brick and mortar bookstores, has opened its own brick and mortar bookstores after putting them all out of business? The ambitions of this juggernaut have turned to another mountain yet unclimbed: internet connectivity. Amazon Sidewalk, a mesh-network service, will go live in just a few days. It provides an alternate pathway for Amazon devices within proximity of one another to gain access to the internet in case of a local connection problem.
The merest mention of Amazon has the possibility of political undertones. A dubious path towards unionization, and poor warehouse conditions, contrast with Amazonās decent environmental record, and recent stance in favor of marijuana legalization. With its near total domination of the cloud computing marketplace, coupled with strong IOT device offerings, Amazon has technology in itās blood.Ā
As a shameless critic of Amazon, I cannot understate the effectiveness of this company. Thereās a reason Amazon has done so well on so many fronts: I mean, clearly theyāre doing something right. Amazon Sidewalk should be no exception, and on June 7th 2021, unless you opt out, your Amazon devices will be automatically enrolled in this mesh-network. So what is a mesh-network? In simple terms, itās something like Appleās Airdrop, only instead of sending memes to your fellow bus travelers, youāre getting a pathway to the internet through their device via a close range, vendor specific connection. Sidewalk turns devices into wifi extenders, providing no connection themselves, only forwarding you down the pipe.
Amazon Sidewalk is a fantastic idea, at least on paper. Security systems, perimeter lights, even voice activated devices like Echo are vital to some people. These devices must always be connected to the internet in order to fully function. After all, if your internet is down, how will your security system send a digital alert to your device if an alarm is tripped? Might not seem like a big deal sitting at your computer drinking coffee, but what if you were out of town? Iād like to know that thereās a backup in place for my security system in case the internet goes down.
Never fear, Amazon Sidewalk is here! Your neighbor, who just so happens to have a Ring doorbell (also owned by Amazon) has an internet connection. With Sidewalk, your devices can reach the glorious interwebs through the Ring doorbellās short range connection. As per Sidewalkās terms, a percentage of each deviceās available bandwidth is reserved and dedicated to receiving connection requests from fellow Amazon products.
Sidewalk faces a number of issues in its life cycle. There may be legal ramifications to using an internet service providerās connection as an independent connection source. Think stealing power from your neighbor. Free lights for you, theyāre stuck with the bill. Sidewalk expands the attack surface of IOT devices and home networks, and finally, this service is opt-out. This creates a perfect storm for attackers with the combination of misconfigured IOT devices, and poorly secured home wireless networks which can be accessed via something as innocent as a security camera.
Iām a practical guy, and I donāt want to be an opponent to progress. Sidewalk is a fantastic idea, but Iād harbor some apprehension at these services even without Amazonās name in the picture. The idea that your device can be accessed by another device in an informalized manner has poor security undertones.
With more companies diversifying into tech, the future is increasingly unclear as to the cyber threat landscape. Cyber attacks have been well documented, inhibiting blue collar workers as much as their white collar counterparts. The Colonial Pipeline incident, and the recent attack on JBS meat packers are only 2 of a great many examples. Amazon, the online retailer and technology company, also maintains an incredibly far reaching and efficient package delivery service. If Amazon is wound into every aspect of our lives (remember the physical stores too), without proper vendor diversity, we risk the population falling sick to one disease due to lack of variation and resilience.
We live in a world with inconsistent technological adoption. Technology transcends industries and lives, but it does not yet encapsulate them. There are workarounds, hold outs, late adapters and infinite configurations of technologies and systems in our very real world that need patching, translating, or modification to sync up. Soon, technology may become so seamless within our lives there is no way to avoid coming into contact with a particular product or brand. Thankfully, weāre not there yet.
In my opinion, we as a society have already placed too many eggs in Amazonās basket. If every Amazon device is connected to other nearby Amazon devices, a single security incident could wreck all associated infrastructure from top to bottom simultaneously. Imagine a driver, maybe a few years in the future. He wears augmented reality contact lenses and carries a cell phone. His electric truck is controlled by an inhouse operating system and also connects to the internet. He delivers a variety of products using a map app, coordinating with his coworkers through yet another app. All of the products, in every aspect from production, to software, to connectivity are controlled by Amazon. And what if none of this will work properly because it got infected via a compromised Echo in a suburban cul-de-sac somewhere in America?
Whatās next?Ā Will Amazon make smart earbuds, phones, start a cellphone service, or be an internet service provider? These arenāt crazy questions. Amazon, and by Amazon I mean Jeff Bezos, can literally do whatever they/he want.
There have been several notable AWS blackouts over the years. Usually they involve one particular AWS region and are not widespread. These blackouts donāt last long, and have not adversely affected digitalĀ life as we know it for longer than an afternoon. So far that is... Thereās a timer on this situation, and Sidewalk is a notch towards its completion. Nothing is too big to fail. More disturbing still, Amazonās official reaction to the most recent blackout was tepid and uninspiring to say the least. Whether this was a cyber attack, a mistake, or some kind of failure, technical or otherwise, is unknown. All we got was a very corporate āWe are working toward resolution.ā I think Kurt Vonnegut would have something to say about this. After all, just 1 piece of Ice 9 into the ocean, the whole world freezes. Letās hope nobody's preparing to hold Amazon hostage with a piece of digital Ice 9.
With so many devices involved in this Sidewalk technology, and due to the sheer size of Amazon, security is paramount. Lack of vigilance in configuration and patching, coupled with future compatibility issues open up a swath of potential issues to contend with for security workers. Also, Sidewalk increases the attack surface for a small, and questionable gain. If any other company created Sidewalk, maybe it wouldnāt be news-worthy. However, anything Amazon does is newsworthy. I say, political opinions aside, never trust one company for everything. The question remains: am I disabling Sidewalk on my personal Amazon devices? Easy answer: Iād be sure to opt-out, if only I owned anything from Amazon.








