Beyonce Makes Lemonade Too
The album Lemonade by Beyoncé tells the story of the experience as a black woman. Beyoncé retraces the infidelity and reconciliation with her husband, Jay-Z. Beyoncé uses this love story as a platform to the larger story that women have had to face for many generations before her such as black women’s bodies being property, fetishized, the overall disrespect black women have faced from their people and society. While many agree that Lemonade does tell a powerful story of the black women’s’ experience, many are not convinced that this story is one that Beyoncé has faced. Many people believe that Beyoncé & Jay-Z has sold this story to make money, but Beyoncé is indeed telling the story of her relationship with Jay-Z. I argue that Lemonade is not only a reflection of black women’s experience, but of Beyoncé’s life.
One criticism that people first argue over Beyoncé is that she does not write her own music. Nevertheless, that does not mean that a person cannot collect various pieces of original art (songs) to create a large piece of art (Lemonade). When looking at the writing credits of the various songs, many songs have multiple writers, but in every song Beyoncé has writing creds. It is more than possible for Beyoncé to receive a song and have it tailored to her life. For example, in the song “Formation” the lyrics are “My daddy Alabama, momma Louisiana/You mix that negro with that Creole make a Texas bamma” which is where she and her parents are from. It is lyrics like this that are tailored to her life, which Beyoncé more than likely has influence over.
The next point is the lyric “Becky with the good hair” being a reference to someone that Jay-Z cheated with years ago. While it Is mostly speculation as to who exactly “Becky” is, there has been many women that Jay-Z has been suspected of cheating with such as Rita Ora, Rihanna, and most notably Rachel Roy who posted a selfie quoting herself with the “good hair” just days after Lemonade premiered. However, this is not the first-time Beyoncé has talked about cheating while with Jay-Z, as she did a powerful rendition of Resentment in the video listed below. Beyoncé has had her fair share of struggles with her marriage as she has suffered from miscarriages, constant backlash from those who oppose her support of the Black Lives Matter movement, and cheating.
Lastly, one cannot deny the anger and sadness behind her videos such as “Don’t Hurt Yourself” and “Sandcastles”. While music videos are supposed to display a certain emotion depending on the song, in the video “Don’t Hurt Yourself” you can clearly see the rage behind Beyoncé’s lyrics and her movements throughout the video. In “Sandcastles” the sadness behind this song is strong and clear from her acting to the moment she says “Bitch, I scratched out your name and your face/What is it about you that I can’t erase, baby?” At this point, her voice even cracks releasing the tears, as she reflects on her relationship. This type of emotion is even reflected in Jay-Z’s 4:44 with his response to Beyoncé’s album “Lemonade”. Jay-Z affirms things that he has done wrong in their relationship, all of which align with themes and issues that Beyoncé addresses in Lemonade.
In conclusion, no one absolutely knows what goes on behind the scenes with Beyoncé & Jay-Z besides the two. However, there is more than enough circumstantial evidence to infer that there is indeed going on. Beyoncé & Jay-Z are both human beings with flaws and no relationship is perfect. There will be difficult times and there will be great times. While many argue that this is simply a piece of art that Beyoncé is marketing, it can also be said that this reflects her life as well.












