HAVE I RUN TOO FAR TO GET HOME? / SEASON 2 WRITE-UP.
cw for mentions of pedophilia, human trafficking, and graphic violence.
as i mentioned in my divergences for the punisher season 1, frank did not give up being the punisher post-dd s2. instead, he gives it up after the events of the punisher season 1 and starts living the alias of pete castiglione. while working at a construction site in the bronx, where he’s stayed since the ending of season 1, frank meets donny chavez. though frank has kept his head low and has effectively isolated himself from everyone in his life (including curtis, david, and madani) for their own safety, he can’t help himself when a group of men from the site try to kill donny after robbing a mafia-affiliated (gnucci) poker game. frank brutally murders them all and kills all of ma gnucci’s sons thereafter, in what he excuses is to protect donny. realizing he can’t stay in new york city without possibly ruining his pardon, frank leaves to drive upstate to the canadian border.
upon arriving in buffalo, frank rents a motel room for a few nights after travelling non-stop for nearly a day, having taken detours through pittsburgh and cleveland to lay low and attempt to enjoy the travel he’s been encouraged to partake in. on his first night, frank attends the bar next to the hotel because he was drawn in by the live music show from his motel room. it’s there that he happens upon a young girl clearly uncomfortable with an older man who acts invasive and generally menacing toward her. it’d be easy to ignore if he didn’t run into her again later that night with the same man, who was clearly staying with her. finally, the next evening, when he watches the girl try to escape into the women’s room while the man follows behind her, frank steps in to confront him. he has no idea that there are several other people in the same group that night, apparently with the man and the young girl, and a chaotic fight ensues in which frank and the girl narrow escape, but not before his enemies and some bystanders are killed and the patrons of the bar terrified. out of fear, she tells him her name is rachel and she’s eighteen, but once she realizes he’s not law enforcement she tells him her name is actually amy bendix and she’s sixteen. frank discovers she was one of many girls all over the country and that she stole footage that would implicate the philanthropist and CEO of dynaco, a wall street financial firm, harry ebbing in the crimes as well as the son of a new york senator, david schultz, from the man trafficking her. she also reveals that she was in touch with a social worker in new york city and planned to expose the information to her. the man she was staying with was trying to leave the trafficking ring and kidnapped her to bring with him, and she planned on stealing the flash drive to escape on her own after her friend died in the process of trying to expose the footage to said social worker.
while on the run with amy, the two finally stop at a motel in albany, where frank seeks to divulge more information from amy and tells her his real identity. while amy sleeps and frank watches over her to figure out their next move, police cruisers approach the room and demand to come inside. before frank can think to answer, they shoot up the hotel room in a spray of bullets, barely giving frank time to cover amy to protect her. the two of them play dead on the floor when the officers enter the room, which is when frank surprises the officers by shooting them with a gun hidden under the bed while amy hides in a nearby closet. they leave the scene of the crime. from there, several new york state police unions as well as the commissioner of the nypd denounce the punisher as a cop-killer and start a state-wide manhunt. he is also accused of kidnapping amy bendix.
the two consider crossing the border while frank thinks to call dinah, who is the SAC of the new york homeland field office. at first, she refuses his call, but locates the two of them from frank’s cell signal and flies to them via helicopter once she sees the reports about the manhunt for the punisher on television. she takes them back to new york to stay with her to work with frank and amy once she realizes the value of the information amy possesses. while dinah urges frank to stay put for his and amy’s own safety, he leaves her apartment to find more information. after spending a day looking for intel on traffickers in the area, frank finally comes back to ask amy for the social worker’s name from amy after getting nowhere. she reveals her name is jen cooke, a social worker and lecturer. frank sits in on one of her lecturers and follows her into her office, where he gives her the flash drive. after some reluctance, and driven by her own frustration at the inaction of the nypd and corruption clearly from a level above her pay grade. she has also been threatened multiple times, including via snuff footage sent to her that included amy’s murdered friend. frank tells her that once he finds whatever kids that may be captive, he’ll bring them to her, and pursues the names she gives him - first, he starts with a russian diplomat who’s staying in a hotel nearby. frank kidnaps him with amy’s help and from there, they get the address of a house in brooklyn where the girls are kept. frank sends amy back to dinah’s place and goes on his own.
meanwhile, dinah looks into ebbing and schultz on her own and ends up, much to her dismay, faced with similar roadblocks as with the kandahar investigation. she is approached by brett mahoney who immediately suspects her as having something to do with frank castle. the two of them work begrudgingly together as brett is the only man in his unit who remotely is interested in the truth surrounding the punisher manhunt.that is when brett and dinah are approached by jen cooke while at the precinct together, who tells them frank told her to see mahoney for protection and about how she’d told frank about the house’s location. dinah realizes what frank’s done and brings jen back to her place along with brett, only to find only amy there. dinah convinces brett not to call for back-up about the house, who is only convinced due to the nature of the footage dinah finally has a chance to watch herself along with brett for the first time. it’s brett who immediately recognizes schultz and ebbing, and it is dinah who recognizes william rawlins.
meanwhile, frank prepares for a total ambush on the house in brooklyn, and has sent amy to go back to dinah’s place. he manages to kill the men inside and keeps one alive for information. it’s there that he finds a group of young girls and boys, varying in age but mostly teenagers, and escorts them outside, where dinah and brett are waiting. frank insists they leave without him and they do, to bring them back to dinah’s place where jen is also hiding. after frank tortures information about the video and the other traffickers out of the man he keeps alive, he sets him on fire to burn to death. as he drives away, a mercenary hired by ebbing known only as barracuda shoots at his tires and sends frank crashing into a ditch, where he barely manages to pull himself out. after a brutal fight, barracuda beats frank to a pulp, and frank only manages to get away but gouging out barracuda’s eye with a knife. completely worn down, frank calls curtis before passing out in the middle of the road and wakes up on dinah’s couch, with curtis, dinah, amy surrounding him.
frank tells dinah about the corruption and complicity from within the nypd and the location of schultz’ wife’s office, where she runs her operations out of. dinah informs him about rawlins and ebbing. dinah instantly recognizes barracuda’s name, as he is a widely known mercenary in the intelligence community wanted for multiple atrocities, which is only an added complication to their issue. however, dinah and brett have both managed to arrange for a warrant to be issued for ebbing’s arrest. after recuperating in dinah’s place briefly, frank leaves to pursue schultz’ wife and curtis takes amy to safety with him.
after frank plows through schultz’ wife’s office, he tortures her to death. as predicted, barracuda is there in the wake of the carnage, where he and frank fight again. meanwhile, the nypd arrest ebbing and schultz, and the two of them are kept in holding cells amid a media frenzy. frank gets the upper hand on barracuda until barracuda slams his face against a desk corner, effectively also gouging out of one frank’s eyes. he stabs frank in the stomach two times until frank shoots him. as the cops arrive, barracuda escapes, leaving frank to be taken into police custody at the hospital. it’s there that david lieberman arrives, impersonating foggy nelson, revealing that the entire time the punisher manhunt has occurred that he’s kept a distance, but could no longer ignore it when the news of his arrest circulated on the local news. the two manage to arrange a power outage and for frank’s escape with dinah’s help, and it’s together that they get the news that ebbing was found murdered in his holding cell before further information could be had and schultz is nowhere to be found.
completely frustrated, the three of them contemplate their next move. that’s when they decide to expose the footage as well as the footage of kandahar to all to finally incriminate rawlins and uncover the conspiracies that have linked the three of them since the beginning. david releases both onto the deep web. while the public comes to terms with the footage, dinah, who has now become as public of an icon as frank, steps down from her role as SAC of the new york homeland office and becomes acting SAC of the new york FBI field office, where she also is able to be closer to billy russo, whose public shaming and scapegoating has now become such public knowledge that there is a movement for him to receive clemency. brett declines to arrest frank, who has become an internationally known icon and whose name is partially cleared, and steps down from the NYPD. with curtis’ help, frank sends amy to diving school in florida, leaving he and david to work together once more to track down schultz in canada, where frank kills him and returns to new york. now, he has fully accepted and embraced his role as the punisher and is left to reconsider what exactly his role should be as a very wide variety of people start to idolize him as a hero figure.