One thing that I hate doing is throwing out parts of stories that I’ve written. When I went back at the beginning of Those Who Touch the Fire and started editing through it/filling in the holes, I’ve come across lines, paragraphs, and pages that I’ve had to remove entirely. These, I’ve cut out and pasted into another document so as not to lose the.
However, I just recently wrote myself into a corner. I’d been lamenting the lack of action in the story and came across a line I’d written which was to introduce some kind of subterranean monster, which Embla would have to fight/run from. I started on this, drawing a potential connection to something weird (but ultimately inconsequential) Embla had seen just previously. I liked the scene, but I was worried that, since it was weird and eerie simply to be weird and eerie, it wouldn’t go over well with readers who wanted answers.
I started writing strange, unsettling formations in the cave around her, eventually having her encounter a large and disgusting maggot-thing... but I didn’t know where to go after that. I didn’t even really know what sort of monsters she would be facing, and anything I came up with seemed out of place. I thought of things like the Slow Mutants from The Gunslinger (snow-white, feral humanoids are a classic in this sort of situation), and I believe Lovecraft wrote a story (The Cave, I think) which had some sort of yeti-like beast (but he was much more into the horrors of evolution than I am). Now that I think about it, At the Mountains of Madness had caves and also had Shoggoths, a sort of creature which might have worked here... but I don’t think it would have been good.
I cut all this out, losing about a day of work in the process. I just don’t think simply having Embla encounter a monster would have been good. Maybe if she, like, fell down a hole or something and ended up in a nest and had to fight her way out... maybe that would have been alright, but she has a horse with her and that complicates matters. I couldn’t figure out what she would fight or how she would fight it, so I got rid of it.
It sucks, but whatever. Now, I’m nearing the end of this laborious, subterranean trek, writing a scene where Embla crosses an underground stream. I liked the idea of the white maggot she saw, so I’ll have her deal with a monstrous leech (maybe tentacles, too?) in the process. After that harrowing experience, we’ll get a nice scene of her finally making back into her homeland.