Synopsis: Your best friend asks you to take his virginity. As the both of you spend more time intimately together you are forced to acknowledge your feelings for one another.
Contains: idiots in love trope, friends to lovers trope, lovers in denial, one-bed trope, crack and sarcasm, mutual pining, eventual smut, fluff, afab reader, eventual angst, anger issues
Pairings: Hunter Sylvester! x afab! reader
You were preparing for bed, cleaning off the makeup you had put on for hours, feeling a little embarrassed. You had been stood up. It wasn’t the end of the world but it was a little humiliating. You shaved for absolutely nothing, put on a matching pair of bra and panties, wore one of your favorite gowns. You didn’t ' have game' per se but you weren’t doing bad either. At least you thought you weren’t.
You decided to stop your playlist and embrace defeat as you heard the sound of rustling leaves and the stomping of boots on the side of your house. That wouldn’t have been him, right? He knew your parents were out of town. There was no reason to go through all this trouble. That’s when a silhouette showed more clearly.
You freaked out, got to your feet, and locked the window, trying to come up with the most elaborate escape plan on the face of the planet but falling short as your panic clouded your judgment.
"Let me in, please. I think I scrapped my knee pretty badly." a familiar voice came through.
You were on edge still, shaking in place as you slowly dragged your arm to open the window.
Hunter came in with a swift motion, panting heavily, with a manic look on his face. As he collected his breath, he finally saw your expression- you seemed furious, steam coming out the top of your head. You were throwing mental darts, aimed at the boy and shaking your hands furiously.
"What the hell are you doing here?! In the middle of the night, unannounced! I thought I was going to get murdered."
"I knew you weren’t going to be asleep so I thought this time was as good as any… wait… are you expecting someone?" his gaze drifted off to your tight-fitting slip dress.
All of a sudden, he noticed the mood lighting and he remembered not seeing your father’s car parked outside. He felt a little uneasy now but he tried his best not to show it. Maybe him coming to you was a terrible idea after all.
"Nope.. it’s just me… no one's coming…" you squeaked, not wanting to share more of the story.
"Ok, good, because I need a favor and I know that this may sound weird and it might make things awkward between us but I trust you so I think you.." you interrupt his nervous spiel with a concerned look on your face.
"Are you not going to apologize first? You know, for scarring me to death." You replied through gritted teeth.
"Yes! Of course, how inconsiderate of me. I truly am sorry, I didn’t mean to startle you, but it’s an emergency. You are the only one I trust with this. I can’t just not try, the thought of it will haunt me for months on end and I really need this…"
"Wow, dude, slow down for a minute. You didn't have any of the funny juice again, right? Don’t tell me I have to pee in a cup. I’m not doing it."
"That was a one-time thing! An honest mistake, if you must know!" He said defensively- "I would never do that willingly.’"
"Sure thing, buddy." You replied with a smug smile on your face.
"What was so important it warranted you climbing up my window during the witching hour?" You said playfully, trying to calm him down.
"So... I've been thinking a lot about the future and how we have less than a year of high school left and... You know I'm high in demand and everything but.." He blabbered on.
"It's ok, I can help you pick out a collage. I am the wisest out of your friends after all. You can trust me, buddy." You declared knowingly
"No, fuck that. I'm not going to college." He brushed it off.
"Nope, you definitely are!" You demanded.
"No, not a chance that's happening." He replied, sounding a little distracted.
"Ok, we will continue this conversation later. You are going, by the way, but let's not get sidetracked. Tell me what's on your mind."
Hunter started blushing for a minute, uncertain of how to express himself.
"You know how last year you and Kevin were making fun of me for being a virgin.." he explained hastily.
"Yeah, I'm so sorry for that. It was funny as fuck but there is no shame in being a virgin. I mean, I was one up until five months ago." You confessed.
Hunter's cheeks became even rosier, embarrassment written on his face.
"The thing is… I still am one.." He blurted out
"Oh? So do you need me to hook you up with someone? I guess I could make a good wingwoman, I can look around, do a little research." You got all serious and concentrated, lost in thought.
"Puff, no. I'm the singer of a semi-successful metal band and like I previously mentioned I am high in demand." Hunter grinned proudly.
"Ok then, I don't understand the issue."
"Look, when I do decide to pursue any of my many.. and I mean many groupies.."
"Uhuh.." You dozed, rolling your eyes at him.
"I want to be certain of what I'm doing. I have a reputation to uphold. I'm not a washed-up indie singer or something. I am supposed to be a master in the arts of sex.." He rambled.
"Ok, I'm losing you. Stop stretching out the conversation and get to your actual point." You chirped a little annoyed.
"I want you to teach me." He spat out.
"You want me to take your virginity?" You asked a bit taken aback.
"Nope, I want you to teach me. You know how when you practice something, you get better at it? I have been playing the guitar for years and that's how I built upon my skill." He explained, hoping you were paying attention and reading carefully between the lines.
"I don't catch your drift."
Hunter's face dropped. Guess he had to spell it out for you.
"I don't want you to take my virginity and then never do it again. I won't learn anything from just one lesson. I need a proper course. Maybe like a month-long or something. I'm willing to do whatever you want if you agree. And if you don't and try to tell anyone about this interaction, I will deny everything I said up until this point so it will be your word against mine and..."
"Ok, ok mister 'Law and order'. Slow your horses. I'm not going to tell anyone."
A rush of relief washed over Hunter's face.
"So basically you want me to have sex with you in the pursuit of learning..?"
"Like scheduled, strictly mechanical. Just so you learn the woodwork?" You said a bit confused.
"No, of course not. What's the point in that? In real life, people don't show up and have sex out of nowhere. This isn't porn. I want to do the entire thing right- foreplay, intensity, passion, mood lighting, music, etc. I'm not about to half-ass it." He said confidently.
"And why do you want to do it with me?"
"I know you, I trust you and you are pleasing to the eye. That way I won't feel so weird or embarrassed."
" 'Pleasing to the eye', don't be busting out the compliments just yet, you don't want to make me all flustered and shit." You said sarcastically.
"Ok, I'm sorry. That sounded douche-y. What I meant to say is you’re hot and you are basically the only person that matches my energy."
"Yeah.. that sounds wayy less douche-y," You replied, unamused.
"I'm sorry, I'm having a pretty hard time here. If you think of a more appropriate way of phrasing it, please do let me know." Hunter retorted a bit defensively.
"This is such a bad idea, dude. It can go off the rails, you know."
"Can't you help a desperate friend out? Please, I really need this." Hunter pleaded, looking like a sad puppy.
You had to think for a second. This was such a bad idea. For one it could ruin the friendship, make things between you two uncomfortable, but you could see the strained expression on his face. You couldn’t just leave him hanging. Maybe he was going to back down, change his mind if you were to actually agree, so against your better judgment you went along with it.
"God, good thing I feel bad for you after this pathetic pitch you tried to sell me. Guess I'm not as wise.. uh.. sure I will do it, but I have to warn you that I do have some ground rules, some extremely important 'Do's' and 'Don't's'..."
Hunter got all excited and giddy after hearing you that he cut you off mid-sentence. "You will do it! Fuck yeah, thank youu! You are truly the best!" He said and then quickly kissed your cheek.
"I will be considerate of your 'Do's' and 'Don't's' and make sure to make you feel as comfortable as possible." He said matter of factly while saluting you and climbing back out of your window.
"I'm already regretting this." You croaked out to yourself.
Hunter was sitting on your bed, propped up on his elbows with a notebook in front of him and a pen sticking out of his mouth while you were going on your merry rant.
"Don't overdo it with the dirty talk. Don't name any of my body parts. Don't give me a nickname. Don't call me 'mommy' and don't expect me to call you 'daddy', I'm not into it. Don't grab my neck out of nowhere. You can't just go around choking me unannounced!" You scolded.
"So if I announce myself I can choke you?" Hunter's eyebrows raised playfully.
"We'll see about that.. Don't call me a 'good girl' or whatever. It makes me feel weird. Don't tear any of my clothes, I'm pretty attached to them. Don't touch my feet. Ass area is off-limits! I'm not kidding, don't slap it, care about it, try to put something up it, don't even acknowledge its existence!"
Hunter scribbled something in his notebook, highlighted it, and mouthed "no ass".
"Is this all? Or are there more 'Don't's'?"
"I guess there are but they will come up with time depending on the situation. Communication is key after all."
"Ok, what are the 'Do's' then?"
"A lot of attention on the neck, hips, and thigh areas. Reciprocal scratching is encouraged. The same applies to light hair pulling, biting, and slapping at times..."
"Wait, slapping?" Hunter got a little alarmed.
"I'm a very passionate person. I'm not only passive-aggressive. I can also be actively aggressive and sex is a productive way to channel it, ya know." You answered coyly
Hunter wrote down "Surprisingly both a sadist and a masochist."
"I like attention, I like eye contact, I like feeling like a gem. Like I'm God-sent or something. I know how it sounds but I'm being honest, it turns me on. That probably has something to do with my self-esteem issues.. well yet another thing to bring up with my therapist" you drifted off.
"The fact you like to be validated during sex?" Hunter chuckled.
"Yeah.. maybe.. maybe not." You said after sifting the thought through your brain.
"I can be mean during sex, by the way, sometimes I can get nasty." You warned.
"Only during sex?" Hunter teased and you hit his shoulder.
"Oh yeah, teasing is a must! I both hate it and love it so much. Banter is extremely erotic when done right and it has to be incorporated."
Hunter circled "probably has anger issues and gets her panties wet by arguing"
"That's kind of a mischaracterization of what I said but yeah, sure.."
"It's ok, I have anger issues too. I get you, girl." He put his hand on your shoulder while mock empathizing with you.
"Don't ever say that again."
"Ok, putting it in the 'Don't's' section right after the ass stuff." He said all knowingly.
"Oh God, how am I supposed to keep going when you’re not taking anything seriously and acting like such a little brat?"
"Don't get all worked up now babe, we haven't even taken our clothes off." Hunter coughed out and winked at you.
You went on without paying him much attention.
"I also like to take things slow. But that mostly happens when I have developed feelings for the person. Wanting to be in the moment with them."
"So you were the one half-assing sex?"
"Wait, what? I beg your pardon!" You screeched, offended at his suggestion.
"It is all about being in the moment. If it isn't clicking you simply don't go through with it. But sex is all about some basic type of connection between people. It's not only about feelings, it's about respect, it's about dignity. Getting to know someone more intimately, not only for your pleasure." Hunter explained all focused and mentor-like.
"If you know all of this already, what do you need me for?"
"You can't just go around the world with knowing stuff you can’t put to use," Hunter answered like he had thought about it for a long time.
You were quite impressed with him. You had known him for a very long time and you were already aware he wasn't showing everything there was to him to others. Yes, he could be impulsive and childlike, a pain in the ass, and a cocky son of a bitch but he was always strangely emotionally Intelligent at times, and that surprised you. Guess therapy was working for him, huh?
"So, is that the end of our lesson for today?"
"I think so. It's good that the two of us learned some new information today." You smiled, feeling proud of your student.
"Yeah, I now know not to call you 'mommy'. It's information that will shape me for the years to come." He said sarcastically.
"Oh, shut up asshole. You asked for this, remember?" You retorted
"And you were the one that strongly encourages teasing, weren't you." He whispered huskily as he leveled with your face and kissed you, slowly and tentatively. Your cheeks flushed with shock. He opened his eyes to look at you and chuckled softly.
"May I kiss you again?" He pleaded. Your breath caught in your throat. You did agree to this, yes, but there was still some disbelief there.
"He'll probably drop it. He doesn't mean it seriously. It won't come to anything physical, I'm sure of it..." you had already convinced yourself.
You didn't expect anything to actually... Well, happen. But he was only asking for a kiss and he looked like such a sad little puppy, there was no denying him.
"Yes.." you gulped. "You may kiss me." You nervously shift your gaze from his eyes to his lips.
As if he was reading your mind he replied: "Don't worry, I'm anxious too."
And then it was all silence as he closed the distance between you, his lips gently caressing yours. He was holding you tight- one hand on the small of your back and the other on your cheek as he slowly deepened the kiss. He was hesitant with his movements but was trying to impress you. With his tongue fully in your mouth, engulfing you steadily. Savoring every little bit, every time you brushed your fingers through his hair, every time you pressed your palms against his chest or tickled the sides of his face with your fingertips.
He held you like you were made of porcelain, not because he was afraid of you breaking but of you changing your mind, your touch being too infectious to let go of.
Both of you parted to catch your breath and Hunter smiled at you sheepishly, held up your arm to his face, and planted a quick peck on the back of it.
"That was quite the kiss."
"Yeah.. it definitely was." You agreed, flustered, gazing into his eyes.
You were sitting on Hunter's bed, trying your best to focus on doing your homework while Skullflower was practicing. They were getting pretty good, their sound coming off as more refined and confident. Hunter had worked hard on their debut album to the point that even the demos of their songs were professional.
He was very serious when it came to his craft. You could see it now- how particular he was about the acoustics, how much emotion he put in while he sang, and how concentrated he was while strumming on his guitar. He was truly in his element while playing and you could see all of this passion radiating from him. He was in the zone, huffing, and sweating, looking down at the strings and plucking them one by one with his fingers.
Your body tensed at the sight, his long hair swishing, complementing the sharpness and edges of his face. And his eyes looked so.. uh... so... what were you thinking about?! Snap out of it! You were doing homework; you weren't drooling over your best friend. That's nonsense!
You were so focused on expelling all of the non-platonic thoughts out of your head that you barely even noticed that the band had stopped playing and Kevin and Emily were nowhere to be seen.
"Are you done with your homework?" Hunter asked while putting away his guitar.
"Yeah, you could say so. I made a lot of progress." You answered embarrassedly.
"That's good, hard work should be rewarded," Hunter whispered as he started coming close to you.
"Yeah. I should treat myself to desert or something." You fidgeted with your fingers and avoided his gaze.
"I was thinking of something more along the lines of this." He was in front of you now, grabbing your cheeks with both of his hands and kissing you passionately. He then broke away and started gently stroking your hair and playing with the ends.
"You looked pretty all concentrated and serious." He confessed. "But I think it's time for you to take a little break and relax."
"I'm not that tired." You gulped impulsively.
"Good, me neither." He put his hands on your waist and kissed you again so drawn out that it made you weak. It took everything out of you not to whimper at the feeling. If you were none the wiser you would have confused the feeling in your stomach for butterflies, but there was no way Hunter could be causing such a reaction. Definitely not.
"Do you want to hang out, watch a movie, or something?" He suggested nervously.
"Oh wait, I know what you need!" He whispered and wiggled his eyebrows.
Fuck, fuck, fuck, what was he going to do? That was too much. Your heart was racing and you could feel how increasingly anxious you were getting.
As your mind was spiraling, he put on TLC and turned to you.
"Pick your poison. I'm gonna order junk food and we can make fun of whatever show you want " You melted. He knew you so well. Just because you were swapping DNA samples with each other now didn't mean he didn't remember how it was before. He got you.
Hunter could sense you were a little tense and he didn't want to put you off. He wanted you to remember what your relationship was all about- you two goofing off, being idiots, being assholes to others and to each other sometimes but still carrying deep care and understanding for one another.
"That sounds amazing, but it's getting kind of late. I need to go home." You whispered, regret washing over you.
"You can stay over, you know? It's not a school night and for some bizarre reason, your parents are chill with me. Come on captain Crunch, please stay." He looked a little desperate and sad. He wanted you here. He needed you to stay.
"One time I choke on cereal and have it come out of my nose and I never get to hear the end of it, huh?" You answered, acting as if you were upset. "But yeah, ok, I will stay over."
Come to think of it maybe that was exactly what you needed- to remind yourself of what your relationship with Hunter was so you stopped acting as if you had a crush on him, because one thing was for certain- you didn't, nope.
The two of you ate pizza as you laughed at the terrible attempts at flirting made by some poor soul on 90-day fiancé.
"Don't worry about it, beautiful. When we get together, I will buy you an ass." Ok, not such a poor soul after all.
"Boo, who the fuck would actually say that?" You screamed at the TV.
"She is only in on it because she wants to get a green card, you can't get too mad at the guy," Hunter explained.
"Are you defending him?!" You replied dumbfounded by his words.
"No, fuck no. The dude is a total tool." Hunter snickered.
"Good, I was getting worried for a second there."
Hunter held up one of his hands to his chest and declared: "Don't worry sweetheart, I would never even dare to mention your ass." He laughed and you laughed as well, punching his shoulder lightly.
"Oh, fuck off." You spat out, still unable to stop yourself from giggling."I think it's time I call it a night. I'm pretty tired. Toss me one of your tees and some sheets so I can make the sofa..." Hunter interrupted you.
"What are you saying, you're sleeping with me. I can’t have you sleeping on the sofa. We have done this so many times before, there's plenty of space for the both of us."
"I know.. but it hasn’t happened in such a long time." The nerves were returning and a flush was creeping up your cheeks.
"Yeah, that’s true. But you are aware of how comfortable my bed is." He reminded
You could share a bed with him. I mean it was just Hunter. Good old Hunter- your FRIEND. Nothing more, nothing else. What was the point of making a fuss?
"Fine, just give me something to wear, please." You said trying to sound a bit annoyed at the situation.
Hunter gave you one of his band tees. You went to the bathroom to put it on, your toothbrush still being there from previous sleepovers. But was this a sleepover? What if he tried to do something? What if you tried to do something yourself? No, that was nonsense! Why would you, it's not like you desperately wanted to. You can behave yourself!
You came out of the bathroom wearing only his T-shirt and a pair of underwear.
"I know how you like to sleep on the left side but my phone is charging on the bedside table and I'll need to switch the do not disturb mode on at some point so..." He froze as you came into view, looking extremely casual and comfy with your hair down and his shirt adorning your body, ending just at the beginning of your thighs.
"Yeah, that's ok" you whispered.
Was he blushing? He couldn't be, right? There was no way you could make him this shy.
You climbed into bed with him. He also had a shirt on and you couldn’t tell whether he was wearing anything underneath but as your leg unintentionally brushed over his you knew for a fact, he was also only wearing his boxers.
"I'm sorry," you said coyly.
"It's alright." He replied.
To the both of your surprise, you put your hands on his face, pulling him towards you, and kissed him gently. He was so shocked he had his eyes open for a bit, but as the initial feeling warn off, he wrapped around you with both of his arms and held your chest close to his as his tongue slowly came into your mouth. Your legs were tangling between his, and without even thinking of it your grip landed on his shoulders as you tried kissing him harder, more passionately.
You broke away to catch your breaths, with your head laying on his chest. He caressed your hair and planted a kiss on the top of your head while lacing his fingers through yours. Your heart was racing and you could hear his was too. You liked it, how comfortable you felt in his embrace. How well you fit around him.
You reached up to lightly stroke his face and kiss his cheek. "Goodnight, Hunter’’, you put his hand on your waist and turned on your side, making him spoon you.
"Goodnight." He whispered tentatively into your ear.