The first video we’ve watched talked about morality and if it does came from God. The questions that stuck in my head are these two:
“Does God tell us to do what is good because it’s good? or is it good because God tells us to do it?”
In the two questions, I think that the answers to this comes with a “but” or an explanation because it is not answerable by just yes or no. Like in the first question: Does God tells us to do what is good because it’s good? I think the answer is yes because for a slightly religious person like me, I think that God only wants us to do good things and not do bad things which is why I think that God tells us things because it is good. An example is to love thy neighbor. God wouldn’t said that if it isn’t good but he said that so it is good. On the second question: Is it good because God tells us to do it? In line with the first question, I think that God wouldn’t tell us something bad to do because His only intention is to makes us do good things. My answer to the question is yes and no. I think it is good because God tells us to do it but I think it’s also not good because sometimes, God will tell you things to do that is just a way to test your faith. In the example in the video, like if God says that you should burn someone’s house down, I think God can only say this to test your faith in Him by knowing your decision to burn the house down or not. Morality can enter in this kind of situation because you’ll think about it if is it right to do it or not. Thus, my thoughts about “Does morality come from God?” is that I think it depends on the faith you have for God. If you are religious, you’ll believe that morality came from God and if you’re not or you’re skeptic, then you’ll believe that morality is just a collection of social norms or whatsoever.
On the second video, these are the questions and statements that stuck in my head and below these questions and statements are my thoughts regarding them:
“What if you could do whatever you want and get away with it?”
I think this question’s intention is to ask me if what if I could do whatever I want whether it is right or wrong and get away with it. If I could do something bad to gain something from it and get away with it, I think I wouldn’t do it. First, I am responsible for my own actions which is why I wouldn’t do anything bad even though I can get away with it because in the first place, we shouldn’t do bad things. Although I look like a little hypocrite with what I said, I think that is what I will do. However, in some instances, I know I can do bad things knowing that I could get away from it. Like when I ask my mom for money to buy a book. I would ask a higher amount for me to gain some kickback from the money my mom gave because I know that my mom wouldn’t know that I raised the price a bit. Thus, my answer is that it depends on the situation like how bad is the thing that I will do.
“According to Plato, the just person will always be infinitely happy than the unjust person because the just person knows that committing unjust acts messes with his soul and his happiness.”
I agree with this statement that Plato said because I believe that true happiness is obtained when you don’t have any burden or regrets in every action you’re making or you’ve made. For example, I’m a very just person which is why I won’t do anything that will hurt me and will hurt other people. Then, I think if I am really a just person, I would definitely be happy because I know all of the things I’m doing is good.
“Goodness is not derived from material or social gain.”
I somewhat agree with this because maybe sometimes we obtain goodness from material or social gain and sometimes we don’t. For example, I obtained an award from helping in the evacuation centers by giving out the relief goods but when I was giving out the relief goods, it was tiring and it made me annoyed a bit. Although I was a bit annoyed when I was giving out the relief goods, I think I will reflect with what I felt and acted during that time because of the award I received because I would think that I should be deserving of the award. Thus, I believe that material or social gain also helps us goodness in a way.Â