Hi all, how are we doing?
Been watching the new Outlander season in "batches" as it's a busy time of life still. Not professionally, that's stalled currently (annoyingly) and AI isn't helping. I'm kind of "sitting tight" figuring out the next move in that arena while living my best life homemaking. Highly recommend if you're able to do it financially. It's also garden prep season, and mine is going to be triple the size this year so I'm excited!
But anyway I got caught up to 8.07 and well, woof. Brain dump thoughts below for anyone who wants to hear someone else complain about it, too.
I'm the last person to condemn changes from the book to the show, the books are 900 pages and they're different mediums, you can't just translate them 1:1.
But these are big story arc changes. And questionable focuses. I thoroughly enjoy the "Ian and Rachel" and "Bree and Roger" stories in the books (though I think I'd prefer they be spin-off books, not 1/3 of the og series but w/e, in the books it's fine because you still get the full J/C story) but in the show they've massively sacrificed the core couple, the core story, for side quests.
Even the Cunningham story, why was that dragged out so much? It's the last season, they couldn't flesh it out due to time, it's not a story that's going anywhere, so it just wasted what few episodes they had left.
And it's not as if the book didn't have enough J/C to fill the season.
I assumed, since this is the last season AND book 10 isn't a thing yet, that they'd just pick the primary J/C storyline in Bees (and a few side moments with the others) and flesh it out nicely and end the season just as the book ends, with the Frasers and Family continuing on as they do. This a) leaves the door open to do a movie after book 10 is out, but if that doesn't happen it b) leaves the audience/story/characters in a good place.
There was never a doubt in my mind if that'd be what they'd do. Because 'obviously that's what they'll do.'
They didn't do that.
Now I'm a little above the average when it comes to mental horsepower but I'm not some genius. And the showrunners of a massive show like this aren't dumb either. So I can't imagine they "didn't think to just do it that way"
I'm trying to give benefits of the doubt where possible, but with what we just saw, it's getting harder and harder. It feels more like they wanted to create their own story, not just follow what we've all read and been waiting to see. Which, for Show Only fans, the story choices are bad enough as it is (described below with spoilers) but for Book And Show fans it feels self-indulging on the part of the showrunners. Like, Matt, if you wanted to write fanfiction, you can. There are many sites that welcome it. Otherwise, sure, put the "TV" spin on it, but make the book in to a show. Don't radically change the book. What's next? Let me guess, Jamie gets bit by a radioiactive spider and he can time travel now and he's actually Frank's dad? Ugh.
SPOILERS BELOW OF 8.07 in italics
**********************************
spoilers spoilers spoilers spoilers spoilers spoilers
Letting HC survive the fire? Solid change for a visual medium on a show that's about to end and the loss won't further the story other than to put the characters in pain for 3.25 more episodes.
Having Fergus die? Really not sure what that accomplishes with -- 3.25 episodes left.
The William storyline -- hot mess. I don't understand the "why did this make the screen" for most of it. And so help me if they had Fergus die so William could hit up Marsali or something like that.
And none of this is even getting in to the Faith storyline. I'm currently doing a re-watch with my husband as he's never seen it and we needed something else to watch as we anxiously await the return of Clarkson's Farm, and we just finished "La Dame Blanche." And already, knowing how the show changed things, dulls the Faith storyline and I haven't even rewatched that ep again yet. I won't be telling him as he wouldn't want the spoiler but it's frustrating.
While painful to watch and invest in, the Faith story was so powerful. It wasn't just a death to put J/C through peril; it shaped the people they were going forward. It changed them both, especially Claire.
And outside of the show, that story gave voice to every mother watching who has faced that loss.
Going back on it, having Faith secretly live, and try to find them, and then get killed by pirates in the process, is sloppy. And unnecessary. Again. ONLY 3 EPISODES LEFT.
spoilers spoilers spoilers spoilers spoilers spoilers
*************************************
END BIG SPOILERS ^^
Like I said, the showrunners have clearly "forgotten" that they are adapting a book series, not writing their own. And that the viewers will absolutely forgive not having a 1:1 translation of the page to the screen, that there will be omissions, changes, due to the different medium.
But huge plot changes? Especially one that CHANGES a past season? It feels like an "it was all a dream" rug getting pulled.
Needless to say it doesn't feel good as the invested viewer.
And that's not even going in to the other nonsense. The moving target premiere dates during the 18 months between 10-12 episode seasons to convince subscribers to keep paid-up during the release of BomB, the lack of promo, etc.
I was expecting a beautiful bookend season. 12 episodes of primarily J/C's storyine, some Claire voiceover harkening back to season 1 (got some of that at least), and Raya back singing the theme song. I expected it to end as Bees ended, with all looking forward to "the day after"
I expected the door would be open to do a movie if the opportunity presented itself and all were on-board after book 10 was out.
I expected a really fun lead-up to the season premiere, and I expected to be excited to "watch at midnight" every week. Because man these last eps are going to be brilliant and prioritizing watching them over sleep will be a no-brainer.
Boy was I wrong. How disappointing.
Anyway. At least it'll be time for some "tractoring" soon over in the UK. (on prime, not an ad, Clarkson's farm really is just a fun watch.) Jeremy and Caleb would never.
Wonder if Lisa will ever actually keep just hyper-local produce in the farm shop and if the Council will ever let them put in that proper car park.
Time will tell. But you know what is telling? That I'm far more excited to watch the "top gear" guy try to run a farm than I am to see the last three episodes of the show I've been watching and loving for years.
LAST SECOND ADD BEFORE HITTING PUBLISH:
Oh, re-reading for a quick proofing and it hit. MBR is setting up spin-offs. He must want a boat, or another house. He's testing how the audience responds to the side characters to decide who to spin-off first.
And he's doing it at the expense of the couple we're all actually here for. That's the "why" he's doing it like this. Doesn't explain why he's changed the story though, just why he's focused so much precious time on the other characters.
SPOILER AHEAD:
The irony is the only couple I'd really be interested in watching spun-off (and I think he successfully *could* spin-off as an independent story without Jamie and Claire having to be there regularly, and that the actors could carry their own show) would be the one couple that he just killed half of. How dumb.
Oh well, off to metal detect in my back yard some more. It was built on 1800s farmland so I've been finding fun old stuff. Need to get more practice as this summer we're going to do the family farm before it gets sold.