Thoughts regarding Chapter 5 (major spoilers ahead):
I'm a sucker for jester type designs, so naturally I love the Prototype's design. I mean, yeah, it'd have been cool to have more of a mishmash of toys or more body horror rather than just kinda slapping some dismembered toy arms onto a somewhat unfortunate spot on his lower body, but I like this too!
I was not expecting the brother thing. Actually, was that confirmed, or was Elliot Ludwig calling Oliver "my boy" in the sense of an unrelated child?
Giblet was pretty cool in my opinion, though I will admit the repeated line of "I'm not a hero" did come off as a bit unnecessary, probably because nobody prompted him to say that. If he was talking to another character and said that, it'd make sense, but between the silent protagonist, the unintelligible Chum, and Poppy not usually in the same room as him, we don't get any real opportunities to justify that line. That kind of thing doesn't come off as humble unless someone else is pushing it.
On that note, Chum Chumpkins deserved more screen time, he was a sweetie.
One thing I do take issue with is that each chapter feels more like its own loosely associated game rather than a singular consistent narrative; very few characters carry from chapter to chapter, and each location the player passes through seems very isolated from one another. I dunno, I guess that's to be expected when you're producing a game one chapter at a time, but it is kind of choppy in terms of narrative building.
Why the fuck does Sweet Street exist? Like, Playcare, the prison, the labs, etc all have some excuse for being built, but what use did Playco have for a giant plastic dollhouse so far underground?
Not gonna lie, if I were in Huggy's shoes, I'd have absolutely lost my shit too having that Ms. Rachel expy spouting creepy nonsense in my face while getting zapped. How Playtime Co didn't see the massive pressure bomb they were building with that approach is beyond me.
Legit, my reaction to the tape of Gracie Greene getting dragged off to be turned into a toy and brainwashed with her own tapes:
Everyone in this story deserves to swear, but especially Poppy. Poor gal's earned it.
I do wanna hear more about the toys that actually managed to get out and escape to the surface. 23 toys escaped the Prototype's clutches ten years ago... now that's a story!
The reveal that the Prototype killed/experimented on the orphans already wasn't exactly shocking, but I do feel bad for Poppy for hinging so much of her plans on them being able to be released. Logically, their chances of surviving were nil from the very start; we never saw them, they were just a token hostage group to motivate us.
The reveal of the Doctor surviving (kinda) did surprise me a little, but not that much. He was too popular to die (also, they did introduce the brain scanning thing here, which I thought was more sci-fi than before but whatever).