I just re-read Once upon a broken heart a few days back and god, I didn't think it was possible to love Evangeline and the series more than I already did. But, guess what? I was wrong. I fell in love with her and the series ALL OVER AGAIN. And here is why-
There’s something about Evangeline that makes people either adore her instantly or completely misunderstand her. Honestly, I think a lot of that comes from the fact that readers are so used to female protagonists in YA fantasy having to prove themselves through strength in a very specific way: emotionally detached, hyper-competent, sarcastic, intimidating, always ten steps ahead of everyone else. Evangeline just… isn’t that.
She cries. She hopes too much. She believes people even when she probably shouldn’t. She romanticizes love and destiny in ways that feel almost painfully sincere. Because of that, a lot of readers reduce her to being naive or weak, when that’s really not what the series is doing with her character at all.
What makes Evangeline interesting is that she’s soft without the story treating softness like a flaw that needs to be corrected.
Especially in YA fantasy, where female leads are often written to survive by becoming emotionally hardened. Evangeline survives by refusing to completely lose her sense of wonder, even after being betrayed over and over again. That takes a different kind of strength. Cynicism is easy after heartbreak. Staying hopeful is harder.
Throughout the series, she keeps getting punished for believing in love, in people, in the idea that things can still turn out beautifully. Every time, you expect the story to finally turn her into the typical cold YA heroine. But it never fully does. She changes, obviously—she becomes more hurt, more cautious, more aware of how cruel people can be—but she never loses the core of herself. And I think that frustrates some readers because we’ve been conditioned to see femininity, optimism, and emotional openness as signs of immaturity.
But Evangeline’s emotions are actually what drive the story. She makes decisions based on grief, loneliness, hope, love, fear—all these messy, deeply human feelings. She doesn’t move through the world like a strategist manipulating everyone around her, and because of that, she feels more like a real person than a fantasy archetype.
People also misunderstand her because they compare her to characters she was never trying to be. She’s not Jude Duarte or Aelin. She isn’t written to dominate every room she enters with power or intimidation. Her strength is quieter and far more emotional. She’s the kind of protagonist who changes the atmosphere of a story simply by continuing to care when caring is painful.
And honestly, that’s why Jacks works so well with her. Jacks is cynical in the exact way Evangeline refuses to become. He expects manipulation, selfishness, betrayal. She expects meaning. Even after learning harsh truths, some part of her still wants to believe there’s goodness underneath everything. Their dynamic only works because Evangeline never fully bends to his worldview. She softens him without losing herself entirely in the process.
The series itself honestly feels a lot like Evangeline: whimsical, emotional, irrational at times, driven more by feelings and fairy-tale logic than realism. Whether people enjoy the trilogy often depends on whether they accept that tone or keep waiting for it to become something darker and more grounded. Because these books run on emotion first, logic second. Promises matter more than politics. Heartbreak matters more than strategy.
And I think that’s exactly why the series stands out.
It feels like a modern fairy tale in the truest sense—not because it’s soft and pretty, but because emotions literally shape reality inside it.
Evangeline embodies that perfectly. She treats stories, curses, destiny, and love as things that matter deeply because, to her, they do. People might call her unrealistic, but honestly, she feels realistic in a way people don’t always want to admit. Most people want to believe in love. Most people want things to mean something. Evangeline just says it out loud instead of hiding behind irony or pretending not to care.
And yes, she makes frustrating decisions. Sometimes you want to just grab her from the book and tell her to stop trusting people so easily. But that frustration is part of what makes her feel human. She isn’t emotionally detached enough to protect herself properly, and the series never pretends otherwise.
I think what makes Evangeline memorable isn’t that she’s the strongest or smartest YA heroine ever written. It’s that she feels emotionally sincere in a genre where sincerity is often mistaken for weakness.
She reminds you that softness is not the absence of strength. Sometimes it’s strength without armor. And honestly, that’s much harder to write convincingly than another emotionally unavailable girl with a knife.
pixelskylines
snowghoul
s-u-f-j-a-n-s-t-e-v-e-n-s
titsay
