im so obsessed with sinners right now and iโve had a couple of ideas floating around! one specifically has been driving me NUTS
reader being in a committed relationship with smoke, but sometimes her eyes drift to stack. smoke isnโt oblivious, but he also isnโt mad. maybe he arranges a little blindfolded โwhoโs touching you right nowโ with stack for his lady, just a one (or two) time thing!
Dude, YES SAME, I have been going nutso for sinners since it came out and I need to gush!!! I cannot, will not shut up LOL. I loooved this ask, thank you thank you, keep em coming hehe ๐
Smoke x Reader... x (Stack)
Warnings: Spice, blindfolds, wandering eyes, committed relationship with Smoke, ambiguous relationship with Stack
โฟโโโโเผบโเผปโโโโโพย
Being with Smoke is everything youโve wanted and more in a relationship. Heโs dependable, calm and collected, and follows through time and time again. When he commits, he commits. You feel lucky every night you get to share your bed with him.
He makes you feel secure and safe in your relationship, and you trust him entirely.
And yet, despite how perfect and content you feel in your relationship with Smoke, every now and then you canโt seem to keep yours eyes off of his brother
Theyโre equal parts handsome in a literal, identical sense, so itโs unsurprising that youโd also find Stack attractive. However, that small fact does little to ease your guilty conscience
A night of dancing with your front pressed against Smokeโs firm chest, and all the while youโre staring over his shoulder to where Stack is grinding with some girl
Sitting on Smokeโs lap while both twins play cards at a table, and your eyes canโt help but track the way Stackโs throat bobs when he swallows his whiskey neat
Waiting in the car while Smoke and Stack handle business with Bo, unable to keep your eyes from glancing between both their asses
You tried your best to keep your eyes away from Smokeโs equally attractive brother, and yet at every opportunity you drifted them in Stackโs direction without meaning to
The worst part of it isโฆSmoke knew. He had to.
Smoke was not a foolish manโhe kept tabs on every situation. You need to be vigilant when you work with risky money. He read social cues, picked up on subtle body language, and watched for signs of shady business. Itโs what allowed him to command a room.
All this is to say, you knew that he knew.
And, if you werenโt convinced before, you definitely were after you caught Smoke staring right towards youโฆ Caught in the act while you eyed the bulging veins on his brotherโs forearm, lining up a shot at the pool table
You expected Smoke to have confronted you about it earlier. You expected him to get angry, defensive, accusatory, and jealous even.
It was no small stressor as you waited for him to bring it up in the following days
Yet, your reckoning did not come to you in angry words, but in the anticipation of them.
โClose your eyes darlinโ,โ Smoke spoke in that familiar, even toneโcalm and collected as ever. But you knew he knew, and it unnerved you. You watched him loosen his tie, swallowing nervously.
His eyes narrowed at you, and with a twitch you realized he meant business.
โI said, close your eyes.โ
You had little choice but to obey. Your nerves were firing off as your eyelashes fluttered closed. You heard the click of his shoes on the wooden floorboards, stepping closer in your direction.
You jumped slightly as you felt his fingertips against your throatโa ghost of a touch, so light that it brought goosebumps to your flesh.
Your breathing became shallower and more labored as you felt his knuckles trace delicately up to your jawโฆand then the gentle brush of fabric as he used his tie to blindfold you.
โCanโt have your eyes wandering,โ his voice was husky in your ear, and you knew without a doubt that your moment of reckoning had come. He knew.
Being unable to see brought with it an elevated level of sensitivityโthe gentle, yet firm, feeling of his hands leading you to the center of the room. The warm fanning of his breath against the back of your neck. The sound of a door across the room opening and softly clicking shut.
A second pair of footsteps approached you, and you realized with a growing sense of anxiety and exhilaration that another had joined your company.
And then, another pair of work-worn hands touched against your arm, and you audibly gasped.
โMy,โ you heard Stackโs breathy laugh, recognizing it immediately. โSensitive, aren't they?โ
โMm hmm,โ Smoke agreed gruffly, his voice strong and poised. He had complete control over you and the situation at hand.
For a moment, no one spoke. You waited with baited breath as you heard the sound of fabric rustling. Someone was moving. Who?
You felt a large hand grab at your hip, and you jolted, startled. The hand coaxed you as if soothing a spooked animal, trailing up your side and stopping along your ribcage.
โWhoโs touching you right now?โ you heard Smokeโs deep and commanding voice ask from behind you. You were certain if you leaned a few inches back you would bump into his broad chest.
โI d-donโtโฆโ you stuttered out, unsure of how to answer, too tightly wound and agitated to risk a guess. What would happen if you were incorrect?
The hand on your ribcage disappeared, leaving behind a warmth that made the air in its absence feel cold. Then, a sharp nip at your earlobeโฆa punishment for taking too long.
โSmoke!โ you yelped, knowing that had been him.
His dark chuckle sounded so close to your ear that a shiver ran up your spine. Something molten was already beginning to form in your chest. โVery good,โ he praised.
You heard a low whistle directly in front of youโStack, enjoying the scene in front of him.
You didnโt dare reach out for him. You didnโt have to, because within a moment he was pawing at your thigh, squeezing the plush flesh there. Bold, explorative, eager.
โS-Stack,โ you choked on his name, and you didnโt need to see to know that his typical devilish smile was spread across his face.
โDonโt think youโll need to train 'em for too long,โ Stack spoke lowly to his brother. โSeems like they learn better when their eyes are closed.โ
And Smoke mumbled his assent with his teeth against the nape of your neck.