Do you have a favorite tag? One that everytime you see it listed, you have to click and give that fic a try! If so, what are your fav Hazbin fics for that tag?
This is my favorite ask I've received thus far; thanks for that!! I had to put some thought into what tags I keep going back to, since I so often have hankerings for different types of things.
While it doesn't have this particular tag, Haven’t been the same since I expired by kitsunesongs (Rated M, ongoing, last updated Literally Today, eventual Alastor/Lucifer/Lilith, 65k words and counting) is a fantastic example of my favorite aspects of this trope! In this fic, Alastor is sent back to when he'd first entered Hell, and he decides to make a different name for himself this time. Not because he wants to be good or anything - no, he just missed being able to show up at a party or a live band without everyone fleeing at the sight of him. So he becomes Charlie's nanny instead, and receives the admiration of both Lucifer and Lilith in the process.
Star-Crossed by floatycat (Rated M, completed, RadioApple, 79k words) is a beautiful timeloop romance! Such a treat for fans of the trope - very sweet, and with a great sexuality exploration on Alastor's part and some platonic RadioDust!
Tempus Mutat Omnia by Snapeaholic98 (Rated E, ongoing but almost completed, RadioApple, 90k words so far) is a spicier take on "what if Alastor and Lucifer were stuck in a timeloop together", always brilliant on the reread!
Gay Chicken (or "Relationship Chicken", as I call it, in circumstances where it's just a matter of combatively escalating affection without really bringing "no homo" into it)
Self-promo time, because this is one of those situations where I wrote the fic I wanted to see in the world: Unaffected by CursedCatJoules (Rated E, oneshot, RadioApple) involves a bet about which of them would be less "affected" by sexual situations (where Alastor is simply not inclined towards being turned on, while Lucifer considers himself experienced enough to have a handle on his libido - notably, both are also hubristic little shits).
A Game We Didn't Know We Played by MothballMilkshake (Rated E, oneshot but BE WARNED you may then get the hankering to read her entire completed 557k epic "Stolen Moments" afterwards since this serves as kind of a prequel, RadioApple), while not having the tag itself, encapsulates the vibe perfectly! This features Alastor and Lucifer accidentally challenging each other to a hookup, then stubbornly going through with it. You'd think this would've inspired my fic, but I actually hadn't read it before writing it!
Freaky Friday by titanic_trash (Rated E, oneshot, RadioApple) involves a temporary body swap scenario where they hook up and Alastor gets to take his own virginity!
More self-promo: The Freakiest Friday by CursedCatJoules (Rated E, ongoing, hasn't been updated in a hot minute but I SWEAR I'M SO CLOSE TO FINISHING CHAPTER 4, multiship feat. AppleDust, Chaggie, and solo Alastor) involves a temporary genital-only bodyswap situation for the entire hotel, plus the Vees! Very cracky, and there's plenty of smut to go with it!
I recently recommended this already, but Rewind by JadeTigress (incomplete, last updated in 2020, Rated M but no sexual content and just some canon-typical blood, RadioDust) has the most intriguing amnesia plotline I've ever seen, and even if it's incomplete, I would highly recommend giving it a read! This features a Pilot!Alastor who gets amnesia, can't remember anything from his time in Hell whatsoever, and just...doesn't tell anyone. It's the most realistic character decision I've ever seen for him; he literally just yes-ands everyone else's reactions to him, and coasts through every social interaction that way, it's hilarious!
A recent favorite: same old song and dance by marsh5000 (Rated M, Ongoing, RadioStatic) involves Vox losing his memory of everything since dying, and the Vees helping him out. Meanwhile, Alastor is delightfully perplexed-yet-scheming as he gets to know this new-old Vox. I love how this fic gets me to question whether Alastor would take this particular opportunity if it were offered, the possibility of starting over with Vox.
Say It by sanguinolency (Rated T, complete, RadioApple) is SOOOOO sweet!!! It features a RadioApple in which Lucifer thinks Alastor is his husband after getting temporary amnesia, and Alastor is so perplexed that he just kinda rolls with it for a bit. It is AMAZING.
...And finally, anyone who knows me from the Hazbin Discord servers will know that I am a FIEND for the Somnophilia tag. Blanket CW for noncon here, or at MOST very very dubious consent; while there are plenty of lovely fics out there that feature consensual somnophilia between established partners who have given consent ahead of time, these particular recommendations are notably...Not That.
Selfless Sin by Fluffyboots (Rated E, Oneshot, RadioBelle) honestly makes for a fascinating character study of Charlie while also being hot as hell, pun intended. She is the perpetrator in this case, and it dives into every rationalization her mind conjures up for why it's okay that she's doing this, it's fine actually for her to take this juuuuuuust one step farther, and the result is a delightfully depraved fic that highlights the way Charlie could justify damn near anything she wants to herself (and this is coming from someone who is NOT on the Charlie Morningstar Hate Train, just someone who finds the character fascinating for better and worse).
Naughty Night by Anonymous (Rated E, Ongoing Multichapter, RadioApple) is highly self-indulgent on the author's part, and I love every update. Lucifer is the perpetrator, Alastor is the recipient/victim, and the details are very much A Thing. There might be some plot sneaking its way into the PWP, but I have no idea, and I'm strapped in for the long haul either way!