I know you have not departed yet, but I wished to write something for you for when you are at last away. Tomorrow could not come any slower; I dread the rising of the sun, the opening of your eyes, though I long to look into them all the same. I know you are loyal to the Lord of Waters and his cause, just as I am to mine, and yet still I wish there could be a world where they do not shackle us to a fate where we must be apart.
I wish you would stay with me, Volwë. Though you sleep here peacefully, I know you will be away soon, and already I mourn for the days I must spend away from your company. How have you managed to capture my heart so utterly? Each moment you are not beside me is like a thousand years of torment, and each moment there is a piece of me missing; I am incomplete without you. If only we may be together, not relegated to these fleeting moments of intimacy.
I am in love with the way you laugh, the jokes you make, unfunny as they are. I am in love with your love for that fish of yours, and your passion for all the useless things in Arda. I am in love with your beauty, your kindness, your patience. I am even in love with how you snore, your tacky sense of fashion, even your love for stale breads and poor quality cheeses. Each time we meet again I fall in love with you all over again. I wish I did not have to mourn you when you are away, but at least the time spent apart makes me love you more.
I hope this will not have to be forever. I hope that one day, both our duties will be fulfilled, and then we can finally build the life we want. You said when we were younger that you wanted a cabin by the shores, away from the crown and away from your responsibilities. I hope we can have that.
There is so much more I can speak of, but I do not want to risk you waking up and seeing your arms empty. I hope that in hard times, my words may at least keep you company. I love you, Volwë.
Volwë read the letter many times in the days that followed. Though he was traveling across land unsettled and unexplored, and wished to keep the precious words safe for many long years yet, he kept risking them by drawing them out of the document wraps in his saddle bag and reading again. His fingers even traced some of the words (my dear sea jewel), a great sin to preservers of documents, for it left the oils of the skin and the grime of travel on the page where over time they would decay.
He couldn’t stop himself. He reread the letter by flickering firelight and in dappled afternoon sun, in the halls of Menegroth and in a farmer’s cottage in the Falas, and every time was like a new revelation.
It was in Eglarest some weeks later that he finally had the time and ink to respond.
You succeeded; I only found your letter the first night of my journey toward Arossiach, when I was making camp. I read it while I drank the wine you insisted I take, wearing the pendant you insisted I take, after brushing and feeding the horse you insisted I take. If I were half as generous with forgiveness as you are with your wealth, we would not have fought at the Mereth Aderthad at all. But then, we may have had no need to make up, and what a dark thought that is! I will write no more of such terrible things.
I remember waking the morning after you wrote to me and finding my arms were not empty at all. You had returned to them without my knowledge, just as you said in your letter, and I recall thinking that you seemed to glow in the early rays of sunlight, as if with the inner fire of the Noldor. I wished never to let go of you, but knew in the same breath I must.
It is impossible to know how this happened. We did not love each other in Valinor, did we? There we were selfish and playful youths, heedless of danger, for it hardly existed. I must believe, too, that you did not yet love me during the Darkening. Was it the fight? One day I found you brilliant and arrogant, and the next I found the arrogance endearing and the brilliance as necessary to me as air and water.
Our fates may lead us apart, but I hope that you will always take a moment to think of me at dusk, when the sun completes its arduous journey across the sky and returns to the embrace of the sea.
p.s. You snore, too. Perhaps no one has been brave enough to tell you (though with six brothers and an ex-wife who hates you, I doubt that). I don’t want to hear a word about my snoring until you stop shaking everything in the room all night.