That Summer Story
CHAPTER ONE: SUMMER HOUSE
an episode-by-episode rewrite fic of the summer i turned pretty feat. conklin!reader
summary: Back at Cousins Beach for the last summer before college, everything should feel familiarâthe same traditions, the same faces, the same rhythm of days. So why is your sweet little sister suddenly turning into a heartbreaker? Your brotherâs chaos is somehow becoming your problem too, and the two childhood friends you thought you could read like an open book feel strangely⌠off. Maybe this summer isnât about keeping things the same. Maybe itâs about how the place you swore would never change ends up changing you.
pairing: Conrad Fisher x Reader, Jeremiah Fisher x Reader (slow burn, childhood frenemies to lovers)
warnings: swearing, written in first person, no ây/nâ so far, otherwise none ;)
word count: Â 8.4K
| next chapter
a/n: reader is belly's & steven's older sister, episode could be split into multiple chapters bc those are long-ish
The coast was always a peculiar place to me. I wouldnât say I could relate to those people who went all in on seashell dĂŠcor and âlifeâs a beachâ slogans, not in the slightest. And yet, even though I never serenaded the place the way my sister did, every time Iâd been away from the shore for too long, I started to miss it. The longing came and went like a tide, but it gnawed at me nonetheless.
Iâd find myself staring out the classroom window, imagining waves crashing against the sand. Or on my walk home, Iâd picture the scent of beachgrass we used to dash past on our way to see who could fling themselves into the water first. Somehow, somewhere, Iâd been tethered to that place, and I wasnât sure it would ever let me go. Which, honestly, made sense. Weâd been coming here every summer for as long as I could remember.
So now, on our way to Susannahâs beach house, I rolled down the window and, not going to lie, I felt⌠elated.
The weather is perfect, which meaâ
âUh, can you guys turn it down a little, please?â mom asked, massaging her temples and yanking me out of my thoughts.
âGladly, Laurel,â Steven grumbled, turning the volume down. He only ever used momâs first name when he was siding with her. I think it made him feel as official and commanding as she usually was. Which was hilarious, because, well, Steven.
He shot a look at Belly in the backseat. She promptly stuck her tongue out at him and kept singing along to the radio, just a tad quieter. Steven groaned.
âOh, real classy. What are you, ten?â he muttered.
âThat makes you eleven, dumbo,â Belly fired back without missing a beat.
âAs the lawful twelve-year-old, I say both of youâquiet,â I sighed, pretending to be annoyed. Truthfully, our bickering always cracked me up.
âUgh, whatever.â Steven crossed his arms and stared out the window. âTechnically, youâre not older by a year yet.â I had a hunch he was extra sulky because mom had let me drive us this morning. And heâd been moodier these last few months whenever the four of us hung out. I figured it had to do with him missing dad after the divorce.
Despite all his teasing about me being dadâs âfavorite,â which wasnât even true, Steven always lit up when dad took his side. And that happened pretty often to be fair. But I couldnât blame dad for it, whenever mom, Belly, and I ganged up on the two of them, nine times out of ten we came out on top, naturally.
Soon he wouldnât have to worry about being the lone guy in a sea of girls anymore. After all, the one thing as guaranteed as sand in your shoes and salty air in your lungs at Cousins beach house was the boys. Susannahâs sons. Our childhood crew would be back together soon.
The fuel light blinked on the console.
âWeâre gonna have to stop for gas,â I told everyone. Bellyâs face fell for half a second.
âNo pouting! You and mom can grab some snacks while I fill the tank,â I winked. That perked her right up. She was so desperate to get to the beach house already it was practically tattooed across her forehead. Honestly, Iâd half-expected her to be waiting in the driveway with her bags packed the moment I pulled in this morning.
Iâd taken a quick trip to the store for some essentials earlier today. When I pulled back into the driveway, Steven was already standing on the porch, ready to cram our summer luggage into the trunk of the dingy Honda Civic.
âJesus Christ, mom, I know youâre a writer but are you bringing a library with you or something?â he groaned, nearly herniating himself with her suitcase. Mom just laughed.
âItâs only a couple of extra outfits for special occasions, Steven, you'll be fine.â
âRight, Steve-o, what happened to all that muscle? Pretty sure I saw you flexing in the bathroom mirror this morning, Mr. Universe.â
âShut up,â he muttered, shoving me aside.
âOh my god, were you actually kissing your biceps? Be honest.â
He gave me a flat look. âAre you spying on me now? Gross, sis.â
âEw, not like that. You just take forever in the shower. I needed to comb my hair.â
He smirked. âWhat hair? This haystack?â He spun around and mashed my head like I was a stress ball.
âSteven!â I shrieked, batting his hand away. My hair was already a cursed in-between texture, just a mess waiting to happen. Humidity made it look like those characters whose science experiment went wrong and exploded in their face.
âDonât worry, sis,â he said with mock sincerity. âSome guys are into⌠whatever that is.â
âYeah? And some girls are into trolls, so I guess youâll be fine too.â
âKids, please,â mom sighed. âBug, can you check on Bean? Weâre leaving in ten minutes and sheâs still up there with Taylor,â she added, her brows knitting together. Lately, even with things she looked forward to, mom carried a quiet weight. When she laughed with us, it wasnât entirely free, it felt like a student forcing themselves to enjoy a party the night before finals. I guess the divorce with Dad had left its mark even on such a strong woman. That familiar pang hit my chest. I swallowed it down. At least she was in a good mood, she was calling me her Bug again.
Actually, I knew for a fact that she was glad we were taking this trip. Summer always seemed to bring out a different side of her. Around Susannah, she could breathe again, as if the years of stress slipped off her shoulders, if only for a little while, and I loved seeing her like that.
Nodding, IÂ bolted into the house and upstairs to the room Belly and I shared. I could hear her giggles all the way from the first floor. Taylor had come earlier to help Belly pack, which was perfect. As much as I adored her, the boundless excitement often left her easily distracted and us, in turn, constantly late. Taylor balanced her out.
We had been friends since we were little girls. It was a combination that justâŚworked. Belle with her constant curiosity and infectious positivity, Taylor with her no-nonsense, ride-or-die confidence, and meâŚwell, I guess I brought something into the mix too. Being two years older never mattered. Age doesnât matter between friendsâwhat mattered was sisterhood, and Taylor had always felt like that. Like family.
ââŚYou want his tongue in your mouth, you dirty little slŐ˝t,â Taylorâs voice rang out as I pushed open the door.
âHow scandalousâŚâ I said monotonously theatrical, and smirked at Belly as I entered.
âShut up, Taylor,â Belly rolled her eyes, a bashful smile tugging at her lips.
âMom told me to come get you. My stuffâs already in the trunk, and Steve-oâs pissed she picked me to drive us today. Weâre leaving in ten, and your suitcase is stillââ I looked at it pathetically lying on the floor, underwear and swimsuits spilling out between bright t-shirts. ââa total work in progress. Come on.â
I moved to the wardrobe and started folding the shorts I knew Belly loved, setting them aside.
âWait, youâre coming too?â Taylor glanced at me, holding a bright pink dress that was definitely hers and that she was definitely going to put in Bellyâs bag. âWhat happened to your plans to stay here for the summer and work? I thought weâd finally have some time to hang out here.â Her frustration was clear. I looked down, a little guilty.
âI know, I⌠I really thought so too, Tay. But momâdonât ask me whyâshe really insisted I come this time.â
âTrue,â Belly chimed in while tucking in her toiletries. âShe even guilt-tripped her about last summer when she skipped Cousins to work at dadâs school and then the fact that sheâs leaving for college, now that..that was the final blow.â
âSorry,â I mouthed to Taylor. She sighed and shrugged. I could see she wasnât angryâjust a little disappointed.
âHave you seen my striped sweater?â Belly asked suddenly. I shook my head. She darted out of the room, calling for mom in search of it. I stayed behind, folding the rest of her clothes into neat little squares so her bag would actually close.
Taylor flopped onto the bed, kicking her feet. âSo,â she said slowly, âHow about you? Any lucky person putting their tongue in your mouth this summer?â
I grimaced. âPlease donât say it like that. It makes me want to throw up my breakfast.â
She snorted. âWhat, youâd prefer âsharing a magical first kiss under the fireworksâ? Youâre such a buzzkill.â
âBetter a buzzkill than gagging at the thought,â I muttered, tucking another T-shirt into place.Â
Taylor tilted her head, studying me in that way that always felt like she was peeling me open, layer by layer. âYou can roll your eyes all you want, but youâre not fooling me. You care. You just wonât admit it.â
I looked up at her, deadpan. âNo. I donât care. Crushes are like⌠the flu. Everyone catches it, everyone acts miserable, and eventually it goes away. Iâd rather not.â
That made her laugh. âGod, you sound like a grandma. Youâre seventeen, not seventy. Donât you ever want to⌠I donât know, try? Câmon, when is the eldest Conklin gonna get to first base?â She wiggled her eyebrows, eyes brimming with mischief, and grabbed something from the clothes pile on the bed, tossing a red piece at my face. I caught it and realized it was a bikini top.
âDunno. I donât think I even want to,â I said. âAnd I doubt Iâll have time for that anyway. Iâll probably sign up for some part-time job at Cousins and help around the house like usual. You know how it is with that lot. And itâs the last summer before college, soâŚâ
Taylor rolled onto her stomach, chin propped on her hands, eyes sparkling like she had me cornered. âBull. Youâre sooo full of it. You act like youâre above it all, but you just donât put yourself out there. Youâve been busy being a good student, a good daughter, a good sister for so long you donât even let yourself be a little stupid. Or just⌠yourself.â
Before I could think of a comeback, she sat up and rummaged through her tote, pulling out a bottle. She held it out to me. âStep one. You always complain about your hair, right? Thisâll help. Self-care doesnât bite. And I did ask Lucinda for the best possible option for your hair type.â
I blinked at her, and a reluctant smile twitched at the corner of my mouth. âAre you seriously product-pitching a conditioner to me right now, Tay?â
âIf thatâs what it takes. Come on, you deserve more than folding everyone elseâs T-shirts and doing the summer reading, you always are stuck doing that. But this summerâŚwhy not change it up? You said it yourself, youâre off to college soon. Maybe a hookup or two? Who cares! You justâŚYou donât let yourself enjoy things.â
She grabbed the bikini top sheâd thrown at me earlier out of my hand and held it up in front of my torso. I recoiled instantly. âAbsolutely not.â
âExactly,â she said, catching my hesitation. âThatâs why. How will you know if it feels right? How will anyone notice the real you if you donât try finding her? How will you even figure out what you like if you never take a chance? It's about damn time you ditch those sport swimsuits Laurel got you when you were fourteen.â
I sighed, feeling the corners of my resistance soften. It wasnât that I suddenly realised I wanted to go on dates and have makeout sessions, but Taylorâs face was so earnest, so stubborn. A giggle slipped out before I could stop it.
âFine,â I said, groaning. âIâll⌠try.â
Taylor squealed and threw her arms around me. âSee? I knew there was hope. My grumpy little cynic is finally cracking.â
I groaned into her shoulder. âYouâre insane.â
âObviously.â
âLove you, Taytay,â I muttered, mushing my face against her shoulder.
âDuh, Iâm the best.â Her laugh was soft and affectionate. She cooed obnoxiously, pinching my cheek and pulling back. âFor the eldest of the bunch, youâre such a baby.â
I laughed, nudging her. âDonât tell the others.â
She smiled âPromise.â
âPromise me youâll all be better about helping out this summer,â mom said from the backseat, her voice the kind that didnât need to rise above conversation to make everyone sit straighter. âI know since Bugâs here this time it wonât be as bad as last year, but still⌠donât just dump your dishes in the sinkâuse the dishwasher. And no leaving candy wrappers or wet towels lying around. And not just your own, Steven.â
Beside me, Steven threw up his hands like heâd just been accused of grand larceny. âWhat? But Iââ
âI want you to be good houseguests,â mom cut in, calm as ever.
Steven slumped back with a groan. âMom, Susannahâs rich. Like, maids-and-butlers-rich. Donât they handle that stuff?â His voice tilted smug.
I smacked his knee before mom could. "You sound like a spoiled brat.â
âOw!â He winced, clutching his leg like Iâd broken bone. âTraitor.â
In the rearview, I caught Bellyâs mouth twitching, the corners curling despite her best effort. We all knew how mom got about money. The fact that Susannah had it in spades and we didnât sit heavy with her, especially when we were staying over.
âJust⌠be considerate. Act like I raised you right,â mom said, her sigh filling the car. âSteven, that means donât stay out too late.â
Stevenâs head thunked dramatically against the seat. âWhy am I the only one getting roasted?! Iâm too old for a curfew!â
âWait, what about me?â Belly perked up, eyes suddenly shining. âI donât get a curfew either, right?â
Mom shot her a look in the mirror that translated to donât push your luck.
âWhat do you need a curfew for? You donât go anywhere,â Steven said, grinning wide. âSave mom the trouble.â
âDonât be a jackass,â I muttered, giving him a side-eye.
âWhat?â He spread his hands in mock innocence. âAnd what about you, Miss Honors Classes? Oh right, you donât even need a curfew. Too busy being b-o-o-o-o-o-o-o-ring.â He stretched the word boring until it practically squeaked.
Mom pinched the bridge of her nose. âEnough. And Bellyâweâll talk if something comes up.â
Belly crossed her arms, sulking for exactly two seconds before leaning between the seats toward Steven, her voice syrupy sweet. âOh, and donât forgetâyou promised youâd take me driving.â
âI told you Iâd take you,â I reminded her, drumming my fingers on the steering wheel.
âYeah, but youâre too⌠bossy.â
I gasped, mockingly offended. âExcuse me? Are yall hearing this?! The audacity!â
She tried to keep a straight face, but her mouth betrayed her, twitching upward. Even mom was biting back a laugh.
Steven leaned in like he was sharing government secrets. âSheâs not wrong.â
âBoth of you can walk the rest of the way to Cousins. I donât care.â I said flatly. The grin tugging at my lips didnât help my case.
I swung into the gas station on the edge of town. Mom and Belly hopped out for snacks while I filled the tank. Steven leaned against the hood, arms crossed, eyebrows drawn into that same tight pinch mom wore when she was annoyed.
I knew exactly what that was about. Heâd gotten his license a couple months back, and every mile I drove was one less he could brag about later.
âHere.â I tossed the keys. He caught them clumsily, fumbling and staring at me like Iâd just offered him a kidney.
âItâs yours for the last stretch,â I said, popping my back with a fake wince. âI could use a break.â I wasnât tired.
His face lit up, pure sunshine. âOh, sweet!â Worth it.
Belly came barreling out of the store, arms full of chips and candy. âShotgun!â she shrieked, nearly colliding with the passenger door.
I helped mom with a box of sodas before slipping into the back. Letting Steven drive meant one thing for sure: summer had officially begun.
âAnd FYI, mom,â Belly said, chin tilted high, âIâm not a little kid anymore. Itâs not this huge perk to pick out what kind of pie we get.â Ah, so whatever theyâve been talking about at the gas stationâmom had used the pie flavor card. I smiled into my hand.
Mom glanced past her sunglasses. âSteven, what kind of pie do you want for the first night's dinner?â
âStrawberry rhubarb,â he said instantly, smug like heâd been waiting for the question. I tried to swallow my chuckle and it came out a little choked.
âYou dick,â Belly groaned. âYou know I hate rhubarb! Please can we get blueberry? Itâs Susannahâs favorite too.â
I hated rhubarb as well, but when it came to Steven or Belly, I never bothered protesting. Theyâd just double down out of spite. And I could live with whatever pie there was.
âBug?â Mom suddenly asked, nudging my knee. âWhat about you?â
âLemon? But I'm fine with any,â I said without thinking or even looking their way.
Steven made a gagging noise. âBitter, just like someone I know~â he said, meeting my eyes in the rearview mirror, I flipped him off.
Mom hid a smile, then said, âIf you come with me to Whale of a Tale, youâll be the one who gets to decide. Otherwise, strawberry rhubarb it is.â So thatâs what this was aboutâthe book signing at the downtown bookstore. Susannah had convinced Mom she should do one for her new release.
I hadnât read this one. The first of momâs books I refused to touch. The copy she left for us at home still lay on my desk, unopened, its spine uncracked, the pages as crisp as the day theyâd been printed. I couldnât bring myself to lift the cover. Couldnât even glance at the blurb on the back. Knowing what it was about from the snippets she shared before the release was enough. More than enough.
âFine. Iâll come,â Belly huffed, as if she were doing us all some great favor. She pulled down the visor and slicked on lip balm, yanking her hair loose, then pausing with it around her shoulders like she couldnât decide whether to tie it back up or leave it. If it were me I wouldnât do all those things, wouldnât hair stick to the lip balm if the windowâs open and itâs all windy?
I leaned my head against the glass, watching the big rocks lining the shore, then stores and cafes of Cousins blur past. Before I knew it, we were parking in front of the house. Belly reached out and honked twice. I winced. I really disliked sharp loud noises but this is how itâs supposed to go, the ritual, our signal for the boys to come out and help with the bags.
Susannah was the first to come into view, gliding down the porch steps like a swan, or a water lily, I couldnât decide. Something gentle, mesmerising and eye-catching. She was all soft linen and pale cashmere, hair sunlit from expensive highlights. When I was little, I thought she was the closest thing to a princess Iâd ever meet. Now I was older, and I knew betterâbut somehow, she still carried that glow. If âsecond momâ was a real title, she had it. And she never let me forget she thought of me and Belly as her daughters, too.
Her face lit up as soon as Steven parked the car and mom stepped out.
âSteve-o!â Jeremiahâs voice rang out like a stadium announcer. He was already bounding down the steps, broad shoulders and sunburned cheeks, blond curls practically shining. He moved through the world like an untrained puppy, too fast, overenthusiastic but impossible not to like. I guess this is what people would call a golden retriever guy, but to me, he was more of a cocker spaniel, with his expressive eyes and floppy hair. Always so loud, so full of himself, yet somehow endearing. You couldnât help but notice him, even when he wasnât actively trying.
He bolted past Susannah and hugged mom so hard she laughed breathlessly, then pounded Steven on the back like they were frat brothers instead of high schoolers. He had this⌠energy that made you either roll your eyes or smile. I usually did both, trying to remind myself that he was harmless, though a little exhausting. Honestly, part of me secretly admired that he could fill a space so completely.
I stayed in the car, gathering napkins and soda cans from the floorboards. Someone had to make sure our car didnât look like a dumpster if Susannah peeked inside. By the time I looked up, Belly had slipped out. Jeremiahâs eyes landed on her and widened, just for a beat. The dumbstruck kind of look boys get when they look at a girl. He blinked it away, but not fast enough.
âLook who came back all grown up!â he crowed, scooping her up and spinning.
Belly squealed, swatting at his shoulder. âPut me down, Jere!â He only did so after what seemed like five full spins.
I watched all of it from the car, suppressing a laugh. It was ridiculous and chaotic. A little much sometimes, but he made everything feel brighter, even if just for a moment. Often I couldnât comprehend how the constant presence of someone like Jere could be handled by a person as calm and grounded as his brother.
And there he was. Conrad. Heâd just turned eighteen a few weeks ago, and it showed. Taller, broader. God, had he always been this tall? His hair was shorter around the ears, still messy but neater than before. His specs werenât perched up on his nose like they usually were. He hugged my mom, offering her one of those shy half-smiles she adored. Conradâs smiles always felt like rare wins, like catching a lightbug. But they were teasing as well. Even when his face was straight, I swore there was always the ghost of a smirk lingering, ready to appear.
Jeremiah was the oppositeâquick to grin, cheeks flushed, heart right there on his sleeve.
I lingered in the car, pretending to check my phone. The air outside was thick with salt, as if the tide had crept right up to the yard. The house looked exactly the same: white trim, grayish siding, steady against the dunes. It waited. Always waiting.
Conrad walked up to Belly, and I didnât need to see her face to know her eyes were sparkling. All he said was that he liked her better with glasses, and I could practically hear her heartbeat announcing itself to the entire block. I let out a breath that came out half a laugh. My sister, the hopeless romantic.
Alright. Time to quit stalling. I was already here after all.
âBreathe out. It's gonna be okay. Nothing has changed.â My inner voice told me.
I shouldered my bag and finally climbed out. For a second, neither boy noticed me. Then they did.
Conradâs eyes flicked over, quick. A double take, though I doubted that could be true. His hand, halfway to patting Bellyâs head, froze in the air. He dropped it, then lifted it again, giving her a distracted friendly nudge instead. His face lookedânot blank, not casualâbut like something had caught him off guard. But as soon as it appeared it went away.
âYouâŚare here,â he muttered, more to himself than to anyone else. I wanted to say âduhâ because wellâŚduh. âMom said you werenât coming this time.â
âWish she was rightâ I wanted to say on instinct, but for some reason didn't. Would that be too mean? But weren't we friends? Friends can be jokingly mean with each other. Or was I overthinking it?
Waving a limp hand, mouth tugging into a crooked smile, all I said was a lame âHey.â
Conrad blinked rapidly. Iâd always liked when he did that, it made him look both confused and focused on processing something. And almost boyish. âHi.â He exhaled, and the corners of his mouth lifted as he stepped toward me. Then, in true Conrad fashion, he ruffled my hair like I was a pet.
âQuit it!â I swatted his hands away, huffing. He just chuckled.
âThey keep multiplying,â he said under his breath, nodding at my face.
My freckles. Always my freckles.
When we were seven, a boy at the beach tried to rub at my face, convinced I was dirty. When nothing came off, he doubled over laughing, calling me a potato-head because of the freckles, like the âspots on a peelâ. My stomach knotted hot and mean, and before I could think twice, I shoved him straight into his sandcastle. This time, the tears on his cheeks werenât from laughing too hard.
Mom dragged me away then, giving me one of her rare scoldings about pushing kids. My cheeks burned so hot I thought they might never cool. And when I looked back, Conrad was there, standing a little apart, watching, his head tilted like he was trying to figure something out. My face burned even hotter under his gaze. And the strange thing is, I canât even remember the boyâs face anymore. But I remember how hard my cheeks burned.
Now, with a sideways glance at Belly and Steven, he added, âMust be a curse, being the only one to inherit those.â Classic Conrad.
âRight,â I muttered.
Before I could say more, Jeremiah swooped in, wrapping me in a hug that nearly lifted me off the ground.
âNo way. Conklin Prime finally shows her face after skipping a whole summer. I was betting youâd flake again.â Jere pulled back, squinting at me like I was some rare animal. âHold upâdid you get shorter?â
I shoved at his shoulder. âIâve always been this tall, genius. Belleâs the one who hit her growth spurt.â I wriggled free, nose crinkling. âAnd for the record, you smell like a gym sock left in the sun.â Sweaty.
âSame old Teddy,â he laughed loudly and proudly.Â
The way he said it made me feel like I was little again, pulled straight back to that same summer of the âpotatoâ incident.
Weâd been in the kitchen. The whole place smelled like toast. I was perched on one of her stools, legs swinging, cheeks sticky with orange marmalade. The jar was almost scraped clean, spoon clinking as I chased the last bit. Iâve always had a thing for citrus, very bitter and sour thingsâMom liked to say I got it from my dad.
Jeremiah, grass-stained and barefoot, pointed at my mouth and cracked up.
âYou look like Paddington. You are Paddington!â
We had watched the movie that weekend and Susannah made the marmalade from scratch after, for a âthorough experienceâ. The others werenât really impressed but for me it was the best thing Iâd ever tasted back then.
Conrad lifted his head from an encyclopedia on ancient Egypt he had been looking at, squinting at me. Then he nodded, slow and certain. âMore like a teddy.â
Steven, never one to miss his chance, grinned wide and piled on. âYeah, teddy bear. Sticky, hairy, messy, always hungry.â
âHey! Iâm notââ I tried to protest, but it came out muffled through a mouthful of toast.
 That sealed my fate.
Jeremiah started chanting then, âTe-ddy, Te-ddy, Te-ddy!â until little Belly joined in, clapping along like it was the best name sheâd ever heard.
Not even a day passed and it became as official as my real one. We were playing a memory card game on the floor of the patio as mom and Susannah shared an evening glass of white. The sun had started to sink, spilling honey across the water.
âTEDDY!â Jeremiahâs voice rang out first, high and teasing. âYou cheated! I saw youââ
âI did not!â came the indignant reply. âSteven, tell him!â
Bellyâs voice followed, shrill with laughter. âCheater!â
Conrad cut through. âYou all cheat. Every time.â
That sent Steven into a fit of cackling. âThatâs rich.â He had just learned that phrase after hearing it on the TV.Â
Jere shoved him, Steven retaliated and that caused both Belly and Conrad to be shoved as well. They started chasing each other and I stayed, gathering up scattered cards, tugging two out from under my leg with a guilty giggle. Okay⌠fine. I did cheat.
My mom tipped her head toward Susannah, âItâs ridiculous,â I heard her say. âBoth of my daughtersâ...Belly is silly enough of a name and I have to thank John for that one. But Teddyââ she shook her head, almost ruefullyââitâs not even short for anything.â
Susannahâs laugh came soft and bell-bright, the kind that made people nearby want to laugh too. âOh, but it suits her. Donât you think?â
Mom raised her brow, skeptical but amused.
âBecause,â Susannah elaborated, lifting her wineglass, eyes following the other kids as they tore across the shoreline, âSheâs got that kind of heart. Teddy bear heart. Fierce like a bear, but also soft if you really look for it. You canât tell me that isnât her.â Her eyes caught mine then and as if I was doing something I wasn't supposed to, eavesdropping, I glanced away immediately, busying myself with the box from the game.
Mom sipped her wine, lips pressing together as she watched the others, the corners of her mouth tugging into a reluctant smile. âYouâre too sentimental, Beck.â
Susannah tipped her head back, her smile dazzling even in the dying light. âMaybe. But one day theyâll be grown, and these little nicknames will be the pieces we get to keep.â
And though she didnât say it, something in momâs expression softened. She let herself laugh, low and fond. âGod help them if those names stick forever.â
âThey will,â Susannah said. âThatâs the best part.â
From that day on, whenever they came tearing down the beach or storming through the house, it wasnât my real name they called. It was always Teddy. Or some version of it.
Like no matter how much I grew, this house froze me into place.
Froze people into place.
Only, it hadnât.Â
Not Belly or Steven. Not Jeremiah. Not Conrad. And not me, either.
Steven grinned, that wicked little look he always got before causing trouble. âHey, guys. I think itâs time⌠for a Belly flop.â
She yelped, bolting for the house, feet slapping against the hot pavement. She almost made it too, but Conrad snatched her around the waist, hauling her back as she squealed.
âConrad, let me go!â she kicked, laughing and shrieking all at once.
Steven was on her legs in an instant, Jeremiah on her arms. They carried her over to the pool and swung her back and forth like she was a sack of grain.
âOne, two, threeââ Steven counted, and then Belly went flying into the pool with a splash big enough to soak the tiles all around.
When she came up, sputtering and pushing her hair from her face, she yelled, âI hurt my ankle, you creeps! Somebody help me out!â
I walked up to the pool quickly, hovering at the edge, squinting at her. âGood job you guys.â I side eyed them. âHow much does it hurt?â
Belly blinked and mouthed something at me but I couldnât understand.
 âWhat?â
Jeremiahâs grin sharpened.
âOhhh, look who is a little worrywart,â he said, pointing straight at me. âThis calls for a⌠Teddy toss!â
That's when my poor lip reading skills finally caught up and I deciphered that Belly was mouthing: âI'm jokingâ.
Fuck.
âWhat?! No. No, no, no! Absolutely not!â I stepped back fast, but Steven blocked the entrance to the house, his grin evil.
âYou are way too dry,â he declared.
âDonât you dare,â I warned, dropping my duffel bag and extending my hands to put some distance between me and them, like that was going to protect me. If anything I looked like that Jurassic World meme.
Conrad moved toward me then, silent, a shadow cutting across the grass. His mouth twitched like he was fighting a smile.
âConrad,â I said, glaring, âdonât even think about it.â
He only raised a brow, cockily, as if I was challenging him. This motherfucker. And before I could dodge, Jeremiah lunged, catching my arm. I twisted hard, but Conrad caught the other wrist. My heart leapt into my throat as my feet were lifted clear off the ground by Steven.
âGuys, stop! I swear Iâll kill youââ
âOne, twoââ Jeremiah dragged it out, laughing so hard he could barely breathe.
âThree!â
I panicked, hands grabbing at anything to stay out of the water, anything happened to be clutching the front of Conradâs shirt. He let out a muffled half-groanââGet off, you littleââ but he was too late to notice and we both toppled straight into the water.
The pool swallowed us whole.
Cold rush hit me, bubbles bursting past my ears. I tried opening my eyes, the chlorine stung. For one suspended second, the chaos above felt far awayâJeremiahâs cackles, Bellyâs shrieks, Stevenâs muffled tauntsâall dulled under the surface in some incoherent gurgles. Down here it was just the two of us, faces so close I could see the blur of his eyes, the shape of his mouth. His thumb brushed against my side. I hated it instantly, releasing his shirt out of my grip and lurching upward.
Then we broke the surface at the same time, gasping, sputtering, his hair plastered to his forehead. I guess mine didnât look any better.
âYouâre insane,â I choked, pushing wet strands from my face. My voice cracked, too breathless.
He only shook his head, water dripping down his cheeks. âYou dragged me in, remember?â
Before I could respond, he shoved a hand to the top of my head and dunked me under again. I spluttered, surfacing with a gasp. âYou jerk!â I coughed, water dripping down my face. I could hear his chuckle. Conrad had such an endearing laughâfor a guy whoâd always seemed impossibly composed, it sounded almost too goofy and too light.
The laces of my top caught, tangling my arm, and I flailed briefly, struggling to keep afloat without thrashing. Then I felt a hand. Steady. Right at my side. I blinked away the droplets blurring my vision. Suddenly I was too aware of the situation. The way he was close. So close I could feel him breathe, arm holding me up as if instinctively, the sharp, clean scent of some cologne clinging to him.
For a suspended moment, my mind flooded with too many thoughts: since when did he use cologne? How broad his shoulders had become, the curve of his jaw stronger, the way his posture made him seem⌠different. Older. More solid somehow. There was a heat to the awareness, sudden and inconvenient, that this boy I had known since forever had grown into someone I wasn't as entirely familiar with as I used to. His eyes found mine.
This wasn't sensible. This moment suddenly felt like it was dragging. How long were we looking at each other? Why couldnât I tellâŚ
I yanked myself from him, the spell breaking instantly. âLet go,â I snapped. Turning I swam to the edge, getting out of the pool and not looking back.Â
I checked on Belly. Her ankle was fine.
We dragged our feet inside leaving puddles. It was a hot day and Susannah was the best host I had ever seen, so of course she was already pouring each of us a glass of ice cold lemonade. Over the counter my mom was smiling at her, Susannah met her eye.
âI missed you,â Susannah whispered.
âMissed you more,â mom said, and for a second it was like they were the only two people in the house. Like Belly and I were watching something private we werenât supposed to see.
Then Susannah turned, and her face lit up the way it always did when she looked at us. âMy girls!â
Belly was the first to leap up, of course. She practically launched herself into Susannahâs arms, hanging on like a favorite plushie.
âOh, look at you,â Susannah said, tipping Bellyâs chin into the light. âEvery inch of youâjust a beauty. Laur, do you see this? Sheâs taller. Sheâs glowing. Youâve grown into yourself, my special girl.â
Momâs told that story a dozen timesâhow dad was away for work, and when she suddenly went into labor, Susannah ditched Mr. Fisher with the kids and rushed her to the hospital. She stayed through every agonizing minute, the first one to see Belle before anyone else. So yeah, the âspecial girlâ thing was very real.
Belly ducked her head, blushing furiously, but I could tell she liked it, she really liked to be seen.
Then it was my turn.
âDonât think I forgot about you, my darling, I havenât had the chance to marvel at you last summer,â Susannah said, tugging me in. The hug felt close and lingering, the kind that made you wonder who would pull away first. She smelled faintly of gardenias and something I couldnât place, something familiar and yet.
When she pulled back, her hands stayed on my shoulders, holding me where she could really look at me. Susannahâs eyes had always been sharp but kind, disarmingly so, in a way that unsettled me, like she saw what even mom missed. Perhaps those were the âeyes of an artistâ.
âOh,â she said softly, shaking her head in disbelief. âYouâve changed too.â
I tried to deflect, feeling on the spot. âNot really. Just shorter than Belly now.â
Steven spoke up, appearing out of nowhere and leaning against the banister. âYeah, kinda embarrassing for the eldest, huh?â
âShut it, Beanpole,â I said, rolling my eyes, but my cheeks were hot.
Susannah ignored him. She was still studying me like I was some painting sheâd forgotten she owned but now had found in the attic and felt guilty for not hanging up in the living room, or at least near the staircase. âNo, not the same. My girl, when did you grow up on me?â
I didnât have an answer for that. Moreover, something in the way she said that last part sounded almost solemn. And a little shiver rippled inside me. Did I imagine it? She must be really sad that I didn't visit last time.
So I said, half-joking, âSomewhere between applying to colleges and finalsâ.
A flicker in her eyesâconcern, maybeâbut she only smiled wider, squeezing my arms. âPhenomenal. Thatâs what you are. Just phenomenal.â
Belly laughed from beside me. âYou sound like a movie character.â
âI mean every word,â Susannah said, turning between us like she couldnât decide who to praise more. âMy girls. Laur, weâve raised the most beautiful girls in the world.â
Amused by the sudden cheesiness and meeting Bellyâs eyes we chuckled, giving each other a small acknowledging theatrical bow as if we are contestants on Miss Universe.
Momâs mouth twitched, she shook her head. âDonât let it go to their heads.â
But Susannah was already hugging us again, whispering, âItâs going to be a summer youâll never forget.â
Jeremiah strolled into the room then, grin stretching ear to ear. âDid we miss out on the love-fest?â he asked, voice sing-song. Conrad trailed behind him, his long strides almost lazy.
âJust in time,â Susannah said warmly, swooping her arm around Jeremiah to draw him in. âMy handsome boys. Donât they get taller every year, Laur?â
âMom, stop!â Jeremiah laughed, ducking his head like he was twelve again.
âSteven, maybe,â Conrad muttered, smirking under his breath.
Steven shot him a glare, puffing up his chest. âHey, Iâm taller than you now, Fisher. Admit it.â
âMaybe in your dreams,â Conrad fired back.
Susannahâs eyes sparkled as she looked between us. âDonât the girls look different this summer?â she said, nudging Jeremiahâs shoulder, her gaze flicking to Conrad like she was coaxing something out of him. She did this oftenâsetting the boys up to hand out compliments for us, she wanted them to be gentlemen but the set up made it all so performative.
Conradâs eyes landed on Belly first, then skimmed over to me. His mouth twitched. But Jere beat him to it.
âFor real. Did we all agree not to tell me the Conklin sisters were coming back different this summer?âÂ
âDifferent how?â Belly asked quickly, the pink already creeping up her cheeks.
âDifferent pretty,â Jeremiah announced, eyebrows wagging dramatically. He even threw in a wolf whistle for good measure.
Belly bit her lip, regretting she asked.
I crossed my arms. âEw. You need new material.â
âSee, she's still mean,â he said looking at his mom, pointing at me like Iâd just proven his point that complimenting us was a burden. âCanât believe I wasted a whole summer not witnessing this transformation. Not thisâŚâ He dragged out the word like it had a hundred syllables. âOu-ter-world-ly beauty.â
Steven, never one to miss a chance, started humming âIsnât She Lovelyâ in the background, off-key on purpose. Jeremiah snapped his fingers to it like they were doing a lounge act.
âJere Bear,â Susannah warned, though she was laughing. âStop embarrassing my girls.â
Jeremiah clutched his chest dramatically. âBut itâs my calling.â
Susannah ignored him, clapping her hands suddenly like sheâd remembered a secret. Her whole face lit up. âSpeaking of my girlsâI have news.â
I shot Belly a look. She mirrored my confusion instantly, eyes wide.
âYou two wonât be sharing a room this summer,â Susannah announced with a flourish.
Bellyâs face fell. âWhat? Why not?â
âWait, what?â I blinked, sitting up straighter.
âI redid one of the guest rooms,â Susannah said proudly. âMade it all yours, sweetheart.â She looked right at me, her eyes shining like sheâd been holding onto this surprise for months. âIt was about time. Youâre both growing up. Youâll want your own space. Privacy. Even from each other.â
Mom frowned slightly, setting her glass down. âBeck, that wasnât necessaryââ
âYes, it was,â Susannah interrupted, brushing her off with a smile. âTheyâre young women now. Who knows?â She winked between Belly and me. âEven sisters might want to keep a secret or two.â
Belly blushed to her hairline. I swallowed hard, my throat suddenly dry.
âThank you,â I said softly, though my voice came out tighter than I meant it to.
Susannahâs grin widened, triumphant. âEach one was made perfect for you. Wait until you see.â
âBoys,â Mom cut in briskly, clapping once like a coach. âTake the girlsâ bags upstairs.â
Jeremiah lunged first, snagging Bellyâs suitcase and swinging it over his shoulder with a flourish. âPrincess service,â he declared with a wink. âEscort included.â
Belly laughed, trailing after him.
Steven grabbed his own bag, grumbling something about not being anyoneâs bellhop.
I hooked my fingers through my duffel strap before Conrad could even reach for it. âIâve got mine,â I said firmly.
âYou donât have to-,â he started, his voice low, almost careful.
âItâs not that heavy,â I cut him off, sharper than I meant to. He didnât budge. âLet goâ I said again, meeting his eyes.
For a second, he just stood there, hand half-raised, caught between insisting and letting it drop. Those two words. Finally, he lowered it, his mouth pressing into a thin line.
âOkay, Miss Independent,â he muttered under his breath.
I blinked at him, startled, because it almost sounded like an accusation. An insult. âDonât make something out of nothing. I literally just want to do it on my own. Thatâs all.â The words came out too quick, too defensive, and I knew it. Did they sound harsher than I meant them to? Maybe. But I hadnât said anything wrong.
So why did he look at me like that? Like my answer wasnât enough, like I was supposed to follow it up with something else, anything else. His gaze pinned me in place and suddenly I felt like I was on the spot, like I owed him an explanation I couldnât put into words. He was so frustrating.
I turned away, lifting my bag higher on my shoulder. My feet carried me up the stairs before the silence could press down any harder.Behind me, Conrad lingered. Then he sighed, raking a hand through his hair, and followed after.
Downstairs, the house quieted once our footsteps faded overhead. Susannah crossed to the boxes of soda mom bought and she started to load them into the fridge. Her smile was still there, bright as always, âTheyâre growing up too fastâ.
Mom sighed âDonât I know it. Stevenâs practically obsessed with the gym these days, and is constantly texting someone on that phone, which makes me happy he is doing anything other than gaming or cramming. And Belly is doing well as varsity volleyball captain, she also decided to take her french classes more seriously. And, well, you saw her. Sheâs⌠indeed glowing. More herself somehow.â Pride laced her voice, warm and certain.
âAnd Teddy?â Susannah asked gently, turning back toward her friend.
Mom hesitated, surprised. âSheâs fine.â
âFine?â Susannah tilted her head, unconvinced. âThat doesnât sound like you. You usually canât stop talking about your girl.â
A short laugh broke the tension, though it sounded strained. âSheâs just, I donât know, more snappy these days, that's all. In her head. But she always has been.â
âShe seems troubled,â Susannah said, carefully choosing the word.
Mom frowned, shaking her head. âSheâs not troubled. You know Teddy, sheâs the least trouble-inducing out of my herd. Maybe itâs the senior year of high school, you know? Sheâll be off to college in the fall. And you know her, sometimes it takes her a while to fall in step with everyone else.â
âDid she want to come?â Susannahâs voice was soft, but it cut straight through the air. âI believed she didnât, even told my boys she wonât be here this time as well.â
Stiffened, she was caught off guard. âOf course she did.â Then, after a beat, quieter, âShe needed a little push, thatâs all. Teenagers, you know how it is.â
Susannahâs smile dimmed. She set her glass down, folding her hands in front of her. âThereâs a difference between a push and a shove, Laurel.â
Mom bristled, then exhaled through her nose, shoulders sinking. âI didnât force anyone.â
âI know you didnât mean to,â Susannah said, her tone softening, her eyes bright with something close to pleading. âBut kids remember how they feel in a place, not just what they did there. If Teddy walks through that door carrying something heavy, she needs to feel like she can put it down. Here. With us.â
Glancing away, mom stared at the pale spill of sunlight through the curtains.
âI hate when youâre right,â she muttered, though there was the ghost of a smile tugging her lips.
Susannahâs answering giggle was gentle, like the clink of glass in her hand. âThatâs why you keep me around.â There was a small hush after. Then she tilted her head, studying. âAnd college? Has she decided yet?â
Mom waved a hand, as though batting the question aside. âNot exactly. Sheâs circling a few ideas and her grades are great as always, Iâm not worried at all. Thereâs time. Conrad?â
Susannahâs smile softened. âBrown. Heâs thinking Brown.â
Another beat of silence, like dust on an untouched shelf. The unspoken truth passed through both of themâthis was the last summer when all of the kids were still kids.
Susannahâs eyes drifted to the mantle, to the neat line of picture frames standing proudly there. The seashells and sand clumsily glued onto the sides disappeared slowly from the oldest to the newest ones. Each one capturing a different year: tanned faces, missing teeth, sun-bleached hair, arms thrown around each other in lopsided embraces in front of the house on the deck. A record of time stretching over a decade suddenly felt too short.
The photo from the summer before last still carried the haze of childhood. Conrad and Teddy were sixteen then, Steven and Jeremiah fifteen, and Belly fourteen. Jeremiahâs braces flashed bright, his hair slicked down too carefully, he hadnât learned how to take care of his curls yet and didnât care to do so. He was smaller, but his grin was wide enough to fill the frame, his arm slung around Belly. She stood stiffly beside him, all angles and awkwardnessâglasses sliding down her nose, shoulders hunched, braces catching the light. The camera had caught her mid-look, gaze tipped toward Conrad with unguarded admiration.
Next to her, Teddy looked no less reluctant. Her posture slouched, shoulders drawn inward, as though she were trying to disappear from the lens. The summer sun had scorched her cheeks and shoulders that year, leaving them blotched and red, not to mention the bangs that did her no favors. Her shirt hung wrong, too loose, as if borrowed, and the whole of her seemed caught in that in-between stage where nothing fit. But Conradâs arm lay casually across her shoulders, an easy claim that drew her into the picture whether she wanted to be there or not. He grinned at the camera, braces newly gone, cap backwards on his head, one eye squinting shut against the glare of the sun. On his other side, Steven leaned in, mouth half-open mid-sentence, caught looking goofy in his bright anime T-shirt.
Beside it stood the photograph from last summer. Conradâs smile closed-lipped but warm, his arms stretched around them all as though anchoring the group together. He looked broader and his glasses were gone, hair falling into his eyes in careless strands. Steven and Jeremiah stood side by side, braces behind them now too, both throwing up peace signs with exaggerated bravado. And Belly, tucked close at Conradâs side, right in the middle of them all she beamed wide, her hair pulled neatly into two braids.
Mom followed her gaze to the frames. âWell, at least everyoneâs here this year. Weâll get a new one for the collection.â Susannah turned to her and smiled, nodding.
a/n: happy wednesday













