happy valentine’s day! : who knew having a threesome with your two hot neighbors was an option?
18+ toji + shiu x fem reader, threesome, smut, blowjobs, fingering, spitroasting, creampie, cunnilingus, minimal degradation, hurt/comfort, bit of angst, fluff (5k w.c)
you meet your neighbors only an hour after you sign the lease to your brand new shoebox apartment on the edge of town.
toji watches you lug all your belongings out of your car and into the sidewalk, cigarette pinched between his teeth while you huff and puff your way up the rickety staircase, all the way up to the grimy door opposite of his.
you manage to get through the brunt of everything in ample time. no thanks to him, obviously. his best friend is the one to finally offer you a helping hand, smacking toji upside the head after he shoulders past you with a grunt into the comfort of their shared apartment.
“my roommate.” shiu grumbles, gesturing behind him with a sorry look. “you let us know if you need anything, okay?” you nod, thanking him for the help.
you end up seeing more of toji after that, whether you mean to or not.
you learn your neighbor likes to smoke his morning marlboro downstairs, keeping the door to the building propped open with his arm outstretched when he forgets his key. doubles don't have patios, that's just the trade off of splitting rent int he city.
he whistles every time you duck under him on your way to work, staring long enough for you to feel his eyes on you as you settle in your car and turn the ignition.
you hear him through the walls of your apartment more than you do face to face. he’s brash, vulgar. rattling off insults targeted at his roommate when he doesn’t get his way. fist slamming against the table or the wall every time he’s on a phone call or a goal gets announced on tv.
but with you, toji’s quiet.
he doesn’t acknowledge you save for a nod the day you pad downstairs, clad in mismatched pajamas with your arms crossed over your body.
your eyes are puffy. rimmed red like pomegranate kernels from how hard you’ve been crying all day. he doesn’t ask what’s wrong, and to be honest, you can’t even recall what you were upset about that day.
he wordlessly passes you the butt of his cigarette, call it his version of an olive branch. you take it from in between his fingers, sniffles dying down once the smoke seeps into your lungs and the tobacco’s settled into your bloodstream.
you stamp it out under your feet, and for the first time since you’ve gotten here, toji addresses you with something close to a grin.
“wanna do something about it?”
toji to put it very bluntly, fucks like an animal.
“is shiu-” he’s already shaking his head before you can get the question out, bending to get his hands under the backs of your knees so he can pull you up and fasten your legs around his waist.
shiu isn’t home that day. in fact, toji opts to “get your spirits up” in his roommate’s bed just because he can, pistoning into you like a well oiled machine while you try your best to avoid ruining the headboard with how hard you’re grabbing at it.
he knows exactly what he’s doing and how to do it. he’s sloppy with it, teeth bared at the base of your neck like he wants to sink them down to the marrow. like claiming you isn't an option but a necessity.
you go for hours. noon turns to evening, evening turns to night. and soon enough, you’ve gone so many rounds that toji’s shooting blanks.
“fuck, i think i gotta tap out.” he breaths, chest heaving with exertion as he rolls off of you with a hearty groan. you’re both dripping with a mix of sweat and whatever else managed to splash it’s way onto you. but honestly? you’re kind of proud to admit that it doesn’t feel half bad.
toji sends you off with a bottle of water and a pat on the ass, braced against the doorframe with his joggers slug low on his hips. you all but limp your way back to your apartment with your spirits high and your dignity surprisingly still intact.
you sleep so well that night it might as well be a world record. and for the first time in months, toji can say he might have actually had a decent day.
your first taste of your other neighbor comes a week later.
toji does a great job at feigning nonchalance when shiu invites you in, just for the sake of keeping your little rendezvous a secret. you haven't seen him since that night with how busy you've been, and the way he's treating you right now has you seriously reconsidering a part two.
he sits motionless on the opposite end of the couch, eyes glued to the tv with a takeout box balanced in his lap. he's practically ignored you the entire night, only bothering to speak to you when addressed directly.
so much for keeping it pleasant.
shiu looks none the wiser from where he sits between you two, arm thrown over the back of the couch with his body shoulder brushing yours.he's swapped his usual blazer and slacks for something more casual, and you'd honestly be lying if you said it wasn't doing anything to you.
he looks bigger like this. stronger in ways you never quite noticed even with how often you pass each other on the stairwell. he's almost as built as toji is, muscles pressing up from underneath the thin fabric of his tee.
"you smell good, y'know that?" the shorter roommate comments. shiu had been packing the affection on heavy for days now, and, oddly enough, it kind of feels like it's working.
toji, despite his bored expression, is clutching his fork so tight you're afraid he'll bend the utensil. you can't help but think he might be a little jealous of the attention you're getting.
let him be jealous, you think. if he wants to sit there and throw a silent tantrum, then let him. you've never discussed being exclusive in any capacity. what's a little bit of flirting going to cost?
the night drags on. shiu tells you about himself, his job, how he ended up living in this shitthole apartment with his best friend in the first place. toji butts in every once and a while just so you know he's listening, voice low and uninterested.
"he can act his ass off at the poker table, let me tell you." shiu laughs. his strong arm now lies loosely around your shoulders, caging you so close to his body that you feel the heat radiating off of him.
"oh I'm sure he can." you offer casually. the implication hangs heavy in between you and toji. something known, but unspoken. he could act detached and uninterested all he wanted to, that still wouldn’t change what the two of you did last week.
it isn't long before you're standing to grab your things and head home, thanking them both for hosting you. toji lies half asleep on the couch, throwing you a curt nod before you're out the door with shiu following close behind.
"you know you're welcome back anytime, right?" he mumbles, watching you turn the key in the lock and prop your door open. you can smell his cologne from here. that deep, woodsy scent he spritzes onto his neck before he heads out every morning. "always happy to take care of you." he offers.
you're not lost on what shiu's offering, standing right in your doorway with his body pressed against yours and his scent filling every nerve ending in your brain. you think of toji and the way he looked tonight. that far off bravado in his eyes, the way he brushed you off like a fly on the wall. your stomach sours.
you turn to look back at shiu one last time before the night ends. maybe thank him again for being such a gracious host and settle in for the night. but all that comes out instead is a very forward:
"do you want to come in?"
you come to learn pretty quickly that shiu loves pretty things. soft, warm bodies he can stand over and toy with on nights like these. using his charm to break you in and get you all pliant for him before he fucks you good.
he starts with his mouth. deep, sinful strokes of his tongue against yours, and then the soft suction of his lips around your clit. he takes pleasure out of pleasing you, stiffening up in the cagey fabric of his briefs as his tongue sends bolts of electricity down your spine and to your aching core.
"yeah? is this what you've been needing?" he whispers, licking a stripe from just above your mound to below your navel. you nod because he couldn't be more spot on. you craved softness like this every once in a while. being on the receiving end of some of that tenderness felt nice once in a while.
he blows cold air against the wetness just to watch goosebumps prickle up on your body, humming low and alive in his chest like it's the hottest thing he's ever seen.
thick, wide strokes of his tongue over your heat gradually melt into soft, gentle sucks on your clit. you can't quite remember when he laced his hand with yours, the warm weight keeping you grounded while you paint the lower half of his face in slick.
“don’t cum yet,” he says sternly, flicking his tongue back and forth over your hole. you nod despite the stars clouding your vision, hand squeezing his like a vice. you hike your knees up to your chest as he shucks his pants down the rest of the way, keening at the praise you get for catching on so quickly.
don’t cum, not because he doesn’t want to see it happen, but because he wants you to do it on his cock.
he’s gentle as he guides his length into your mouth, whispering soft praises while his thumb strokes over the swell of your cheek, obstructed by the shape of his cock slipping in and out of your throat. shiu wipes the tears from your eyes every time his tip hits that fleshy part at the back of your throat, pressing a kiss your hairline with a promise of "i'll train that out of you, don’t worry.”
he’s a tease through and through when he finally gets you on your back, legs bracketing his hips. he slaps the weight of his dick on your opening before pushing in, basking in the way your face screws up with desire. two hands lock iron-tight around your waist to pull you down onto his cock.
you don’t need to warn shiu before you cum. he already knows, licking his thumb and rubbing quick circles into the swollen bud of your clit. sucking dark marks into the delicate skin of your neck as you convulse around him, feeling him pull out and paint your stomach not long after.
you feel oddly reminiscent of your first ever night with toji, watching shiu send himself on his way after making sure you're all taken care of.
you're beyond conflicted now. the implication of what you just did was beyond serious. fucking two men at the same time was one thing, but roommates? and behind each others' backs at that? the hole you've dug yourself into might be inescapable.
even so, you can't help but wonder what it'd be like to keep them both on the line for a little longer as you drift off to sleep.
"i said make sure she gets home safe, not walk inside and fuck her." toji seethes, no doubt throwing something at the other man judging by the crash you hear through your bedroom wall.
"what's it to you?" shiu laughs, clearly not understanding his roommate's gripe with your little escapade. they bicker for another hour. insults coming hot and heavy as you sit cross legged on your bed in the early morning, listening to them fight over you.
you're paralyzed, hastily rethinking all of your choices up until this point with a careful edge. the men continue to take jabs at each other, literally and figuratively.
you know you’re the root cause of this issue. the common denominator who flew too close to the sun and wanted both to yourself. but who could blame you, really, for being so ambitious?
toji curses a final time before stomping off toward the front door, mumbling obscenities to himself. the brute rips the door to his apartment open and manages to take a few heavy paces before stopping.
right in front of your door.
toji doesn’t knock, or slam his fists against the fragile wood of your front door. he waits. foot tapping against your shabby doormat while you desperately try to brainstorm a way to escape the situation.
“i know you’re home.” he states plainly. you picture him waiting outside in house slippers, hood covering his shabby black hair with his arms over his chest. you’re so fucked.
the front door obviously wasn’t an option at the moment. all things considered, you could try the window if the fall doesn’t kill you.
“c’mon, we just wanna talk to you.” shiu says cautiously, having joined his roommate while you tried to craft an escape plan.
there was no getting out of this, whether you liked it or not. you put on a brave face and take a few deep breaths as you pad over to the front door, revealing yourself to the men waiting in your doorway.
it’s silent for a moment, which doesn’t fare well for your blood pressure. toji gives you a quick once over like he’s still deciding what exactly he’s going to do with you. shiu stands with his clasped behind him, looking between the both of you.
“so you’re double dipping now? that’s it?” toji spits, jealousy brimming at every word.
“we fucked one time.” you whisper harshly, peeking out into the hall to scope for any onlookers, thankfully finding none. “you never said you wanted things to be exclusive.”
“okay, fine, fuck other people, but not behind my back.” he gestures up and down at shiu with a single hand like his roommate isn’t even there, face permanently etched with distaste.
“you know what, let’s all take this inside. okay?” shiu chides, shoving toji forward with a clap to the back. you step aside to let them both in, letting the door shut behind you. “nice place by the way.” he offers, clearly trying to lighten the air.
toji makes a beeline straight for your bedroom, sitting on the edge of your mattress with his heel bouncing against the carpet. you choose the opposite edge, with shiu settling in between the both of you like a buffer.
it’s quiet again, and you wish it would stay like that. no snarky comments, no fighting, just comfortable silence between the three of you.
“you fucked her.” toji speaks up first, addressing his best friend directly. he runs a hand through his fringe like he’s still trying to process the fact.
“how was i supposed to connect the dots when you were acting like you didn’t know her?” shiu grumbles.
toji flips back against the length of your mattress with a pointed sigh. he runs his hands down the length of his face as all the air whooshes out of his chest.
“he has a point.” you offer, tracing shapes into the fabric of your bedsheets. anything to avoid looking at your very frustrated neighbor.
“okay—fuck—i know.” toji sighs into his palms. “i know, i thought it’d be better that way. less drama.”
shiu must be over the whole situation too because he flops onto his back next, hands clasped on his stomach while the both of them look up at your ceiling in contemplation.
“sorry, for, y’know…” toji starts, eyes finally flitting over to meet yours. “being an asshole.”
you take a minute to consider, really consider the gravity of everything’s just happened. and you laugh, because there’s really no way that your neighbors of all people were throwing punches over you only minutes prior.
toji chuckles too, shaking his head from side to side like he’s thinking the exact same thing.
Your other neighbor claps his hands together with finality and sits up, looking at the both of you with a knowing grin.
"so how are we gonna do this?” he questions. "you get her 3 days a week, I get her 4?"
“hold on asshole, why do i only get 3 days with her?” toji scoffs, sitting up from the mattress with a scowl.
“who said i wanna keep having sex with either of you? your question cuts their bickering off at the source,m. both men turn to you with embarrassed expressions.
“right, that’s fair.” shiu accepts your statement with grace. toji, on the other hand, looks quietly devastated.
“if this is going to be a thing,” you pause, carefully choosing your next words. “we should probably all have a say in what happens.” you punctuate the word all as hard as you can.
“like a threesome?” toji asks tensely. the two men share a knowing look, somehow exchanging an entire conversation without even talking. they must come to a consensus because shiu turns to you with a surprisingly calm look, cocking his head to the side with a smile.
shiu leads you up the bed by the hand, letting you settle cross legged in the middle of the mattress while toji clambers forward to join the both of you. both men flank either of your sides now, like sharks circling in on their prey.
toji is the first to make contact, hands encircling your waist to guide you back against the pillows roughly. soft lips trail a path up the curve of your neck, tongue flitting out to taste you like he just can't help himself.
"you want both of us?" he teases, chuckling to himself when you nod in response. "good, you'll get both of us."
toji dives forward to claim your mouth, running his tongue over the seam of your lips. you oblige, opening your mouth ever so slightly to let him taste you, feeling that patch of scarred skin rub against you as he licks into your mouth.
shiu makes quick work of your bottoms from his spot further down the bed. you lift your hips up to aid him, feeling the cool air brush against the wet patch nestled in the center of your panties.
the two men work their magic surprisingly efficiently. toji has your shirt over your head and your bra unclipped in no time, feeling the weight of each of your tits while shiu rucks your panties off your hips and down to your ankles.
"have you two done this before? like, with a third?" you ask breathlessly, squirming when you feel shiu's fingers swipe through the wetness gathered at your core. you toe your panties off clumsily, gasping as he kitten licks over your little bud.
"oh yeah, us in college? forget about it." shiu purrs. "we know what we're doing."
toji jabs his elbow back far enough to clip his roommate in the shoulder, effectively shutting him up.
"can't fuck her if you're talking my ear off the whole time." he grumbles, turning his focus to you with a drawn out breath through his nose. you pull him in for another kiss to calm him down.
shiu hooks both of your legs over his shoulders, letting you write under him. not a single part of your pussy lies untouched now that he's eased a finger inside of you, rubbing up against that special spot you know and love.
your other neighbor breaks away from the kiss only momentarily, squeezing one of your breasts for good measure before he's ridding himself of all his clothes. shiu takes the time to quickly undress too.
"is he going first, or am i?" toji asks it so casually you think he would've just ordered his morning coffee. like he just asked for directions to the bank and not which of the men in front of you was going to have a turn with your pussy before the other.
the two men wait for your answer with their heads cocked. shiu continues to work his fingers inside of you, already working with two at this point. toji stands with his fist encircling his cock, spreading pre up and down his shaft.
you don't know. you have no idea who you want first and it kills you. you could choose shiu and be brought to the precipice of your orgasm for forever if that's what he wanted. feeling the epic highs and lows of being fucked open by his fingers and tongue until you end up begging for it.
or you could choose toji and be taken for the ride of your life. stretched, and bent, and rubbed to his will while his gives you both what you need most at an incredible pace, hips snapping forward with practiced force as his dick hits every single delicious spot your toys always seem to miss.
shiu must catch onto your train of thought, because he chooses for you.
"you first, i want my dick sucked." he reasons, nodding in toji's direction.
"no complaints here." toji laughs, rubbing over the swell of your lips with his thumb so gently it almost surprises you. the taller roommate circles to settle in between your legs, watching shiu piston his fingers into you a few more times while he strokes himself.
"pretty little pussy, look at that." shiu mumbles, spreading you open for the taller man with a thumb hooked on either side of your lips. toji whistles low and quiet, like he almost can't believe what he's seeing.
that sends electricity right to your center and into your limbs. the way they talk about you like you're not even there makes your pussy throb with wanted. you needed both of them, whatever they were willing to give you to the fullest extent.
shiu takes a moment to rub over your clit, taking you completely by surprise.
"oh, she likes that." toji comments, eyes set so low they almost look closed from this angle. shiu brings his bottom lip between his teeth with a huff, no doubt regretting his choice to part with your sopping wet center until after toji's had his fun.
they officially switch spots, with shiu settled at the head of your mattress, and toji situated between your shaky legs. the taller man pushes in with a grunt, shivering at the way you suck him in as soon as your bodies make content.
"oh, fuck." toji gasps. shiu chuckles under his breath at the taller man's reaction.
so fucking tight." toji agrees. you clench harder around the length of him, letting him ease all the way to the hilt before feeling his hands clamp down on your waist pulling you down onto his cock to meet his powerful thrusts.
your moans only spur shiu on, because he's already kneeling with a hand against your headboard, dick in hand.
"c'mon, open." he commands, jaw going slack as you take him in between your lips to the best of your ability.
it's sloppier than expected given the way toji's thrusts jostle your body every time your bodies meet. but shiu only grains, low in his chest, letting his fingers curl around your chin to keep your head in place.
you feel so filthy right now now. spit roasted at both ends by two men you hadn't even known the names of a handful of months ago. you're plugged up in the most delicious way, tasting, and feeling, and hearing absolutely everything they give to you, letting them take what they need while giving it back to you twice as good.
"fuck, i'm gonna cum." toji grumbles, more to himself than anything. "pussy's too wet."
"i bet it is." shiu whispers, eyes meeting yours with a knowing look. you can't help but imagine a world where this is all the three of you do all day as your organs approaches. just fuck, and hump, and lick on each other until you've had your fill, and then do it all again the next day.
"you want it inside, baby?" toji grits out, still thrusting into your heat with unbroken strokes.
you nod the best you can, squeaking out a yes over the girth of shiu's spit-slicked shaft with heavy eyes. shiu only smiles, giving his best friend a thumbs up from behind.
you grab onto whatever you can as you high engulfs you. digging your nails into shiu's biceps, then toji's sweat-slicked abs, desperately seeking purchase from the mind shattering feeling of it all.
toji's orgasm seems to last for ages, filling you from the bottom up until you're sure you'll be leaking for at least then next hour. he pulls out of you with an obscene squelch and a groan, flopping down onto the open space beside your body with one of his hands still skimming your waist.
"fuck, need a minute." he grumbles. that was toji for you, always pushing himself to the brink just to feel those extra few moments of you wrapped around him.
shiu eases out of your mouth to let you recuperate. he leans his body back only a tad to try and get a better look at the mess leaking out of you.
"holy shit." he laughs, eyeing the small puddle of cum gathered atop your sheets. "you're gonna get her pregnant."
toji only chuckles to himself, face pressed into the mattress while his thumb rubs apologetic circles from where it's thrown over your waist.
the three of you take a moment to breathe, chests heaving with exertion. you could cut the tension between all of you with a knife, the brunt of it being the fact that you could very much go again, judging by the heat that ramps up in your core as soon as you think about how good it'll feel to have shiu inside of you.
you give the shorter man a pointed look that says it all. shiu nods, standing to circle the bed just as toji had.
"alright, alright." he jests, lining himself up with your sticky sweet hole. "we're getting there." his dick meets little resistance between the mess of cum still leaking out of you and the slick your pussy offers up.
shiu's able to slide home in no time,fucking his best friend's release into you like it's the most normal thing in the world. your heart jumps at the consideration that this could be a normal thing for the three of you. that being fucked like this could be something you could ask for open and unabashedly.
toji seems to sober up at the sounds of your shared pleasure. he lifts his head groggily with a huff, taking a moment to watch where you and his roommate's bodies meet.
"that's a fucking sight." he whispers, watching in pure awe as shiu fucks into you over and over again. "you enjoying yourself, pretty?"
"s--o mu--ch." you sputter, feeling yourself trip over every syllable as the cock inside of you keeps you held open and pliant. you wouldn't last much longer at this rate. shiu probably won't either judging by his white-knuckled grip on your thighs.
toji finally saunters onto his knees with the grace of a baby deer, legs gone shaky from his orgasm earlier. unsurprisingly enough, he's still rock hard, which you come to find out as soon as he takes himself in his hand and gestures for you to open up.
you obey, and he rewards you handsomely, easing himself onto your palette to let you suck your combined releases off of his dick.
"perfect fucking mouth." he hisses through grit teeth. shiu makes a sound of agreement behind the both of you, still fucking you like he means it.
you hollow your cheeks with a hum just as shiu mumbles something about summing together. you let him rub over the swell of your clit with a whine, still sucking the salty taste off of toji's member.
"c'mon baby, do it." toji whispers. you feel his fingers curl into the hair nestled at the base of your scalp, pulling you further onto his cock with a satisfied groan. "give us one more."
you cum with a noise so desperate you're not even sure where it comes from. every muscle in your lower half seems to contract and relax at the same time, ebbing and flowing like the tide.
shiu doesn't have it in him to last any longer with you gripping him so sweetly. he slides out of you and cums with a string of expletives, letting his spend drip down the apex of your mound and between your lips until it joins the ever growing puddle right beneath your ass.
"holy shit." he groans to himself. "fuck." toji slides out of your pliant mouth with a hum, still cradling your cheek in his palm.
"got what you came here for?" he asks jokingly. the air between the three of you feels so much different than it did when you'd first sat down.
"yeah." you giggle, wiping your mouth clumsily, you look between the two men shyly, "did you?"
"fuck, are you kidding me?" shiu gasps, laying down next to you with a lazy smile. "best fuck of my life."
toji settles down next to you on his forearm, chest still heaving from exertion. he nods, lips curled up in a sly grin.
"so, what, are we just gonna do this every week?" he asks the both of you. shiu looks at you with an inquisitive quirk to his brow, letting you take the reins from here.
"sure, why not?" you offer, reveling in the laugh that gets you from the both of them.
a/n: based on an old oneshot of mine from 2023 that i deleted lol, thank you to everyone who took the time to read all of my valentines day specials ! writing this was so so fun.
vaporwave
titsay
izzy806
areudirty
janainaart
annaxmalina
