Layers of Emotion in Carly Rae Jepsen’s “Your Type”
“Your Type” by Carly Rae Jepsen is the best song on the album Emotion. I will preface this by saying I don’t listen to much pop, but across all music genres, I can’t think of a more gripping song about unrequited love. To start, let us assert that the title of the album, Emotion, is bold. How can Carly summarize or capture something so vast in 15 songs? So, she focuses mostly on love and its different forms. Emotion explores many different shades of love from exciting new crushes (“I Really Like You”), the comfort of a loved one after a long day (“Favorite Color”), fleeting moments of cherished intimacy (“Let’s Get Lost”), to unrequited love (“All That,” “Your Type”). The album explores many relationships and gets gritty with the messiness of love. “Your Type” however, is in my opinion, the emotional summit of Emotion. First, we must consider its placement on the album. The first three songs on the album, “Run Away With Me,” “Emotion,” and “I Really Like You” establish an upbeat, catchy pop standard. Those first three songs are great songs to drive or dance to; Jepsen expertly balances defiance, romance, and rebellion. The next two songs take a turn for the more emotional. “Gimmie Love” is about not receiving the love the speaker feels they need. But where “Gimmie Love” eventually picks up, “All That” stays meditative. In “All That,” the song builds to an emotional climax where Jepsen feels that she’s not “All That.” After painting love as a picture of excitement and happiness, Jepsen details the more intricate interior of intimacy. The next two songs, “Boy Problems” and “Making the Most of the Night” both come on strong as rebellious dance anthems. The beauty of the first seven songs on Emotion is that Jepsen pulls the listener in slightly different directions with each song. Then comes “Your Type,” and she smashes it all down. The force behind the song elevates its message above the previous seven versions of love. “Your Type” feels like finally, this isn’t the team of pop songwriters, but Carly being Carly. And when that happens, she reaches into the depths of unrequited love and pulls out a message of raw, defiant love in 3 and a half minutes.
Now let’s get into the song. It starts the way many Emotion songs do. Jepsen often utilizes simple synths as the base layer of the song and builds the beat around them until she delivers a hook. Verse, chorus, verse, chorus, bridge, chorus, chorus variation, fin. A throbbing synth bass picks up just before Jepsen’s voice delivers the first line from high above. “I used to be in love with you,” sets the tone for the first verse. Right away, we know this will be a song about difficulties of intimacy. Over the next four lines, Jepsen sets the scene of her mangled love; “You used to be the first thing on my mind / I know I’m just a friend to you / but I will never get to call you mine.” Her voice in these opening lines is tender, potentially damaged. This song is a lot about being damaged by love, and still going back for more. It is about hope, it is about resilience. These first lines portray dualities of strength and vulnerability, comfort and loss, and goodwill and lack of intimacy. The second lines states that the object of the song, the “you,” used to be the “first” thing on Jepsen’s mind. This superlative indicates that her affection is in the past. However, the song starts with these thoughts hinting at something on the horizon in the future. Stay with me guys, this is where it gets good. “I know I’m just a friend to you” establishes the imbalance of speaker’s relationship with the object of her love while hinting at her yearning for something more. She reveals that in the next line, “but I will never get to call you mine.” It seems clear she’s yearning for romantic possession of the object of her love.
Jepsen delivers these first four lines in a slow tender voice, as if she were writing them out. The next set of lines comes in a hurry, as if she has set her diary’s pen down and is simply running through the intricacies of her thought as fast as they appear to her mind’s eye. “But I still love you, I’m sorry, I’m sorry, I love you, I didn’t mean to say what I said / I miss you, I mean it, I try not feel it, but I can’t get you out of my head.” With these lines, Jepsen resurrects the unrequited love the opening lines placed in the past. The lines dart around, delivered in a breathless murmur, bordering on panic. Where Jepsen previously let love be one thing in other songs, it is now a melting pot of yearning and commitment. She can’t ignore her feelings, yet she must fight to subdue them. Just as there is an imbalance in the object’s relationship with Jepsen (him wanting friendship: her wanting more), Jepsen has an imbalance within herself (her wanting to respect the object: her unable to get them out of her head). These lines are filled with regret, shame, and most all, yearning. Saying sorry twice in a row indicates that the first time, she is sorry for still being in love, the second sorry indicates she is sorry (potentially to herself) for repressing those feelings. An apology for apologizing. The “I’m sorry’s”’ are sandwiched by two “I love you’s” which is another example of the theme of dualities. On the one hand, she is imagining apologizing for revealing her feelings. In the next line, in which the order of “I love you” and “I’m sorry” is reversed, she is imagining saying that she is sorry but she loves them. As if she won’t hide her feelings. This is the beautiful conflict of “Your Type.” She resurrects her love, dragging it out of the past with all its imperfections. The other important things this second set of lines does is establish that she is trying not to feel her love, as if it is not something she is dragging out of the past, but rather something that she can’t control, like a wave coming to envelop her. The next lines are where the theme of defiance comes into play. “But I want you to miss me / when I’m not around you.” Here she delivers more intentionally, declaring her feelings. The building of the song continues, and the chorus and her tidal wave of emotion on the horizon, swells. The last line before the chorus picks up speed as she declares, “I know that you’re in town, now won’t you come around to the spot that we met.” This line brings the relationship into the present. By saying she wants to meet where they first met, Jepsen ties the love in the present to her affection in the past. By saying “now,” she confirms that she wants the love, experiencing a moment of clarity which opposes her former confliction.
Before getting into the chorus, let us establish that Carly’s strength is in writing hooks. Most lay people know her as the singer of “Call Me Maybe” and “I Really Like You,” songs largely known for their surface level emotional content and catchy hooks. On “Your Type,” she delivers on the hook with full force while maintaining emotional depth. What makes it so effective is another duality. Rather than the convoluted emotions she was digging through in the opening verse, Jepsen digs to the bottom of her love to find truth. She sings that truth with all that she has, and the chorus hits like a brick wall. In a song that was largely stasis for the first verse, the chorus feels like movement. The beat cuts out as she says the final word of the first verse, “met” and a single drum fill descends in pitch before Jepsen plunges into the chorus. It the emotional equivalent of finally jumping off a diving board into the pool of her past love. “I’m not the type of girl for you, / I’m not going to pretend, / I’m the type of girl you’d call more than a friend.” Jepsen’s delivery here is a proclamation, she belts it over the beat. The beat in the first chorus is a drum and snare marching along with the throbbing bass and the riveting synth. At the end of that first line is the declarative “hey!” which seems to state, here I am, bearing my truth, and I don’t always feel proud, but I do have hope. In terms of lyrical analysis, she sings three truths in the first half of the chorus. The first is that she acknowledges she might not be the ideal partner for the person she loves. She is not their type. Next, she declares that she won’t pretend, meaning her intention is not emotionally waffle in the chorus the way she did in the opening verse. The line may also be analyzed with the addition of the following line, “I’m the type of girl you’d call more than friend.” The potential combination of this line is another duality. It could mean that one of the truth she discovers is that she is not a realistic romantic partner because of the imbalance of affection in their relationship. It could also mean that she will not pretend that they wouldn’t be a good couple, precisely because she would not pretend. Instead, she would wear her truth like a badge of honor, as she does in the chorus.
The chorus continues. “And I’d break all the rules for you, / break my heart and start again, / I’m not the type of girl you’d call more than a friend.” As she finishes that last line her voice falls away in sorry acceptance. In what might be the most glaring example of dualities in the song, the first time through the chorus she says that she is the type of girl that would be more than a friend and the second time, the more emotional time around, she claims she is not. This is indicative of her conflict. The idea of the chorus being a pool or a wave continues as Jepsen utilizes the verb “break.” She would break all the rules for her love, implying that the person she loves is the most important aspect of her life. She then claims that she would also break her heart, just for the chance to be with them. The emotion behind this line, the layer of emotion underneath her love, is not quite desperation and more resilience and being true to herself. It would be desperate to hope to convince the object of her love to be with her. Instead, the tone is more about making peace with herself and knowing that she will love despite not receiving love back. This is what breaks her heart, this is how she starts again, picking up the pieces of herself to give love. This is the central theme of the song. Beneath the layer of love and affection, is the layer of what Jepsen must do to access those emotions. Loving this person, while acknowledging that it can’t work, is an act of resilience, hope, and harm all at once.
Before you know it, the chorus ends suddenly, and its echo hangs in the momentary silence. Jepsen starts the second verse by adding a third character. “I bet she acts so perfectly / You probably eat up every word she says.” The introduction of the romantic interest’s romantic interest is not sourly jealous, but more reserved. Jepsen certainly wishes she were perfect in the eye of her love, and she yearns for it, but she does not hate the person in her place. The line in which she describes the other woman is perfect implies that it is not the love interest that sees the third character as perfect, but Jepsen herself; for anyone that can hold the eye of her love (whom she has idealized) must be in some ways perfect. After those two lines, the beat comes back in. The song starts building towards the chorus again. Jepsen croons, “And if you ever think of me, / I bet I’m just a flicker in your head.” She gives herself zero credit with the “if,” as if it’s a possibility that she does not even exist to her love. And even if she does, she is only a “flicker.” A flicker is certainly a small vulnerable thing. The flame of the love’s thought could go out at any time and Jepsen would be forgotten. But it is still fire. It still hints at something larger to come. And every forest fire, and Jepsen’s struggling love, in which everything breaks, is torn down, and subsequently rebuilt in the memory of the past, starts as just a flicker. On the surface layer of the song, there is not much hope, only an unrequited love. But underneath a few layers, Jepsen’s hope lies in the fact that she knows she will not give up on love, even at the cost of the destruction of all the rules and the breaking of her own heart.
From here, the song consists of material from the pre-chorus. Jepsen runs through the “I love you’s” and the “I’m sorry’s” before going into the chorus with the same wrecking ball force as before. The emotional content of this has all been discussed. Its repetition is merely adhering to a form for pop songs which furthers Jepsen’s conflict. However, the chorus doesn’t end suddenly like before. Jepsen continues into a slight variation. The beat stays as radiant as ever as she proclaims, “I’ll! Make! Time for you!” four times. Twice in the forefront of the experience and twice as echo’s in the background with a slight melodic variation. This part is haunting. Jepsen’s delivery verges on raspy, as if she’s been crying. If her verses were sniffles and whimpers, the chorus and the “I’ll make time for you” is a sob and a death rattle. It is her final manifesto, after digging and digging through her emotions. It is the action that her love requires. The delivery of these lines seems to say Here I am, I’m not sorry I love you, I’m sorry you don’t love me, and despite all my confliction before I can synthesize my love into one message, five words: I’ll make time for you. “Your Type” is a song of love despite. Despite the other woman, despite her best instincts, despite the imbalance of affection in the relationship, Jepsen loves. And gives what she considers her most valuable gift, her time. It is a tragic demise of a heroine, true to her emotions, which are her fatal burden in the end.
After all her conviction in delivering “I’ll make time for you” twice, the song quickly dips back into, “I love you, I’m sorry, I’m sorry, I love you, I didn’t mean to say what I said / I miss you, I mean it, I try not feel it, but I can’t get you out of my head.” As this happens, the beat drops out except for a single synth line, tracking just the chord changes. And then the song appears to end, on a moment of conflict. Those lines, placed after her resolute declaration of giving time, indicates the difficulty of her decision. She decides to commit herself to a life of unrequited love. Then after those lines of confusion, the music entirely stops. No matter where you are listening to the song, whether in concert, on the way to work, or a party, those seconds of silence are sacred. To the attentive listener, that momentary quiet makes what comes next all the more holy. She makes her decision, goes back on it, and then uses the silence to represent her making the decision for sure this time. The unrequited love is what she wants if that is the way she can be true to herself. So she sings it with all her power.
She declares this truth with the third chorus and second set of “I’ll make time for you.” She is sure of her decision. This is where the song is the most powerful. After repeating the line four times (with four echoes repeating it back), the song ends suddenly. There is no fade out of the triumphant message. There is no victory parade for the sacrifice she makes. She is only martyr for herself. The song does not say how the recipient of her love even receives if it, if they do at all. It just ends, leaving the traces of the chorus playing in the mind of the listener.
In conclusion, “Your Type” is a song about unrequited love, the layers of emotions that paint it, and the importance of dualities. It is about diving into your soul, and swimming to the bottom of it to drag back up a nugget of truth. Jepsen’s emotional labor is inherent in the craftiness of the lyrics, and the passion in their delivery. There is no happily ever after, either. There is only the truth, underneath layers and layers of emotions, buried in the past. It is unforgivable that the very shallow “I Really Like You” was the single for the album. “Your Type” much more indicative of Jepsen’s power, and the emotional depth of the album. I hope you enjoyed reading this. If you got this far, I’m glad, but your time may have been better spent just listening to the song over and over again. And finally, it’s hard to pick a favorite on Emotion, and I’ve had many favorites since I’ve known it, but “Your Type” sits above the rest, resilient in its unwavering truth.