Nightmares Are Real @interrogatethecreeps - Tumblr Blog

Toby and EJ what’s under your masks :0

“Fuckin’ hell dude, I don’t ever want to see under Jack’s mask again its just gross. Like, I have a rotten out cheek and you can see my teeth, but him? His eyes?? Where the hell did they go??? There’s just like, this black ooze that leaks out of his eyes sockets and he’s also got sharp as hell teeth? The fuck is up with this guy honestly...” Toby explained, trailing off. “I’ve only seen his face once and it freaked even me out.”

#eyeless jack #EJ #ticci toby #creepypasta #creepypasta ask blog #ask creepypastas #asked #Anonymous #ask

Ya'll alive?

"I mean, that's debatable sometimes. But we're here, waiting and fuckin bored." Toby sighed. "We haven't gotten anything in a loooong time."

#ask #ticci toby #creepypasta ask #ask creepypasta #creepypasta #i #ididntaskforyoursympathy #p l s s end asks for toby or jack #I (myth) also take asks for my OCs over on WelcomeToTheDen #asked

imtheoneinpunk

ASK ME THE WEIRDEST MOST CREATIVE QUESTIONS YOU CAN THINK OF

#I bought fangs for my EJ cosplay #I wanna get pics soon but its h a r d #in the mean time PLS SEND ASKS!! I wanna answer some

inboxstuff

Send me a ‘✉’ for a drunk text from my character.

#ask games #EJ or toby! and maybe Break Away if u want

yall who wants an Eyeless Jack cosplay wip- I tried him on quickly w a placeholder black hoodie

#myth posts

Hey Jack, have any of your victims ever escaped?

“I mean, I don’t always kill them. That can get boring honestly.”

“Ever heard the reaction from someone waking up in a tub of ice with ‘CALL 911 OR U WILL DIE’ written on their bathroom mirror? It’s priceless! They’re freaking out because the phone is out of reach!”

“... I should do that more often honestly. But eh, it’s risky.”

#eyeless jack #EJ #creepypasta #creepypasta ask blog #asked #ask #anonymous #Im sO SORRY this didnt show up when I check the ask box on mobile idk why tumblr is a lil bitch #so FINALLY I RESPOND #Anonymous

imtheoneinpunk

ASK ME THE WEIRDEST MOST CREATIVE QUESTIONS YOU CAN THINK OF

#ask box is open #if you sent one and we havent responded tumblr probs ate it #pls send us asks #on a side note I (Myth) am working on putting togther a cosplay of EJ based of Stealth's headcanon for him

Would you rather be stuck on a desert island with each other, or would you rather be stuck on a desert island on your own but with a dog.

"Fuck, dude, I'd rather a dog because at least I can eat the dog and like, it won't steal my kidneys. I wouldn't eat Jack, who the fuck knows what he's made of. He leaks black ooze! Or something. I ain't touchin' that with a ten foot pole."

#ticci toby #eyeless jack #creepypasta #asked #Anonymous #ask

squat in an empty one and kill the owner if he goes there, some of 'em collect mansions like normal people collect serial killer memorabilia

“Yeah but what if- wait, what the fuck? People collect what now?!”

#ticci toby #creepypasta #asked #Anonymous #ask

if you want a mansion, steal one. No one will notice.

“Oh yeah, sure, I’ll just pick up a giant fucking building with my own two goddamn hands.”

“And I’m pretty sure people would notice a mansion missing. They’re huge. Also, how the fuck would I fit in among all these goddamn trees!? I ain’t chopping them all down myself.”

#ticci toby #creepypasta #asked #Anonymous #ask

How do you both keep warm in the winter? It must be hard living in that old drafty mansion sometimes.

“Listen, I don’t know where the fuck you’re from, but if you’re calling this shitty, dilapidated cabin a mansion, man oh man...”

Toby sighs.

“I wish I had a mansion. You ever see the couch here? I sat on it once. And it shattered. How the fuck does a couch shatter?! I don’t know but hey. It did.”

Meanwhile, in someone’s attic, a mask-wearing cannibal sits up straight.

“Wait... We have a mansion??? I never got that memo, what the hell?!”

#ticci toby #eyeless jack #creepypasta #asked #Anonymous #ask