Elements I’d assign the Signs if they had to be a different one ⭐️
Aries - Water: I see aries as a very passionate, loving and caring sign, which resonates the most with water (apart from fire). I think air is too detached, aries is a sign that is usually all in & deeply involved. Earth seems to be too analytical and well thought through by nature.
Leo - Earth: Ironically, I find Leo placements to be much more thought through than they’re being given credit for. They usually move with purpose and know exactly why they do what they do.
Sagittarius - Air: I think Sagittarius placements are a lot more detached yet easy going and light to be around, but not necessarily strongly analytical and logical like earth signs. Although I think Jupiter ruled signs (+Cancer) have a special kind of intuition, I don’t think water really fits.
Taurus - Water: I find many Taurus placements to be a lot more emotionally invested, they care a lot and they usually have a strong gut feeling. Although I think they can be explosive at times, I find that Tauruses fit more into water than fire due to the lack of spontaneity and not thinking things through.
Virgo - Fire: I think this is a controversial take but I experience many people with virgo placements as very domineering, not necessarily in a way that comes naturally to them but definitely in a way that suits them.
Capricorn - Air: Capricorn placements just tend to be a bit detached by nature and more so on the analytical side, that’s why I think air is the best fit out of the three options. I also think one quality of Capricorns that is massively underrated is their ability to mask and adjust quickly.
Gemini - Fire: In my experience, many people with Gemini placements aren’t really shy, but rather ambivert. They don’t fw with everyone and definitely aren’t everyone‘s cup of tea but they’re fine with it, which is what I think fits very well into the element of fire.
Libra - Water: Libra placements tend to be very sensitive to their surroundings, they are affected by bad vibes and bad influences, they know how to read and absorb energy. I think that most libra placements are too considerate for fire and too spontaneous and intuitive for earth.
Aquarius - Earth: Aquarius placements are very unique and hard to describe which is why I lean towards earth for them. They only share a fraction of what’s on their mind and many people with strong aquarius influences are very wary of who they allow into their lives and what they tell others.
Cancer - Earth: I find cancer placements to be a lot more analytical than they are portrayed. Although they tend to analyze emotions, they analytical skills are top notch. Fire and water share a few characteristics such as deep emotions and strong reactions but to me, most cancer placements are too cautious and deliberate about their choices.
Scorpio - Fire: This is probably the most obvious one, but I think Scorpio placements can be as dramatic and big as a stereotypical fire sign. Although I can also see air detachment tendencies and earth analysis, I think they fit the stereotype of being the fire sign of the water signs well.
Pisces - Air: Although Pisces are typically described as sentimental and sensitive, their detachment abilities are massively overlooked. Similarly to cancers, they also have analytical skills especially regarding emotions, however I think it is a lot more chaotic with the possibility of spiraling in comparison to the way earth signs analyze.