the past jai shared with emmett was a bit of a complicated thing, to say the least. the two dated in the past and although they were close, it often times felt more like a friendship than an actual relationship. the two men never even kissed, but jai expected that was because he simply wasn’t ready. despite the obvious romantic tension, things just sort of fizzled. if he was being honest, their feelings never fully went away, but he pretended he was cool with just being friends. if emmett only wanted to be friends, he couldn’t blame him for that. as emmett spoke, jai couldn’t help but laugh at his endorsement of the tragedy. it wasn’t their favorite, but even hipster jai recognized the appeal of the classics. “i guess you might have a point. i get to play mercutio. without a doubt, he’s the best in the entire production. no big deal,” he joked with a small smile. “um, you should come by one of the shows and see me cast ‘a plague on both houses’ and dramatically die,” he said, getting into character for the iconic line before quickly slipping back into regular ol’ jai mode. “i mean, if you aren’t busy? i won’t assume you even, like, want to,” jai said, a bit of their insecurity in the situation coming to the front. oops. jai couldn’t help but silently cringe, yet attempted to brush it off with a smile.
“yes! you’d make an amazing angel. from what i remember, you have quite the stage presence. i fully endorse this audition,” jai exclaimed. it made them happy to see emmett’s eyes light up with excitement, something he missed seeing from him the most. they started off as friends growing up and were extremely close. there was quite possibly next to nobody in the world that made them as happy as emmett. emmett knew about their strained family relations and how hard it was for them to find themselves in the world. “i don’t mind at all. i can text you the audition times. you still have the same number?” he asked, secretly wondering if emmett’s name in their phone still had the pink heart emoji beside it. at emmett’s next remark, jai felt his stomach tighten up. could it be that emmett missed him, too and he had no idea? for a while, he thought he fucked it up by expecting too much from him. “it’s good to see you! i’ve been thinking a lot about those movie nights we used to have at my place. i still haven’t found someone who can put up with me calling out plot holes in every film quite as well as you,” he reminisced with a smile. “other than that, i’ve been pretty good. i adopted a hairless cat, so i’m a dad now,” he laughed. “how about you?”
as much as emmett wanted to deny it, a part of him knew that his past with jai would always linger in the back of his mind. honestly, emmett felt as if he had never given them a chance to fully experience what it would be like to date. his insecurities often plagued his thoughts, preventing him from doing the majority of what he wanted to do with jai. for example, holding his hand in public. he wanted to reach for jai's hand so many times, yet, he never did because he silently felt like he'd embarrass the other. and he never fully felt like he was enough; there was always this nagging feeling like he could be doing more, he could be more like he was holding jai back from experiencing everything from someone. and the more he continued to let himself believe this, the more he began to distance himself and unintentionally throw them both into the friend zone. even if, despite emmett not knowing, things between the two were never really friend-zoned. seeing jai now, watching him light up at the idea of playing mercutio, he felt so much regret having missed out on all the chances he had with jai to do hold his hand. "you know mercutio is my favorite out of the entire cast, so, i'm extra excited to see you plague both houses." he lightheartedly laughs as jai dramatically dies, gently nudging him a bit, "please. make it extremely dramatic when you die. get a fake blood packet, too, and just really get wild with it." he offers jai a warm smile, "i would love to come and see you. it's a date." even if he had said the word 'date' he hadn't noticed that he let the word slip from his lips, the warm smile on his lips only grew. "i hope you're ready for a huge bouquet of roses, too. i'm going to buy you the most obnoxiously huge bouquet for your opening night."
then as they talked about RENT and jai endorsed his audition for angel, it really felt like nothing had changed between the two, like none of the time that passed had even gone by, and it was a feeling that only jai could bring to emmett. he was the only one who could make emmett feel instantly at home; in a way, he probably always would be. "y-yes, it's the same number. you can text me any time," he admits, hoping the other wouldn't ask him to pull out their phones; his mind instantly shot to jai's contact info and how there was still a bunch of emojis with hearts next to his name. he hadn't exactly gone through to delete anything from the other as a part of him really thought the two would end up together again someday, but as time went by he also kind of just forgot to erase things. when he hears jai mention how he's been thinking of the movie nights they used to have, emmett tries to ignore how the idea made his stomach tighten with nerves butterflies, he couldn't quite pin the feeling. he kept as casual of a look on his face as he could, though on the inside, everything was twisting and turning in ways he hadn't expected to feel. "you have?" he lightly asks, looking over at the other, "you know, you're still my favorite movie buddy too. i haven't been able to find someone who can just sit there and watch movies with me until all hours of the night while we laugh at the plot holes. plus, no one quite gets my taste in movies like you do. if i'm honest, i miss that feeling." he figured it didn't hurt to admit that, right? it was innocent enough. but he also didn't look away from jai as he spoke; he wanted to see if there was any sign that maybe he missed him too, though his smile continued not to falter. "aw. congrats on being a kitten dad, jai. i'm so happy for you! i can't wait to see pictures of the little guy and hear updates. i'm kind of a father myself, except aristotle is roommate's pup and not mine."
then andrej came to his mind, and with that thought, so did everything else that had been going on. his smile did falter then, his eyes dropping to look at his hands, he turned to face forward as he answered jai's question, "uh. life..." he felt terrible pouring his feelings out right now, considering he hadn't seen jai in so long, and this was his ex, but things were never the same jai as they were other people, ".... life's been a bit rough. i'm not going to deny that. there's a lot of stuff going on with my roommates. um. i don't know. it's all such a mess, jai." and before he knew it, he went on to talk about the andrej situation, how he and grayson were in an open relationship, how emmett didn't know, the feelings confessed between himself and andrej, and he tried not to tear up but failed by the end of it. "and it's just rough, you know? i wish i would've known he was in an open relationship. i wouldn't have allowed myself to develop feelings, but i didn't, and now it's too late. now i feel like i've ruined someone's relationship, or chances of going forward fully with it, i've ruined my friendship with andrej by moving out, and i have zero idea what i am going to do to fix any of it. i hate myself for all of it. but the bright side?" he lets out a sad laugh, shaking his head a little, turning to look at jai, "at least i finally got my first kiss from a guy."