I am a marketing capacity builder with more than 15 years experience in marketing, communications and social media. I work with small to medium businesses, not for profits and social enterprises to deliver purpose-driven, values-based marketing programs while identifying and building their internal marketing skills. As founder of Just Good Marketing and the Positive Marketing Initiative, I am passionate about heralding in a new wave of marketing that is uplifting, inspiring and adds value to our community. I want to change the world by changing marketing. I believe in the concept of Positive Marketing â which youâll read a lot about in my blog & on the Just Good Marketing blog. I am also a social scientist and love working in the space where community development and marketing meet. I work with community groups to create congruency between their social programs and their marketing Away from work, I am a geek, a traveller and a bookworm. I live with a feral cat who occasionally impersonates a domestic moggy. You can follow me on Twitter @jacquelineod or look me up on Linked In
What marketing can contribute to national heritage week
What on earth could National Heritage Week have to do with marketing?Â
Most people would probably 'not much' but to me, marketing plays such a huge role in shaping our culture and it can either promote or diminish ideas about heritage. The government defines heritage asÂ
"Heritage is about the places and stories that make Australia special. It includes our amazing natural places, our rich Indigenous heritage and the diverse historic sites that together reflect our development as a nation.
Our heritage contributes to our sense of place and to our community and personal wellbeing, it informs us about where we have come from and who we are, and is fundamental to our national identity."
One of the saddest changes I've seen in marketing in Australia over the past decade has been the shift to using 'international ads' without alteration. Many years ago, this was almost unheard of but changes local content laws have removed the need for voiceovers to be in an Australian voice. As such, many of the current ads have distinct American accents, terminology and phrasing, and even cultural or geographical references.Â
The images shown of cities, landscapes, buildings and homes rarely represent our Australian aesthetics.Â
And when Australian heritage is represented, it is often done in a very overt manner or in a nostalgic fashion, focusing on the rugged, pioneering, outback aspect or the white, suburban, nuclear family. While these are valid aspects of our heritage, they are also a very limited representation of modern Australia.Â
With more than 2/3 of our population living in urban centres, nuclear families becoming increasingly rare, and a hugely diverse and multicultural society, for marketing to continue to represent Australia in such a limit way - or to neglect to represent Australia at all and rely on imported advertising - can be very damaging.
It is time for marketing to play a more positive role in reflecting modern Australian culture - full of diversity, national shared values that are different to other Western states, and a thriving urban lifestyle that supplements our gorgeous natural heritage.Â
By focusing on what works in Australian culture and highlighting the uniqueness that we share as a community, marketing can help to create a cohesive, happy society and truly support the success of our country as a multicultural society. This includes showcasing our beautiful cities and the wonderful buildings, bridges and public spaces we have built (there is more to Australian architecture than one bridge and an opera house!) so that we are reminded of their significance and remember to protect them into the future. It also includes showcasing of our local talent, in visual arts, music, dance and theatre, so that we remember our unique heritage there too.Â
So, this national heritage week, let's ask our marketers and advertisers to step up!
What unique aspects of Australian heritage would you like to see reflected in marketing campaigns?Â
Some years ago, after a bad day at work in the corporate office filled with Dilbert-style cubicles, of which I was at that time a prisoner, I accidentally happened upon a small, soft-cover book that was heavily discounted in order to clear the few remaining copies from the store... and thus, serious life-change began!
We all have our stories, a turning point, where we had to do more. Strangely enough, I'd been firstly disenfranchised by working class parents who believed that if you fell below a certain socio-economic line your best was to put up and shut up - and work harder; and secondly by sufficient international commercial success based on my ability to adapt, and project capability and IQ, beyond my station (she says mockingly) to understand that it wasn't that simple.Â
I'd never wanted anything more than to make the world a fairer, happier and healthier place yet I had begun to lose all of my naive, stupidly optimistic, ridiculous hope.
And then I opened the covers of this book.Â
It had the simplicity of the self-help books I'd come to love - simple one-sentence summaries of hope, one after the other, all making sense. But it also had amazing real life examples of spiritual warriors (my words not his) who were actually living examples of people with integrity. Simple stories that seemed like they could have been achieved by anyone... and maybe they really were that simple :)
Each chapter was punctuated by Martin's beautiful nature photographs but that was simply the icing on the cake. The real gift of this book was, and is, the oxygen than hope needs to fuel its flame.Â
 A number of my dinner companions quickly jumped to the Simon Sinek talk that got everyone talking purpose-driven business a few years back. (If youâre not familiar with this TED talk, check it out here http://bit.ly/WmgEtT ) My point, supported by at least one other person at the table, was that purpose means very little if you donât carefully construct how you are going to deliver it to ensure that your purpose doesnât become simply marketing spin. Basically, I believe that âhow mattersâ â the ends donât justify the means, as such. This is particularly important for social businesses and not-for-profits who may sometimes believe in their cause so much that they are willing to compromise on some things in order to achieve their mission â Iâll write more on that particular topic later, for now I want to focus specifically on purpose-driven approaches to for-profit businesses.
My major concern with the current focus on Purpose for businesses is that there seems to be an automatic assumption that if a company has sat down and worked out what its purpose is that it will include an aspect of social responsibility and environmental care. The term purpose-driven business has become synonymous with more authentic, transparent and âgoodâ business practices, with greater social integrity. Letâs be clear on this though, Simon Sinek never said his presentation was about changing business to a model of greater responsibility or sustainability â his presentation was positioned as an insight into why some brands or people inspire us and some donât. He was simply pointing out that starting a conversation with âwhyâ â our passion, our vision, our values â is more engaging and inspiring than starting our conversation with what we do and how we do it. It was a model for better branding and better story telling. He does make the point that profit is not the purpose of business, that it is simply an outcome but this in itself does not exclude purposes that are detrimental or anti-social.
One of the shining examples Simon Sinek gives of a purpose-driven business that inspired people by focusing on the âwhyâ is Apple. Yet in recent years many of their business practices â from employment conditions in China to increasing rates of perceived obsolescence of products to contribution to growing e-waste worldwide â have come under question. Sinek notes that Appleâs âwhyâ is about challenging the status quo and thinking differently. Steve Jobs however described it as Apple, at its core, believing that people with passion can change the world âfor the betterâ.
In 1997, in Jobsâ presentation on Apple Brand Purpose, highlighted that marketing is about values â âitâs a complicated world, a noisy world, we have to be really clear on what we want them to know about us.â He noted that it was important not to talk about technical features, that customers want to know âwho you are and what you stand forâ. This is of course, one of the reasons that Apple is so frequently used as an example of a visionary business with a clear purpose. And it does actually include a social aspect, where real good could have been contributed to the world.
What went wrong?
My dinner companions and some other colleagues have put forward two suggestions. The first is that the purpose wasnât well embedded into the organisation and thus couldnât really be considered the purpose of the business, just of the leader at the time. The second is that the only businesses that maintain their purpose are those that remain owned and run by the person who set the purpose in the first place.Â
The first point speaks to my argument about stopping the conversation at âwhyâ and forgetting that âhow mattersâ. Even Simon Sinekâs book was called âStart with whyâ â he recognised it was only the beginning point! The truth is, if you get the âwhyâ clear and well-defined, it will guide you every step of the way on the how and the what providing that you donât stop at âwhyâ and think your work is done. I believe that once youâve worked through how you are going to deliver on your purpose in every part of your business (think every single aspect of your operations, product design and marketing), you can embed it so deeply that you donât need the owner at the head of the business for the purpose to survive.
If you listen to the second half of Jobsâ presentation, it gets really interesting. It is clear that he had intuitively understood what Sinek was describing years later â that sharing your passion and values is more inspiring and creates greater loyalty than talking about the drier, more technical aspects of what you do. You see, his talk was about planning Appleâs first brand marketing campaign that was going to begin in the coming weeks. He was adamant that Appleâs core purpose needed to be at the heart of everything they presented to the world.
The campaign was focused on people who had changed the world â this was the famous âthink differentâ campaign. The TV ad spoke to this:
 Hereâs to the crazy ones. The misfits. The rebels. The troublemakers. The round pegs in the square holes.
The ones who see things differently. Theyâre not fond of rules. And they have no respect for the status quo. You can quote them, disagree with them, glorify or vilify them.
About the only thing you canât do is ignore them. Because they change things. They invent. They imagine. They heal. They explore. They create. They inspire. They push the human race forward.
Maybe they have to be crazy.
How else can you stare at an empty canvas and see a work of art? Or sit in silence and hear a song thatâs never been written? Or gaze at a red planet and see a laboratory on wheels?
We make tools for these kinds of people.
While some see them as the crazy ones, we see genius. Because the people who are crazy enough to think they can change the world, are the ones who do.
You can watch the entire Steve Jobs presentation here: http://youtu.be/ugqcXqTEVMAÂ
Jobs focused on the brilliance of the Nike brand as his inspiration â no discussion on product or comparison with competitors; everything focused on athletes so that the audience automatically associates the Nike brand with the feeling of athletic brilliance, success and glory. This was Jobsâ vision for Apple, to create an automatic emotional response to the Apple brand that was linked to visionary change-makers and innovative thinkers.
Maybe this is where the purpose got lost? Was it all built into the brand rather than being built into the operations? For my friends who believe that only the businessâ original owner can hold a company on purpose, I think that is a very limited perspective but to those who believe that a clear vision and definition of your purpose is enough, I think Apple serves as brilliant lesson.
Around 4 years after Apple won the worldâs hearts with its âThink Differentâ campaign, Forbes asked the question âWhere is Appleâs social purpose?â  If Steve Jobsâ original focus on people who change the world âfor the betterâ had been carefully engineered into Appleâs overall operations, there is no way that this question would have been necessary â and no way I would have been writing this article another 2 years on!
What can you learn from Apple about using purpose to inspire great customer loyalty and brand passion? I believe it is as simple as ensuring that your purpose includes clear social consideration (including environmental factors) and that the moment you have it clarified, you work at incorporating it into every aspect of your business. Be explicit about it â donât leave it to chance! Build it into your procurement, distribution, recruitment, outsourcing, production etc And very importantly, be incredibly careful to build it into your marketing methodology and tactics, not just your marketing messagesâŠ
For the most part, I consider myself fairly lucky on this count - especially over the past few years when brunettes started making a comeback and were allowed to be the attractive girls in films not just the smart girls. I'm not saying I look anything like the girls they use in movies or advertising campaigns. Far from it! But I am a lot more similar than many people I know.Â
I've been talking about this topic with a lot of people lately, trying to get a better feel for how conscious or otherwise people are to this feeling of not being represented. During one of these conversations I had a really personal realisation: no matter how 'comfortable' I am with myself or much I accept my own physical appearance, I have never stopped dying my hair since it started going grey in my mid-20's.
Suddenly I started looking really closely at the women my age in the media and entertainment realm. I couldn't find a single one with grey hair. Hell even the women 30 years older than me usually presented with full-coloured hair! Each day for the next few weeks I looked at the women around me in the streets, on the train, in cafes... I could only find 2 or 3 under the age of 60 who were letting their natural grey be seen by the world. Strong, opinionated, boldly dressed women who were not at all afraid to show that they were not going to conform to the narrow definitions of beauty imposed upon them were still dying their hair.Â
I realised there was only one thing to do - challenge myself to go grey! Now, anyone who knows me well will know that I'm not afraid to experiment with my hair: I've permed it, Bali-braided it, dyed it, bleached it, streaked it, grown it, cut it and pretty much anything else you can think of... I've even gone natural every now and again :) Oh, and I took clippers to it once to make a point (only to discover that a buzz cut pretty much makes everyone assume you are either undergoing chemotherapy or a lesbian). But to be honest, even with only a couple of inches of grey starting to peak through, I'm really not sure if I'm going to be able to follow through on this completely.Â
I do have Helen Mirren and Jamie Lee Curtis to inspire me Maybe if there were just a few more female role models sporting natural grey locks, like there are men (think Patrick Dempsey, Pierce Brosnan and George Clooney) it would feel a little easier?
When I was working in large companies working with, not for, meant that I allowed others to have input into my work, answered their questions about why I had done things the way I had, and documenting my work processes in detail so that basically anyone could my work for me. Strangely enough, this approach is often seen as a weakness in many large corporations - holding knowledge that no one else does is a sign of power and accepting others inputs is often interpreted as being indecisive.Â
In my social science studies, I came across many instances of work that was being done 'for' people - in particular, outsiders (mostly Westerners) going into poorer communities and 'fixing' things. But I've also seen - and been involved in - work where the local community decided what was needed and the 'outsiders' were there to work with them as an extra pair of hands, a knowledge bank to be drawn on as required, and for morale (there is nothing like knowing a complete stranger wants to give up everything to help you out for a while to make you feel empowered).
Teams that develop skills within - even if the overall work is still to be outsourced - provide greater resilience to the organisation, able to respond to opportunities or threats quickly and with confidence. Strategies and plans are more likely to be well implemented if the team has understood the process and contributed from their own experience and skill base. Understanding different skills also helps team members to have a greater appreciation of each other and reduces the ranking of skill sets based on perceived difficulty, creating an awareness that everyone's work requires a unique knowledge base that is valuable. This approach sometimes comes at the cost of some efficiency initially but the payoff in the longer term is too significant to be sacrificed.Â
Ensuring everyone feels able to contribute and participate does require some different skills and methods to our work. I'll write more about these in other posts. In the meantime, do you have a personal experience to share of a time you saw a deliberate decision to work with, not for get results?
Do positive messages make audiences more receptive?
I am a huge believer in positive messaging - it is a core technique for our Positive Marketing model. I don't have scientific research to specifically back my perspective but there are certainly plenty of fringe studies on the effects of fear and negativity in keeping people compliant. My observations of the world, and significant reading in some of these fringe areas, has me convinced that negative and positive messages produce very different mindsets and behaviours.
The Responsible Business by Carol Sanford (@CarolSanford) is one of the most inspiring business books I have ever read. Working with some of the world's big name, old-market businesses, Carol Sanford has been able to establish a business methodology for a brave new future.Â
(Click on the picture above to go directly to its listing on Fishpond* if you'd like to buy this book.)
I think for me the greatest thing about this book is that while it is highly radical in its thinking, the material is presented in a manner that will be comfortable for people from a more traditional business background.Â
The pentad (5-pointed star) model that forms the basis of the methodology provides a simplicity that belies the enormous shift in thinking that is required to put this change into action. The detailed case studies however are not only reassuring in their proof that this can work but also clearly demonstrate how the thinking can be applied to very diverse business problems.Â
Certain ideas really jumped out at me when I read it; ideas I can't let go of that are effecting every decision I make to this day.Â
Firstly, the shift that can be achieved when the customer is viewed as a collaborator and the product is examined at its integration point in the customer's life, rather than in the isolation of the business. And leading from this, every employee having direct responsibility to the customer and as such being trusted co-creators of every part of the customer's experience.Â
I love the description of the Earth as the source and final destination of everything we make. The simple suggestion that extracting materials 'sustainably' is insufficient and that we need to be evolving to a model where businesses are looking to see how they can help the Earth to thrive or to increase its wellbeing and capability because of the way the do business.
Similarly, I was captivated by the concept of the business as a guest of the community it operates in. How it needs to behave well and be considerate of the community members and their needs - that it should always remember that it needs the community's permission to be able to stay.Â
If you are looking for a solid structure upon which to base a customer-centric, responsible and sustainable business, this is the book to guide you. It describes processes for retrofitting an existing business and for designing a business from startup.Â
* We are an affiliate of Fishpond and if you purchase the book via our link, we receive a small commission. We only recommend books that we have personally read, found to be highly insightful and that we think would be useful to our clients.Â
Imagine if you discovered that your team was full of people with hidden skills that were really useful to what you were trying to achieve. Or if it turned out that some of your team members had a strong desire and motivation to learn skills quite disparate to the skills you hired them for, and these new skills were something you really needed!Â
There were so many great insights and discussions at our workshop last night with Dr Donnie Maclurcan of the Post Growth Institute and the Australia Project that I'm going to have to just pick one or two to write about for you. This first one though about hidden strengths was one that I know a lot of people could really benefit from, particular in the not-for-profit, community and startup sectors so we'll start with that.Â
Donnie took us through the in-depth "asset-mapping" process that he used in starting the Post Growth Institute. He committed significant time and effort into getting people to think about the strengths they had and the ones they would like to develop. Importantly, this is not strictly about skills as many of us would traditionally think. Strengths is broader than that and includes passions, interests, knowledge sets and very importantly, connections.Â
For small organisations with little budget for marketing, this technique can provide strength and reach beyond the organisation. What we refer to as "punching above your weight". Suddenly some of the things you've been trying to raise the money to buy can be sourced directly from your own team. Imagine discovering your accountant has a passion for photography and is actually a fairly skilled amateur willing to build your photo library for free. Or that your administration assistant loves Twitter and has a massive following that can be used to publicise upcoming events.Â
Asset-mapping addresses a very simple limitation inherent in most operations - when we are recruiting someone and working with them around their contribution to the team, we generally blinker ourselves by starting with a pre-written list of skills and attributes we are looking for in that role. We may, at best, ask what skills they would like to develop but this is generally kept within a constrained idea of a particular career path. New skills acquired outside of work and those additional attributes (such as connections, passions and interests) rarely make it on to the radar because they don't fit into the existing templates.Â
Additionally, when we begin to work on a problem, our focus is entirely on the problem. Significant time and energy is put into discussing 'what doesn't work' and even sometimes 'what was tried before and failed!' This often leads us to a problem-solving model that involves trying to 'fix' the situation rather than a bigger picture discussion that could see more innovative and alternate solutions put forward.
Donnie has shown through his own research and work that when you start by discussing the strengths of the group and the resources it has built into it, a number of significant difference appear. One is that people have greater trust of each other - as such they are more open to new ideas or different ways of thinking. They are also more aware of what they have to bring to the table outside of their usual 'job skills' so they consider much broader possibilities about what they could contribute. And very importantly and almost magically, they are more hopeful and optimistic about creating an outcome that eliminates the problem.
(I'm going to write a separate post on the concept of 'fix, change, replace or eliminate' at a later date but I want to note here that sometimes we are so focused on the problem that we forget to go back our real purpose and see if there is a better option to solving the problem.)
The great thing about asset-mapping and starting your project or problem solving task with an asset-based approach is that it doesn't actually cost you anything. It won't even necessarily take more time. All it takes is a little preparation and careful facilitation. The more you do it, the more quickly and effectively you will be able to do it.Â
I'll be up front and say I don't like the terms asset-mapping or asset-based. Maybe I spent too many years in the financial services sector and I have an aversion to hearing people and their characteristics referred to as assets (or resources for that matter). But what was underneath the words used was a very human - and humanising - technique for empowering an organisation by uplifting, inspiring and turbo-charging your team to go ahead and achieve your mission.Â
Iâve noticed a lot of people lately talking about shifting from âbroadcastâ to âconversationâ for social media. I understand where they are coming from â as a business, it is a new mindset that our customers can easily talk back to us and engaging with them to build a trusting relationship makes sense. But the reality is, if you are only viewing social media as a conversation, you are missing some of the best opportunities available.
You see, people come to your social media profile not only to connect with you but to connect with other people who are connecting with you. Why would they want to do this? Iâm sure there are a whole variety of answers to that question but mostly because people like to connect with other people who care about the same thing as they do. As such, your greatest opportunities exist in how you help your followers to connect with each other.
Creating a community has numerous benefits for a business. A community becomes a third entity; greater, more complex and full of possibilities beyond any of the individual community members. Think of the Beatles â each of them were great in their own right but what happened when the 4 came together as the third entity of the Beatles, the magic created was far more than the sum total of each of the individualâs talents.
A member of a community is likely to be more loyal than an individual. Just consider how much easier it is to walk away from one person than it is to walk away from a community that you have become a member of â you are not only walking away from a number of people that youâve grown connected to but the shared experiences, and the magic of that third entity that youâve all created together. And perhaps that is where the power of community comes from â that fact that it is created by all of members, at least in part.Â
A community can also provide better insights into your customerâs needs and aspirations than conversations with any of them as individuals can. This is simply because community members are going to talk to each other much more naturally than they talk to you. There will be many different opinions and community members will feel confident questioning each other, challenging each otherâs ideas and putting forward suggestions. There is safety in numbers and ideas can swell more quickly within a community.
Communities can also work as an additional customer service team with individual members solving each otherâs problems before you even have a chance to. People love feeling useful and knowledgeable and are keen to help each out. Advice on how to fix something that comes from a community member is likely to be well received and used by the individual to âfix their own problemâ. Sometimes this is quite a different reaction to receiving advice from a business where the expectation might be that it is your responsibility to fix it for them.
Of course, creating and managing a community is a very different skill set than communicating to or conversing with individuals. Thatâs why I often say that marketers need to be cross-skilling in community development / community management. Many forward thinking businesses are actually hiring Community Managers to look after their social media instead of leaving it with their marketing team. Perhaps in the future, digital community management will be a completely specialised skill set, although for now these roles are mostly hybrid marketing roles. One thing is for certain though â skip the shift from broadcasting to conversation, go straight to community instead. It will save you upgrading your strategy again in the near future!
What do you need to do differently to start working with a community instead of a conversation?
Every day I read about a new marketing trend â a new addition to social media, content marketing, real time marketing, interactive marketing⊠it is enough to make your head spin. Yet what all of these things have in common is that they are part of the promotional component of marketing. The terms marketing and advertising are used interchangeably and critique of marketing efforts is increasingly based entirely on the activity used to promote the brand or product.
Weâve reached a point where we are buying the story and buying the personality, while the product is left blatantly off to one side. You can liken it to be charmed and entertained by a charismatic stranger while having no idea of the substance of their character.
I am a firm believer in purpose-driven marketing. That is, understanding the real purpose of your business and creating your marketing on this basis. For example, at Just Good Marketing our purpose is to change the world by changing marketing into a positive force. As such, we speak about our commitment to Positive Marketing and we work with our clients to build such marketing capacity within their business so they can continue the work when we are not there. No consult and run. No quick fix, fast sales solutions. Understanding your purpose is a great starting point and will ensure a lot of integrity in what you do. Many believe this is the new way forward in marketing and that it will bring integrity back into business.
The danger however is if you build your purpose into your promotion and continue to forget your product!
It is, after all, the actual product (or service) that satisfies the customerâs needs. We can make them feel better about their choice of juice by making them love our brand but itâs ability to quench their thirst and meet their taste preferences is ultimately delivered by the product. In fact, one of the problems with our overly narrow focus on promotion is that it can actually lead to dissatisfaction as our products fail to live up to the relationship the customer has built with our brand and our story.
Before marketers and business owners start reviewing their promotional activities or working on their brand, they need to have a really good look at their product. Is it meeting a specific need in the community? Is it well designed to meet this need and to add value? Is it produced sustainably? Can it be maintained and repaired conveniently? Have you considered itâs various uses and disposal solutions? Does your service offering empower your customer? Have you considered the integration point (where your product or service integrates with your customerâs life as it is being used)? Do you know how or why your product is really being used? Does your product or service design reflect your real purpose for being in business?
Aside from driving serious satisfaction that no brand relationship could ever achieve on its own, careful and considerate product development makes the promotional work easy â you wonât be looking for ways to spin things, you will simply be sharing the truth about your product and it will be a winning story. It also helps to make price irrelevant, replacing the concept of cheap with that of value-for-money.
What would your customers change about your product today, given a chance?
Once upon a time, in a land far far away, a young woman discovered something inside herself that she never knew existed...
...that despite being uncoordinated, clumsy and awkward, she was actually really good at taekwondo!
But that was then and this is now. 5 years without practicing! 5 years with lots of sitting in front of desks and spending time in my own head. 5 years of getting older and even less coordinated.Â
2 years ago I found a taekwondo gym near my home. I emailed, checked the timetable, and asked all the right questions. And just as I would expect from any taekwondo teacher, I was given the instruction: just do it. Come in, start training and the rest will follow.Â
I responded in my usual way: no - first I must get fit. I must practice my poomses until I remember them. I will come back soon though, I promise.
Today I felt sick to the stomach all day. You see, I'd made my decision to go to class known. I had made myself accountable to someone else. And all I could think all day was "Which will be worse? How self-conscious and ridiculous I will feel turning up to class and not being fit enough and not remembering the forms? Or how pathetic I will feel telling my colleague that I chickened out?"Â
Not very constructive but not an uncommon thought pattern either. Personally, I am sick of chickening out of things. Especially things that aren't that scary to start with - I mean I've had some pretty wild adventures in my life and faced some interesting challenges so what on earth makes this such a big deal?Â
So I went to class. And I did every exercise I was told to do. Some of them I almost got right. Some I got really wrong. I even fell backwards on my bum, kicking while off balance - something I didn't even do as a white belt! And I huffed and puffed from every small round of kicks or punches. But I did it. And actually I did better than just doing it - I relaxed and enjoyed it!Â
Iâve been thinking about deficit thinking a lot lately. As a marketer, this style of thinking is deeply embedded in taught methodologies. Most marketers, whether consciously or intuitively will follow a deficit thinking pattern to drive their marketing solutions.Â
Deficit thinking is all about canât, problems, weakness, obstacles etc So marketers will often start by asking âWhatâs wrong?â "What's the problem?" or âWhere are a customerâs pain points?â That is, we seek to find dissatisfaction that we can then address with the product or service we are selling. (Or create a new product or service to meet that need.)
Itâs a simple but effective formula:
This is what is wrong in your life;
By using this product or service we can solve that problem
The brand is the hero, the customer is supposedly satisfied and we all live happily ever after.Â
Except that this isnât really how it works. You see, our cultural obsession with deficit thinking (it infiltrates all aspects of media and marketing at the moment) actually works to have us all feeling a little dissatisfied all of the time. We spend most of our time focused on what is wrong!
The opposite of deficit thinking is asset-based thinking. This is about focusing on what is right and building on that. Itâs important to note that this isnât about positive thinking â it is about looking at what already exists that is good and looking for opportunities rather than problems. We donât ignore our problems or bury our head in the sand, we just shift our perception towards opportunities.
From a marketing perspective, the way I like to do this is instead of looking for âpain pointsâ (just the terminology makes my skin crawl!) I work with positive visions. A positive vision is simply an imagining of the world at its best. With that vision in mind, we can then identify what products and services meet that vision. As such our marketing becomes very aspirational, sustainable (nobody imagines a positive future in which all of our natural resources have been destroyed!) and inclusive. Because in our positive vision, those things are that are causing us dissatisfaction or pain are gone, we are still working to solve those problems but we are driven by a hopeful and optimistic mindset rather than one troubled by dissatisfaction and frustration.
Positive visioning can be a really powerful exercise to run with your staff, customers and suppliers. Create a shared vision of the future that you want to work towards and then see how you can make it happen. We have personally found that positive visioning leads to immediate action. With a strong shared vision, everyone grows confident in making decisions and generating ideas. It is clear whether or not actions fit with the future youâve described. See how your ideas change when shift your perception â and how your energy follows!
If you would like a facilitated Positive Visioning session with your organisation, contact us today at Just Good Marketing.Â
I like to say that every minute you spend watching your competitors is a minute that your attention is not on your customer. But comparing ourselves to others is even more damaging than that.
I have a clear picture of what success looks like to me. We have a clear picture of what success looks like to Just Good Marketing. It's a great vision - and achieving this vision is what makes us leap out of bed in the morning and charge into our day. We've set out objectives based on this vision, so our business strategy includes outcomes around social impact, the ability of the business to afford us opportunities in personal growth, and other such things, in addition to wanting to be profitable.Â
Like most businesses though, we sometimes start noticing what other people are doing. Suddenly, we wonder why we're not doing that too - I mean, they're in marketing, we're in marketing, if it works for them it will work for us to.Â
Whether it works or not is beside the point. It isn't what we want to do! And it will only work for us if it is actually a task that leads to our objectives being met. No point meeting someone else's objectives, is there?
2. It makes us more or less than - which makes others more or less than too!
The moment we start comparing ourselves to others a degree of ranking kicks in. We're less trendy than that company, we're more sophisticated, we're less PR-savvy... and of course for every more or less label we put on ourselves, there is a flip-side label for the other party.
This might make us feel superior - which means we're less likely to see opportunities for collaboration or learning. We may also fail to see what appeal the company has to our customers - and at the end of the day, the more or less than comparisons we do as professionals in the same sector, is not going to be the same as a customer's point of view.Â
It might also make us feel inferior. No one is at their best when they are feeling not good enough. It makes us defensive and less creative. It makes us feel like we need to hide or weaknesses and so we are less transparent and honest with our customers.Â
It is possible to be awesome and see everyone around you as awesome too. And it feels really good!Â
3. It makes things finite. (Which means we can only have something when someone else doesn't.)
There can only be one best. If we are focused on this instead of on how many GREAT things there are, it becomes a competition for first place.
At this point some people will say "what's wrong with a little healthy competition?"
Surprisingly, there is significant evidence that competition isn't healthy. All the things we believe it drives - efficiency, creativity, productivity - are actually damaged by competition. Alfie Kohn (No contest: the case against competition) found in his study on the topic that victory and excellence are conceptually different - you can either put your energy into winning or put it into doing well. I believe the fact that many businesses are focused on triumphing over their competitors is actually what is letting them down - they've taken their focus of being excellent for their customers.Â
Now imagine instead a group of businesses in the same sector, all putting their full attention and effort into pleasing their customers. Each will do it differently, and as such will attract different customers, but they will do it really well. The customer is the real winner because now they have choice - and their choices are great because the bar has been raised. As they say, a rising tide lifts all boats. The best thing your business can do is be the bar raiser (or tide raiser).
So what does your vision of success look like?
Set a clear vision of what you want your business to achieve. Not just profit - real goals based on a clear purpose and positive vision.Â
What will your business be known for? How will people describe it? What will it be seen to bring to the world that no one else does?
One of our goals at Just Good Marketing is actually about working with other marketing companies to raise the bar in our industry - we want help build a collective voice for marketers that are using Positive Marketing approaches. As such, we reach out to other marketers to share and collaborate. We pass on ideas, books and resources that we know work. We have a deliberate No Competition policy! We see part of our success as making sure our customers always have good alternatives if they want to work with someone else. Our vision is a marketing industry that operates ethically and adds real value back into the community.Â
Think big with your vision. What would a better world look like to you and what role can your business play in making that vision come true?
Purpose in business is simple. You exist to meet people's needs.Â
If you can't clearly describe what needs you are trying to meet and how your product or service succeeds in meeting those needs, go back to the drawing board.Â
Once you are clear on this your marketing will come easily - you will identify people who have that need and introduce them to your product or service. You become the matchmaker!Â
Tuesday night is my Buddhist class and meditation night. I am finally being disciplined and not letting anything else get in the way. Which is harder than it sounds - I thought I'd made it easy by picking a Tuesday night class but from the moment I did, amazing invitations and opportunities started presenting themselves on Tuesday nights! (It was almost like I was being tested...!)
My teacher is amazing - he has the whole class in giggles for most of the hour and a half that we are there. Although not the part we spend meditating, of course! He brings such joy and playfulness into the teachings that there is no way to feel bad. He points out behavioural patterns that we personally berate ourselves for and make them look so silly that it is easy to laugh at - and forgive - ourselves.
I think sometimes we forget that it is easier to learn a hard lesson while you are feeling good. We get all caught up in the lesson having to be a serious as the topic we are teaching. Yet all it does is make us more uptight, more angry and less ready to hear new ideas.Â
I know when I was teaching English to elementary school kids in Korea the same applied. If I could get them laughing and having fun, they learned really quickly. It was like they forgot it was hard to learn, so it wasn't any more. Maybe this is the problem with how we are trying to solve the world's social and environmental problems at the moment - we've made it all too serious and people are stressing about it but not learning it. As hard as it may seem, I think we need to bring more joy back into it all.
One of the key learnings from class tonight was about meditation practice but it applies to trying to do anything difficult really:
1) expect no results (but do it anyway - do it because it is the right thing to do even if you're not successful)
2) inject delight into every aspect of what you do
3) never give up. Not ever.
I love the idea of 1 and 3 together - the idea of just choosing to do the practice because you trust it is the right thing to do, discarding all thoughts of achievement and deciding to just keep doing it forever, no matter what. Of course, it seems a bit like hard work if you have something really difficult (like meditation!) in mind. And then number 2 jumps in - and if you are doing the endless practice, with no expectation of success, ensuring it is fun and joyful is surely the only way to go!Â
There are so many things in my life this applies to right now but setting up Just Good Marketing especially. I need to be doing it whether it succeeds or not, just because I know it is the right thing to do. But, by golly! it needs to be done with delight :)
What could use a shot of joy, laughter or delight in your world right now?
There are many articles and help guides around that will assist you to build a Twitter following but if you are a specialised or localised organisation, you may prefer to use Twitter to actively engage with your relevant community.
This community may be donors or investors, service users or people interested in your cause but if your communications plan has indicated that this is the approach you want to take, many of the help guides wonât be quite so relevant.
I recommend doing this separately to your organisationâs main Twitter handle. Why? Because as you can see above, you could have multiple communities you want to talk to â and this isnât just a matter of wanting to highlight different things to different people, you are actually wanting to build and nurture a community. Just think, you wouldnât ask your donors and end-users to a single event and spend half of it explaining the social return on investment while interspersing the presentation with speeches on how we can all support each other and share our stories to get more out of the program, would you? No â youâd run a donor information night and peer support group quite separate of each other!
Also, make sure someone is allocated as Community Manager. This usually wonât be a full time role â it may sit with an existing marketing or communications person, or a social worker. Importantly, donât allocate the position to someone because they are good at Twitter â choose the person that would be best managing this particular community. Twitter is not difficult to learn but community building is!
Why would you build a community on Twitter?
Before I get too much into the detail of what you need to do differently to build a community on Twitter, I should talk about why you would do this. The main reason to do so would be that members of your community are active Twitter users and like communicating that way. Because at the end of the day, good communications are about communicating with people in THEIR preferred manner!
There are also times when it is not appropriate. Twitter is public â Protected Tweeting and Direct Messages aside â when used in itâs most common way, these are very public conversations so people outside your community can see the conversations. As such, it is not be the best option for sensitive conversations where privacy is important.
But if, for example, you are building a community of activists and you want to be able to quickly share information on people doing great and terrible things in your area of interest, and you want these activists to be able to interact and share with each easily, Twitter could be a fast and effective way to do this.
Your profile
Almost all of the Twitter help guides start by telling you to get your profile looking good â this still applies! It should be easy for people to recognise you and know what you are about. So a logo or a photo of your organisation, a brief description with some relevant keywords, and a link to your website or other online presenceâŠ
What you do need to do differently is make sure it is obvious that this isnât your organisationâs Twitter handle, it is your communityâs. For example it may be @ABC_activists Your purpose on your profile would reflect this too and redirect people to your main handle for general business.
Protected Tweets
If your community is somewhat private or sensitive â for example, you might be a service club whose Twitter community is not for general information sharing but is instead for inter-member discussions leading up to meetings to enable better decision making â you could use a Protected account. In this instance, all of your Tweets are only visible to followers youâve approved. No one can follow you without you first approving them and your followers cannot reTweet your tweets.
Build a following
Unlike when you are building a general following, you will already know the main people in your community from their existing relationship with your organisation. As such, you can either search for them individually through Twitter (probably a bit time-consuming unless it is a small group) or you can use non-Twitter communications (such as direct email, your newsletter, your website etc) to let them know the community is starting and inviting them to join. Make sure you express your purpose for the group, let them know the types of interactions to expect and why it would be valuable for them to be involved.
Growing a community
The two best ways to grow a Twitter community are:
Wherever you are meeting relevant people in the real world, be sure to promote the Twitter community. For many people this may actually be a simple way to begin getting involved with your organisation. It is low risk commitment that doesnât require much time and as such, may be preferred over attending meetings etc
Ask your members to invite friends and colleagues to join. Your members should have a good idea about the types of people that would be valued as members of your community so this should be an effective growth strategy. It also helps to increase the loyalty of your community because it is something they are now growing themselves.Â
Hashtags
You want your community to be able to easily interact with each other and follow conversations. Let them basic hashtags you will be using so they can search for the conversation easily. Match your hashtags to the purposes of the community â if you are talking about environmental issues, water issues and climate change for example, you may set up 3 tags #ABCenv #ABCwater and #ABCcc Because you include your organisation or community name in the tag, it is unlikely to be used by others making it easier for your members to drown out the noise.
Tweetchats
Just like regular membership meetings, regular Tweetchats give your members a chance to interact in real time. You can do this within Twitter or you may find a platform such as tweetchat.com to be more effective.
To set up a Tweetchat, all you need to do is let your members know what date and time youâll be chatting and which hashtag youâll be using. Members simply enter the hashtag in each Tweet they send.
A great way to do a Tweetchat is for the host to pose some questions for the audience to respond to. Number the questions so that people donât need to retweet the entire question.
A Tweetchat can be a great introduction to your organisation for potential community members. It is able to showcase the quality of discussion you can facilitate, demonstrate the knowledge of your organisation and provide insight into the connectedness of your community.
In simple steps
1. Start with a clear group purpose so you know why you are doing this. Check that Twitter is the right forum for this group.
2. Set up a distinct handle for the community. Decide whether to be public or protected. Get your profile set up.
3. Communicate to your community through the usual channels and encourage them to get involved with the Twitter handle. Explain the type of content youâll be providing and the benefits to them of being able to share with each other and work towards your common goal.
4.  Set up clearly identifiable hashtags for use by your community.
5. Host a Tweetchat â either on an ad hoc basis as required to engage and energise the community, and crowdsource ideas and knowledge, or on a regular basis, similar to a memberâs meeting.
What else would you like to know?
If you have any questions about this article or if there is a different topic youâd like us to write on, let us know! Weâd love to hear your ideas and thoughtsâŠ
I've been trying to live more actively, eat more healthily, be more social, meditate and reflect, and well - all the usual things we know we probably should do if we want to be healthier and happier. Some weeks are great and it all seems incredibly natural and fun. Then out of the blue, a week comes along that just whips you!
So I've decided that Sunday (which is usually the slowest, most peaceful day in my house) is Clean Slate Day. On Sunday mornings, I take a few moments to reflect on the week - what went well, what didn't, and how it all felt. Then I simply LET IT GO!Â
And I start again...
I don't plan for the coming week or make lists of what I'm going to do better this week than last week. I just start again.Â
I know that I already know how to live a great life, so a I start doing it. But with a clean slate - because the truth is, even if I've just finished a great week where I did all the "right" things, it doesn't really count for anything this week.