"Ecclesia Reformata, Semper Reformata"
John Sawyer
Bedford Presbyterian Church
8 / 9 / 26 – Summer Sermon Series[1]
Romans 12:1-2
Matthew 5:38-48
Philippians 1:3-11
“Ecclesia Reformata, Semper Reformanda”
(Foundations of Presbyterian Polity – Part 8)
Many of you know Blair Moffett, who is a retired Presbyterian Pastor, living in Wolfeboro, and friend of our congregation. He’s actually preaching here, next week. Blair was the first person to ever tell me about Bedford Presbyterian Church – way back in 2011 or 2012.
Last month, Blair parked his car – his new car – at a golf course and went out to play a round of golf. When he returned, he found that a stray golf ball from some unknown player’s golf club had hit his new car’s windshield and cracked it so bad that it needed to be replaced. So, Blair reached out to me and said something like, “It looks like I’m going to be spending the day in Manchester at the automobile dealership because the windshield of my new car has all these electronic doohickeys that require professional help. Apparently, you can’t just easily swap out a windshield anymore. Do you want to grab lunch?” I responded by saying, “Of course I’d love to grab some lunch.” And, “Isn’t technology wonderful?!?
Whether you need a new windshield or not, it sure does seem like we are innovating ourselves at a rate that’s hard to fathom.
Last month at Disneyworld in Orlando, an attraction called “The Carousel of Progress” shut down. For fifty-one years, The Carousel of Progress (which actually made its debut in 1964) has been showing a multimedia presentation about the remarkable progress and innovation that human beings made in the 20th Century. Apparently, the Carousel couldn’t keep up with the rate of change, though. So much more innovation has taken place in the last 50 years that the Carousel is closed for a whole year in an effort to catch up and update the presentation.[2] Of course, like Blair Moffett’s new car and so many other things, it will probably all be out of date before the repairs are complete.
Isn’t technology great?!? Aren’t change and innovation fantastic?!?? Not always. . . I don’t know about you, but sometimes, it’s enough to drive me to seek professional help!
From our place in 2026 – in our lightning-fast 21st century world – it might seem quaint to think about the world of 500 years ago – before cars, before telephones, before Artificial Intelligence. And yet, the world at the time of the Protestant Reformation was teeming with change and innovation, beginning with the printing press that revolutionized the spread of knowledge and information to people in their own languages – mass-producing books and pamphlets that, previously, had to be copied, individually, by hand.
There was also this revolution of ideas taking place – ideas around trade, and economics, and government, and literature, and religion. And, in response to this revolution, there were some who were early adopters and others who were decidedly not.
When Martin Luther, and John Calvin, and other pastors, and theologians, and regular church members, went about the task of seeking to reform the church, they did so with the knowledge that many of their reforms would be critiqued by those who were decidedly not early adopters of so much change. And yet they still adopted a motto for what they were doing. You know about mottoes right – a short phrase that expresses a guiding belief or principle? Nike shoes: “Just Do It.” Scouts: “Be Prepared.” The motto of the United States: “E Pluribus Unum,” or “Out of Many, One.”
Well, the Protestant Reformers came up with the motto: “The Church Reformed, and Always Reforming” or, for you Latin scholars out there, Ecclesia Reformata, Semper Reformanda. Now, this phrase did not originate with Luther or Calvin, but came nearly 100 years after Calvin died. The Protestant Reformation had entered its adolescence, if you will, having stuck around long enough to not just be seen as a short-lived movement of anti-Roman Catholic rabble rousers. With the theological foundation laid by Luther and Calvin (and others!) later Reformers were able to build upon that foundation. And one of these people was a Dutch Reformed pastor named Jodocus van Lodenstein in the city of Utrecht.
Ask anyone who their favorite Protestant Reformer is and, chances are, Jodocus van Lodenstein of Utrecht probably isn’t even on the radar. But this humble preacher – who had a lifetime of health troubles and overcame a speech impediment as a young man – would often attract thousands of people to hear him speak. The phrase, “Ecclesia reformata, semper reformanda,” is attributed to Jodocus van Lodenstein of Utrecht,[3] but, to be clear, he may have been quoting one of his teachers.[4] Either way, the phrase serves as a kind of summation of the Reformed movement up until that point. It still fits us.
It’s important to note that “the church reformed, always being reformed” is not an argument for change, simply for the sake of change. Instead, the Reformers believed that they were returning to the roots of Christianity. According to Anna Case-Winters, a professor at McCormick Theological Seminary,
The Reformers believed the [Roman Catholic] church had become corrupt, so change was needed. But it was a change in the interest of preservation and restoration of more authentic faith and life — a church reformed and always to be reformed according to the Word of God. The cultural assumption of the Reformers’ day was that what is older is better. This is strange to our contemporary ears. We do not share this assumption; if anything, we applaud the new and “innovative.” But one of the serious charges church authorities hurled at the Reformers was that they were “innovating.” John Calvin responded to this and other charges in his treatise “The Necessity of Reforming the Church.” As he put it, “We are accused of rash and impious innovation for having ventured to propose any change at all [in] the former state of the Church.” He then goes on to counter that they were not “innovating,” but restoring the church to its true nature, purified from the “innovations” that riddled the church through centuries of inattention to Scripture and theological laxity. The appeal was to a more ancient source, Scripture — “sola scriptura” (Scripture alone). . . the churches of the Reformation movement were purging themselves of these unwanted “innovations” and returning to a more ancient and therefore purer form of church life.[5]
In today’s reading from the Gospel of Matthew, we find Jesus – in his Sermon on the Mount – reading scripture in this same way. “You have heard that it was said [to those of ancient times]. . .” Jesus says to the people, giving them two different examples – one about “eye-for-an-eye” revenge justice and the other about “loving your neighbor and hating your enemy.” “But I say to you. . .” Jesus says to the people, “turn the other cheek” and “love your enemies.” Here is Jesus, radically reforming the way that scripture is to be interpreted – offering a reading of the ancient law that seems impossible to his hearers. “It’s one thing to follow the letter of the law,” Jesus seems to be saying here, “(anyone can love their friends and hate their enemies) but I want you to follow the true and intended spirit with which the law was written.”
Do you hear what Jesus is doing here? He’s getting to the heart of what it means to love as he loves. This is foundational to who Jesus is.
Over the course of this summer, we have been learning about some of the things that are foundational to who we are as Presbyterians. As I shared a few weeks ago, one study from 2019 estimated that there were over 45,000 different Christian denominations around the world. Probably, every time you hear a church bell ring, there’s yet another denomination that has split off from another.
When the Apostle Paul was writing his letter to the Philippians, he knew – even at that early stage – that churches were prone to internal disagreements and yet the act of faithfully disagreeing with one another is one way of listening for and discerning what the Holy Spirit is saying and doing in the present moment.
There are so many things that I love about being in Presbyterian, starting with our theological foundations. But one of the things that is expressed in our Book of Order is the right of people of good conscience to disagree with one another and yet still love each other.[6] Yet another thing I love about being Presbyterian, is our openness to the leading of the Holy Spirit. The last part of the “Foundations” section that we’ve been exploring this summer points us toward this openness. It’s an openness that some Christians might find too open, but when I think about the wideness of God‘s mercy and the depth of God‘s grace, I see our openness as a church as strengths and gifts – essential parts of who we are.
We are a denomination that desires to work with other Christians even if they don’t share our same Presbyterian label. We are a denomination that celebrates the God given gifts and skills of people of every ethnicity, sexual orientation, and gender expression, and ability – made one in Christ by the power of the Spirit. Why be so open? Because we believe that our rich diversity gives us a glimpse of the rich diversity of the kingdom of God.
It is also our hope that our “openness” to the Holy Spirit and one another helps us to:
. . . see both the possibilities and the perils of [the institutional church] in order to ensure the faithfulness and usefulness of these forms to God’s activity in the world; and a new openness to God’s continuing reformation of the Church ecumenical, that [we] might be more effective in [our] mission.[7]
In other words, we are striving to be a denomination that is not afraid of self-examination, of humble and heartfelt confession of past wrongs, or acknowledging our present failings. It’s all part of the process of opening ourselves to God’s reformation of the church. Note that I said “God’s reformation of the church” and not “Our reformation of ourselves.” Plenty of people might accuse our denomination of reforming ourselves in our own image (just like just about every other Christian denomination out there) but I hope that our first priority is being open to what God is doing in our midst.
So that, as Paul writes to the Philippians, “. . . the One who began a good work among you will bring it to completion by the day of Jesus Christ.” (Philippians 1:6) For Paul (and for us), this Holy and faith-filled work is guided by “love that overflows more and more with knowledge and full insight.” (1:9) In other words, the work of discipleship – the work of being the church, together, and of always being reformed – requires a love that is at work in both our hearts and our minds.
Plenty of folks have thought of Presbyterians as being too intellectual over the years. But there is nothing wrong with a faith that is seeking understanding – using our brains to think about God – as long as all of our intellectual seeking is guided and undergirded by love.
If there’s any innovation here, it is that God is guiding and undergirding all of it. I’ll close with this. . .
Last week, I spent five minutes on the phone saying, “Representative. . . Representative. . . Real Human Being, Please!” before the AI robot to which I had been speaking and which wasn’t able to answer my simple question finally sent me to a real person who was able to answer it. I admit to you that I am not looking forward to a similar phone call that I need to make, tomorrow. Isn’t technology wonderful?
There are plenty of reforms that need to be made in our world – not just reform or change for the sake of reform or change, but for the sake of making the world a better place. . . more loving, more peaceful, more person-to-personal, more whole.
As a church, we believe that God is guiding and undergirding it all and that God is bringing this new creation – this “on earth as it is in heaven” new creation – to fruition through you and me. . . yes, even you and me. . . as humble bearers of God’s image and humble vessels of God’s grace.
God is not done with us yet. Semper reformanda. . .
In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.
--------
[1] Based on “The Foundations of Presbyterian Polity” from The Book of Order of the Presbyterian Church (USA).
[2] https://disneyworld.disney.go.com/attractions/magic-kingdom/walt-disney-carousel-of-progress/.
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jodocus_Van_Lodenstein.
[4] A certain Dutch Reformed theologian named “Johannes Hoornbeek” – https://www.christianstudylibrary.org/article/history-and-meaning-semper-reformanda.
[5] https://pcusa.org/ecclesia-reformata-semper-reformanda.
[6] See The Book of Order of the Presbyterian Church (USA) – F-3.0101.
[7] The Book of Order of the Presbyterian Church (USA) – F-1.0404.








