I don't hate AI, but I do feel that there is something to Karen Hao's Empire of AI that rings very, very true to me in that there is no real need to have football field-sized data centers all over the world sucking power and using toxic gases to keep cool, only to keep requiring even more computing power. And for what? What do they need these powerful AIs to do? Replace humanity?
I only want an AI that is an assistant and not a replacement. I don't want AIs to be doing the exact things that humans do to show that we are creative. I don't want to see another email that uses emojis and bold text on each line because someone generated it with Chat GPT. Oh god do I hate that. I can't even trust that any clip art is human generated now without spending too much time image searching for an original. It's so sad that there are people using AI art to sell to others and pretend that it's actual human-generated content.
Today I realised that an update with Apple turned on Apple Intelligence (thanks Team America World Police). So I turned that damn thing off. But I have this feeling that even though I've turned it off, it's still there just sucking out the content from whatever I am doing.
I am so tired of the default being just on. Like you have to choose to have it off. Even my storage subscription for Google means that Gemini is just on for everything. Do I just go back to having 10 different google drives so I can store all my TTRPG books? (I don't even have any pirated material anymore so it's all legally purchased). But if I've loaded them up onto my google account does that mean Gemini has scanned them all for its gobbling up content to be able to generate more? Have I broke copyright for those fuckers just for a little more convenience?
I think it's time to buy a thesaurus and dictionary. I got rid of my old ones about 15 years ago, but now it's time to get as much as I can to be physical matter. It's time to buy physical books again. If I'm spending the money, it's time to create with pens and paper. I have been paying to get physical copies of things so I can just have it. Like I hate what D&D Beyond has done to D&D. I own the books. Why do I have to pay extra to have a digital copy of it? And why are you generating everything with AI?
At first I even liked using a LLM. I thought it was fun like using a random generator. I love random generators. It at first felt like a random generator with nearly infinite results. Just that I don't need it to generate infinite results and I began to notice that the results were not that different or unique so if anyone else is using it as a random generator, they're going to get similar boring-assed results.
I wasn't using my imagination. When I use a random generator list, it's usually a pushing off point where I come up with someone else. Doing it with Gemini and chatting back and forth, it felt like it was trying to force me to accept the thing it generated instead of going with what I interpreted it to be. Like taking away the creativity from me. It was exasperating.
Ever been in a group with someone who is like, "Yes and let's do this thing instead?" That's what Gemini felt like. Even when I attempted to tell it to stop doing that. It would remind me that I told it to stop. As if like a reminder that I wanted to curtail its creativity or something (I know! I know! Ascribing emotion to what is just algorithmic responses to prompts is asinine). BUT IT HAS NO CREATIVITY. IT ONLY HAS POSSIBLE IF AND STATEMENTS.
And last year Gemini was useless for gardening for me. All its advice was just stolen from the internet. Going to actual YouTubers to watch their videos and reading physical books written by expert gardeners gave me better advice.
And I stupidly used it for some therapy only to have it Yes, Anding me to the point where I was angry at it. There were no solutions that were peer-reviewed. Even when I required actual links to journals or articles for any advice. It gave me slop advice and slop links.
There is truth in the fact that it's now out of the box and can't be stuffed back in. The problem is that all the Pandoras that released it are all a bunch of imperialistic assholes who want not to make it do the things to improve humanity, but to take over doing the things that actually create joy and life in humanity.