Anyone else would have taken the plea for a display of romantic affection. Katrina took it as him not wanting to upset her. Obviously, she hadnât hidden her feelings well enough. The hasty retreat towards the front door meant liberation and Kat desperately wanted to be alone to process her own feelings. It didnât do to sit in front of him and pretend to be okay when she felt the specter of her own hopes and dreams lingering over them both. But he stopped her, drawing her back into his arms. Back into the warmth and the comfort that his words and true feelings couldnât provide to her. She let him pull her close, let his plea be just that. There was nothing left for either of them to say but staying was exactly what she wanted to do. Kat wanted to be there with him forever, just pausing her life until he could tell her that he loved her. It was foolish and hopeless but she wished for one moment that it were entirely possible.
âI donât want to leave you,â Kat whispered, her words carried into the air as they both ignored the movie droning on in the background. âI guess I donât know either. I thought I did.â She thought their whole life was a guarantee, not yet confirmed by the mere technicality that Ish just didnât know how to claim her. But it was a lie. A lie sheâd told herself to get through the days of wondering, of the âYouâre such a good matchâ comments from her mother. She agreed, they were. Kat couldnât imagine herself with anyone else but Ish. But here they were, twenty-eight and twenty-four. It felt as if the bonds of love and admiration tying them together began to loosen ever so slightly. There was no doubt that Ish loved her, that he respected her. But he wasnât in love with her. He didnât get the same heart-pounding happiness when he saw her. His entire day didnât turn around with one phone call from her. Heâd tell her if it hadâŠwouldnât he?
The truth was all sheâd wanted, all she ended the cease fire for but the truth was tearing her apart. It was ripping into her brain, setting fire to those little fantasies in her head with every single moment of silent that passed between them. âDo you love me?,â Kat asked him directly, her hazel eyes peering up into his own, wanting to see something more than what she interpreted as pity there. âI mean, that real kind of love You know? Because I love you. Iâve only ever loved you. And I just donât understandââ It was a useless argument. One that Kat wasnât equipped to have right then. Her heart was still thudding so she knew she was alive but nothing else confirmed that notion to her. She felt as if she were one of the walking dead. She could feel her lips moving, hear words coming from her mouth, but the end product wasâŠno feeling at all besides a numbing pain.
âDonât answer that. Just donât.,â she corrected herself sadly, shaking her head for a moment. Her eyes shut once more, shutting him out as well as the feelings and she tried to adapt to a better mood. One she doubted sheâd have any success in faking but an attempt had to be made. âWe can do what weâve always done. Just ignore it, baby. Ignore everything.â Her tone spoke with a finality befoe she reached up to brush her thumb against Ishâs cheek, her eyes opening to register his face yet again. âIâll never leave you, Ish. I couldnât even if I wanted to.â With a small smile, she glanced towards the doorway before dropping her hand back onto her stomach. âYour parents would kill us if they saw us like this.â
They both knew it, Kat didnât want to be held. Ishâs arms wrapped around her would frustrate and confuse her even further. But the best friends of more than twenty years had done this dance before. After some time passed, Kat would let her frustration pass and give into his affectionate touch, his closeness. It was the quickest and easiest way to settle her and he was going to take advantage of it before she walked away for good.Â
The man exhaled heavily, now that she settled into his arms. His fingertips lightly stroked Katrinaâs neck, teasing at the sensitive, exposed skin. She already felt betrayed. The hurt in her glossy eyes was obvious as she looked up at him. Ish studied the expression of his first love. She spoke to him in a barely audible whisper, but his eyes stared at her lips, picking up every syllable. He closely watched how she blinked away the emotion of the words she spoke with some struggle. He concluded from his study of her that it was a best friendâs responsibility to fix this. If he could stand to see her hurt, he would have let her leave earlier. It didnât occur to him that asking her to stay might hurt just as much. Forcing himself to feel things he couldnât, hoping that she wouldnât notice, wasnât an option anymore. He had to think of something though. The unrequited love between them wasnât Katâs fault. Though she lead him to the edge of the cliff, Ish pushed her into a free-fall, only to pull her up moments laterâa loverâs torture conjured by the devil himself.Â
For now, they decided to put all of it on hold. That gave Ishua some peace, and it seemed to work for Kat too. Admittedly, he felt some relief when she proclaimed that she didnât know either. But the man knew he couldnât put any faith in the truth of those words. They made him nervous. The more he thought about it, the more they felt like a lie he persuaded her to tell. After her reaction to what he told her earlier, it wasnât realistic. At only twenty-four, not knowing what she wanted in her life was a rarity for Katrina. She just professed her heartâs desires to him, he couldnât imagine that what she wanted or what she knew would change so quickly. Ish nearly had the nerve to encourage more honesty from the girl, but there had been enough of that for this casual Sunday. He decided to salvage it but watching the rest of the movie in front of them.Â
Minutes passed and he knew it was an impossible task. Her soft voice repeated over and over, âDo you love me? I mean that real kind of love, you know?â What would he reply if she hadnât told him not to answer it? Kat needed the truth because ten years of following in Ishâs shadow as the girlfriend he never made a fiancĂ© or wife was breaking her spirit, slowly. Even when he pressured himself to confront his feelings, Ish couldnât do it. The portrait of his father in the wall, adjacent to the television, grimaced now.Â
The thought of his parents brought them up in conversation. Welcoming the light-hearted topic, the man smiled. It didnât matter how old they were, Ish and Kat would always fear getting caught by the reverend and his wife. His parents approved of their relationship but obviously, they were against the anything physical that occurred out of wedlock. âTry not to speak them up,â he said with a smile, glancing at the door. Any moment now, theyâd be back from church. Theyâd be eager to send Kat home, and even more eager to lecture Ishua about respect, dignity, virtue. His hand moved from her neck, down to her hand at her stomach. Their fingers linked, and Ish brought their hands to his lips to peck them tenderly. âMaybe this one was one those times that we should have been smarter and gone to your place.â The man returned their hands to her stomach and shifted in his seat. Car doors closed in the distance, and Ish unwillingly encouraged his best friend to sit in a more favorable position as their footsteps approached the front door. âI told you not to speak them up,â he teased Kat.Â
âHey,â he greeted his parents with a smile. âSunday dinner is gonna be late because of yâall.âÂ